VALORAÇÃO MONETÁRIA DE DANOS AMBIENTAIS:
EXPERIÊNCIAS NA ZONA COSTEIRA, FERRAMENTAS E COMENTÁRIOS
!"!#$%&!'(('")*+,'--.
Roberto Varjabedian
Introdução
"
#$%! &'()*+,-%! .-&/01-,%! 2%! #/-3-4%567! 2%!
8'11%$'+/%! 2%! 9%371%567! $7+'/:1-%! 2'!
danos ambientais, seria interessante listar
%3;#+&! 27&! '9'+/7&! $%-&! -$<71/%+/'&!
7,711-27&! +%&! 2=,%2%&! 2'! >?@ABCA! +%&!
47+%&!,7&/'-1%!'!$%1-+.%!27!D,'%+7!E/3F+/-,7G!-+,3#-+27!
H#17<%G! E$=1-,%! 27! "71/'G! I%1-J'! '! E$=1-,%! 27! K#3L!
M711'N! I%+N7+G! E$7,7! I%2-4! '! O7'! I737,7/17+-G! <%1%!
,-/%1! %<'+%&! %3;#+&P! D&! $=/727&! '! /=,+-,%&! 2'! /1%J%3.7!
'$<1';%27&! '$! ,%2%! ,%&7! +'$! &'$<1'! '&/-9'1%$!
%,'&&Q9'-&G! <1-+,-<%3$'+/'! &'! ,7+&-2'1%$7&! (#'! %&!
ocorrências datam de um período que antecedeu aos
$'-7&! '3'/1R+-,7&P! E! $Q2-%G! +7! '+/%+/7G! -+,#$J-#S&'! 2'!
2-9#3;%1!7&!,%&7&G!2'&/%,%+27!&7J1'/#27!7&!<1'T#Q47&!,7$!
<'12%&!2'!&'19-57&!%$J-'+/%-&!'!2%+7&!U!<%-&%;'$P
;1%+2'&!(#%+/-2%2'&!2'!03'7!X.-217,%1J7+'/7&YP!I.%$%9%!
%!%/'+567!7!/'$<7!'$!(#'!<1%-%&!'!,7&/Z'&!,7+/-+#%9%$!
,.'-7&! 2'! 03'7! 'G! (#%+/7! %7&! &'1'&! 9-97&! 2'! $%-71! <71/'G!
%&!%9'&!,%$J%3'%+/'&!'!$71-J#+2%&!+67!2'-[%9%$!(#'!%&!
/1%;=2-%&!87&&'$!'&(#',-2%&P
K-$#3/%+'%$'+/'G! ,-'+/-&/%&! '1%$! -+&/%27&! %! ,7+/1-J#-1!
2'!%3;#$%!871$%!<%1%!&'+&-J-3-4%1!%/71'&!&7,-%-&!'!%;'+/'&!
;79'1+%$'+/%-&! <%1%! %! +','&&-2%2'! 2%! ,7+&'19%567! 27&!
1',#1&7&!+%/#1%-&G!,7$7!%!:;#%G!J'+&!,7+&-2'1%27&!V+-/7&!
'!+67!1'+79:9'-&P!E!<1'&&67!27&!;'&/71'&!%$J-'+/%-&!2%&!
47+%&! ,7&/'-1%&G! <1-+,-<%3$'+/'! 2%! E$=1-,%! 27! "71/'G!
<%&&7#!%!87$'+/%1!%!'&/1#/#1%567!2'!<17T'/7&!'&<',QV,7&!
<%1%! 37;1%1! #$%! $'/72737;-%! ,%<%4! 2'! /1%+&871$%1!
1',#1&7&! +%/#1%-&! -$<%,/%27&! '$! 9%371! $7+'/:1-7P!
I.';%9%S&'!%7!2-3'$%L!9%371!'!<1'57P!D!(#'!+%!1'%3-2%2'!
D!-$<%,/7!9-&#%3!2%&!87/7;1%V%&!'!2%&!V3$%;'+&!,1-7#!+%! '&/%1-%$!,%3,#3%+27!&'1-%!%<'+%&!7!<1'57!2'!%3;7!<'12-27G!
,7$#+-2%2'G! /%+/7! 3'-;%! ,7$7! ,-'+/QV,%G! %! +','&&-2%2'! T%$%-&!7!9%371!27!1',#1&7P
2'! &'! <1'<%1%1! <%1%! '9-/%1! +79%&! ,%/:&/178'&P! W$%! 2%&!
formas seria criar um tipo de multa pecuniária pelos "67!/%127#!<%1%!(#'!'9'+/7&!7,711-27&!+%!,7&/%!J1%&-3'-1%!
2%+7&! ,%#&%27&! +67! &0! %7&! <'&,%271'&G! ,7$7! /%$J=$! /%$J=$! 7,#<%&&'$! '&<%57&! +%! $Q2-%G! %3'1/%+27! <%1%!
%7&! <10<1-7&! 1',#1&7&! +%/#1%-&! 27&! 3-/71%-&! %/-+;-27&! <71! o fato de que o aumento no consumo mundial de
50 !MPMG Jurídico Especial
.-217,%1J7+'/7&G! &7J1',%11';%+27! %&! 17/%&! $%1Q/-$%&G!
,.';%1%! %7&! +7&&7&! <71/7&P! I7$! 3';-&3%567! %$J-'+/%3!
%9%+5%2%G! .%9-%! J%&'! 3';%3! <%1%! $#+-,-%1! %5Z'&! (#'!
9-'&&'$! %! <17<71! %! 1',#<'1%567! 27&! J'+&! 3'&%27&P!
\-9Q%$7&!-+/'+&%$'+/'!7&!<1-$'-17&!2-%&!2%!]'-!^'2'1%3!
+P_! @P?`aG! 2'! `>! 2'! %;7&/7! 2'! >?a>G! ,7$! %! -+&/-/#-567! 2%!
b73Q/-,%!"%,-7+%3!27!c'-7!E$J-'+/'P!E!1';#3%$'+/%567!2%!
3'-!'$!>?a`!;%1%+/-%!&#%!-$'2-%/%!%<3-,%567!X%1/P!>dG!-+,-&7!
e\G!f!>_YG!J%&/%+27!7!+'[7!,%#&%3!<%1%!%<#1%1!7!9%371!2%!
-+2'+-4%567!7#!2%!1'<%1%567!27&!2%+7&!,%#&%27&!%7!$'-7!
%$J-'+/'!'!%!/'1,'-17&G!%8'/%27&!<71!&#%!%/-9-2%2'P!I7$!%!
<17$#3;%567!2%!]'-!^'2'1%3!+P_!CCP`dCG!2'!gd!2'!T#3.7!2'!
>?ahG!2-&,-<3-+%+27!%!%567!,-9-3!<iJ3-,%!2'!1'&<7+&%J-3-2%2'!
por danos causados ao meio ambiente, ao consumidor e
%7! <%/1-$R+-7! ,#3/#1%3G! V,%9%! ,%1%,/'1-4%2%! %! V;#1%! 27&!
