C  
PROCESSO SUMÁRIO
O princípio da celeridade versus
as garantias de defesa do arguido
$GYRJDGRVMXt]HVHPDJLVWUDGRVGR0LQLVWpULR3~EOLFRHVWmRFRQYLFWRV
GHTXHHPEUHYHVHUiGHFODUDGDDLQFRQVWLWXFLRQDOLGDGHFRPIRUoD
REULJDWyULDJHUDOGRDUWžQžGR&yGLJRGH3URFHVVR3HQDO
   
$
/HLQžGHGH
IHYHUHLURTXHHQWURXHPYL
JRUDGHPDUoRGH
LQWURGX]LXDOWHUDo}HVSURIXQ
GDVDR&yGLJRGH3URFHVVR
3HQDO&33HQWUHDVTXDLVVHGHVWDFDD
DSOLFDomRGRSURFHVVRVXPiULR)DODPRV
HPFRQFUHWRGRDUWžQžHD
HOLPLQDomRGRFULWpULRTXDQWLWDWLYRDQ
WHULRUPHQWHDSOLFDGRTXHGHWHUPLQDYD
DH[FOXVmRGDDSOLFDomRGHVWDIRUPDGH
SURFHVVRDRVFULPHVFXMDSHQDPi[LPD
DEVWUDWDPHQWHDSOLFiYHOIRVVHVXSHULRU
DFLQFRDQRVGHSULVmR$DOWHUDomROHYRX
DXPDXPHQWRH[SRQHQFLDOGDVVLWXDo}HV
HPÁDJUDQWHGHOLWRTXHSDVVDUDPDDG
PLWLUDDSOLFDomRGHVWDIRUPDHVSHFLDO
GHSURFHVVR
REQUISITOS E COMPETÊNCIA
$QRYDUHGDomRGHWHUPLQDTXHVHMDP
MXOJDGRVHPSURFHVVRVXPiULRRVGHWLGRV
HPÁDJUDQWHGHOLWR´DTXDQGRjGHWHQ
omRWLYHUSURFHGLGRTXDOTXHUDXWRULGD
GHMXGLFLiULDRXHQWLGDGHSROLFLDORXE
TXDQGRDGHWHQomRWLYHUVLGRHIHWXDGD
SRURXWUDSHVVRDHQXPSUD]RTXHQmR
H[FHGDGXDVKRUDVRGHWLGRWHQKDVLGR
HQWUHJXHDXPDDXWRULGDGHMXGLFLiULDRX
HQWLGDGHSROLFLDOWHQGRHVWDUHGLJLGR
DXWRVXPiULRGDHQWUHJDµ
$SHQDGHSULVmRDSOLFiYHODRFULPHGHL
[DGHWHUTXDOTXHUUHOHYkQFLDRTXHWHP
LPSOLFDo}HVLPHGLDWDVQDGHWHUPLQDomRGR
WULEXQDOFRPSHWHQWH2WULEXQDOVLQJXODU
SDVVDDWHUFRPSHWrQFLDSDUDMXOJDUWRGRV
RVSURFHVVRVTXHUHVSHLWHPDFULPHVTXH
GHYDPVHUMXOJDGRVHPSURFHVVRVXPiULR
GHDFRUGRFRPRDUWžQžDOtQHD
FGR&33$QWHVGDDOWHUDomRFULPHVFRP
XPDSHQDPi[LPDDEVWUDWDPHQWHDSOLFiYHO
VXSHULRUDFLQFRDQRVGHSULVmRSRGLDPVHU
VXEPHWLGRVDMXOJDPHQWRHPWULEXQDOVLQ
JXODUDSHQDVVHR0LQLVWpULR3~EOLFRDVVLP
RVROLFLWDVVHDRDEULJRGRDUWžQž
24
JANEIRO 2014 Ordem dos Advogados
$DOWHUDomRH[FOXLXDFRPSHWrQFLDGR
WULEXQDOFROHWLYRQRMXOJDPHQWRGRVFULPHV
HPSURFHVVRVXPiULRGHDFRUGRFRPR
DUWžQžDOtQHDVDHEGR&33
TXHGHWHUPLQDTXHGHYHPVHUMXOJDGRV
HPWULEXQDOFROHWLYRFULPHV´DGRORVRV
RXDJUDYDGRVSHORUHVXOWDGRTXDQGRIRU
HOHPHQWRGRWLSRDPRUWHGHXPDSHVVRD
HQmRGHYDPVHUMXOJDGRVHPSURFHVVR
VXPiULRRXEFXMDSHQDPi[LPDDEVWUD
WDPHQWHDSOLFiYHOVHMDVXSHULRUDFLQFR
DQRVGHSULVmRPHVPRTXDQGRQRFDVR
GHFRQFXUVRGHLQIUDo}HVVHMDLQIHULRU
ROLPLWHPi[LPRFRUUHVSRQGHQWHDFDGD
FULPHHQmRGHYDPVHUMXOJDGRVHPSUR
FHVVRVXPiULRµ
INCONSTITUCIONALIDADE
MATERIAL DA NORMA
$ LQWHUSUHWDomR GR DUWž ž Qž GR&33QRVHQWLGRHPTXHRSURFHV
