V Congreso Latinoamericano de Ciencia Política. Asociación Latinoamericana de
Ciencia Política, Buenos Aires, 2010.
DEMOCRACIA DELIBERATIVA,
ESPACOS PUBLICOS E SABER
TECNICO: A EXPERIENCIA DAS
AUDIENCIAS PUBLICAS EM CURITIBA.
Guto Augusto Junior Clemente y Souza Nelson
Rosário.
Cita: Guto Augusto Junior Clemente y Souza Nelson Rosário (2010).
DEMOCRACIA DELIBERATIVA, ESPACOS PUBLICOS E SABER TECNICO:
A EXPERIENCIA DAS AUDIENCIAS PUBLICAS EM CURITIBA. V Congreso
Latinoamericano de Ciencia Política. Asociación Latinoamericana de
Ciencia Política, Buenos Aires.
Dirección estable: http://www.aacademica.org/000-036/161
Acta Académica es un proyecto académico sin fines de lucro enmarcado en la iniciativa de acceso
abierto. Acta Académica fue creado para facilitar a investigadores de todo el mundo el compartir su
producción académica. Para crear un perfil gratuitamente o acceder a otros trabajos visite:
http://www.aacademica.org.
!
"#
"%&%
'
/ 0
-.
5
-7
( ) *+ ,
1123 4
-
, 6
/ 0
!" !#$%&'"
7
-
(( ) *+ ,
2 8
( )
*
999999999999999999999999999
(
((
0.
8
:
=
=
;
;
7
* <
* <
+
+
6 ) *+ ,
6 ) *+ ,
$%
<
<
B
>?
;
>
@
C>
>?
8
8
E
>?
<
6
<
F
0 8
"%%A
8
?
0
<
>D
G
F
<
D
H !I,: 7 &AJ"
8
6
;
?
68
<
;
@
,
<
<
8
< >?
= =
<
;
@
F
;
>?
D
@
< >D
+
C
<
>?
&A1%
K
L
<
>?
?
<
8
>?
!
>?
>?
<
E
8
5 F
E
8
>?
<
E
C
>
I
+
4
6
7
.
C>
8 E
"%%"
<
&
>?
<
>?
K
4
@
8
= .5 5C
F
@
F
0
K
I
!
6
0
6
7C*M
"%%$
%N
<
< >?
>?
<
>?
>D
F
>? +
8
!
<
-
;
8
@
>
:
;
:
:
C>
B
;
@
;
<
@
"%%N
C>
B
6
8
8
>?
8
=
C>
H
:
6
C
F
=C
6
<
<
;
-
?
D
F
6
:
6
?
C
E
8
4
8
&JN +
<
L
>?
:=!
F
@
?
C>
@
6
8
>
C>
C>
;
<
< 0
>? K
C>
>?
>?
F
F
O
8
B
8
+
K
<
>
C
:
<
0
8 >?
+ &A##
@
@
"%&% 7
0
<
"%%A F
6
&A##
K
8
&A#$
&A## F
8
K
>
I
D
?
6@
E
F
? F
<
L
<
8
?
<
F
6
L
>?
<
6
4
8
F
>
@
<
7
<
?
>?
<
:
>?
>?
6
>
E
8
@
<
0
I
>
6
F
4
4
?
>?
>?
>?
I
4
I
B8
>?
<
8
G5
&AJ" &A#N &AA"
C K8
B
<
?
P
@
F
6
H
I
;
>
>
'
?
C
>?
0
C
8
6
L
8
< >?
?
68
8 >
>
<
,
-
@
<
6
"
I
!-! ./01&230 04 ! 15! " 647&'" ! 230 0#89&'"%&-"
Q
"%%%
F
F
8
8
8
<
8
C
<
4
K
<
E
?
@
<
>? 8
"%%# "%%A
D
< >D
= =R
<
8 = 5
, 6
8
6
>?
6
<
?
;
8
<
8
<
8
-8 4
CR S
>?