J'+&! 2-8#&7&G! &#1;-+27! %! <7&&-J-3-2%2'! 2'! %/1-J#-1! <'+%!
contra atores de danos que lesem o bem comum, no qual
%!9Q/-$%!=!2-8#&%P
Danos ambientais na zona costeira
D!,%&7!27!+%9-7!jO7'!I737,7/17+-kG!,#T7!9%4%$'+/7!2'!03'7!
7,711'#!+7!V+%3!2%!2=,%2%!2'!>?CA!+7!I%1-J'G!%/-+;-+27!%!
<%1/'!&#27'&/'!2%!e3.%!2'!b71/7!l-,7G!'$J71%!&'$!;1%+2'!
,7J'1/#1%! <'3%! $Q2-%! -+/'1+%,-7+%3G! 87-! &';#-27! <'3%!
,7$#+-2%2'!,-'+/QV,%G!U!2-&/F+,-%G!'$!;1%+2'!<%1/'!27!1-/7!
/1%+&,711-27!+%!,71/'!2%(#'3'!H&/%27!]-91'!E&&7,-%27!27&!
H&/%27&!W+-27&!2%!E$=1-,%P!M%39'4!/'+.%!&-27!%!<1-$'-1%!
9'4! '$! (#'! %! :1'%! %8'/%2%! ,7+/%&&'! ,7$! -$<1'&&-7+%+/'!
J%+,7!2'!2%27&!,-'+/QV,7&G!<'1$-/-+27!%,-11%27&!2'J%/'&!
/=,+-,7&! %7! 37+;7! 27! <17,'&&7! 3'9%27! %! '8'-/7! '+/1'! %!
&';#1%271%!27!+%9-7G!7!]7N2&!2%!e+;3%/'11%G!'!7!;79'1+7!
2'!b71/7!l-,7P!"%!=<7,%G!T:!+%!2=,%2%!2'!>?aAG!7&!<'1-/7&!27!
;79'1+7!2'!b71/7!l-,7!V4'1%$!#&7!2%!/=,+-,%!2'!9%371%567!
<'3%!&#J&/-/#-567!27&!1',#1&7&!<'12-27&G!'&<=,-'&!%+-$%-&G!
9';'/%-&!'!7!<10<1-7!&#J&/1%/7!-$<1';+%27!<'37!03'7G!<'37!
9%371! 2'! +797&! '3'$'+/7&! '$! &#J&/-/#-567! U(#'3'&! 2%&!
:1'%&! %8'/%2%&P! D! $=/727! +67! ,7+9'+,'#! 7&! 7<'1%271'&!
27!2-1'-/7!'!<%&&7#S&'!%!%,7$<%+.%1!7!3'+/7!'!/1%#$:/-,7!
<17,'&&7!2'!1'&/%#1%567!27&!$%+;#'4%-&!2'!m%.Q%!K#,-%P
H['$<37!2'&&%!&-/#%567!=!7!,%&7!27!17$<-$'+/7!27!2#/7!
2%! b'/17J1:&G! +%! %3/#1%! 27! I%+%3! 2'! m'1/-7;%! XKbYG! (#'G!
'$J71%! 7,711-27! %7&! >d! 2'! 7#/#J17! 2'! >?a`G! /*$! &#%&!
,7+&'(#*+,-%&!<%&&Q9'-&!2'!$7+-/71%$'+/7!%/=!7&!2-%&!2'!
.7T'G!,7$7!%!<1'&'+5%!2'!03'7!+7!&'2-$'+/7!27!$%+;#'4%3!
27! l-7! e1-1-P! "'&&'&! ,%&7&G! %<'+%&! 2%+7&! %;#27&! %,%J%$!
&'+27! ,%1%,/'1-4%27&! <71! 7,%&-67! 27&! 3%#27&! <'1-,-%-&G!
8%/7!(#'!%$<3-%!%-+2%!$%-&!7!9%371!1'%3!27!2%+7!%$J-'+/%3!
2%(#'3'! %<#1%27! <71! (#%3(#'1! 2%&! /=,+-,%&! (#'! <7&&%$!
&'1!'$<1';%2%&!'$!,%2%!,%&7P
E(#-! +7! m1%&-3G! $%-&! <1',-&%$'+/'! +7! H&/%27! 2'! K67!
b%#37G! 7! c-+-&/=1-7! biJ3-,7! '&/%2#%3! %,7$<%+.%9%! 7&!
acontecimentos mundiais em termos de auditoria sobre
2%+7&! %$J-'+/%-&G! (#%+27! 7! '9'+/7! %,-$%! $'+,-7+%27!
$7/-97#!-+-,-%3!%7!n#2-,-:1-7!2'!K%+/7&!XKbYG!%!V$!2'!(#'!
87&&'! -+&/%#1%2%! \-&/71-% Ad Perpetuam Rei Memoriam,
$'2-2%!,%#/'3%1!%+/',-<%/01-%!2'!<179%!<%1%!,%1%,/'1-4%567!
'!%9%3-%567!27&!2%+7&!%7!$'-7!%$J-'+/'P!I7$7!<%1/'!27&!
(#'&-/7&! 78'1/%27&G! 3:! '&/%9%! 7! (#'! -+2%;%9%! %,'1,%! 27!
9%371! 27&! 2%+7&! <719'+/#1%! .%9-27&! &7J1'! 7! %$J-'+/'P!
"%(#'3%! 7,%&-67G! 8#-! +7$'%2%! b'1-/%! n#2-,-%3! <'37! ccP!
n#-4!2'!p-1'-/7!2%!>q!\%1%!IQ9'3!2%!I7$%1,%!2'!K%+/7&!r!
b17,P!g`a`Ba`G!9-+27!%!&'1!<'1-/%!+%!7,%&-67!2%!<1-$'-1%!
%<3-,%567!2%!]'-!^'2'1%3!+P_!@P?`aBa>P
O tempo passou e muitos foram os laudos periciais que se
'+,7+/1%9%$!,7$!7!$'&$7!(#'&-/7L!js#%-&!%&!2'&<'&%&!'!
7&!/1%J%3.7&!+','&&:1-7&!<%1%!%!1'<%1%567!2'&&'!2%+7tk!E!
+','&&-2%2'!27!%/'+2-$'+/7!%7&!(#'&-/7&G!,7$7!/%$J=$!
%! +','&&-2%2'G! %-+2%! $%-&! #1;'+/'G! 2'! %<#1%1! 9%371'&!
$7+'/:1-7&! %! &'1'$! ,7J1%27&! <'37&! 2%+7&! +%! /'+/%/-9%!
2'!-+/-$-2%1!7&!-+81%/71'&!$7/-97#!%!,1-%567G!+7!,7+/'[/7!
do nosso próprio laboratório, de equipe de estudantes
;1%2#%27&! <%1%! <7&&Q9'-&! &73#5Z'&! %7! <17J3'$%! 2%!
9%371%567!',7+R$-,%P!H&/%9%!,3%17!(#'!%7!1'&<7+2'1$7&!
