ANÁLISE DE PERFORMANCE NA UTILIZAÇÃO DOS PROTOCOLOS
802.11b E 802.11g EM WLAN
6$17$1$0D[LPLOLDQR*XLPDUmHV
)DFXOGDGH0XQLFLSDO³3URI)UDQFR0RQWRUR´)03)0
PD[JVDQWDQD#JPDLOFRP
&$59$/+20DQRHO3HOXVR)LOKR
)DFXOGDGH0XQLFLSDO³3URI)UDQFR0RQWRUR´)03)0
PDQRHOSHOXVR#JPDLOFRP
RESUMO: &RPRFUHVFLPHQWRGDXWLOL]DomRGDVUHGHVVHP¿R:LUHOHVVHPWRGRVRVVHWRUHVGDVR
FLHGDGHHRVXUJLPHQWRGHYiULRVSDGU}HVGH¿QLGRVSHOD,(((,QVWLWXWHRI(OHFWULFDODQG(OHFWURQLFV
(QJLQHHUVVXUJHXPDQHFHVVLGDGHGHDYDOLDUTXDLVSDGU}HVZLUHOHVVSRGHVHUPHOKRUDSURYHLWDGRVHP
GHWHUPLQDGDVVLWXDo}HVHFHQiULRVTXHRFRUUHPDWXDOPHQWH1HVWHWUDEDOKRVHUiUHDOL]DGRXPH[SHUL
PHQWRGHGHVHPSHQKRVRPHQWHHQWUHRVSDGU}HVEHJSDUDTXHVHMDSRVVtYHODQDOLVDUR
FRPSRUWDPHQWRGHDPERVHPWUrVFHQiULRVGLIHUHQWHVRQGHKDYHUi3&VHUYLGRU3&VFOLHQWHVH
$3$FFHVV3RLQWMXQWDPHQWHFRPRVRIWZDUHOLYUH-3(5)SDUDVLPXODURWUDIHJRGHXPDUHGH:/$1
HYHUL¿FDUDWUDQVPLVVmRGHGDGRVHQWUHRVFOLHQWHVHRVHUYLGRU$SyVWRGRVRVWHVWHVUHDOL]DGRVVHUi
SRVVtYHOPRVWUDUDYHORFLGDGHHPTXHRVGLVSRVLWLYRVVHFRPXQLFDPHVWDQGRFRQHFWDGRVQRPHVPR
SDGUmRHSULQFLSDOPHQWHTXDQGRHVWLYHUHPFRQHFWDGRVHPSDGU}HVGLIHUHQWHV
PALAVRAS-CHAVE: UHGHVVHP¿RSDGU}HVWHFQRORJLD
ABSTRACT: With the growing use of wireless networks (wireless) in all sectors of society together with
JURZWKRIWKHWHFKQRORJ\LWVHOIDQGWKHDSSHDUDQFHRIYDULRXVVWDQGDUGVGH¿QHGE\,(((,QVWLWXWHRI
Electrical and Electronics Engineers) arises a need to study and evaluate which wireless standards can
be better used in certain situations and scenarios that occur today. In his project will be conducted a performance test only between 802.11b and 802.11g standards to be able to analyze the behavior of both
in three different scenarios where there will be a PC server, two client PCs and one AP (Access Point)
DORQJZLWKIUHHVRIWZDUH-3(5)WRVLPXODWHWUDI¿FRQD:/$1QHWZRUNDQGYHULI\WKHGDWDWUDQVPLVVLRQ
between clients and server. After all tests will be possible to show the speed which the devices communicate being connected in the same standard and especially when they are connected in different
standards.
KEYWORDS: Wireless Network, Standards, Technology.