7
@
<
8
:
>?
*+ , 5
= =R
CR
F
E
8
K
F
'
F
*+ ,
K
!
<
>?
<
L
<
>?
;
, ?
<
F >?
<
<
&AAA
H
7
, ?
E
I,
F
, ?
<
@
F
<
<
<
5
K
<
D
0
! " , ?
<
8
8
6
<
0
L
?
#
D
F
<
<
04
:
?
>
@
>D
8
8
>?
<
>?
8
<
<
<
0
<
<
8
D
<K
ED
>D
<
S
E
F
<
>?
8
;
8
>
I
6
I
>?
K
4 K
8
@
C
%
<
I8
8 E
@
H
F
U
UU
8
<
V
4
$ %
<
+
>
7 D
<
>D
K
T
$
4
L
<
<
8
<
<
< >D
0
>D
4
<
@
@
8K
W
&AAA
< <
8
<
<
5?
;
)
F
C
I8
@
K
<
<
I,
< K
4
?
4
I
&AJ" )
&'
>?
<
>?
>D
T
<
<
6
>
0
F
K
>?
< >?
>?
>
$
B
<?
<
<
0
F
8
<
8
4
0
@
>?
@
6
E?
K F
F
<
0
F
>?
5
I,
8
>?
8
4"9&1#0
6
>
>? 4
< 0
<
6
>
F
X
F
>?
8
F
>
)
*
+
,
H , IY
$
"&$
<
E
>?
8 T
<
4?
8
6
<
8
#
60 - 4
F K
:
"%%N
6
@
V<
F
8
F
W
L
F
W
>?
5
F
L
F
V
?
>?
7
>
<
>?
8
>D
, MI,
C7
E
?
6
8
@
K
5
<
8
<
-
8
V
88
>D
4
UU
>?
<
(
<
K
8
4
?
8
<
>D
>?
4
>?
>
<
8
6
(
$
&A#A
>D
< <
>?
8E
7?
&AAA
K
W
7
<
<
8
":30 91% 8#!9%"7 90
6
8 E
>D
<
V8
8
<
8
,
0
?
W
>?
?
>
F
8 4
5
3+
K
K
<
@
.
6
E
K
3
<
>?
? KF
?
8
"%%Z 7 3 ! 4
? 0
4
F
4
<
Y
<
K
6
?
>?
<
8
< 4 K
S
E
C
&AA"
F
<
8
8
>?
F
@
@
7
K
<
"%%&
5
F
<
E
68
8
C 6
K
>? K
F
8
>?
46
E
F
>?
<
<
8
>
6
L
V
F
W
4
<
;
<
8
?
*
>?
<
8
K
7C*M
>?
"%%&
>?
>?
=
>?
8
8
8
?
;
8
>?
>? B
K0
C8
/ $.
6
K-
$.
$
0
+
7C*M
0
F
=
B
F
?
<
>?
8
<
>
6
&&%
4
K
8 8
8
[ \ C
E
8 >
<
8 >?
8 >D
>?
;
5
8 >
8
>?
F
7C*M "%%&
&%#
F
?
E
8
?
F
F
"%%&
F
F
4
4
F
4
>
W
BF
V
4
<
F
<
8 >D
F
8
>?
<6
?
6F
C
KF
>?
8 >
8
@
C
< K
>?
>
K
?
K
K
K
E
8
>?
6
8
6<
<
>?
V
8
,
7C*M
+)
@
5
K
8
8
W
CF
1
"%%&
&%A
, "; 30 0#/0 %"#!9%"7 ;" 7&%! ;#&9&1% "%&-" ;! 8 &%&4"
I
=
8
<
6
8
&#
8
4
F
4?
4
7
&AZ"
T
8
5
8
>?
8
<
*
* <
+
<
=
F
&AJN
'
>?
6 ) *+ , )
?
> 0
I
7?
F
8
F
6
7
Q 4
4
C
7
=
>?
7
< 0
?
