ACEF/1314/14397
Decisão de apresentação de pronúncia
ACEF/1314/14397
de pronúncia
Decisão de apresentação
Decisão de Apresentação de Pronúncia ao Relatório da
Comissão de Avaliação Externa
1. Tendo recebido o Relatório de Avaliação elaborado pela Comissão de Avaliação Externa
relativamente ao ciclo de estudos em funcionamento Engenharia Mecânica
2. conferente do grau de Licenciado
3. a ser leccionado na(s) Unidade(s) Orgânica(s) (faculdade, escola, instituto, etc.)
Escola Superior De Tecnologia E De Gestão De Bragança
4. a(s) Instituição(ões) de Ensino Superior / Entidade(s) Instituidora(s)
Instituto Politécnico De Bragança
5. decide: Apresentar pronúncia
6. Pronúncia (Português):
Exmos. Srs.,
Anexamos pronúncia ao relatório preliminar elaborado pela Comissão de Avaliação Externa,
solicitando a reanálise do processo e apresentando os argumentos que, em nosso entender,
justificam a acreditação do ciclo de estudos sem condições, por um período de 5 anos.
Com os melhores cumprimentos,
Luís Pais
Vice-Presidente do IPB
RIES
7. Pronúncia (Português e Inglês, PDF, máx. 100kB): (impresso na página seguinte)
pág. 1 de 1
Anexos
1234546789839ABC8DE273912BC7F74829893F739B98C7839DB248
9 9!76B4678D"289BF94#B4$82789%B6&4768
8963C89'"(B27329B9)B643C3#789B9*BD3
39+4D7D"D3913C7D,647639B9-28#848
1234567829ABCDE6D2FC2C5676E82C2C462F624EA6267E5E562FC2D888239E
2 C786D6A 2 6 2 DC78DE6 2 FC 2 8A68 87E86 2 F6 2 5E576 2 FC 2 C4AF64 2 FC 2 7E5C5E8AD8 2 C!
3C"8DE82#C5$E5828256 E562FC2C48D2825A!BDED26F642642BDC5CE642C5C44%DE64
B8D8 2 8 2 4A8 2 85DCFE86& 2 6!C8F8!CC 2 6 2 'AC 2 DC4BCE8 2 ( 2 56!B64E6 2 F6 2 56DB6
F65CC& 2 56)6D!C 2 C4EBA78F6 2 6 2 *C5DC6+CE 2 ,- 2 ../012.3& 2 FC 2 4 2 FC 2 8646& 2 C 2 6
F65A!C6 2 5678799 2 *3 2 :;1+<61=>9 2 *3 2 39991+ 2 *963?3 2 171 2 1
1673*1=>92*3266+992*3239;*99@&2 CD462.,.&2FC24CC!D62FC212.3&2C786D8F6
BC7821A5E82FC21 87E862C215DCFE862F6234E629ABCDE6D21339,
<6E& 2 B6D86& 2 56! 2 C6D!C 2 4ADBDC48 2 'AC 2 CDE)E5%!64 2 'AC 2 8 2 66!E446 2 FC 2 1 87E86
3BCD8261325657AEA2'AC25625E5762FC2C4AF642568256!256DB62F65CC2BDBDE62C2FC
856DF6 2 56! 2 64 2 DC'AE4E64 2 7C8E4 2 C! 2 CD!64 2 FC 2 C!CD6 2 FC 2 F6A6DC4& 2 !84 2 6 2 6
5DEDE62DC4BCE8C2(2C4BC5E87ED862F62!C4!6@,
EA78!642'AC28725657A462)E56A282FC CD4C2(42FC4E8FC428F68F842BC78239E
B8D82842%DC8425ECG)E5842F625E5762FC2C4AF642'AC&287256!62856C5C282CCD87EF8FC
F842E4EAEFC42FC2C4E624ABCDE6D&262A!256DDC4B6FA5E82FEDC8256!2842%DC842F8
67844E)E586 2 ?85E687 2 F84 2 HDC84 2 FC 2 3FA586 2 C 2 <6D!86 2 6?13<& 2 FC)EEF84 2 8
6D8DE8 2 ,- 2 1/I0122/& 2 FC 2 .I 2 FC 2 !8D6&2 'AC 2 8 2 1339 2 564EFCD82 8BD6BDE8F84 2 B8D82 8
FC)EE62F842%DC842FC2)6D!862)AF8!C8E42FC2A!25E5762FC2C4AF64,2
?6 2 F65A!C6 2 5678799 2 *3 2 :;1+<61=>9 2 *3 2 39991+ 2 *963?3 2 171 2 1