1. INTRODUÇÃO
$ WHFQRORJLD GH UHGH VHP ¿R :L
UHOHVV VXUJLX SDUD FRPSOHPHQWDU DV UH
GHV FDEHDGDV H SDUD GDU PDLV SUDWLFLGDGH
H HFRQRPLD QD LPSODQWDomR GH XPD /$1
/RFDO $UHD 1HWZRUN TXH QD PDLRULD GDV
YH]HVVmRPXLWRWUDEDOKRVDVGHVHPRQWDU
GHYLGR j GL¿FXOGDGH GH VH OHYDU FDERV D
WRGRV RV SRQWRV TXH WHUmR DFHVVR D UHGH
$OpPGLVVRIRUQHFHXPDJUDQGHFRPRGLGD
GHDRVVHXVXVXiULRVTXHQRVGLDVGHKRMH
SRVVXHP YiULRV DSDUHOKRV SRUWiWHLV 1RWH
ERRNV3'$VFHOXODUHV6PDUWSKRQHVHWF
17
TXHWHPDFHVVRjVUHGHVVHP¿RSRVVLELOL
WDQGRDVVLPPDLRUPRELOLGDGHHSUDWLFLGDGH
na sua utilização.
$VWHFQRORJLDV:/$1HVWmRVHQGR
PXLWR XWLOL]DGDV SDUD GLVWULEXLU LQWHUQHW HP
FLGDGHV GR LQWHULRU HPSUHVDV H DPELHQWHV
GRPpVWLFRV VHUYLQGR FRPR XPD H[WHQVmR
GDVUHGHVFDEHDGDV'HSHQGHQGRGDFRQ
¿JXUDomR H HTXLSDPHQWR XWLOL]DGR p SRV
VtYHO DOFDQoDU FRP DV :/$1V XPD WD[D
FRQVLGHUiYHOGHWUDQVPLVVmR3RUH[HPSOR
R SDGUmR E DOFDQoD XPD YHORFLGDGH
QRPLQDO GH 0ESV HQTXDQWR R SDGUmR
J DOFDQoD D YHORFLGDGH GH 0ESV
Interciência
& Sociedade
$PERVRVSDGU}HVRSHUDPQDIDL[DGH
*+] WHQGR FRPR GLIHUHQoD SULQFLSDO D WHF
QRORJLD GH WUDQVPLVVmR XWLOL]DGD 2 ,(((
E XWLOL]D R '666 H R ,((( J
XWLOL]D R 2)'0 3RU VHU PDLV H¿FLHQWH R
2)'0 FRQVHJXH ID]HU FRP TXH R SDGUmR
JDOFDQFHRV0ESVQRPLQDLV$OpP
GHVVHV GRLV SDGU}HV H[LVWHP DLQGD RXWURV
TXHIRUDPGHVHQYROYLGRVRVPDLVXWLOL]DGRV
DOpP GHOHV VmR RV SDGU}HV ,((( ,(((DH,(((Q(VWHVRXWURV
SDGU}HVVHUmRGHVFULWRVFRPPDLRUHVGHWD
OKHVQR&DSLWXOR
Nesse artigo será abordado um
EUHYHFRQFHLWRGDVUHGHVVHP¿RMXQWDPHQ
WH FRP SULQFLSDLV SDGU}HV XWLOL]DGRV DWXDO
PHQWHHWDPEpPDVFDUDFWHUtVWLFDVGHFDGD
XP 3RU ¿P VHUmR UHDOL]DGRV H[SHULPHQWR
GH GHVHPSHQKR HQWUH RV SDGU}HV E
H J XWLOL]DQGR R VRIWZDUH OLYUH -3HUI
SDUDUHDOL]DUDVLPXODomRGRWUiIHJRGHXPD
:/$1SRGHQGRDVVLPYHUL¿FDURFRPSRUWD
PHQWRGHFDGDSDGUmR6HUmRFRQ¿JXUDGRV
FHQiULRV FRP FRQ¿JXUDo}HV DOWHUQDGDV
RQGHHPFDGDFHQiULRVHUmRJHUDGRVJUi¿
FRVHORJVSDUDTXHVHMDSRVVtYHODQDOLVDUH
FRPSLODURVUHVXOWDGRV7RGRVRVUHVXOWDGRV
VHUmRGHVFULWRVGHWDOKDGDPHQWHQR&DSLWX
OR
2. Wireless Local Area Network
8PD UHGH ZLUHOHVV p XPD H[WHQ
VmRGHXPDUHGHORFDO/RFDOÈUHD1HWZRUN
± /$1 FRP ¿R FULDQGR DVVLP XP QRYR