H
C
- *
4
>?
F
>?
*
F
*
4
"%%&
F
C
8
>?
>
K
6< W
>
K 0 4
?
<
<
V
?
8
W
F
V
8
W
F
,
<
6
F
W- 2 &&3 4&
&
<
7C*M
=
"%%&
)
(
&&%
*
<
=
"
I
6
>?
=
<
7
>?
>
&AJN
0.
<
6
>?
(
8
?
6
>?
<
K
7
6
>D
E
D
F
>?
<
<
<
@
F
3
7
>?
<
0
<
0
C
<
>D
>D
) $1
>?
F
<
V4
4
<
>D
K
I
F
8
F
"%%%
4
>?
E
I,
>
>?
K
V
8
F
*
F
7
=
*
8
>
0
I
K
< >?
F
4
8
>?
6
= 8
8
E
?
<6
F
D
<
>?
8
F
<
>?
C
I,
"%%%
E
8
K
)
)
E
7
AN
I
< >D
6 [ \ =
<
:
4 +
7? ' K
4
0
6
<
?
<
+
0
F
?
8 >
8
>
F
F
*
'
>
8
8
S
<
E
H
&A1&
C
<
[
8 \
7
60
4
8
>D
E0
0
*
E0
8
FP
*
>?
<
>?
0 4 <
4 =
@
*
<
4
E
?
-'
7
*
=
C
8
>
I,
"%%%
&%%
?
8
FP
8
7
,
F
64 <
>?
B
C
D
>?
<
=
+
F
7
8
+
I,
4
"%%%
&%N
B
<
8
<K
&A#A
>?
>?
<
>?
,
>?
>?
K
6
K
E
<
>?
8
,
T
>D
8 <
=
C
6
>?
:
>?
>?
>?
?
F
?
8
<
>
F
+
<
B
8
8
7
0
?
8
0
, F ?
B
< <
K
4
<
8
<
<
>
:=! ,
5
>?
E >?
4
8
:
8
B
?
?
:=! F
C
>?
?
>
&A#$0&A##
=
@
8
F
8 <
<
8
&A#%
8
'
<
I
>?
>D
:
K
8 <
7C*M
V
>
"%%&
W
0
W
?
?
F
4
F
<
K
V
F
;
8
5
V
K
>? W
K
]
8 >
R
F
F
>?
?
8 ;
?
< >?
4
"%%&
7C*M
&A##0&AA" 8
&&%
<
>?
K
>?
H6
>
46
<
>?
H , IY &A#A
<
0
F
6
0
8
'
6
6
<
>?
4
8
:
>?
L
:
K
@
:
>?
6
.
"%%$ *
<
I
&AAZ .
<
E
>?
B
8
4
8
8
?
? 0 <
E
7C*M
@
:
L
<
, 8
<
K
<
8
8
C: !
:
8
C: !
JZJ
'
<
1#"A
E
F
0
C: !
:
F
>?
8
T
<
F
C: !
F
8
>
<
6
B
E
=
<
4
4
N
<
6
<
<
@
:
>?
4
>?
>
<
5
K
?
?
C: !
&AA&
I
N
B
<
! L
>?
>?
@
<
^
K
5
?
6
>?
F
<
C: !
4
:
?
.
< F
<
<
D
C
8
F
.
6
4 &AA10"%%Z
*
F
>?
F
<
>?
:
* <
7
5
*
"%%N
>?
*
+
>?
>?
>?
<
F
*
:
8
<
:
?
4
, : ,
4
< ?
F F
8
8
D
F
? 0
6
[ \
6
? 0
>?
6
*
F
, : ,
&ZJ
4 )
!
, 4 )
E0<
F
)
"
.
$.
%# C
F
E
?
<
?
<
$
'
K
8
?
E0
: -
J
8
6
&'
F
E
*
E
<
C
<K
"
+
+
> B
F
)
C
>?
C F
<
I,
"%%%
'
J&
8
F
8
;
<
?