1673*1=>92*3266+992*3239;*99@&2 CD462.,.&2FC24CC!D62FC212.3&2821339
578DE)E56A 2 'AC 2 J46 2 5HDC84 2 FC 2 )6D!86 2 )AF8!C8E4 2 F6 2 5E576 2 FC 2 C4AF64@ 2 8'AC784
'AC&2FC2"8D!6E8256!28257844E)E586 2F842%DC842FC2CFA5862C2)6D!86 28BD6 8F8
BC7826D8DE82621/I0122/&2FC2.I2FC2!8D6&2DCBDC4C8!2BC762!C6421/K2F626872FC
5DFE6428DE623-&287GC82"&2F62*C5DC6+CE2-24L0122I&287CD8F62BC762*C5DC6+CE2../012.3&2FC242FC28646M&2!84&262CCFE!C62F8239E&28213392624ACDEA
'AC28424EAEFC4287CD844C!282C4DAAD825ADDE5A78D2F6424CA425AD464&26!C8F8!CC
842FC4E8FC42F842%DC8425ECG)E5842C2828D8A5E82FC4842!C4!842%DC84,
?6C4C2'AC&262)6D!A7%DE62F821339&2B8D824A!E4462F62DC78DE62FC28A68 87E862FC
A! 2 5E576 2 FC 2 C4AF64& 2 6 2 )8D 2 'A87'ACD 2 DC)CDA5E8 2 8 2 %DC84 2 6?13<&2 8 2 6 2 4CD 2 84
'AC4FC421,4257844E)E5862F842%DC842BDE5EB872C24C5AF%DE842F625E5762FC2C4AF64,21
39E 2 EFE56A& 2 578D8!CC& 2 8 2 'AC46 2 1,4,.& 2 8 2 %DC8 2 6?13< 2 5/1.#C87ADE8 2 C
!C876!C5$E58@&2 'AC 2 2 6 E8!CC 2 8 2 %DC8 2 FC 2 )6D!86 2 )AF8!C87 2 F6 2 5E576 2 FC
C4AF64& 2 C 2 7E!E6A4C 2 8 2 A48D 2 %DC84 2 5ECG)E584 2 56! 2 FC4E8FC4 2 56 C5E68E4 2 84
'AC4FC421.3,L2%DC8425ECG)E5842C25DFE642'AC2FC C!24CD2DCAEF642B8D82826C6
F6 2D8A& 2 1.L 2 B786 2 FC 2 C4AF64& 2L,.,. 2)E5"84 2 5ADDE5A78DC4 2F64 2 F65CC4 2 C 2 L,.,1
C'AEB82F65CC2F625E5762FC2C4AF64,2?62'AC2DC4BCE82(42%DC8425ECG)E5842F625AD46&
)6D8!2EFE58F8428'AC7842'AC25648!2F82B6D8DE82FC25DE862F625AD46&2C'A862'AC&
B8D82842%DC842F842"8E7E8FC42858F!E5842F642F65CC4&2)6D8!2EFE58F8428'AC7842'AC
5648!26424CA425CDE)E58F642FC2"8E7E8FC4,
9C2)EDCD!6428256DDC4B6FA5E82CDC2842%DC8425ECG)E5842EFE58F842BC78239E284
'AC4FC421.3,L2C21.L2C2842%DC8426?13<&256)6D!C28BDC4C8F62828C782.24CAEC&
B6FCDC!64 2 56488D 2 'AC 2 8 2 %DC8 2 6?13< 2 5/1.#C87ADE8 2 C 2 !C876!C5$E58@
1
56!BDCCFC2..L25DFE642369,266!6287&24CD%2C48282%DC82)AF8!C872F625E5762FC
C4AF64&256)6D!C2FC)EEF62827CE47862C2B64CDE6D!CC24E4C!8ED8F62BC7821339,
8C782.2266DDC4B6FA5E82CDC2%DC8425ECG)E5842EFE58F842BC78239E256!2826?13<
HDC826ECG)E58239E
HDC826?13<
6DFE642369
37CDE582C21A6!86
/1337CDE582C28A6!86
I
#C5$E582F642<7AGF642C2NEFD%A7E58
/1.#C87ADE82C2!C876!C5$E58
.1
#C5$E582F64297EF642C234DAAD84
/1.#C87ADE82C2!C876!C5$E58
3I
CD!6FE$!E582C2D65C44642D!E564
/1.#C87ADE82C2!C876!C5$E58
.O
664DAFC42#C5$E584
/1.#C87ADE82C2!C876!C5$E58
L1
D6PC6
/1.#C87ADE82C2!C876!C5$E58
I
<G4E58
LL.<G4E58
C46
3L/C462C28F!EE4D86
I
)6D!%E58
LO.6EA5E842E)6D!%E584
I
#8C!%E58
LI2#8C!%E582C2C48G4E58
:AG!E58
LL1:AG!E58
.1
32
I
9C262!C4!62CBCD5G5E62)6D2C)CA8F62B8D82842%DC8425ECG)E5842EFE58F842842'AC4FC4
L,.,.2C2L,.,1&256)6D!C28BDC4C8F62828C782124CAEC&2B6FCDC!6428EF8256488D
'AC 2 41K 2 F64 2 F65CC4 2 F6 2 5E576 2 FC 2 C4AF64 2 4C 2 C'A8FD8! 2 8 2 %DC8 2 6?13< 2 5/1.