FRQFHLWRUHGHORFDOVHP¿R:LUHOHVV/RFDO
ÈUHD1HWZRUN±:/$1$WHFQRORJLDZLUH
OHVV DWHQGH DV QHFHVVLGDGHV TXH RV XVX
iULRV SRVVXHP GH PRELOLGDGH DOpP GLVVR
p FUHVFHQWH R QXPHUR GH HTXLSDPHQWRV
GH FRPSXWDomR PyYHLV FRPR QRWHERRNV
VPDUWSKRQHVH3'$V
$V UHGHV VHP ¿R LQWHUOLJDP Yi
ULRVHTXLSDPHQWRV¿[RVRXPyYHLVDWUDYpV
GD WUDQVPLVVmR VHP ¿R VH WRUQDQGR XPD
DOWHUQDWLYD DOWDPHQWH ÀH[tYHO jV UHGHV FD
EHDGDV (ODV XWLOL]DP RQGDV GH UiGLR SDUD
FRQYHUWHU RV GDGRV H UHDOL]DU D FRPXQLFD
omRHQWUHGLIHUHQWHVGLVSRVLWLYRVVHP¿RLQ
WHUOLJDGRVDXPSRQWRGHDFHVVR'HDFRUGR
com a tecnologia de transmissão utilizada e
RUHFHSWRUDVUHGHVVHP¿RSRGHPDWLQJLU
GLVWkQFLDV H WD[DV GH WUDQVPLVV}HV VLJQL
18
¿FDWLYDV DOpP GLVVR D WHFQRORJLD VHP ¿R
SRGH VHU XWLOL]DGD SDUD UHGHV GH DFHVVR D
LQWHUQHW FKDPDGD :L)L :LUHOHVV )LGHOLW\
SRGHQGROHYDUHVVHWLSRGHFRPXQLFDomRD
OXJDUHVRQGHQmRVHULDSRVVtYHOXWLOL]DQGR
XPD UHGH FDEHDGD 3RUWDQWR DV :/$1V
XQHPDPRELOLGDGHGRXVXiULRFRPFRQH[mR
GHYHORFLGDGHVHOHYDGDVHPDOJXQVFDVRV
6HJXQGR,(((D
3RUpPVHJXQGR7RUUHVDV
WHFQRORJLDV GH FRPXQLFDomR VHP ¿R QmR
YLHUDP SDUD VXEVWLWXLU D UHGH FDEHDGD H
VLP VHU XVDGD FRPR H[WHQVmR RX WHU PDLV
RSo}HVGHQWURGRVVLVWHPDVGHFDEHDPHQ
WRVGLVSRQtYHLV
'HYLGR D JUDQGH HYROXomR GD WHF
QRORJLDZLUHOHVVR,(((,QVWLWXWHRI(OHFWUL
FDO DQG (OHWURQLFV (QJLQHHUV GHVHQYROYHX
R SDGUmR ,((( HVSHFLDOPHQWH SDUD
DSOLFDo}HVGHUHGHVHP¿RFRPD¿QDOLGD
GHWUD]HUDRPXQGRWRGRVRVEHQHItFLRVTXH
utilizamos atualmente.
3. Arquitetura de uma WLAN
$V :/$1V SRGHP VHU VLPSOHV RX
FRPSOH[DV$FRQH[mRPDLVVLPSOHVpDTXH
RFRUUHHQWUHGRLVFRPSXWDGRUHVHTXLSDGRV
FRP DGDSWDGRU ZLUHOHVV GHVGH TXH VHMD
REHGHFLGD j IDL[D GH GLVWkQFLD HQWUH HVWHV
GRLVFRPSXWDGRUHV-XQLRU2SDGUmR
,(((pEDVHDGRHPXPDDUTXLWHWXUD
GRWLSRFpOXODRQGHFDGDXPDGHVVDVFpOX
ODVpFKDPDGDGH%66%DVLF6HUYLFH6HW
RX3RQWR%iVLFRGH6HUYLoR2GLkPHWURGDV
FpOXODV p GH¿QLGR FRPR D GLVWkQFLD HQWUH
XPD HVWDomR 9iULRV HOHPHQWRV FRPS}H D
DUTXLWHWXUDGHXPDUHGHVHP¿RFRPRSRGH
VHUYLVWRQD¿JXUD
Interciência
& Sociedade
Figura 1: $UTXLWHWXUDHVHXVHOHPHQWRV
)RQWH,(((
D67$6WDWLRQ±(VWDomR
$V67$VVmRYiULRVFOLHQWHVFRQHF
WDGRVHPXPDUHGHVHP¿RTXHVHFRPXQL
cam entre si dentro do BSS.