VRVXPiULRpDSOLFiYHODFULPHVFXMD
SHQDPi[LPDDEVWUDWDPHQWHDSOLFiYHO
pVXSHULRUDFLQFRDQRVGHSULVmRWHP
JHUDGRDFHVDVGLVFXVV}HVGRXWULQiULDVH
MXULVSUXGHQFLDLV
2 SULPHLUR DFyUGmR GR 7ULEXQDO
&RQVWLWXFLRQDOVREUHDPDWpULD$FyU
GmRGHGHMXOKRGHFOD
URXDLQVFRQVWLWXFLRQDOLGDGHGDQRUPD
FRPDUHGDomRTXHOKHIRLGDGDSHOD
/HLQžGHGHIHYHUHLUR
SRUYLRODomRGRDUWLJRžQRVH
GD&RQVWLWXLomR27&HQWHQGHXTXHR
SULQFtSLRGDFHOHULGDGHSURFHVVXDOGHYH
VHUFRPSDWLELOL]DGRFRPDVJDUDQWLDV
GHGHIHVDGRDUJXLGRHHQIDWL]RXTXHR
SURFHVVRVXPiULRpXPDIRUPDPHQRV
VROHQHHJDUDQWtVWLFDSHORTXHQmRSRGH
VHUDSOLFDGRDWRGRVRVDUJXLGRVGHWLGRV
HPÁDJUDQWHGHOLWRVHPWHUHPFRQVL
GHUDomRDSHQDDSOLFiYHO2VDFyUGmRV
TXHVHVHJXLUDP
HXWLOL]D
UDPDPHVPDIXQGDPHQWDomRHGHFLGL
UDPQRPHVPRVHQWLGRYHUFDL[D)LFRX
DVVLPVHPVXVWHQWDomRRDUJXPHQWRTXH
MXVWLÀFDUDDRSomROHJLVODWLYDWRPDGD
SHOR0LQLVWpULRGD-XVWLoD
´2VWULEXQDLVWrPSRUIRUoDGDSUiWL
FDHDVXDLPHGLDWDOLJDomRDRVFDVRVGD
YLGDXPDVHQVLELOLGDGHIUHTXHQWHPHQ
ACÓRDÃOS DO TRIBUNAL CONSTITUCIONAL
'(&,6¯(6(06('('(),6&$/,=$d®2&21&5(7$
6(*8,5$072'$6120(6026(17,'2
2VVHLVDFyUGmRVGR7ULEXQDO&RQVWLWXFLRQDO7&GHFODUD
UDPDLQFRQVWLWXFLRQDOLGDGHGRDUWžQžGR&yGLJR
GH3URFHVVR3HQDOGHDFRUGRFRPDUHGDomRLQWURGX]LGD
SHOD/HLQžGHGHIHYHUHLURQDLQWHUSUHWDomR
VHJXQGRDTXDORSURFHVVRVXPiULRDtSUHYLVWRpDSOLFiYHO
DFULPHVFXMDSHQDPi[LPDDEVWUDWDPHQWHDSOLFiYHOpVX
SHULRUDFLQFRDQRVGHSULVmRFRPIXQGDPHQWRQDYLRODomR
GRDUWLJRQžžQRVHGD&RQVWLWXLomR2$FyUGmR
GHGHMXOKRPDUFRXDSULPHLUDGHFLVmRVREUH
DLQFRQVWLWXFLRQDOLGDGHGRUHIHULGRDUWLJRHDDUJXPHQWDomR
XWLOL]DGDVXVWHQWRXDVUHVWDQWHVGHFLV}HVGR7&
$FyUGmRGHGHMXOKR
27ULEXQDO-XGLFLDOGR(QWURQFDPHQWRUHFXVRXVHDDSOL
FDURDUWžQžQDLQWHUSUHWDomRVHJXQGRDTXDO
RSURFHVVRVXPiULRDtSUHYLVWRpDSOLFiYHODFULPHVFXMD
SHQDPi[LPDDEVWUDWDPHQWHDSOLFiYHOpVXSHULRUDFLQFR
DQRVGHSULVmR27&GHFODURXDLQFRQVWLWXFLRQDOLGDGHGD
QRUPDQDLQWHUSUHWDomRUHIHULGDSRUFRQVLGHUDUTXHD
PHVPDYLRODYDRDUWžQRVHGD&RQVWLWXLomR27&
HQWHQGHXTXHR´SULQFtSLRGDFHOHULGDGHSURFHVVXDOQmRp
XPYDORUDEVROXWRHTXHGHYHVHUFRPSDWLELOL]DGRFRPDV
JDUDQWLDVGHGHIHVDGRDUJXLGRµ6XEOLQKRXTXHRSURFHVVR
VXPiULRPHQRVVROHQHHJDUDQWtVWLFRQmRSRGHVHUDSOLFDGR
DWRGRVRVDUJXLGRVGHWLGRVHPÁDJUDQWHGHOLWRLQGHSHQ
GHQWHPHQWHGDSHQDDSOLFiYHO$UJXPHQWRXR7&TXHD
SURYDGLUHWDGRFULPHHPFRQVHTXrQFLDGRÁDJUDQWHGHOLWR
SRGHGHPRQVWUDUIDFWRVMXULGLFDPHQWHUHOHYDQWHVSDUDD