F
, 15! " 647&'" 0709&:";" ! " &;";!
J
B
<
>?
8
8
"%%$
C
>?
8
7C*M
<
-
6
5667
F
6
I
8
"%%%
&ZJ
F
+
< >?
"%%%
/
>
/
>?
7
)
*
) )
<
K
%
$1
<
>
8
F
?
"%%% 4
6
8
8
<
4
K
>?
0;!7";"
F
=
<
>?
+
"%%1
>?
>?
8
<
F
F
V
W
<
D
;
F
< >D
<
I
?
<
8
>D
< [
>?
6
\8
<
Z%
D
K
1% K
>? F
+I,, ,
0
&J&0&J"
<K
F
8
8
V<;W
8
>?
4
K
-
;
"%%1
8
K
+
8
I
4
>? K
6
<
<
F
<
4
F
>?
7
6
@
+
8
F
46
I
>?
H6
< >?
I
<
>?
D
I
8
F
>
<
X
<;
4
<
F
L
<
< -
<
[ \
6<
K
K
[ \
4
<
<
+I,, ,
*
@<
<
>D
0
6
?
<
8
F
< F
&J#0&JA
"%%1
=
8
>?
F
F
F
F
I
/
,
_ * H _'I ` ,C7
"%%1
8
&%J
K
?
I
F
7
>?
8
<
@
E
K
4
F
F
D
>?
F
F
. ,
< F
E
C
46
F
K
<
F
&AA1
? 4
]
R
;
<<
_ * H _'I ` ,C7 "%%1
E
&%10&%#
I
4
>?
V @
8
W
F
@
6
? 8
>
<
;
F
8
8
@
8
6
B
< >?
, 1 8;&=9'&"1 647&'"1
I
2"#!9%$ &"1
C
1% 8%8 " 91%&%8'&09"7
0
"%%N
8
E
<
=
C>
6
=C
>? +
C>
+
!
=C
CF
8
6
C
F
4D
E
$&N
4D
?
K
<
<
,a
>?
V
&
<
9 )
566: 56;5
'
)
W1 7
$1
@
<
<
>
8
6
F
>?
Z#
)%
(
?
>
<
+ C,
b4
;
>
) F
< B
F
-//ccc
/
> ? @
/
?
ZZ
>D
&% "N1/"%%&
;
>?
7?
F
* ?
<
!-=
&Z
<
) ,+ )
F
C "%%N =
" "
@
>?
@
2"#!9%0
<
6
=
>?
)
C
F
>?
8
;
=
$1
>
<;
4D
8
?
:
"%&%
<
4D
6
4
,a $ A%1
,a $$
>
&JN
F
=C
,a $ AZ
)
?
6
8
>?
C
8
KF
@
B
<
K
&7AB!1 !# 9-!1%&#!9%01,
"%%A
;
EG
d&1$Z% e
-
: )
8
5
=
"A 5 <
8
:
<
"%%A
-
>?
=
>?
F
8
<
=
I
>D
,+
F
@
=
6
@
I
8
<
8
<
0
>
<
>
<
7C ,I7 "%%"
I
V+
C
W 4
>
?
>D
?
:=!
>?
<
<
8
-!
!
+
5 <
=
"%%
! F
7?
?
:
,
4
4
"%%%
,
K
;
@
?
C
2$
(
I
.
D
;
>
0
>?
>?
<
#
C
K
F
5
8
E
<
E
<
6
>?
>?
<
=C K
=C
=C
5
=C
<
=
8
C
B
V.
WK
=C
:
F
>?
<
C
C
,
K
C
F
< 60
8
K
C
8 >?
C
C
C
?
F
?
L
E
<
>?
<K
>
C>
B
F
C
C
7I
:
4
<
8
6
7
=C
<
<
8
C
>?
<
<
=C K
0
:
B
8
@
<
7I
7
&N%
8
?
I
?
>?
F
,
4
E
!.I
8
8
,
8
<
>?