E%66%DVLF6HUYLFH6HW±3RQWR
%iVLFRGH6HUYLoR
8P %66 %DVLF 6HUYLFH 6HW SRV
VXLDIXQomRGHFRQWURODUTXDQGRFDGDXPD
GDVHVWDo}HVSRGHWUDQVPLWLURXUHFHEHUGD
GRVGHQWURGD%660RUDHV
F'6'LVWULEXLWLRQ6\VWHP±6LV
tema de Distribuição
&RUUHVSRQGH DR ORFDO GD WRSROR
JLDHPTXHRV$3VVHLQWHUFRQHFWDPQXPD
UHGHSRGHQGRVHUXPDUHGHORFDOQRSDGUmR
Ethernet ou em um Backbone.
G(66([WHQG6HUYLFH6HW±3RQ
WRGH6HUYLoR(VWHQGLGR
7UDWDVHGHXPFRQMXQWRGHFpOXODV
%66 FXMRV $3V HVWmR LQWHUFRQHFWDGRV SRU
um sistema de distribuição. Neste cenário
XPD67$SRGHVHPRYLPHQWDUGHXPDFp
OXOD%66SDUDRXWUDSHUPDQHFHQGRFRQHF
tada a rede.
H $3 $FFHVV 3RLQW ± 3RQWR GH
Acesso.
2V$3VVmRHTXLSDPHQWRVUHVSRQ
19
ViYHLV SHOD FRRUGHQDomR GDV 67$V GHQWUR
GD%66HWDPEpPSHORSURYLPHQWRGRDFHV
VRDR'62$3VHUYHFRPRXPDSRQWHHQ
WUHXPD:/$1HXPD/$1
I3RUWDO
2SRUWDOIXQFLRQDFRPRXPDSRQWH
HQWUHXPD:/$1HXPD/$1FDEHDGDFRQ
YHQFLRQDO
De acordo com a Figura 1, cada
67$FRQHFWDVHHPXP$3SRUXPDOLJDomR
VHP¿RV2FRQMXQWRIRUPDGRSHOR$3HDV
67$VQXPDPHVPDFpOXODGHFREHUWXUDIRU
PDR%66TXHHVWiFRQHFWDGRDRXWUR%66
DWUDYpV GR '6 FRQVWLWXLQGR XP (66 (VVH
PRGHOR GH DUTXLWHWXUD p FKDPDGR :/$1
com infraestrutura. Segundo Soares et al.
XPHOHPHQWRIXQGDPHQWDOQDDUTXL
WHWXUDGHUHGHORFDOVHP¿RFRPLQIUDHVWUX
WXUDpR$3
4. PADRÕES WIRELESS 802.11
&RQIRUPH UHODWD 7DQHQEDXP
DSyVDSXEOLFDomRGRSDGUmR
HPRTXDOGHVFUHYHVHXIXQFLRQDPHQ
WR FRP YHORFLGDGHV GH 0ESV H 0ESV
QRPLQDLV VHQGR TXH SRVWHULRUPHQWH RV
Interciência
& Sociedade
XVXiULRVUHFODPDUDPGDEDL[DYHORFLGDGHH
DVVLPLQLFLRXRGHVHQYROYLPHQWRGHSDGU}HV
PDLVUiSLGRV$SDUWLUGHVVDGDWDR,(((GH
VHQYROYHXXPDVpULHGHSDGU}HVSDUDUHGHV
GHWUDQVPLVVmRGHGDGRVVHP¿RTXHIRUDP
HYROXLQGRSRGHQGRDWLQJLUXPDYHORFLGDGH
de transmissão maior.