H[LVWrQFLDGRFULPHHSDUDDSXQLELOLGDGHGRDUJXLGRPDV
QmRSRGHDIDVWDUD´FRPSOH[LGDGHIDFWXDOUHODWLYDPHQWH
DDVSHWRVTXHUHOHYDPSDUDDGHWHUPLQDomRHPHGLGDGD
SHQDRXDVXDDWHQXDomRHVSHFLDOPRUPHQWHTXDQGRUHV
SHLWHPjSHUVRQDOLGDGHGRDJHQWHjPRWLYDomRGRFULPH
HDFLUFXQVWkQFLDVDQWHULRUHVRXSRVWHULRUHVDRIDFWRTXH
SRVVDPGLPLQXLUGHIRUPDDFHQWXDGDDLOLFLWXGHGRIDFWR
RXDFXOSDGRDJHQWHµ
'HFLV}HVSRVWHULRUHV
$HVWDGHFLVmRVHJXLXVHR$FyUGmRGHGH
DJRVWRPRWLYDGRSRUPDLVXPDUHFXVDGR7ULEXQDO-XGLFLDO
GR(QWURQFDPHQWRHPDSOLFDURDUWžQžGR&33
GHVWDYH]VHPTXHWHQKDVLGRXWLOL]DGRRPHFDQLVPRGH
OLPLWDomRGDSHQDDDSOLFDUHPFRQFUHWRDXPPi[LPRGH
FLQFRDQRVGHSULVmRSUHYLVWRQRDUWžQžGR&33
(QWHQGHXR7&TXHDSHVDUGHDLQWHUSUHWDomRQRUPDWLYD
VLQGLFDGDVHUGLIHUHQWHGDGHVFULWDQR$FyUGmR
KDYLD´LGHQWLGDGHVXEVWDQFLDOGRREMHWRQRUPDWLYREHP
FRPRGRVSDGU}HVYDORUDWLYRVFRQYRFDGRVµ
2$FyUGmRGHGHQRYHPEURWHYHQDVXD
RULJHPDGHFLVmRGR7ULEXQDOGD5HODomRGH*XLPDUmHV
TXHGHVDSOLFRXDQRUPDH[WUDtGDGRDUWžQžQD
LQWHUSUHWDomRMiPHQFLRQDGDGHWHUPLQDQGRDDQXODomRGR
MXOJDPHQWRHGDVHQWHQoDHRUGHQDQGRDSURVVHFXomRGR
SURFHVVRHPDSUHoRVREUHDIRUPDGHSURFHVVRFRPXP2
7&FRUURERURXFRPRMXt]RIRUPXODGRQDGHFLVmRGD5HODomR
7DPEpPQR$FyUGmRGHGHGH]HPEURR
7&GHXUD]mRDR7ULEXQDO-XGLFLDOGH3RQWD'HOJDGDTXH
GHVDSOLFDUDDQRUPDH[WUDtGDGDFRQMXJDomRHQWUHRDUW
žQžDOFHRDUWžQžDPERVGR&33
2$FyUGmRGHGHGH]HPEURYHPFRUURERUDU
FRPR-Xt]RGD3HTXHQD,QVWkQFLD&ULPLQDOGHÌOKDYRTXH
SURIHULUDXPGHVSDFKRDGHWHUPLQDUDUHPHVVDGRSURFHVVR
SDUDDIRUPDGHSURFHVVRFRPXPFRPRIXQGDPHQWRGD
LQFRQVWLWXFLRQDOLGDGHGRDUWžQž
$UHFXVDGR7ULEXQDOGH3HTXHQD,QVWkQFLD&ULPLQDOGH/LVERD
QDDSOLFDomRGRDUWžFRPIXQGDPHQWRQDYLRODomRGDV
JDUDQWLDVGHGHIHVDHGRSURFHVVRHTXLWDWLYRYHLRFXOPLQDU
QR$FyUGmRGHGHMDQHLURHPTXHPDLVXPD
YH]R7&MXOJRXLQFRQVWLWXFLRQDODDSOLFDomRGDQRUPDSRU
YLRODURDUWžQRVHGD&RQVWLWXLomR
Ordem dos Advogados JANEIRO 2014
25
C  
WDUPDLVWDUGH2MXOJDPHQWRUHJHUVHi
SRUSULQFtSLRVEDVLFDPHQWHLGrQWLFRV
DRVGRSURFHVVRFRPXPHSRGHUiVHU
FRQFOXtGRDWpGLDVDSyVRFULPHµ
FRPHQWD
VISÃO CRÍTICA
DOS ARGUMENTOS DO TC
WHPDLVDSXUDGDTXHROHJLVODGRUSDUD
DVTXHVW}HVGDVJDUDQWLDVGRVDUJXLGRV
2OHJLVODGRUWUDWDGHVWDVTXHVW}HVDQt
YHOPDLVWHyULFRµFRPHQWD*HUPDQR
0DUTXHVGD6LOYDDGYRJDGRSURIHVVRU
FDWHGUiWLFRHSUHVLGHQWHGR*DELQHWH
GH(VWXGRVGD2UGHPGRV$GYRJDGRV
$FRHUrQFLDHXQLIRUPL]DomRGDVVX
FHVVLYDVGHFLV}HVGR7&IDFHjÀVFDOL
]DomRPDWHULDOGDQRUPDOHYDUDPDTXH
R0LQLVWpULR3XEOLFRWLYHVVHVROLFLWDGRD