:
L
<
6
C
D
>?
D
F
?
4
C
B 7I
5
<K
+ 4
8
=
C
D
4
4
E
<
<
<
-##
"%%# &N $
<
"%%A
<
>?
@
D
&# "
6
F
"%%1 &"
"%&%
E
>?
=C
;
<
@
8 E
>?
8
,
@
?
>?
<
, !/ 0;8230 0#/0 %"#!9%"7 ;"
5
&9C#&'" ;"1
>?
E
>?
<
C
<
<
<
6
> 0
>
@
C
-
<
6
E
B
6
>
<
>?
6<
<
6
@
>?
B :
<
,+
<
>?
8
>
>?
=C
>?
F
I
>?
F
8
<
?
<
6
>
;
6
6
8
8
?
<
?
>?
8 >?
>
F
F
*
8
-
=
6
8
?
<
@
>?
0
F
I
"%%A
<
F
<
1
L
F
68
+
0
C
?
I
K
6
E
?
>?
>?
@
,
8 4
46
F
F
?
6
I
4
8
<
F
4 B
<
,
8
+ 4
F
! F
<
4
?
F
A
<
5 8 4
<
E
0
?
4
+ 4
@
I F
8
6
<
,
8 4
46
+
:
F
F
F
0
>?
4
8 4
>?
4
<
C
8
4
?
,
2$
4 6
F
$1
.
0
.
=
+
(
4 6
F
<
>?
=C
C
8
6
F
KF
4
6
?
E
*
8
W
E
>D
K
>
F
D
>
46
E
K
8
C C
>
?
K E
?
F
8
F
F
!
>?
4
F
F
<
, 4
5
L
:
E
K
;
< K
@
>
@
?
<
E
46
?
;
>
<
C
V
<
F
8 4
>? B
@ #%&<"A
)
F
D
.
,
)
&
6
(
K
1
4#
:
K
L
X
?
F
C
8 >? F
8
4
7
@
8 4
4
>?
6
E
>?
K
7
T
< K8
F
F
<
?
F
8
(
;
@
. &
>
C
$
>
<
C
<
E
<
5?
C
K
46 + 4
;
@
K
8
F
/ $.
? KF
D
<
%
>
K
L
<
8
S
5
F
F
?
E
<
L
K
< K
< >D
I
E
C
<
<
8
<
7
8
W
8
8
?
8
F
5
V<?
K
:
F
I
?
E
8
?
,
@
?
60
S
<
E
<
F
?
< >?
F
<
8
L
C
@
V
C
W
<
V
V
W
8
8
?
D
<
F
C <
W
8
6
8
F
C
?
B
<
<
K
K
8
H6
,
F
8
F
<
F
F
8
>?
<K
>?
6
<
8
;
C
,
0
<
8
?
F
5
5
C F
46
8
E
F
>
F
6
,
F
4
46
6
8
,
B
>
E
>?
4
F
8
?
<
<
,
>
6
>? K
<
C
E
<
F
L
<
7
?
:
C
>
"%
F
8
@
$%
#%
V @
F
:
F
+
,
B
:
<
/
>
D
W
C
@
; 7
6
8
6
E
E
<
?
8
,
8K
5 F
F
8
?
C
>
8
K
L
:
; 8
E
E
L
<
C
8
6
L
?
F
I
C
D
+
>?
6
L
E
<
F
F
8
C
?
&JN
?
<
F
<
C ;
4
>?
F
>
C F
"&4
,
<
"%
&Z4
K
L
> <
@
>
<
8
C
&%4
<
I
C
+
?
@
8
K
?
<
C
<
<
=C
8
<6
+
>
>?
<
<
<
V W
C
F
K
&A4
K
? B8
K
D
T
8
I
<
K
46
46
K
<
?
5
C
>?
I
8
K
V @
0
@
6
C
F
>D
>D
. <
<
W C
K
<
I
W
/
K
<
E
:
V
<
?