(P MXOKR GH IRL FULDGR R SD
GUmR,(((ETXHIRLFRQVLGHUDGRXPD
HYROXomR GR ,((( SRLV XWLOL]DYD D
PHVPDIDL[DGH*+]PDVFRPXPWLSR
GH PRGXODomR GLIHUHQWH R TXH SURSRUFLR
QDYDDWLQJLUDYHORFLGDGHQRPLQDOGHDWp
0ESV1RDQRGHRSDGUmREIRL
DSURYDGRHDRPHVPRWHPSRIRLGLVSRQLELOL
]DGRRSDGUmRDTXHSHUPLWLDWHRULFD
PHQWHDRSHUDomRHPIDL[DVGHDWp0ESV
QDIUHTXrQFLDGH*+]3RVWHULRUPHQWHR
,((( GLVSRQLELOL]RX R SDGUmR J (V
WHVGRLVSDGU}HVVmRFRPSDWtYHLVSRLVRSH
UDPQDPHVPDIDL[DGHIUHTXrQFLDGH
*+]2TXHGLIHUHQFLDXPGRRXWURpDWLSR
GHPRGXODomRTXHHOHVWUDEDOKDPHQTXDQ
WR R ,((( E WUDEDOKD FRP R '666
'LUHFW6HTXHQFH6SUHDG6SHFWUXPR,(((
J WUDEDOKD FRP R 2)'0 2UWKRJR
QDO )UHTXHQF\ 'LYLVLRQ 0XOWLSOH[LQJ 3RU
VHUPDLVH¿FLHQWHR2)'0SURSRUFLRQDDR
SDGUmR J FKHJDU WDPEpP D WD[D GH
WUDQVPLVVmRQRPLQDOGH0ESV
'H DFRUGR 'XQWHPDQQ¶V XPD LPSRUWDQWH IXQomR GR ,((( p GHVHQ
YROYHUHHVWDEHOHFHUQRYRVSDGU}HVWHFQR
OyJLFRV$ SDGURQL]DomR p LPSRUWDQWH SRLV
DPSOLD R PHUFDGR H WDPEpP SRVVLELOLWD RV
GLIHUHQWHV IDEULFDQWHV D SURGX]LUHP WHFQR
ORJLDVTXHWHQKDPLQWHURSHUDELOLGDGHXPDV
com as outras.
Nos itens a seguir estão detalha
GRV RV SDGU}HV H VXDV SULQFLSDLV FDUDFWH
UtVWLFDV
,(((D
,(((
(VWH H[SHULPHQWR WHYH FRPR SULQ
FLSDOREMHWLYRDVLPXODomRGRWUiIHJRGHGD
GRV HP XPD :/$1 XWLOL]DQGR RV SDGU}HV
E H J HP WUrV FHQiULRV SDUD
TXH IRVVH SRVVtYHO D DQiOLVH GH GHVHPSH
QKRGDUHGHZLUHOHVVQRVSDGU}HVGHVFULWRV
acima.
Para realizar os testes foi utiliza
GDXPDVDODFRPDSUR[LPDGDPHQWH[
PHWURVGHiUHDWRPDQGRVHRGHYLGR
FXLGDGR SDUD TXH QmR KRXYHVVH QHQKXP
(VWHIRLRSULPHLURSDGUmRGHUHGH
VHP ¿R FULDGR 2 ,((( HVWDEHOHFH
WDQWRRVSURWRFRORVGHDFHVVRDRPHLRFRPR
RV GD FDPDGD ItVLFD 3DUD HVWH SDGUmR IRL
utilizado como tecnologia de transmissão o
'6662,(((WUDEDOKDYDQDVYHOR
FLGDGHV GH RX 0ESV QD IUHTXrQFLD GH
*+]0RUDHV
20
2SDGUmRDIRLDSURYDGRHP
FRQMXQWR FRP R E QR DQR GH HOHRSHUDQDIUHTXrQFLDGH*+]TXHWUD]
XPD YDQWDJHP VLJQL¿FDWLYD HP UHODomR D
IUHTXrQFLDGH*+]WHQGRHPYLVWDTXH
DVHJXQGDpH[WUHPDPHQWHXWLOL]DGDHHVWi