(#'! juPPPv! 7&! <1'T#Q47&! &67! 2'! $7+/%G! +67! <'1$-/-+27!
contudo serem calculados os danos causados ao meio
%$J-'+/'P!D!<17J3'$%!'$!(#'&/67!<72'1:!&'1!'(#%,-7+%27!
<71! 9-%! 2'! #$! 7<71/#+7! %1J-/1%$'+/7G! (#%+27! &'1-%$!
calculadas as despesas com base nos custos estimados
Parece que o insucesso na cobrança de pelo menos parte 27!+i$'17!2'!%+7&!(#'!3'9%1-%!%!:1'%!<%1%!1',#<'1%1S&'G!
27&! <1'T#Q47&! %$J-'+/%-&! 27! jO7'! I737,7/17+-k! -+2#4-#! ,7+&-2'1%+27!uPPPvkG!%<'+%&!1'$'/Q%$7&!<%1%!#$!8#/#17!%!
%! (#'! +7&! H&/%27&! W+-27&! 2%! E$=1-,%! 87&&'$! ,1-%27&! +','&&-2%2'!2'!'+81'+/%$'+/7!27!<17J3'$%P
;1#<7&!2'!/1%J%3.7!-+/'12-&,-<3-+%1'&G!+7!F$J-/7!8'2'1%3G!
<%1%! J#&,%1! 801$#3%&! (#'! &'! %<17[-$%&&'$! 27&! ,#&/7&! b172#4-$7&! 9:1-7&! 27,#$'+/7&G! &'$<1'! +%! /'+/%/-9%! 2'!
monetários das perdas ambientais e que, ao mesmo '&/%J'3','1! /=,+-,%! $%-&! %2'(#%2%! <%1%! ,%2%! ,%&7G! #$%!
/'$<7G!%/'+2'&&'$!%&!'[<',/%/-9%&!2'!#$!n#2-,-:1-7!(#'! 9'4!(#'!,3%17!'&/%9%!(#'!+67!.%9'1-%!#$%!i+-,%!801$#3%!
,%<%4! 2'! (#%+/-V,%1! /727! '! (#%3(#'1! 2%+7! %$J-'+/%3!
&'!-+-,-%9%!+7!j2-1'-/7!%$J-'+/%3kP
XKIwEH^^HlS"D\H]]eG!>??go!xlEKKD!y!KIwEH^^HlS
E! 3-+;#%;'$! #/-3-4%2%! <'37&! 7<'1%271'&! 27! 2-1'-/7! "D\H]]eG!>??do!MDx"H]]E!y!KIwEH^^HlS"D\H]]eG!
+','&&-/%! 2'! -$%;'+&! 2'&,1-/%&! +7! F$J-/7! 27! <1'/7! '! 27! >??do! xlEKKDG! >??do! MDx"H]]EG! >??ho! xlEKKD! et alPG!
branco, enquanto que os laudos periciais dos peritos >??ho! KIwEH^^HlS"D\H]]eG! >??@G>??CG>???o! xlEKKD!
%$J-'+/%-&G!+7!$'3.71!2%&!.-<0/'&'&G!,.';%$!%!#$!;1%#!2'! y!KIwEH^^HlS"D\H]]eG!>???o!MDx"H]]ESpHSlDKEG!
,-+4%!'&,#17!7#!2'!,-+4%!$#-/7!,3%17P!H&&'!2-:37;7!'[-;-%! gAAAo!xlEKKDG!gAAAo!bDOeS"HMDG!gAA>YP
/'[/7&!$%-&!37+;7&!+%!/'+/%/-9%!2'!78'1/%1!7!,7+9'+,-$'+/7!
+','&&:1-7!%7&!T#Q4'&!2'!2-1'-/7!<71!7,%&-67!27!T#3;%$'+/7! /!-+"!01+#2+3'45".!#6#"'-!4+#7'#'89'".:3%.!;
2%&! %5Z'&! (#'! '+9739-%$! 2%+7&! %$J-'+/%-&P! E2'$%-&G!
'&&'&!2%+7&!+'$!&'$<1'!&'!<17,'&&%$!2'!871$%!-$'2-%/%o! I%1'+/'&!2'!/1%J%3.7&!+7!F$J-/7!+%,-7+%3G!-+-,-%$7&!<71!
+%! $%-71-%! 27&! ,%&7&G! %&! <'12%&! 967! &'! $%+-8'&/%+27! %7! #$!3'9%+/%$'+/7!'[/'+&-97!2%!J-J3-7;1%V%!-+/'1+%,-7+%3!
37+;7!27&!%+7&G!+67!&'+27!<7&&Q9'3!&#%!/7/%3!(#%+/-V,%567! (#'!/1%/%9%!2%!9%371%567!',7+R$-,%!2'!2%+7&!%$J-'+/%-&!
-$<7&/7&! %! %$J-'+/'&! ,7&/'-17S$%1-+.7&P! W$! +797!
&'+67!$'2-%+/'!$7+-/71%$'+/7!<71!2=,%2%&P
MPMG Jurídico Especial !51
$7+'/:1-7&G!%!V$!2'!(#'!%!I#1%271-%!27!c'-7!E$J-'+/'G!
%7!'+/1%1!,7$!%!%567!,-9-3!<iJ3-,%G!T:!<7&&%!<17<71!7!9%371!
2'! -+2'+-4%567! <'37! 2%+7! ,%#&%27P! E! <7&&-J-3-2%2'! 2'!
2'V+-1!7&!/-<7&!2'!2%+7&!'!7&!,1-/=1-7&!2'!(#%3-V,%567!27&!
%;1%97&!X%!#$!,711'&<7+2'+/'!+#$=1-,7!(#'!9%1-%!2'!A!%!
`Y!/71+%!'&&%!8'11%$'+/%!$%-&!%2'(#%2%!<%1%!,%1%,/'1-4%1G!
1%47%9'3$'+/'G! 7&! 2-8'1'+/'&! ;1%#&! 2'! -$<%,/7! &781-27&!
por cada um dos recursos ambientais constituintes do
p'+/1'! %3;#+&! 27&! <172#/7&! 2%! =<7,%G! 2'&/%,%$S&'! ,.%$%27!meio ambienteG!,7$7!8%#+%G!z71%G!%1G!&737G!&#J&737P
7&! 27,#$'+/7&! <172#4-27&! <'3%! National Oceanic and
Atmospheric AdministrationS"DEEG! 27! p'<%1/%$'+/7! 2'!
I7$=1,-7!27&!H&/%27&!W+-27&!2%!E$=1-,%G!%7!2-9#3;%1'$G!
(#-5:G! %&! <1-$'-1%&! ,73'/F+'%&! &7J1'! 7! #&7! 2%! %+:3-&'!
',7+R$-,%! +%! 9%371%567! 2'! 2%+7&! %! 1',#1&7&! +%/#1%-&!
XAssessing the social costs of oil spills: the Amoco Cadiz case
studyG!>?a`G!' The use of economic analysis in valuing natural
resource damagesG! >?adYP! E! '&&'&! 27,#$'+/7&! &7$%9%S
&'! <172#/7! 2'! {%+;! et alP! X>?adYG! 27! Environmental Law
Institute!2'!|%&.-+;/7+G!pPIP
problema apareceu: esse tipo de produção não se
'+,7+/1%9%! ,7$7! /1%J%3.7&! <#J3-,%27&G! -+/';1%+27! %!