#C87ADE82C2!C876!C5$E58@2C2'AC282!8E6D2B8DC2FC4C42F65CC42B644AE262D8A2FC
*6A6D,23!2565DC6&2FC2CDC2642.O2F65CC42EFE58F64&2..2I.K2462*6A6DC42F8
%DC82)AF8!C872F625E5762FC2C4AF64,
8C78212266DDC4B6FA5E82F842%DC8425ECG)E5842FC258F82F65CC256!2826?13<
*65CC
*6A6D
HDC826ECG)E58
HDC826?13<
68D764217CD6276FDEAC421FD8FC
9E!
3,2#C5$E58
/1.#C,2C2!C876!C5$E58
37D82#8DE82#6D8E42<64C58
9E!
3,2#C5$E58
/1.#C,2C2!C876!C5$E58
9DE62#8AC72FC296A4827648
9E!
3C"8DE8
/1.#C,2C2!C876!C5$E58
68D7642E6DC2F82765"828748
9E!
6EA5E842F823,
/1.#C,2C2!C876!C5$E58
3FEC2#8DE4266DFCED6
9E!
H7CD8
LI2#8C!%E582C2C48G4E58
7AE217CD62#8FCED82#85CF62FC2+E!8
9E!
3C"8DE8
/1.#C,2C2!C876!C5$E58
+AG42#EAC7268 87CED62:ACEP6
9E!
3,2#C5$E58
/1.#C,2C2!C876!C5$E58
E6421,2FC268D 87"62687 C4
9E!
3,237CD6,266!BA,
/1337CDE582C28A6!86
8A76217CB8FDC2687 C42E766
9E!
3,2#C5$E58
/1.#C,2C2!C876!C5$E58
2
8A762*A8DC2<CDDCED826A CE8
9E!
#8C!%E58
LI2#8C!%E582C2C48G4E58
E662F82765"82C29E7 8
?6
3,2#C5$E58
/1.#C,2C2!C876!C5$E58
+AG42#8AC72<DQ727ECED6
9E!
3,2#C5$E58
/1.#C,2C2!C876!C5$E58
R87FC!8D278A7278!6428D5E8
9E!
#C5$E582F642<7AEF64
/1.#C,2C2!C876!C5$E58
E6623FA8DF62E62684D627ECED6
9E!
3,2#C5$E58
/1.#C,2C2!C876!C5$E58
#8DE82678D827,2C62R8D2<CD8FC4
9E!
3,2FA4DE87
/1.#C,2C2!C876!C5$E58
+AG42#8AC727ECED62#C4'AE8
?6
3,2#C5$E58
/1.#C,2C2!C876!C5$E58
*6D827,2FC29,2#858P62<CDDCED8
9E!