DWXDOPHQWHPXLWRVREUHFDUUHJDGD0RUDHV
'H DFRUGR FRP 5X¿QR HVWH
SDGUmRXWLOL]DRVLVWHPD2)'0SRVVLELOLWDQ
GRDOFDQoDUDWD[DQRPLQDOGH0ESV
,(((E
(VWHIRLRSULPHLURSDGUmRGHULYDGR
GR,(((SRLVXWLOL]DDPHVPDIDL[D
GHIUHTXrQFLDFRPR'666SDUDRSHUDUFRP
YHORFLGDGHQRPLQDOGHDWp0ESV(VWHSD
GUmRDLQGDHVSHFL¿FDWD[DVGHIDOOEDFNHP
0ESV0RUDHV3DUDDWLQJLUD
YHORFLGDGHQRPLQDOGH0ESV
,(((J
'H DFRUGR FRP 0RUDHV R ,((( J p XPD H[WHQVmR GR ,(((
E(VWHSDGUmRIRLFULDGRQRDQRGH
HWHPFRPRFDUDFWHUtVWLFDSULQFLSDOD
FRPSDWLELOLGDGH FRP R ,((( E7HQ
GR HP YLVWD TXH DPERV RSHUDP QD IUHTX
rQFLD GH *+] p SRVVtYHO TXH HOHV VH
FRPXQLTXHP PHVPR HVWDQGR HP SDGU}HV
GLIHUHQWHV2,(((JWUDEDOKDFRPD
tecnologia de transmissão OFDM, a mesma
XWLOL]DGD SHOR ,((( D VHQGR SRVVt
YHOFKHJDUDYHORFLGDGHQRPLQDOGH0ESV
FRP XP IDOO EDFN GH 0ESV
5. Metodologia do Experimento
Interciência
& Sociedade
HTXLSDPHQWR TXH WUDEDOKDVVH QD PHVPD
IUHTXrQFLD TXH RV DSDUHOKRV XWLOL]DGRV QR
WHVWH LVVR SDUD TXH IRVVH HYLWDGR DOJXP
WLSR GH LQWHUIHUrQFLD QR H[SHULPHQWR 3DUD
a obtenção dos resultados foi utilizado um
VRIWZDUH OLYUH GR WLSR FOLHQWHVHUYLGRU FRP
LQWHUIDFH JUi¿FD FKDPDGD -3(5) TXH IRL
GHVHQYROYLGR SHOR 1/$15 1DWLRQDO /DER
UDWRU\ IRU $SOLHG 1HWZRUN 5HVHDUFK (VWH
VRIWZDUHWHPFRPRIXQomRID]HUDPHGLomR
H VLPXODomR GR WUi¿FR GH GDGRV GH XPD
UHGHDWUDYpVGHORJVHJUi¿FRVJHUDGRVSRU
ele.
Foram simulados três cenários
FRPGLIHUHQWHVFRQ¿JXUDo}HVHQWUHRVHTXL
SDPHQWRV XWLOL]DGRV 1RV H[SHULPHQWRV
IRL XWLOL]DGR XP FRPSXWDGRU SDUD WUDEDOKDU
FRPR6HUYLGRUHRXWURVGRLVSDUDWUDEDOKDU
como Cliente. Em cada PC foi instalado um
DGDSWDGRU :LUHOHVV 86% 7SOLQN :QQ
PESVSDUDTXHRVFOLHQWHVHRVHUYLGRU
WLYHVVHPRPHVPRUHFHSWRUGHVLQDO)RLXWL
OL]DGRXPURWHDGRUZLUHOHVVSDUDFULDUXPD
UHGHHQWUHWRGRVRVWUrV3&V'HSRLVGHWR
GRVRVHTXLSDPHQWRVHVWDUHPGHYLGDPHQWH
FRQ¿JXUDGRV IRL XWLOL]DGR R VRIWZDUH -SHUI
SDUD VLPXODU R WUDIHJR GH GDGRV HQWUH RV
FOLHQWHVHRVHUYLGRUHYHUL¿FDURFRPSRUWD
PHQWRGRVPHVPRVQRVSDGU}HVEH
J$SyVD¿QDOL]DomRGHFDGDFHQi