,.%$%2%! 3-/'1%/#1%! ,-+4%P! HG! ,7$7! /%3G! '$! &'/'$J17! 2'!
>?aA!9'$!U!3#4!%!/'&'!2'!27#/71%27!2'!m%3!KP!l%$2-%3G!2'!
M1-+-2%2!N!M7J%;7P!D!/Q/#37!2%!/'&'L!E!-$<71/F+,-%!&7,-%3!
'!',7+R$-,%!2%&!z71'&/%&!27!b%1(#'!2'!I%17+-!XThe social
and economic importance of the Caroni swamp forestsYP
E3;#+&! 27&! $=/727&! ,.';%9%$! %! 8%4'1! #&7! 2'! 9%371'&!
,711'&<7+2'+/'&!%!#+-2%2'&S<%2167G!,7$7!7!,%&7!'$!(#'!
7!9%371!2%&!,%371-%&!2'!,%2%!%+-$%3!'1%!/1%+&871$%27!'$!
9%371!$7+'/:1-7!2%!'+'1;-%!'3=/1-,%!'(#-9%3'+/'!<%;%!<'37!
,7+&#$-271P! H&&%! /=,+-,%! 87-! 37;7! -+9-%J-3-4%2%! <%1%! &#%!
<1:/-,%! +7! m1%&-3G! #$%! 9'4! (#'! %! '+'1;-%! '3=/1-,%! /-+.%!
parte subsidiada, sem contar a quase total impossibilidade
2'! ,%3,#3%1$7&! 7! 9%371! 2'! ,%371-%&! <%1%! ,%2%! #$%! 2%&!
'&<=,-'&!2'!%+-$%-&!<'12-2%&!'$!2%27!'9'+/7P
H! %&&-$! 7! /1%J%3.7! +7&! <%1',-%! $#-/%&! 9'4'&! #$%! /%1'8%!
2'!KQ&-87G!2%!$-/737;-%!;1';%G!<7-&G!(#%&'!%/-+;-+27!7!/7<7!
2%!$7+/%+.%G!#$!+797!J37,7!2'!17,.%!173%9%!&7J1'!+7&&%!
,%J'5%P
K';#Q%$7&! /'&/%+27! ,%2%! #$%! 2%&! /=,+-,%&! <%&&Q9'-&! 2'!
'$<1';7!+%!9%371%567!2'!',7&&-&/'$%&!+%/#1%-&L!%9%3-%567!
2'!J'+'8Q,-7&o!<1'57!2'!$'1,%27o!<1'57&!7,#3/7&G!9%371!2'!
<17<1-'2%2'! X<1'57! .'2R+-,7Y! '! ,#&/7! 2'! 9-%;'$o! 9%371!
,7+/-+;'+/'o! 2-&<7&-567! %! <%;%1o! 2-&<7&-567! %! %,'-/%1!
,7$<'+&%567o!'!,#&/7&!2'!7<71/#+-2%2'G!2'!'8'/-9-2%2'!'!
2'!1',#<'1%567!XxlEKKDG!>??dYP
"7! %+7! &';#-+/'G! M7;+'33%! X>??hY! 2'8'+2'#! 2-&&'1/%567!
+%! (#%3! %<3-,%1%! %7! ',7&&-&/'$%! $%+;#'4%3G! '$! '&/#27&!
2'!,%&7!'$!I%+%+=-%!'!'$!m'1/-7;%G!%&!&';#-+/'&!/=,+-,%&L! <,+-=01+#'#4'37:3%.!;#3+#%'35".+#7!#,!-+"!01+#
9%371! ,7+/-+;'+/'o! M=,+-,%! p'3<.-o! &#J&/-/#-567! 2'! !2>.'34!$'1,%27o!,#&/7!2'!9-%;'$o!'!%9%3-%567!2'!<172#/-9-2%2'P
D!,7+,'-/7!2'!j9%371!',730;-,7k!<1-71-4%!%!&#&/'+/%J-3-2%2'!
b%1%3'3%$'+/'! %! /727&! 7&! '&87157&! %,%2*$-,7&G! &';#-%! ',730;-,%!27&!',7&&-&/'$%&P!b71!'&&'!,1-/=1-7G!=!<1-$712-%3!
%! +','&&-2%2'! 2'! %/'+2'1! %7! (#'&-/7! &7J1'! 7! 9%371! a proteção de todos os processos e componentes dos
monetário do dano, item presente em todas as ações ',7&&-&/'$%&! ,%<%4'&! 2'! 3.'&! %&&';#1%1! &'#&! <%21Z'&!
,Q9'-&P! p#%&! 8'11%$'+/%&! %<%1','1%$! ,7$7! -$<71/%+/'&! 2'! 1'&-3-*+,-%G! -+/';1-2%2'! '! 1'&-&/*+,-%P! p'&&%! $%+'-1%G!
&#<71/'&! U! /%1'8%! 2'! $7+'/%1-4%567! 27&! 2%+7&G! ,7$7! %! ,%<%,-2%2'! 2'! <179-&67! 2'! J'+&! '! &'19-57&! <%1%! %!
%! b17<7&/%! c'/72730;-,%! <%1%! \%371%567! 2'! p%+7&! .#$%+-2%2'! +67! &'1-%! -+V+-/%G! $%&! ,7+/173%2%! <71! #$!
E$J-'+/%-&!XwEw"!et alPG!>??>Y!'!%!D12'$!2'!K'19-57!27! 3-$-/'!2'!#&7!&#&/'+/:9'3G!(#'!2'<'+2'!2%!,7+/%J-3-2%2'!
ID"pHbwEEM!X>??hYP!E!<17<7&/%!2'!w%.+!et alP!Xop.cit.) 2%&! -+/'1%5Z'&! 2-+F$-,%&! '+/1'! &#%&! 8#+5Z'&G! 9%371'&! '!
/'$!&-27!%<3-,%2%!'$!9:1-7&!3%#27&!<'1-,-%-&!XKIwEH^^HlS <17,'&&7&!'&<',QV,7&!XpH!xlDDM!et alG!gAAgYP
"D\H]]eG!>??gG!>??CYG!&'$<1'!(#'!7&!2%+7&!&'!'&/'+2'$!
%7! %$J-'+/'! ,7$7! #$! /727G! +7! ,7+/'[/7! 2%! <10<1-%! W$! -$<71/%+/'! '['$<37! 2'! 9%371! ',7+R$-,7! %&&7,-%27!
<%-&%;'$! X,7+T#+/7! 2'! ',7&&-&/'$%&YP! E! <17<7&/%! /'$! %7&!&'19-57&!7#!8#+5Z'&!27&!',7&&-&/'$%&!87-!,%3,#3%27G!'$!
,7$7!7JT'/-97!,711'3%,-7+%1!2%+7&!%$J-'+/%-&!,7$!9%371'&! '&,%3%! ;37J%3G! <71! I7+&/%+4%! et alP! X>??CYG! (#'! ,7+&/-/#-#!