3C"8DE826E E7
/O1664,25E E72C2C,25E E7
+AG42#8AC7217 C4
?6
6EA5E842F8266!BA,
LO.6EA5E842E)6D!%E584
CF6 2 C! 2 568 2 C4C 2 C4578DC5E!C6& 2 DC78E 8!CC 2 86 2 56DB6 2 F65CC 2 F6 2 5AD46& 2 8
39E2564EFCD82'AC2625E5762FC2C4AF642FC27E5C5E8AD82C!23C"8DE82#C5$E58
FC C24CD285DCFE8F62B6D25E562864,
3
1234567891A78B73CD69E4FD539E4DC645
19945449C694 76C78916C6445C6
123456277847941362A787BC4DAE4FDADB33A479423478C362A64A34794DBDAD
51 4 3E 4 23 4 389D33A 4 3 7 4 97 4 23 4 F362DA6D8 4 ABA33AB
EC46C6834A423467A!67A42D4498984D884234 363 4A33E3E4974D663ED7A"
D68D8C4D43BDE423467 77A47942343D62AB4D99"4D4 8D3E4A4#3633
$D%4A7&4''()*+',4794-4.B"4DAE4A4234E763A4/03D497413D62341D896D7A
9745EC40C6834.663ED7A/"4!37A4'&'"453 334*+',"4 3 D3E4C4234.B3A6C
974.33A4DAE4.663ED7A47942B234E6D7A4.,5&
4%D42339734%24B3D4 342D4%34A73E42D423433AD84!D8D7A4DA38
0.467A68E3E42D44234EC46C68342D447%A43D62AB4D994A4D667EDA6347423
83BD843533A4A434794A347942#"44A74D667EAB4748D%43533A
3BDEAB4 36D86D7A7&
834383!342D42467A687A4%D4E34742734E3BAD7A4DE7 3E4C451
7423463A964D3D4794234EC46C68342D"4D42D 3A4A4742B2343E6D7A
A7A"42D!34A74E364673 7AE3A634%24234D3D47942349D7AD8408D96D7A
79 4 E6D7A 4 DAE 4 1DAAB 4 .3D 4 09.:" 4 D 4 E39A3E4 A 4 ;E3 4 A7& 4 *(<)*++( 4 79 4 '<
FD62" 4 %262 4 .,5 4 67AE3 4 D 7 D3 4 97 4 23 4 E39A7A 4 79 4 23 4 9AED3AD8
3E6D7A4D3D4794D4EC46C683&
A 4 23 4 E763A 4 /03D 4 97 4 13D623 4 1D896D7A 4 97 4 5EC 4 0C683 4 .663ED7A/"
!37A4'&'"453 334*+',"4.,5468D93E42D4=79AED3AD84DAAB4D3D479423
EC 4 6C683/ 4 D3 4 273 4 2D" 4 A 4 D667EDA63 4 %2 4 23 4 68D96D7A 4 79 4 3E6D7A 4 DAE
DAAB4D3D4D 7!3E4C4;E34A7&4*(<)*++(4794'<4FD62"43 33A4D483D4*(>479
7D84015463E4.6834,"4 DDBD 2424794#3633$D%4A7&4-?)*++<"4D4D3AE3E4C
#3633$D% 4 A7& 4 ''()*+', 4 79 4 - 4 .B@" 4 " 4 D667EAB 4 7 4 23 4 AE3DAEAB 4 79
51" 4 .,5 4 EE 4 A7 4 BB33E 4 2D 4 23 4 A7A 4 278E 4 D83 4 23 4 668D
634794234EC46C683"4A68EAB4E36 7A479463A964D3D4DAE423467 3
7942334D34D3D&
97342D4234.,549743E49747A4794234389D33A43 74794D4EC
6C683"4DA34A743933A6347409.:4D3D"4A834A4537A4.&-468D96D7A479
DC4 DAE 4 367AEDC 4 D3D4 79 4 23 4 6C683& 4 51 4 683D8C 4 AE6D3E 4 A 4 537A
.&-&' 4 23 4 09.: 4 D3D 4 /(*'F3D88BC 4 DAE 4 3D8%7A/" 4 %262 4 4 7!78C 4 23
9AED3AD8 4 DAAB 4 D3D 4 79 4 23 4 EC 4 6C683" 4 DAE 4 3E 4 63A96 4 D3D 4 %2
67A!3A7AD84E3BAD7A4A4537A4.',&?463A964D3D4DAE463E42D443
7DA3E439734D4E3B3344D%DE3E"4.'?4EC4 8DA"4?&'&'4668D4367E479
3D6234DAE4?&'&*4EC46C683B4D6DE364D99&4:7423463A964D3D4794234EC