,
?
&N%
?
,
<
>?
K
8
<
K
IE >D
&J4
F
K
8
8
;
<
"%
>?
<
>
F
X
F
<
8
V
W
?
C
:
4 <
<
8
>?
6
<
F
I
8
6 V
4
4
W
>?
,
L
?
V8
W
<
F
F
<
8
<
8
< >?
S
<
6
<
>D
=
L
<
<
E
<
> 0
<
K
>?
46
>?
?
8
I
?
+C*
<
*
&A11
>?
8
@
<
?
@
+,I ,I
&AJJ
<
<
>D
8 4
D
@
B <
<
-
4
< >D
>?
>?
4 >?
<
@
T
8
8
>?
>?
>?
<
<
<
>
:
>?
<
46
>?
?F
K
8
>?
?
6
T
? 8
<
<
8
F
0
>?
;
C
F
>?
>?
f
:
<
K
6
@
>?
0
@
8
<
4
>D
>
6
>?
E
L
4
@
>?
8
>?
<6
B
>
8
<
>?
C
4
<
68
4
>?
I
?
;
>D
6
F
8
?
F
I
?
K
5
D
F
E
0
K
4
8
<
E
>?
<
I
E
?
V 4
<
6
>? W
>?
F
8
F
,
>? 8
F
V
W
>
8
>?
5? 46
6
8
<
W
4
4
V
B <
E?
T
& 8C
4
@
<
<
4 6
8
B
F
L
C
F
< >D
:
8
< KF
?
+ 4
8
>?
<
?
>
F
8
8
F
?
<
-
E
4
<
I
<
C 4
<
8
< >D
>
46
4
@
<
,
E
<
?
6
8
< <
<6
K
< >D
>?
>?
K
< 46
:
<
K
L
86
<
F
<
;
F
D
B
K
K
!
K
B
(
F
2?
<
E
F
?
K
K
@
W X
6F
<
5 F
F
F
B
E
8
> 0
K
,
>?
;
@
>D
,
D
4
<
4 W
-
@<
6
V
V
4
F
E
?
;
V F
<
4
W
8
F
5
.
?
8
8
V
)
4
<
F
WB
8
K
:
<
W
F
!
4
8
E
T
K
I
>
8
<
< >?
>
F
F
C
,
?
A.
)
)
E 0
E
V
0
W
,
6
;
8
F
K
6 4 <
V
W F
B
<
>D
8
8
6
F
0
V
- 0,
K
8
) .
0
6
7
K
F
6
:
4
?
F
<
E
8
F
F
>?
$
V @
4
<
<
6
- "
5
<
, 0 )
>? :
$.
6 4 <
,
I
W
0
<
5
,
<
7
. G6B % ,
<
< <
>?
5F
F
>? W
>D
4
?
E
V 4
K
8
0 ) .
4%3"
B
>?
,
$
<
8
)
< >?
K
:
8
/ $1 ! = 0 4
C
K
?
4
?
.
/
8
K
8
.
/
B 8
<
0
8
7
/
>?
?
<
>?
8
<
<
<
>?
V
8
=
4
<
8
8
F
6F
D
B
W
C
B
8
C
E
F
< <
>D
>
>?
F
.
"
<
;
&'
I
F
< >?
?
< >D
?
>
8
5
8
,
C
>?
>?
=C 4
<
<
?
>?
F
>?
7
6
6
. <
5
:
F
V
C 7
L
8
<
< 8
!
8
@
6
E
<
? F
C
,
7
<
E
5 F
C
)
<
:
8
>
8
< K
?
>
?
W
E
.
C
4
>?
F
=C
C
K
8
0 $
@
<
?
?
- #
8
>?
<
0
6
<
8
C
<
F
V
.
F
F
K
C>
;
>? F
? 46
B 7I
W
F
<
< >D
>?
?
6
8 E
8
<
8
<
<
6
8
?
8
8
< F
F
F
0
/
8
<
*
4
< <
8
7
C>
<
?