52 !MPMG Jurídico Especial
#$%! 2%&! <1-+,-<%-&! <#J3-,%5Z'&! 2%! H,7+7$-%! H,730;-,%!
%! 1'&<'-/7! 27! /'$%P! E/1%9=&! 2'! %J712%;'+&! ',7+R$-,%&!
+'7,3:&&-,%&G!,7$7!7!$=/727!2'!9%371%567!2'!,7+/-+;'+/'G!
871%$!'&/-$%27&!7&!9%371'&!2'!>C!&'19-57&!',7&&-&/*$-,7&!
27&!>@!<1-+,-<%-&!J-7$%&!27!<3%+'/%G!(#'!T#+/7&!/7/%3-4%9%$!
#$!J'+'8Q,-7!2'!WK}!``!/1-3.Z'&!<71!%+7P!I7+&-2'1%+27S&'!
7! bem! $#+2-%3! '$! >??dG! 2'! WK}>a! /1-3.Z'&G! 7J&'197#S&'!
(#'! %! 9%+/%;'$! ',7+R$-,%! -+2-1'/%! 2%! <1'&'19%567! 27&!
',7&&-&/'$%&!&#<'1%9%!&'#!9%371!2'!#&7!2-1'/7P
E3;#+&! 1',#1&7&! %$J-'+/%-&! +67! <7&&#'$! '[<1'&&67!
$7+'/:1-%!,711'+/'G!7#!&'T%G!+67!8%4'$!<%1/'!2'!/1%+&%5Z'&!
$'1,%+/-&!X9%371!27!%1!3-$<7G!<71!'['$<37YP!"%!',7+7$-%!
,7+9'+,-7+%3G! 7! <1'57! 2'! #$! <172#/7! 2',711'! 2%&!
2'&<'&%&!X-+&#$7&G!$67!2'!7J1%G!&'19-57&!2-9'1&7&Y!'!27!
3#,17P! D! <1'57! $'2'! 7! /1%J%3.7! .#$%+7! %;1';%27G! $%&!
+67!,7+&-2'1%!%!,7+/1-J#-567!2%!+%/#1'4%!+%!871$%567!27&!
-+&#$7&!#/-3-4%27&G!<71!'['$<37P
"'&/'! ,7+/'[/7G! '+/'+2'S&'! (#'! %&! %J712%;'+&!
$'/72730;-,%&! <17$-&&71%&! +'&/'! /-<7! 2'! %9%3-%567!
&67! %(#'3%&! (#'! %9%+5%$! '8'/-9%$'+/'! +%! -+/';1%567!
7#! ,7+'[67! '+/1'! 7&! &-&/'$%&! ',7+R$-,7&! '! ',730;-,7&G!
%27/%+27! 2%! 871$%! $%-&! %$<3%! <7&&Q9'3! #$%! 9-&67!
&-&/*$-,%P
?+3%-=;@';
As propostas da equipe inserida no amplo processo
.-&/01-,7!'9-2'+,-%27!%+/'1-71$'+/'!1'+2'1%$!$%-&!81#/7&G!
$%&!%!/67!%3$'T%2%!'(#%567!<%1%!9%371%1!$7+'/%1-%$'+/'!
-+2'+-4%567! 7#! 1'<%1%567! 2'! 2%+7&! ,%#&%27&! %7! $'-7!
%$J-'+/'!'!%!/'1,'-17&!+67!/-+.%!&-27!%/-+;-2%P!W$%!,7-&%!
=!,'1/%L!(#%3(#'1!1'&#3/%27!2'!9%371%567!$7+'/:1-%!2'!#$!
bem ou de recurso ambiental será sempre inferior ao seu
1'%3!9%371G!#$%!9'4!(#'!7&!&-&/'$%&!,7$<3'[7&!+67!<72'$!
/'1! &#%&! <%1/'&! 9%371%2%&! -&73%2%$'+/'! 27! ,7+T#+/7G! T:!
que os sistemas naturais estão interconectados e seu
8#+,-7+%$'+/7!2'<'+2'!2%!-+/';1-2%2'!27!/727P
"7! '+/%+/7G! 2'9'$7&! ,7+&-2'1%1! (#'! #$! /'$%! 2'!
2-&,#&&67!81'(#'+/'!+%!3-/'1%/#1%!2%!H,7+7$-%!H,730;-,%!
=!%!+','&&-2%2'!2'!$=/727&!2'!9%371%567!(#'!&'T%$!$%-&!
J-78Q&-,7&! 7#! J-7,*+/1-,7&G! <%1%! ;'1%1! #$! ,7+/1%<7+/7!
'$! 1'3%567! U(#'3'&! $%-&! %+/17<7,*+/1-,7&G! 7&! (#%-&! &67!
'$<1';%27&!+%&!%9%3-%5Z'&!2'!,#&/7SJ'+'8Q,-7!2%!9'1/'+/'!
+'7,3:&&-,%! 2%! H,7+7$-%! XbEMMHlKD"G! gAAgG! apud
|EME"EmHG!gAAaYP
e&/7! <71(#'! %&! %J712%;'+&! $'/72730;-,%&! 9-+,#3%2%&! U!
9'1/'+/'! +'7,3:&&-,%! 2%! H,7+7$-%! '&/67! &#T'-/%&! %! #$%!
9%371%567!(#'!%,'+/#%!%-+2%!$%-&!%&!&#JS'&/-$%/-9%&G!#$%!
9'4! (#'! &'#&! 8#+2%$'+/7&! &67! 2'1-9%27&! 2%! H,7+7$-%!
/1%2-,-7+%3! '! +67! &67! ,%<%4'&! 2'! ,7$<1''+2'1! /72%! %!
,7$<3'[-2%2'! '! -$<71/F+,-%! 27&! ,7+,'-/7&! 2%! ',737;-%!
X%J712%;'$!2'!',7+7$-%!',730;-,%YP
p-%+/'! 2'&/'! #+-9'1&7G! '! 2%&! 2'$%+2%&! #1;'+/'&! (#'!
&'! ,737,%$G! '+/'+2'S&'! (#'! <%1%! %! 9%371%567! 2'! 2%+7&!
%$J-'+/%-&! &'! $7&/1%1! <1%/-,:9'3! '! %/-+;-1! '8'/-9%$'+/'!
7&!&'#&!<17<0&-/7&G!%/=!$'&$7!+7!F$J-/7!2%&!%/-9-2%2'&!
2%&!:1'%&!/=,+-,%&!27&!2-8'1'+/'&!IED&!XI'+/17&!2'!E<7-7!
D<'1%,-7+%-&! 27! c-+-&/=1-7! biJ3-,7YG! '$! +Q9'3! +%,-7+%3G!
,%J'!%!,7+&-2'1%567!2'!#$%!&=1-'!2'!,#-2%27&!'!$'2-2%&!
<1=9-%&G! (#'! &'! -+-,-%$! ,7$! %! ;%1%+/-%! 2'! 1'%3-4%567! 2'!