ÀVFDOL]DomRDEVWUDWDGRDUWLJR
REAÇÕES DA COMUNIDADE
JURÍDICA
´'HVGHLQtFLRGRSURFHVVROHJLVODWLYRTXH
WHQKRPDQLIHVWDGRRPHXSURIXQGRGH
VDJUDGRFRPHVWDDOWHUDomRµFRPHQWD
*HUPDQR0DUTXHVGD6LOYD´$GPLWLUR
MXOJDPHQWRSHORWULEXQDOVLQJXODUGH
TXDOTXHUFULPHLQGHSHQGHQWHPHQWHGD
SHQDDSOLFiYHOUHSUHVHQWDXPDSURIXQ
GDPXGDQoDGHSDUDGLJPDDDQXQFLDU
QDPLQKDSHUVSHWLYDDH[WLQomRGRV
WULEXQDLVFROHWLYRVµDFUHVFHQWD
$$VVRFLDomR6LQGLFDOGH-Xt]HV3RU
26
JANEIRO 2014 Ordem dos Advogados
WXJXHVHV$6-3WDPEpPVHPRVWURX
FRQWUiULDjPRGLÀFDomR´(VWDIRUPD
SURFHVVXDOVHPSUHIRLVXVWHQWDGDQD
H[LVWrQFLDGHÁDJUDQWHGHOLWRVHJXL
GDGHMXOJDPHQWRTXDVHLPHGLDWRPDV
DSHQDVSDUDFULPHVGHSHTXHQDHPp
GLDFULPLQDOLGDGH$VVLPVHULDVHPSUH
JDUDQWLGDDFHOHULGDGHDXPSURFHVVR
MXGLFLDOTXHDVVHQWDQDSURYD¶IUHVFD·
PDVFRPSDWLELOL]DGDFRPDVJDUDQWLDV
GHGHIHVDGHXPSURFHVVRDTXHQXQFD
SRGHULDVHUDSOLFDGDXPDSHQDVXSHULRUD
FLQFRDQRVGHSULVmRµUHIHUH-RVp0RX
UD]/RSHVSUHVLGHQWHGD$6-3
2SLQLmRGLIHUHQWHpDGH5XL&DUGRVR
SUHVLGHQWHGR6LQGLFDWRGRV0DJLVWUDGRV
GR0LQLVWpULR3~EOLFR6003TXHVXEOL
QKDTXHDVJDUDQWLDVGHGHIHVDQmRVH
SRGHPUHFRQGX]LUDSHQDVDRQ~PHUR
GHMXt]HVTXHLQWHUYrPQRMXOJDPHQWR
HTXHDFUHGLWDH[LVWLUHPPXLWRVRXWURV
DVSHWRVUHOHYDQWHVTXHHVWDYDPDVVHJX
UDGRVQRSURFHVVRVXPiULR´2DUJXLGR
WHPRPHVPRSUD]RTXHQRSURFHVVR
FRPXPSDUDSUHSDUDUDVXDGHIHVDH
DSUHVHQWDUDSURYDTXHSRGHULDDSUHVHQ
$GYRJDGRVMXt]HVHPDJLVWUDGRVGR0L
QLVWpULR3~EOLFRHVWmRFRQYLFWRVGHTXHR
DUWLJRžQžGR&33VHUiGHFODUDGR
LQFRQVWLWXFLRQDOFRPIRUoDREULJDWyULD
JHUDO
*HUPDQR0DUTXHVGD6LOYDFRQFRU
GDFRPDJHQHUDOLGDGHGRVDUJXPHQWRV
DSUHVHQWDGRVSHOR7&HDFUHVFHQWDTXH
QRVHXHQWHQGLPHQWR´DVXEPLVVmRDMXO
JDPHQWRHPSURFHVVRVXPiULRSRUFULPHV
JUDYHVFRPDVOLPLWDo}HVGHFRUUHQWHVGR
SUySULRSURFHGLPHQWRHGDDWULEXLomRGD
FRPSHWrQFLDDRWULEXQDOVLQJXODUQmRp
XPSURFHVVRHTXLWDWLYRHSRULVVRYLROD
D&RQYHQomR(XURSHLDGRV'LUHLWRVGR
+RPHPD&RQVWLWXLomRHRLGHDOGHPR
FUiWLFRµ
´-XOJRTXHVyDGHFLVmRGHLQFRQVWLWX
FLRQDOLGDGHFRPIRUoDREULJDWyULDJHUDO
SRGHUiUHSRURHTXLOtEULRHQWUHRH[HU
FtFLRGHXPD-XVWLoDFpOHUHHRVGLUHLWRV
GHGHIHVDTXHVmRSUySULRVGHXP(VWDGR
GH'LUHLWRµHQIDWL]D-RVp0RXUD]/RSHV
7DPEpP5XL&DUGRVRDFUHGLWDTXH
VHUiGHFODUDGDDLQFRQVWLWXFLRQDOLGDGH
GDTXHODQRUPDFRPIRUoDREULJDWyULD
JHUDO&RQWXGRHVWiFRQYLFWRGHTXH
D DUJXPHQWDomR GR7& p ´PXLWR VX
SHUÀFLDOµHTXHQmRFRQVLGHUDWRGDVDV
TXHVW}HVH[LVWHQWHV´5HFRUGRTXHR&33