6C683"4%343E42347A342D4D 3D4A4234;E3479463D7A4794234EC46C683"4%283
974234D3D4794D6DE3645D896D7A47943D623"4%343E42347A342D4D 3D4A
234D6DE3646396D3&
9 4 %3 4 DA3 4 23 4 673 7AE3A63 4 3%33A 4 63A96 4 D3D 4 AE6D3E 4 C 4 51 4 A
537A4.',&?4DAE4.'?4DAE409.:4D3D"4D427%A4A41D834'4387%"4%346DA433
2D423409.:4D3D44(*'F3D88BC4DAE43D8%7A7467 34''?4015463E&4A
24%DC"42442349AED3AD84D3D4794234EC46C683"4D4E39A3E4A423483B8D7A
DAE48D34C3D63E4C4.,5&
1
1D834'44073 7AE3A6343%33A451463A964D3D4DAE409.:4D3D
514563A964.3D
09.:4.3D
015403E
8367A64DAE4.7D7A
(*,8367A64DAE4D7D7A
<
:8E4F362DA64DAE42CED86
(*'F3D88BC4DAE43D8%7A
'*
578E4F362DA64DAE4563
(*'F3D88BC4DAE43D8%7A
,<
1237ECAD64DAE4123D847633
(*'F3D88BC4DAE43D8%7A
'C
F362DA6D8407A67A
(*'F3D88BC4DAE43D8%7A
?*
7D36
(*'F3D88BC4DAE43D8%7A
<
2C6
??'2C6
FDADB33A
,?(FDADB33A4DAE4DEAD7A
<
A97D6
?C'07 3463A63
<
FD23D6
?<+FD23D64DAE4D6
023C
??*023C
'*
,+
<
94234D343336344 3973E497423463A964D3D427%A4A4537A4?&'&'4DAE
?&'&*"4D427%A4A41D834*4387%"4%346DA43342D4-*>47942343D6234794234EC
6C683494A74234(*'409.:4D3D4DAE42D4234DD7C479427343D6234D342#
278E3&45 3696D88C"4D7AB4234'C4AE6D3E43D623"4''4<'>4D342#4278E3479
234A3C4D3D4794234EC46C683&
1D834*44073 7AE3A6343%33A423463A964D3D47943D6243D6234DAE409.:
13D623
2#
563A964.3D
09.:4.3D
0D874.8374E7EB34.AEDE3
F3
F362DA6D84ABA33AB (*'F3D88BC4DAE43D8%7A
86D4FDD4F7D4:7A36D
F3
F362DA6D84ABA33AB (*'F3D88BC4DAE43D8%7A
5GB74FDA384E3457D4E7D
F3
ABA33AB
(*'F3D88BC4DAE43D8%7A
0D874H7B34ED4E762D4D8D
F3
ABA33AB4563A63
(*'F3D88BC4DAE43D8%7A
E34FDA407E37
F3
.8B3D
?<+FD23D64DAE4D6
E4.8374FDE3D4FD63E74E34$D
F3
ABA33AB
(*'F3D88BC4DAE43D8%7A
$I4FB3840D!D837413D7
F3
F362DA6D84ABA33AB (*'F3D88BC4DAE43D8%7A
H7G4.&4E340D!D82747AD8!3
F3
83&4DAE407 &4AB&
D874.833DAE347AD8!34877
F3
F362DA6D84ABA33AB (*'F3D88BC4DAE43D8%7A
D874#D34:33D47!3D
F3
FD23D6
H7J74ED4E762D43458!D
97
F362DA6D84ABA33AB (*'F3D88BC4DAE43D8%7A
$I4FDA384:K8GA4E37
F3
F362DA6D84ABA33AB (*'F3D88BC4DAE43D8%7A
(*,8367A64DAE4D7&
?<+FD23D64DAE4D6
2
LD8E3D4ED84ED74D6D
F3
:8E4F362DA6
(*'F3D88BC4DAE43D8%7A
H7J74EDE74A740D74E37
F3
F362DA6D84ABA33AB (*'F3D88BC4DAE43D8%7A
FDD408DD4E&43A74LD64:3ADAE3
F3
AED84ABA33AB
$I4FDA384E374F35D
97
F362DA6D84ABA33AB (*'F3D88BC4DAE43D8%7A
#G7D4E&4E345&4FD6DAD74:33D
F3
0!84ABA33AB
(C*07A&4DAE46!843AB&
$I4FDA384.8!3
97
07 34563A63
?C'07 3463A63
(*'F3D88BC4DAE43D8%7A
1DAAB4A74D667A4234 7!E3E468D96D7A4A438D7A47 4234EC46C68343D62AB
D99"451467AE342D4234EC46C6834A4F362DA6D84ABA33AB4278E43
D663E3E49749!34C3D&
3