'&/#27&! '! 1'z'[Z'&! $%-&! %<178#+2%27&! &7J1'! 7! /'$%G!
(#'! =! '[/1'$%$'+/'! 2-9'1&-V,%27G! '! ,7$! %! ;*+'&'! 2'!
#$%! '&/1%/=;-,%! ,7'1'+/'! '! ,7+9'1;'+/'G! '+9739'+27!
,711'&<7+&%J-3-2%2'! 2'! 2-9'1&7&! %/71'&G! '9-/%+27! (#'!
%&! $%+-8'&/%5Z'&! +7! F$J-/7! 2%! -+&/1#567! 2%&! 2'$%+2%&!
T#2-,-%-&! &'T%! +';%/-9%$'+/'! '[<371%2%G! -+,3#&-9'! <71!
$'-7!2'!/#$#3/7&!'!<17/'3%5Z'&G!'$!8%,'!2%!%$<3%!;%$%!
2'! (#'&/-7+%$'+/7&! '! <7&-,-7+%$'+/7&! '[-&/'+/'&! 2-%+/'!
2'! /%-&! $%/=1-%&P! ~! &%J-27! (#'! .:! $#-/7&! -+/'1'&&'&! +7!
#+-9'1&7!2%&!2'$%+2%&!T#2-,-%-&!(#'!<72'$!<1-$%1!<'3%!
J#&,%! '! '[<371%567! 2'! ,7+/1%2-5Z'&G! '! 2'! <1','2'+/'&G!
,7+&-2'1%+27! %! 2-9'1&-2%2'! 2'! <7&/#1%&G! 7! (#'! <72'! &'1!
<17$79-27! %$<3%$'+/'G! +67! &0! 2'+/17! 2'! #$! $'&$7!
H&/%27G! ,7$7! '$! /727! 7! <%Q&P! b71! &'#! /#1+7G! <72'$7&!
/1%J%3.%1!<%1%!'9-/%1!'&/'!(#%217P
I7$! 7! 2'9-27! %<178#+2%$'+/7! '! 2-&,#&&67! <1=9-%G! +7!
F$J-/7! ,7+,'-/#%3! '! $'/72730;-,7G! =! <7&&Q9'3! '9-/%1G! 2'!
<17+/7G! (#'! &'T%$! <1%/-,%2%&! '! 1'<172#4-2%&! 2-&/715Z'&G!
&-$<3-V,%5Z'&!7#!#&7&!-+%2'(#%27&!27&!<10<1-7&!,7+,'-/7&!
'3'$'+/%1'&! 2%&! ,-*+,-%&! %$J-'+/%-&! '! ',7+R$-,%&G!
<17,#1%+27! ,7+&-2'1%1! 2'! 871$%! $%-&! %$<3%! <7&&Q9'3! %!
<10<1-%! ,7$<3'[-2%2'! -+'1'+/'! %7&! &-&/'$%&! %$J-'+/%-&!
'! &7,-%-&G! ,#T%! %+:3-&'! '+9739'! $#-/%&! 9%1-:9'-&G! &'+27!
MPMG Jurídico Especial !53
%&&-$!+','&&:1-7!(#'!.%T%!#$%!71;%+-4%567!'!<1'<%1%567! AB"!7'%.2'34+
2'9-2%! <%1%! 3-2%1! ,7$! /%-&! ,7+/'[/7&G! $=/727&G! 2%27&! '!
%J712%;'+&!(#'!&#J&-2-%$!%!&#%!#/-3-4%567P
! -+'&/-$:9'3! <%1/-,-<%567! ;1%,-7&%! 2'! '&/%;-:1-7&! '!
<0&S;1%2#%+27&! 27! ]%J71%/01-7! meDcE! 27! e+&/-/#/7!
p'+/1'! %&! 2-1'/1-4'&! -+-,-%-&! <%1%! %! ,7+&73-2%567! 2'! #$%! D,'%+7;1:V,7! 2%! W+-9'1&-2%2'! 2'! K67! b%#37G! ,7$7! 2'!
'&/1%/=;-%! +%,-7+%3! <%1%! %J712%;'$! 27! /'$%G! /'1Q%$7&G! %3#+7&! 2%! p-&,-<3-+%! eIEShCAC! jE9%3-%567! '! I7+/173'!
entre as recomendações preliminares:
2'! e$<%,/7&! E$J-'+/%-&kG! b17;1%$%! 2'! b0&Sx1%2#%567!
'$!I-*+,-%!E$J-'+/%3!2%!W+-9'1&-2%2'!2'!K67!b%#37!+%!
A) Efetuar uma análise crítica de situações fáticas em '3%J71%567!2'!9:1-7&!3%#27&!<%1%!3-(#-2%567!2'!&'+/'+5%!
(#'! 2-8'1'+/'&! $'/72737;-%&! 2'! 9%371%567! $7+'/:1-%! <71!%1J-/1%$'+/7!'B7#!,7$!%<1'&'+/%567!2'!(#'&-/7&P
2'! 2%+7&! %$J-'+/%-&! 9*$! &'+27! %<3-,%2%&! +%! -+&/1#567!
de demandas judiciais, notadamente por meio das
'[<'1-*+,-%&! 9-9'+,-%2%&! +7! F$J-/7! 27&! IED&! '!
I7$%1,%&G!'8'/#%+27!%!%9%3-%567!,1Q/-,%!2'!/%-&!-+-,-%/-9%&G!
;%1%+/-+27! %! <%1/-,-<%567! 2'! <17$7/71'&! <iJ3-,7&G!
$'$J17&!2%!,7$#+-2%2'!,-'+/QV,%!'!%&&-&/'+/'&!/=,+-,7&!
2'!<17$7/71-%G!'+/1'!7#/17&G!%!V$!2'!(#'!7&!-+/'1,F$J-7&!
2'! -+871$%567! '! %! 2-&,#&&67! '$! J#&,%! 2'! $'3.71'&!
'+/'+2-$'+/7&! '! 71-'+/%5Z'&! <%1/%$! 27! ,7+.',-$'+/7!
das práticas cotidianas e das demandas comumente
9-9'+,-%2%&!+7!F$J-/7!2'!%/#%567!27!c-+-&/=1-7!biJ3-,7P
mY! E! ,1-%567! 2'&/%! 7<71/#+-2%2'! /1%1-%! #$%! <'1&<',/-9%!
para aprofundamento e discussão de aspectos conceituais
'! $'/72730;-,7&! ,711'3%/7&G! J'$! ,7$7! 7! 1'&;%/'! 2'!
(#'&/Z'&!2'!712'$!<1:/-,%G!+%!J#&,%!2'!2'&$-&/-V,%567!2'!
9:1-%&!/'&'&!1',711'+/'&!;'1%271%&!2'!'(#Q97,7&G!,7+z-/7&G!
(#'&/-7+%$'+/7&! '! ,7+/1%2-5Z'&! '$! 2'$%+2%&! T#2-,-%-&P!
"'&/'!,'+:1-7G!#$%!$'/%!&'1-%!%!/'+/%/-9%!2'!<%217+-4%567!
de orientações no tratamento de determinados casos
/Q<-,7&!1',711'+/'&P!