QmRXWLOL]DDSHQDVRFULWpULRGDPROGXUD
SHQDOSDUDUHSDUWLUDFRPSHWrQFLDHQWUH
RWULEXQDOFROHWLYRHRWULEXQDOVLQJXODU
1XQFDDQWHV²TXHVDLEDPRV²IRLTXHVWLR
QDGDDFRQIRUPLGDGHGHVVDVQRUPDVFRP
D&RQVWLWXLomRµFRPHQWD5XL&DUGRVR
5HIHUHDLQGDTXHXP~QLFRMXL]SRGH
VXMHLWDUXPDUJXLGRjSULVmRSUHYHQWLYD
´VHPTXHQLQJXpPRTXHVWLRQHVHQGRDt
DVVXDVGHFLV}HVLPHGLDWDPHQWHH[HTXt
YHLVFRQWUDULDPHQWHDRTXHVXFHGHFRP
TXDOTXHUVHQWHQoDTXHVypH[HFXWDGD
GHSRLVGHHVJRWDGRVWRGRVRVUHFXUVRVµ
3DUDRSUHVLGHQWHGR6003DVG~YLGDVTXH
ÀFDPSDUDRIXWXURVmRPXLWDV
&RQWDFWDGRSHOR%ROHWLPGD2$R
0LQLVWpULRGD-XVWLoDQmRVHSURQXQFLRX
VREUHDPDWpULDDWpjGDWDGHIHFKRGHVWD
HGLomR
$GHFLVmRGR7&GHYHUiVHUFRQKHFLGD
HPEUHYHHFRORFDUiXPSRQWRÀQDOQDV
SROpPLFDVHGLYHUJrQFLDV
A Lei n.º 20/2013, de 21 de fevereiro, é uma lei “feita em cima do joelho”
5XLGD6LOYD/HDO
9LFH3UHVLGHQWH
GR&RQVHOKR*H
UDOGD2UGHPGRV
$GYRJDGRVIDORX
DR%ROHWLPGD2$
VREUHRGHVUHV
SHLWRSHORVGLUHL
WRV OLEHUGDGHV
HJDUDQWLDVGRV
FLGDGmRVTXHUHVXOWDGDVDOWHUDo}HVDR
SURFHVVRVXPiULR
'H XP PRGR JOREDO FRPR HQFDUD
DV DOWHUDo}HV LQWURGX]LGDV SHOD /HL
QžGHGHIHYHUHLUR"
&RQVLGHURTXHpIXQGDPHQWDOUHÁHWLU
VREUHHVWDVTXHVW}HV(VWmRHPFDXVD
QHVWDVPDWpULDVRVGLUHLWRVEiVLFRVGH
WRGRVQyV
( VHQGR R SURFHVVR SHQDO GLUHLWR
FRQVWLWXFLRQDODSOLFDGRMXOJRTXHWHP
VLGRFRPJUDQGHOHYLDQGDGHTXHR&33
WHPYLQGRDVHUVXFHVVLYDPHQWHDOWHUDGR
PXLWDVYH]HVHGHPRGRODPHQWiYHO
FRPREMHWLYRVXQLFDPHQWHSRSXOLVWDV
GHPDJyJLFRVHDWpMXVWLFHLURV
$/HLQžGHGHIHYHUHL
URpEHPRH[HPSORGLVVRHPPXLWDV
GDVDOWHUDo}HVTXHLQWURGX]LXeXPD
OHL´IHLWDHPFLPDGRMRHOKRµDGHQRWDU
FODUDPHQWHTXHQmRWHYHDSUHFHGrOD
XPDHIHWLYDSRQGHUDomRQHPXPDUH
ÁH[mRSURIXQGDVREUHDVUHSHUFXVV}HV
TXHLPSOLFDULDQRVGLUHLWRVOLEHUGDGHVH
JDUDQWLDVGRVFLGDGmRV$GHPRQVWUiOR
FODUDPHQWHHVWmRDVGXDVGHFODUDo}HVGH
UHWLÀFDomRTXHGHIRUPDDWDEDOKRDGD
IRUDPGHVGHORJRSXEOLFDGDVDVHJXQGD
FRQWpPDWpDUHWLÀFDomRGDUHWLÀFDomR
HPDLVJUDYHDDXVrQFLDGHUHWLÀFDo}HV
TXHVHPTXDOTXHUG~YLGDFRQWLQXDPD
LPSRUVHHTXHROHJLVODGRUODPHQWDYHO
PHQWHDLQGDQmRGHVFRUWLQRX
8PGRVH[HPSORVGRGHVUHVSHLWRSHORV
GLUHLWRVOLEHUGDGHVHJDUDQWLDVGRVFLGD
GmRV²HPERUDKDMDRXWURVLJXDOPHQWH
JUDYHVpMXVWDPHQWHRTXHUHVXOWDGDV
DOWHUDo}HVjVQRUPDVGRSURFHVVRVXPi
ULRFRPJUDQGHHYLGrQFLDSDUDRDUW
ž27ULEXQDO&RQVWLWXFLRQDO7&Mi
YHLRGL]rORSRUGLYHUVDVYH]HV
4XDLVDVSULQFLSDLVFUtWLFDVTXHDSRQWD
jVDOWHUDo}HVGRSURFHVVRVXPiULR"
2TXHYHLRGHWHUPLQDUVHFRPD/HL