ULRRSUySULRVRIWZDUHJHURXJUi¿FRVHORJV
TXHSXGHUDPVHUDQDOLVDGRVHFRPSDUDGRV
SRGHQGRDVVLPYHUL¿FDUDGHVHPSHQKRGD
UHGHFRQIRUPHGHVFULWRQRFDSLWXOR
(TXLSDPHQWRVHVRIWZDUHVXWLOL]DGRV
6HJXHDEDL[RGHVFULomRGRVHTXL
SDPHQWRVFRPRVVRIWZDUHVXWLOL]DGRV
6RIWZDUH )RL XWLOL]DGR R VRIWZD
UH OLYUH GR WLSR FOLHQWHVHUYLGRU FKDPDGR
-3(5)TXHWHPDIXQomRGHWHVWDUHPHGLU
RWUiIHJRGHXPDUHGH3DUDXWLOL]DUR-SHUI
p QHFHVViULR TXH R PHVPR VHMD LQLFLDGR
FRP 6HUYLGRU HP XP 3& H FRPR &OLHQWH
HP RXWUR 'HSRLV GH FRQHFWDGRV R FOLHQ
WH HQYLDUi R WUiIHJR 7&3 RX 83' GHSHQ
GHQGRGRREMHWLYRGRWHVWHSDUDRVHUYLGRU
SRUXPDTXDQWLGDGHGHWHPSRGH¿QLGDSHOR
SUySULRVRIWZDUH$SyVRWpUPLQRGRWHVWHp
PRVWUDGRXPJUi¿FRFRPDTXDQWLGDGHWRWDO
GH GDGRV WUDQVIHULGRV H D YHORFLGDGH Pp
GLDDWLQJLGDGXUDQWHRWHVWHVHQGRSRVVtYHO
WDPEpPDJHUDomRGHORJVHPDUTXLYRVGH
WH[WR1HVWHH[SHULPHQWRIRLXWLOL]DGRR-SHUI
QDYHUVmRHPWRGRVRVFRPSXWDGRUHV
6HUYLGRU 1RWHERRN $FHU (PD
FKLQHV(62:LQGRZV3URIHVVLRQDO
FRP *% GH PHPyULD SURFHVVDGRU ,QWHOŠ
3HQWLXPŠ'XDO&RUH7*+=
&OLHQWH'HVNWRS+362:LQ
GRZV ;3 SURIHVVLRQDO FRP *% GH PH
PyULD SURFHVVDGRU 3HQWLXPŠ 'XDO &RUH
7*+=
&OLHQWH 1RWHERRN /* 5
62:LQGRZV3URIHVVLRQDOFRP*%GH
PHPyULD SURFHVVDGRU ,QWHOŠ 3HQWLXPŠ
'XDO&RUH7*+=
$3 6XSHU$FFHVV 3RLQW *76 0ESVFRPSDWtYHOFRPRVSDGU}HVEJ
&HQiULRGRH[SHULPHQWR
2VH[SHULPHQWRVIRUDPUHDOL]DGRV
HP XPD VDOD FRP DSUR[LPDGDPHQWH Pð
RQGH RV HTXLSDPHQWRV IRUDP GLVWULEXtGRV
FRQIRUPHGHVFUHYHD¿JXUDDEDL[R
Figura 3: 5RWHDGRU:LUHOHVV*76
)RQWH*761HWZRUN
Figura 2: &HQiULRGRH[SHULPHQWR
21
Interciência
& Sociedade
3URFHGLPHQWRGR([SHULPHQWR
Figura 4: $GDSWDGRUHV:LUHOHVV73/LQN
$GDSWDGRUHV :LUHOHVV $GDS
WDGRUHV :LUHOHVV 86% 7SOLQN :QQ
PESV FRPSDWtYHO FRP RV SDGU}HV
EJQ
2V H[SHULPHQWRV IRUDP UHDOL]D
GRV HP WUrV FHQiULRV FRP FRQ¿JXUDo}HV
GLIHUHQWHVSRUpPWRGRVRVWHVWHVIRUDPUH
alizados no mesmo dia e com os mesmos
HTXLSDPHQWRV )RL XWLOL]DGR HP FDGD FRP
SXWDGRU XP $GDSWDGRU :LUHOHVV 86% 7S
OLQN:QQSDUDTXHQmRKRXYHVVHGLIH
UHQoDHQWUHDVSODFDVZLUHOHVVRQERDUGGRV
notebooks.