>
6
E
C
8
L
F
)
,
C
<
>?
F
F
V
4
4 W
T
K
C
K
5
>?
<
>?
F
>
D
L
:
F
<
F
6
8
F
;
@
F
<
F
?
<
F
C
K
L
<
C
>?
>
<
6
<
F
K
E
<
<
6
*
?
E
60
<
K
C
E
<
<
>
7
*
V @
8
F
)
F
>
?
.
@
I
>?
4
8
E
>?
46
B 8
F
?
B
F
;
>?
<K
:
;
?
<
46
<
$.
?
?
W
C
<
B
8
<
@
6
>
8
F
>D
8
+
8
5 <
)
7
F
>?
D
C
F
K
<
F
7
<
>?
>?
<
;
>
@
?
<
>?
C
?
8
?
!
6
, 4
*
)
F
46
>?
E
>D
7?
V @
?
F
F
@
4
>
8
F
$.
+)
E
8
6
<
:
W X
F
F
8
C
<
<
7
?
6
?
:
?
H6
7
8
L
7
8
F
I
F
?
E
8
@
I
C
F
E
K
>? F
?
8
V @
8
8
W =
8
>?
8
8
>D
>?
8
0
>?
6 <
L
?
D
F
8 E
V
?
W : *77 &A1Z
>?
;
<
4
:
4
K
>?
>?
K
8 >
>?
K
7
:
E
<
?
8
F
E
C
D
T
<
8
4
;
C
<
F
B
C
?
;
8
F
F
;
<
6
>
@
>D
F
D
C
>?
@
8
H6 F
E
4
F
<
4
H :
F
>?
>?
>D
F
4
8
>?
,
6<
<
4
8
F
0
6<
F
*
?
I
8
V
F
W
8
,
?
V
8
>?
>?
,
C
E
E ;
<
?
>D
<
8
E
W I F
6<
8
5 F
<
E
;
?
>D
;
8
8
H
8
<
8
>D
<K
>?
>?
<
<
8
4
<
0
?
8
>D
7
;
5
,
@
8
6
4
F
8
<
;
8
;
K
?
<
8
8
S
>?
<
<
?
?
< >D
<
@
E
F
>
C K
CV @
<
@
WF
0
8
>D
5
;
K
F
<
0
4
>
8
F
I
:
>?
8
< K
8
8
<
8
8
6
8
<
F
;
<
8
<
<
;E
?
>
6
0
<
E
>?
V<
W
8
K
>?
<
<
:
8 ;
F
>?
<
L
8
;
<
8
6
8
F
B
B =C
C
I
8
@
>?
>?
> 8
F
<
L
B :
6
8
8
>?
?
F
? 0
>
<
46
>?
?
F
L
8
F
?
<
6
8 >
E
, MI,
C7
7 !0 &"
#G &'" "%&9" = =C7 ) , <
1"#
F%&'"
;
!#0' "'&" ! 15! " 647&'" 09'!/2B!1 ! 101 9"
7
,
'
Z1
Z "%%Z
1%$
!, 7 , 091%&%8&230 " !/647&'" E!;! "%&-" 0
"1&7 &A##
&JN
!I5H ! ! 7 &%8"%&9H %A! !75
%A&'1 5 c Y f- ,
&AA"
C7
7
!9;!
0'&!;";!
&-&7 !
+I,, ,
= 0;!7" " &;";! 8 &%&4" ;0 #0;!70 J #0;!7"H!#, 7?
C
+C*
I
-
:
"1&7 7?
647&'01 90
!& 0
=
-
%&5&'&"7, "
!&0 #4&!9%!
"%%N
>?
&A11
&H&" ! 89&
+ I 7
NN0JN
5C _ I O =* , I + O +I,, ,
O
- 4
"%%1
1%"%8%0 " &;";! 0#!9%";0
7?