QžpPXLWRVLPSOHVHGHXPD
JUDYLGDGHH[WUHPD6HDWpGHPDUoR
GHVyRVFULPHVSXQtYHLVFRPSHQDGH
SULVmRQmRVXSHULRUDFLQFRDQRVSRGLDP
VHUMXOJDGRVHPSURFHVVRVXPiULRGHVGH
TXHKRXYHVVHGHWHQomRHPÁDJUDQWHGHOL
WRHHVWLYHVVHPREVHUYDGRVRVUHTXLVLWRV
OHJDLVKRMHFRPUDUDVH[FHo}HVTXDOTXHU
FULPHSXQtYHOFRPXPDSHQDVXSHULRUDWp
FRPDSHQDGHDQRVGHSULVmRSRGH
VHUMXOJDGRQHVWDIRUPDGHSURFHVVR
8PKRPLFtGLRTXDOLÀFDGRSRGHVHU
MXOJDGRHPSURFHVVRVXPiULR%DVWDTXH
WHQKDKDYLGRGHWHQomRHPÁDJUDQWHGHOLWR
UM HOMICÍDIO
QUALIFICADO PODE SER
JULGADO POR UM JUIZ
QUE COMECE HOJE
A SUA CARREIRA
HTXHDGHWHQomRWHQKDRFRUULGRQRVWHU
PRVGDVDOVDRXEGRQžGRDUWž
2XVHMDSRGHVHUMXOJDGRSRUXPWULEXQDO
VLQJXODUSRUXPVyMXL]TXHKRMHFRPHFH
DVXDFDUUHLUDSURÀVVLRQDOHPFRPDUFDGH
LQJUHVVRVySRUTXHRFRUUHXRÁDJUDQWH
GHOLWR3RUTXHVHHVWHQmRH[LVWLVVHVy
XPWULEXQDOFROHWLYRWHULDFRPSHWrQFLD
SDUDWDO6yWUrVMXt]HVQXQFDXPH
QXQFDXPVyMXL]DLQGDTXHSUHVLGHQWH
GRFROHWLYRMXL]GHFtUFXORDSHVDUGH
SRVVXLUMiYiULRVDQRVGHFDUUHLUD
-iXPIXUWRQXPHVWDEHOHFLPHQWR
FRPHUFLDOGHFRLVDPyYHOGHYDORUQmR
VXSHULRUDHXURV²QDVFLUFXQVWkQFLDV
SUHYLVWDVQRDUWžQžGR&yGL
JR3HQDO²QXQFDSRGHUiDJRUDFRPDV
DOWHUDo}HVLQWURGX]LGDVDR&yGLJR3HQDO
SHOD/HLGHGHIHYHUHLUR
VHUMXOJDGRHPSURFHVVRVXPiULRXPD
YH]TXHSDVVRXDWHUDQDWXUH]DGHFUL
PHSDUWLFXODUDSHVDUGHHVWDIRUPDGH
SURFHVVRWHUVLGRJL]DGDDSHQVDUH[D
WDPHQWHQHVVHWLSRGHFULPLQDOLGDGH«
&RPRWHPGLWRUHSHWLGDPHQWHR7&
RSURFHVVRVXPiULRpXPSURFHVVRDFH
OHUDGRHPWHUPRVGHSUD]RVHVLPSOLÀ
FDGRTXDQWRDIRUPDOLGDGHVTXHQmRVH
FRDGXQDSRULVVRFRPRMXOJDPHQWRGH
FULPHVJUDYHVFRPRVmRWRGRVRVSXQtYHLV
FRPSHQDGHSULVmRVXSHULRUDFLQFRDQRV
$HVVrQFLDGDFULDomRGRSURFHVVRVX
PiULRIRLGHVYLUWXDGD"
6HÀ]HUPRVXPHVIRUoRGHPHPy
ULDFRQFOXLUHPRVTXHLQLFLDOPHQWHR
SURFHVVRVXPiULRVyHUDDGPLVVtYHOQR
MXOJDPHQWRGHFULPHVSXQtYHLVFRPSHQD
GHSULVmRDWpWUrVDQRVGHSRLVDOWHURX
VHSDUDFLQFRDQRVHDJRUDSDUDTXDO
TXHUSHQDDLQGDTXHDPi[LPD
(VXEPHWHURDUJXLGRDXPMXOJDPHQWR
FRPLQtFLRHPKRUDVRXFLQFRGLDVRX
GLDVRXQRPi[LPRGLDVFRQVR
DQWHRVFDVRVVHPTXHSRVVDRUJDQL]DU
FRPWHPSRDVXDGHIHVDVHPTXHDVVXDV
WHVWHPXQKDVWHQKDPTXHVHUQRWLÀFDGDV
VHPTXHDIDOWDGHWHVWHPXQKDVSRV
VDGDUOXJDUDDGLDPHQWRGDDXGLrQFLD
FRPXPMXOJDPHQWRVXMHLWRDRPtQLPR
GHIRUPDOLGDGHVFRPDSURYDDWHUTXH
VHUSURGX]LGDHPSUD]RVPtQLPRVFRP
DOHJDo}HVGHQRPi[LPRPLQXWRV
VHPGLUHLWRDUHFXUVRGHTXDOTXHUGH
FLVmRLQWHUORFXWyULDVHPSRVVLELOLGDGH
GHUHFXUVRGDSUySULDVHQWHQoDSDUDR