H&/%&! -+-,-%/-9%&! /'1-%$! 2'! ,7+/%1G! <%1%3'3%$'+/'G! ,7$! %!
<17$7567!2'!$'2-2%&!,7$7!%&!(#'!&';#'$G!&'$!<1'T#Q47!
2'!7#/1%&!&#;'&/Z'&L
>Y!]'9%+/%$'+/7G!71;%+-4%567!'!'&,73.%!2'!,%&7&!'!&-/#%5Z'&!
%! &'1'$! <1-71-4%27&! '$! /'1$7&! 2'! %+:3-&'G! <'1$-/-+27!
87$'+/%1!2-&,#&&Z'&!,7+,'-/#%-&!'!$'/72730;-,%&G!-+,3#&-9'!
,7$! '+87(#'! ,7$<%1%/-97G! ,7$7! /'$%&! ;'1%271'&G!
$7/-9%271'&!'!712'+%271'&!27&!/1%J%3.7&P!
gY! E9%3-%567! ,1Q/-,%! 2%&! -+871$%5Z'&! 2-&<7+Q9'-&! +7!
F$J-/7! 27&! 2-8'1'+/'&! ,%&7&! %+%3-&%27&G! <%1%! ,73%J71%1!
+%! '&,73.%! '! 2'V+-567! 2'! 2%27&! '! 87+/'&! 2'! -+871$%567G!
bem como discutir as possibilidades quanto ao seu uso no
,7+/'[/7! 27&! <17,'2-$'+/7&! 2'! 9%371%567! $7+'/:1-%! 2'! Referências
2%+7&!%$J-'+/%-&P
`Y! H&/%J'3',-$'+/7! 2'! '&/1%/=;-%&! 2'! ,%<%,-/%567G! 2'!
;'1%567! 2'! <#J3-,%5Z'&! &7J1'! 7! /'$%G! J'$! ,7$7! 2'!
'&/1%/=;-%&! <%1%! %! &#%! 2-8#&67! <71! 2-8'1'+/'&! 9'Q,#37&G!
2-%+/'!2%&!71-'+/%5Z'&!2'V+-2%&P
dY! e+,3#&67G! +%&! 2-&,#&&Z'&! %! &'1'$! '$<1''+2-2%&G! 2%!
%9%3-%567!,1Q/-,%!27&!$',%+-&$7&!'!$727&!2'!71-'+/%567!
<%1%! %<3-,%567! 7#! 2'&/-+%567! 27&! 9%371'&! $7+'/:1-7&!
3'9%+/%27&! X9%371'&! -+2'+-4%/01-7&YG! -+,3#-+27! %!
<7&&-J-3-2%2'! 2'! 871$#3%567! 2'! <17<7&/%&! '! %/=! 2'!
$',%+-&$7&!<%1%!%!&#%!2'9-2%!;'&/67P!
54 !MPMG Jurídico Especial
ID"KME"OEG! lPG! p€ElxHG! lPG! pH! xlDDMG! lPG! ^ElmHlG!
KPG! xlEKKDG! cPG! wE""D"G! mPG! ]ecmWlxG! PG! "EHHcG! KPG!
D€"He]]G!lP\PG!bElWH]DG!nPo!lEKe"G!lPxPo!KWMMD"G!bPo!\E"!
pHl! mH]MG! cP! M.'! 9%3#'! 78! ‚7132€&! ',7&N&/'$! &'19-,'&! %+2!
+%/#1%3!,%<-/%3P!*!4="', \P!`aCG!>??CG!<P!gh`Sg@AP
pH! xlDDM! lPKPG! |e]]KD"G! cPEPG! mDWcE"KG! lPcPnP! E!
/N<737;N! 871! /.'! ,3%&&-V,%/-7+G! 2'&,1-</-7+! %+2! 9%3#%/-7+! 78!
',7&N&/'$!8#+,/-7+&G!;772&!%+2!&'19-,'&P!<%+-+B.%!-#<%+3+2.%;,
\P!d>G!gAAgG!<P!`?`SdAaG!
xlEKKDG!cP!A,!-.!01+#'%+3C2.%!#7+#'%+;;.;4'2!#2!3B='D!-:
,7$<3'[7! '&/#%1-+7S3%;#+%1! 2'! I%+%+=-%G! #$! '&/#27! 2'! ,%&7P!
p-&&'1/%567!2'!$'&/1%27P!e+&/-/#/7!D,'%+7;1:V,7G!W+-9'1&-2%2'!
2'!K67!b%#37P!>??dP
xlEKKDG! cP! E37'";4!37.3BF# 2+7'-.3B# !37# ,!-=.3B# 4&'#
-.3G!B';#>'4H''3#-+%!-#%+22=3.4.';#!37#4&'#2!3B"+,';#+(#4&'#
?!'4I# J.,'"# K!L# MNA)K"!D.-OP! b.p! p-&&'1/%/-7+G! ^%,#3/N! 78! /.'!
x1%2#%/'!K,.773G!W+-9'1&-/N!78!c%1N3%+2!%/!I733';'!b%1ƒP!Wce!
p-&&'1/%/-7+!K'19-,'&G!hhd<<P!gAAAP
xlEKKDG!cP!y!KIwEH^^HlS"D\H]]eG!{P!\%371%567!%$J-'+/%3!
+7! ;'1'+,-%$'+/7! ,7&/'-17L! %<3-,%567! 2%! /=,+-,%! 27! j/1%9'3&!
,7&/&kL! d`ASd`hP! e+L! A?P<$N# PPP# $.29Q;.+# 7'# <%+;;.;4'2!;# 7!#
?+;4!#K"!;.-'."!L!&#J&Q2-7&!%!#$!;'1'+,-%$'+/7!%$J-'+/%3P!\73P>!
c%+;#'4%-&!'!c%1-&$%&P!b#J3P!EIeHKb!"7!aCSeG!>??dG!dhg<<P
bEMMHlKD"G!cPxP!H,737;-,%3!<172#,/-7+!J%&'2!<1-,-+;!78!
J-7&<.'1'!<17,'&&P!<%+-+B.%!-#<%+3+2.%;G!\Pd>!<P!dhCSdCaG!gAAgP
bDOOeS"HMDG! pP! K!.8!7!# $!34.;4!F# 2!3B='D!-# '# ,!D!2'34+;#
7'# Q-'+L! #$%! 9%371%567! ',7+R$-,7S',730;-,%P! c'&/1%27G! b0&S
x1%2#%567!'$!I-*+,-%!E$J-'+/%3G!W+-9'1&-2%2'!2'!K67!b%#37P!
gAA>
lEcpeE]G! mPKP! R&'# ;+%.!-# !37# '%+3+2.%# .29+"4!3%'# +(# 4&'#
?!"+3.# S!3B"+,'# $H!29# T+"';4;# X%! ,%&'! &/#2NYP! H3'9'+/.!
I7$$7+‚'%3/.! ^71'&/1N! I7+8'1'+,'G! M1-+-2%2! %+2! M7J%;7P!