-I
, <
*
. ,
&AA1
1/"201
09%!#/0 " I
< 5 $J &AAN
!#0' "'&" ! " &9C#&'" ;" 15! " 647&'"
= .5 5C I
/*
"%%"
+ C,
<
0##89&%I "9; 01%#0;! 9&1# 9
&;";! 1/!%$'870
07F%&'"
H !I,: 7 ' & !&%0 ! !#0' "'&"
'
!
"%%$ [&AA"\
7"9!K"#!9%0 ! &%I
9% ! E"'%&'&;";! !
-
" L!%&9H
"g I
"7&;";!,
<
,
99999
8;"92" 1% 8%8 "7 ;" 15! " 647&'" 9-!1%&H"2B!1 M8"9%0 " 8#"
0'&!;";! 8 H8!1" "g
,
'
!
"%%$ [&AJ"\
"%!H0 &" ;"
99999
[&A#N\
+
&1'8 10 E&701N5&'0 ;"
0;! 9&;";!
H , IY = 09;&230 N1O 0;! 9"
7?
- I >D
3
&AA" [&A#A\
_ * H _'I 7 ` ,C7 :
=* , I + O +I,, ,
=
- 4
"%%1
: *77 :
91"&0 104 ! " $;&-"
:C*++I
C
I,
0 8#
=
#" !1P8&1" 04 ! "1
- :
&H!91 ;"
- 0'&070H&" ! 9% 0/070H&" 7?
-I
!-= > ? @
<
/
I
'
-,
=
-4
<
7C ,I7 I
8;&=9'&" 647&'" 90
N#
"%%" =
<
- b4 -//
"%%A
;#&9&1% "%&-0 '
/
/ E
0'!110
"
5C _ I O
O
-
"%%N
"N
&&0"$
*+ , "%%%
8
:
=
"A
<
-
5 <
6 &AAN
-//ccc
: ) !5!&%8 " 89&'&/"7 ;! 8 &%&4" =
"%
4
"%%A
87%8 "7
- I * &A1Z
&7AB!1 !# 9-!1%&#!9%01 - : )
"%%A
;
5
/
EG
d&1$Z% e
E"-0 ;" %90H "5&" ,
"%%%
8;"92"
#"H!# ;" &;";! ! 0 &-! !# 8 &%&4"
- 8 &%&4" ;0 #0;!70 J #0;!7"H!#, 7?
8 &%&4" ! 0 #&%0 ;" '&;";! #0;!70
&Z
I , 5C :
&2B!1 7?
0;!70 H09F1%&'0 ;! !#0' "'&" , < 7
2"#!9%0 " "
b4 -//ccc
"%%A
0:!
<
5 <
G d$&ZNe
/
J
- "$
7C*M 5 , 7"9!K"#!9%0
4"90 !#
/" %&7A" ;" '&;";! , <
7
8 &%&4" 1"4! %G'9&'0 '7"11&5&'"230 ;01 '&%";&901 !
&J
&%10&""
99999 !#0' "'&" " %&'&/"%&-" ! 07F%&'" 647&'" 90 09%!.%0
;"
&"92" ! ;0 ;07!1'!9%! ;! 8 &%&4"
I, ) UU
E
0 :. "%%$
I,
&;";"9&" ! 09% 07! 0'&"7
30O 1%"%"7 9" !50 #" ;0 1%";0 ,
- I,I ,
'
-+
YC*5. : 0#89&'"230 ! 0 8% 0 7G# ;"
!#0' "'&" Q0K! 0-01 !1"5&01 /" " " !0 &"
!
"%%&
!07&4! "7 0 '"10 ;0 091!7A0
I
5 C 7
! O ., * 5
>? . @
&AAA
!#0' "'&" !7&4! "%&-"
!#0' $%&'" !
-I
QI!I, : '090#&" ! 0'&!;";! E89;"#!9%01 ;" 0'&070H&"
*5! "%%% "%%A
?
647&'0
- 7C*M '
* <
0#/ !!91&-" !
-I