67-pDOJRTXHQmRVHFRPSDGHFHFRP
RMXOJDPHQWRGHFULPHVJUDYHVSXQtYHLV
DWpFRPDSHQDPi[LPDSUHYLVWDQDOHL
(WXGRLVVRFRPXPD~QLFDMXVWLÀFD
omRDGHWHQomRHPÁDJUDQWHGHOLWR
2SURFHVVRVXPiULRIRLSHQVDGRSDUD
VHUXPSURFHVVRPXLWRUiSLGRVREUH
WXGRGHYLGRjVLPSOLFLGDGHGRVIDFWRV
DMXOJDUHjVXDPHQRUJUDYLGDGHQmR
HVWDQGRQRUPDOPHQWHHPFDXVDJUDQGHV
GLÀFXOGDGHVGHSURYDQHPSURYDVGH
FRPSOH[DDQiOLVHQHPWmRSRXFRGH
JUDYHVFRQVHTXrQFLDVSDUDRSUySULR
DUJXLGR(VHMiQmRVHFRDGXQDYDQD
PLQKDSHUVSHWLYDFRPRMXOJDPHQWRGH
FULPHVSXQtYHLVFRPSHQDGHSULVmRDWp
FLQFRDQRVpHYLGHQWHTXHQmRSRGH
FRQVWLWXLURSURFHVVRSUySULRSDUDRV
FULPHVPDLVJUDYHV$VJDUDQWLDVGHGH
IHVDGRVDUJXLGRVQmRVmRGHYLGDPHQWH
VDOYDJXDUGDGDV
&RQFRUGDFRPRVDUJXPHQWRVTXHWrP
YLQGRDVHUDSUHVHQWDGRVSHOR7&QRV
GLYHUVRVDFyUGmRV"4XDOGHYHVHUR
SHVRGR´DUJXPHQWRµFHOHULGDGHHP
SURFHVVRSHQDO"
&RQFRUGRLQWHJUDOPHQWHFRPR7&
$VJDUDQWLDVGHGHIHVDGRVDUJXLGRV
QRMXOJDPHQWRSRUWULEXQDOVLQJXODUVmR
PHQRUHVGRTXHTXDQGRRMXOJDPHQWR
Ordem dos Advogados JANEIRO 2014
27
C  
VHUHDOL]DSRUWULEXQDOFROHWLYR3RUTXH
DXPHQWDDPDUJHPGHHUURQDDQiOLVH
GRVIDFWRVHSRULVVRpPDLRURULVFR
GHXPDGHFLVmRLQMXVWDDOpPGHTXH
FRPRGLVVHXVDQGRRDUJXPHQWRGR7&
RWULEXQDOVLQJXODUpFRQVWLWXtGRUHJUD
JHUDOSRUXPMXL]HPLQtFLRGHFDUUHLUD
HSRUWDQWRFRPXPDH[SHULrQFLDEHP
PDLVUHGX]LGDGRTXHDGHXPMXL]GH
FtUFXORTXHSUHVLGHDRWULEXQDOFROHWLYR
(VHFRPRGL]R7&²QR$FyUGmR
QžSDUDRTXDOGHSRLVUHPH
WHUDPIXQGDPHQWDOPHQWHRVDFyUGmRV
TXHVHOKHVHJXLUDP²RÁDJUDQWHGHOLWR
HPSULQFtSLRIDFLOLWDDGHPRQVWUDomR
GRVIDFWRVIXQGDPHQWDLVSDUDDH[LVWrQ
FLDGRFULPHHDSXQLELOLGDGHGRDJHQWH
RTXHSRGHQmRVHULQWHLUDPHQWHYHUGD
GHQRVFDVRVGHTXDVHÁDJUDQWHGHOLWR«
RFHUWRpTXHQmRSHUPLWHFRQKHFHUGRV
IDFWRVUHOHYDQWHVSDUDDGHWHUPLQDomR
HPHGLGDGDSHQDRXDVXDDWHQXDomR
HVSHFLDOVREUHWXGRTXDQGRVHWUDWHGD
SHUVRQDOLGDGHGRDUJXLGRGDPRWLYDomR
GRFULPHHRXWUDVFLUFXQVWkQFLDVTXH
SRGHPGLPLQXLUDFHQWXDGDPHQWHDLOL
FLWXGHHDFXOSD
-iRDUJXPHQWRGDFHOHULGDGHSUR
FHVVXDOFRPRPXLWREHPDFHQWXDR7&
QmRpUHDOPHQWHDUJXPHQWRQHQKXPVH
QRRXWURSUDWRGDEDODQoDHVWLYHUHPDV
JDUDQWLDVGHGHIHVDGRDUJXLGR'RQž
GRDUWžGD&53UHVXOWDFRPHYLGrQFLD
TXHDFHOHULGDGHSURFHVVXDOWHUiVHPSUH
TXHFHGHUSHUDQWHDVJDUDQWLDVGHGHIHVD
GRDUJXLGR2MXOJDPHQWRKiGHUHDOL]DU
VHQR´PDLVFXUWRSUD]RFRPSDWtYHOFRP
DVJDUDQWLDVGHGHIHVDµRXVHMDVHD
FHOHULGDGHSURFHVVXDOHVEDUUDUFRPDV
JDUDQWLDVGHGHIHVDHQWmRDTXHODFHOH
ULGDGHWHUiTXHFHGHU-XOJRTXHLVWRp
IiFLOGHSHUFHEHU«