M',.+-,%3!I7$$-//''!+o >!^71'&/!b73-,NP!`@<<P!>?aAP
KIwEH^^HlS"D\H]]eG! {P! S!".3!# R"+9.%!-# *5=4.%!# U47!P!
l'3%/01-7! M=,+-,7P! E&&-&/'+/'! M=,+-,%! 27! cbBKbP! c'2-2%!
I%#/'3%1! E+/',-<%/01-%! 2'! b179%! b17,P! gg`B?AG! ga! \%1%! IQ9'3G!
I7$%1,%!27!x#%1#T:P!!>??gP
KIwEH^^HlS"D\H]]eG! {P! S!3B='D!-# 7+# VK'-!;# A"4';WF#
X=!34.Y%!01+# 2+3'45".!# 7+# 7!3+# !2>.'34!-# '2# (=301+# 7'#
!4'""+# '# 7'# 7.;9+;.01+# 7'# "';Z7=+;# ;I94.%+;# 9'-!# N"'('.4="!#
S=3.%.9!-# 7'# P4!3&!I2F# <;4!7+# 7'# $1+# N!=-+F# K"!;.-P! b'1-/%!
n#2-,-%3G!E567!I-9-3!biJ3-,%!,7$!<'2-27!2'!3-$-+%1G!]%#27!<%1%!
3-(#-2%567!2'!&'+/'+5%!<71!%1J-/1%$'+/7G!I7$%1,%!2'!e/%+.%=$G!
H&/%27!2'!K67!b%#37P!>??@P
KIwEH^^HlS"D\H]]eG! {P! P-&!# P3&!9.=2F# K"!;4'""!#
<29"''37.2'34+;#P2+>.-.5".+;#U47![F#S=3.%Z9.+#7'#?=>!41+\
SPP! E+:3-&'! 2'! ,#&/7SJ'+'8Q,-7G! <17<7&/%! 2'! '$<1''+2-$'+/7!
-$7J-3-:1-7P! p7,#$'+/7! M=,+-,7! 1'%3-4%27! <71! &73-,-/%567! 2%!
b17$7/71-%! 27! c-+-&/=1-7! biJ3-,7! 27! H&/%27! 2'! K67! b%#37G! '$!
I#J%/67P!>??CP
KIwEH^^HlS"D\H]]eG! {P! A9="!01+# 7'# ,!-+"# '%+3C2.%+# 7!#
.37'3.D!01+#9+"#-.X=.7!01+#7'#;'34'30!#9+"#!">.4"!2'34+F#%+2#
apresentação de quesitosG! "BM! E1%[:P! p'11%$%$'+/7! 2'! mMH!
+7! H&/#:1-7! 2'! K%+/7&G! m%-[%2%! K%+/-&/%P! ]%#27! <'1-,-%3G! E567!
I-9-3!biJ3-,%G!I7$%1,%!2'!K%+/7&G!H&/%27!2'!K67!b%#37P!>???P
MDx"H]]EG! cPcPbP! /!-+"!01+# '%+3C2.%!: estudo de caso
<%1%!7!',7&&-&/'$%!$%+;#'4%3!r!m'1/-7;%!'!I%+%+=-%G!H&/%27!2'!
K67! b%#37P! p-&&'1/%567! 2'! $'&/1%27P! e+&/-/#/7! D,'%+7;1:V,7G!
W+-9'1&-2%2'!2'!K67!b%#37G!>??hP
MDx"H]]ESpHSlDKEG! cPbP! S!3B='D!.;# %!4!".3'3;';F# K!Z!#
7!# K!>.4+3B!# '# J.+# R!,!"';L! #$%! %J712%;'$! <%1,-%3! 27&!
%/1-J#/7&!',730;-,7&!'!',7+R$-,7&P!M'&'!2'!27#/71%27G!e+&/-/#/7!
D,'%+7;1:V,7G!W+-9'1&-2%2'!2'!K67!b%#37P!gAAAP
xlEKKDG!cP!y!KIwEH^^HlS"D\H]]eG!{P!H,7+7$-,!9%3#%/-7+!
78!$%+;179'!',7&N&/'$&L!>>`S>dgP!e+L!c%NG!bPwP!X71;PYG!*!4="!-#
J';+="%'# /!-=!4.+3# !37# N+-.%L# .3# K"!D.-L! c'/.72&! %+2! I7&/&P!
I73#$J-%!W+-9P!b1'&&G!"P{P!g@g<<P!>???P
xlEKKDG!cPo!MDx"H]]EG!cPcPbPo!KIwEH^^HlS"D\H]]eG!{P!
y!IDcW"HG!EPHP!E<3-,%567!2'!/=,+-,%&!2'!%9%3-%567!',7+R$-,%!
27!',7&&-&/'$%!$%+;#'4%3L!d`Sa>P!e+L!c%NG!bP!X71;PYP!Economia
<%+-QB.%!L! E<3-,%5Z'&! +7! m1%&-3P! H2-/71%! I%$<#&G! lPnP! >C?<<P!
>??hP
"DEE! WPKP! pHbElMcH"M! D^! IDccHlIHP! A;;';;.3B# 4&'#
;+%.!-#%+;4;#+(#+.-#;9.--;L!/.'!E$7,7!I%2-4!,%&'!&/#2NP!>dd<<P!>??`P
MDx"H]]EG! cPcPbP! y! KIwEH^^HlS"D\H]]eG! {P! \%371%567L!
#$%!9-&67!7,'%+7;1:V,%L!d`@Sd`aP!e+L!A?P<$N#PPP#$.29Q;.+#7'#
<%+;;.;4'2!;#7!#?+;4!#K"!;.-'."!L!&#J&Q2-7&!%!#$!;'1'+,-%$'+/7!
%$J-'+/%3P!\73P>!c%+;#'4%-&!'!c%1-&$%&P!b#J3P!EIeHKb!"7!aCSeP!
dhg<<P>??dP
|EME"EmHG!cP!pP!mP!Mata nativa e cana-de-açúcar: cálculo do
9%371!27&!&'19-57&!',7&&-&/*$-,7&!9-+,#3%27&!%7&!,-,37&!2%!:;#%G!
27! ,%1J7+7G! '! 27! +-/17;*+-7! #/-3-4%+27! %! %+:3-&'! '$'1;=/-,%P!
p-&&'1/%567!2'!c'&/1%27G!^HEBW"eIEcbG!I%$<-+%&G!KbG!gAAaP
{E"xG!HPnPo!pD|HlG!lPIP!y!cH"H^HHG!cP!M.'!#&'!78!',7+7$-,!
%+%3N&-&! -+! 9%3#-+;! +%/#1%3! 1'&7#1,'! 2%$%;'&P! <3,."+32'34!-#
U!H#P3;4.4=4'G!|%&.-+;/7+G!pPIG!>?adP
"DEE! WPKP! pHbElMcH"M! D^! IDccHlIHP! R&'# =;'# +(#
'%+3+2.%#!3!-L;.;#.3#,!-=.3B#3!4="!-#"';+="%'#7!2!B';P!>hd<<P!
>?adP
MPMG Jurídico Especial !55