20LQLVWpULRGD-XVWLoDHQWHQGLDTXHR
DUJXLGRQmRYLDDVJDUDQWLDVGHGHIHVD
GLPLQXtGDVQRPHDGDPHQWHSRUTXH
WLQKDDSRVVLELOLGDGHGHUHTXHUHUMXO
JDPHQWRSHUDQWHXPWULEXQDOGHM~UL
&RPRDYDOLDHVWHDUJXPHQWR"
'HVGHORJRHVVDSRVVLELOLGDGHGDLQ
WHUYHQomRGRWULEXQDOGHM~ULQmRpXPD
´EHQHVVHµDWULEXtGDSHOROHJLVODGRURUGL
QiULReDVVLPSRUTXHROHJLVODGRUFRQV
WLWXFLRQDORLPS}HQRDUWžGD&53
'HTXDOTXHUPRGRpDSHQDVXPDSRV
VLELOLGDGHHVVDGDLQWHUYHQomRGRWULEXQDO
GHM~UL3RUTXHVHQmRIRUUHTXHULGRR
WULEXQDOGHM~ULQmRLQWHUYpP(QHVVD
28
JANEIRO 2014 Ordem dos Advogados
DOWXUDOiWHUHPRVRSURFHVVRVXPiULRHP
IXQFLRQDPHQWRHRWULEXQDOVLQJXODUDMXO
JDU(HVVDSRVVLELOLGDGHpTXHPHSDUHFH
TXHQXQFDGHYHULDVHUSHUPLWLGDFRPR
QmRHUDDWpGHPDUoRGH3RUTXH
HVWmRHPFDXVDGLUHLWRVOLEHUGDGHVHJD
UDQWLDVSRUTXHHVWmRHPFDXVDGLUHLWRVGH
GHIHVDGRVDUJXLGRVVXMHLWRVDSHQDVGH
SULYDomRGDOLEHUGDGHJUDYtVVLPDVPHVPR
DSHQDPDLVJUDYHGHDQRVGHSULVmR
$FUHVFHTXHVHRDUJXLGRQmRUHTXHUHU
SUD]RSDUDDSUHSDUDomRGDGHIHVD²H
WHPTXHID]rORHPGLDVDSyVDGHWHQ
omR²SHUGHRGLUHLWRDUHTXHUHUDLQWHU
YHQomRGRWULEXQDOGHM~UL(UHTXHUHQGR
SUD]RSDUDDGHIHVDVHSUHWHQGHUVHU
MXOJDGRSRUWULEXQDOGHM~ULWHUiVHPSUH
TXHUHTXHUrORDWpDRLQtFLRGDDXGLrQFLD
0DLVQRVFULPHVSXQtYHLVFRPSHQD
HQWUHFLQFRHRLWRDQRVGHSULVmRQXQFD
RDUJXLGRSRGHUiUHTXHUHUDLQWHUYHQomR
GRWULEXQDOGHM~ULRTXHVLJQLÀFDTXH
HPFDVRGHGHWHQomRHPÁDJUDQWHGH
OLWRRSURFHVVRDSOLFiYHOVHUiVHPSUH
RVXPiULR
2TXHPHSDUHFHLQWROHUiYHOpDSRV
VLELOLGDGHGHHVWDFULPLQDOLGDGHJUDYH
VHUMXOJDGDHPSURFHVVRVXPiULR-XOJR
TXHDOHLQXQFDGHYHULDSHUPLWLORFRPR
VXFHGLDDWpGHPDUoRGHeTXHD
FHOHULGDGHQmRpHQmRSRGHVHUXPYDORU
DEVROXWRHOHYDGRDRVXSUHPRREMHWLYR
GDVSROtWLFDVGHMXVWLoDSRUTXHWDOQmR
VHFRPSDJLQDPLQLPDPHQWHFRPDVJD
UDQWLDVGHGHIHVDGRDUJXLGR
$FUHGLWD TXH VHUi GHFODUDGD D LQ
FRQVWLWXFLRQDOLGDGH GR DUW ž
QžGR&33FRPIRUoDREULJDWyULDJHUDO"
$QDOLVDQGRWRGRVRVDFyUGmRVGR7&
VREUHHVWDTXHVWmR²HQmRKiXP~QLFR
TXHVHMDGHVLQDOFRQWUiULR²YHULÀFDPRV
TXHDLQFRQVWLWXFLRQDOLGDGHGDQRUPD
WHPVLGRLQYDULDYHOPHQWHGHFODUDGD2
TXHMiDFRQWHFHXHPSHORPHQRVVHLV
FDVRVFRQFUHWRV/RJREDVWDQGRWUrVFD
VRVIDFLOPHQWHVHDGLYLQKDTXHDPXLWR
EUHYHWUHFKRR7&GHFODUDUiDLQFRQV
WLWXFLRQDOLGDGHFRPIRUoDREULJDWyULD
JHUDOGRDUWžTXDQGRLQWHUSUHWDGR
QRVHQWLGRGHTXHRSURFHVVRVXPiULR
DtSUHYLVWRpDSOLFiYHODFULPHVFXMD
SHQDPi[LPDDEVWUDWDPHQWHDSOLFiYHO
pVXSHULRUDFLQFRDQRVGHSULVmRHLVVR
SRUYLRODomRSHORPHQRVGRDUWž
QRVHGD&53