$V¿JXUDVDVHJXLUGHPRQVWUDPDV
FRQ¿JXUDo}HVGRVHTXLSDPHQWRV
$ ¿JXUD PRVWUD D WHOD GH FRQ¿
JXUDomR GR$3 RQGH p SRVVtYHO DOWHUDU DV
Figura 5: 7HODGHFRQ¿JXUDomRGR$3
FRQ¿JXUDo}HV GR PHVPR FRPR R SDGUmR
HP TXH HOH LUi GLVWULEXLU R VLQDO E
E RX EJ FDQDO GH FRPXQL
FDomRVHJXUDQoDHWDPEpPDSRWrQFLDGH
VDtGDGRVLQDOZLUHOHVV
22
$¿JXUDPRVWUDDVFRQ¿JXUDo}HV
GRVHUYLGRUHGRVFOLHQWHVRQGHpPRVWUDGR
R,3GHFDGDXPPRGRGHFRQH[mRHRFD
QDOHPTXHHOHVHVWmRFRQHFWDGRV
&RQ¿JXUDomRGRVFHQiULRV
Interciência
& Sociedade
Figura 6: 7HODGHFRQ¿JXUDomRGRV&OLHQWHVH6HUYLGRU
)RQWH6RIWZDUH73/LQN
$WDEHODPRVWUDGHIRUPDVLPSOL¿
FDGDDVFRQ¿JXUDo}HVGHFDGDHPHTXLSD
PHQWR QRV WUrV FHQiULRV QRV LWHQV DEDL[R
será descrito como foi realizado cada teste
GHVWHH[SHULPHQWR
Tabela 1 ±&RQ¿JXUDomRGRPRGRGHRSHUDomRGHFDGDFHQiULR
ž&HQiULR
1RžFHQiULRR$3IRLFRQ¿JXUDGR
SDUD TXH GLVWULEXtVVH RV VLQDLV DSHQDV QR
SDGUmREGHVWDIRUPDWDQWRRVHUYL
GRUTXDQWRRVFOLHQWHVWDPEpPIRUDPFRQ
¿JXUDGRV SDUD VH FRQHFWDU QR PHVPR SD
GUmR 'HSRLV IRL XWLOL]DGR R VRIWZDUH -SHUI
SDUD VLPXODU R WUiIHJR GD :/$1 HQWUH RV
FOLHQWHV H R VHUYLGRU GXUDQWH VHJXQ
GRVPLQXWRV
žFHQiULR
1R ž FHQiULR D FRQ¿JXUDomR GR
$3IRLDOWHUDGDSDUDTXHRPHVPRGLVWULEX
23
tVVH RV VLQDLV DSHQDV QR SDGUmR J
'D PHVPD IRUPD R VHUYLGRU H RV FOLHQWHV
WLYHUDPDVFRQ¿JXUDo}HVDOWHUDGDVSDUDVH
FRQHFWDU QR PHVPR SDGUmR )RL XWLOL]DGR
QRYDPHQWHRVRIWZDUH-SHUISDUDVLPXODUR
WUiIHJRGD:/$1HQWUHRVFOLHQWHVHRVHU
YLGRUGXUDQWHVHJXQGRVPLQXWRV
žFHQiULR
1R ž FHQiULR R $3 H R 6HUYLGRU
IRUDP FRQ¿JXUDGRV SDUD TXH RSHUDVVH QR
PRGR EJ DXWRPiWLFR LVVR SDUD TXH RV
HTXLSDPHQWRVSXGHVVHPHVFROKHUHPTXH
PRGRHOHVLULDPVHFRQHFWDURXVHMDQRSD
GUmRERXJ0DVSDUDUHDOL]DU
Interciência
& Sociedade
R WHVWH IRL SUHFLVR UHDOL]DU XPD DOWHUDomR
QDVFRQ¿JXUDo}HVGRVFOLHQWHV
2&OLHQWHIRLFRQ¿JXUDGRSDUDWUD
EDOKDUQRPRGREHR&OLHQWHFRQ
¿JXUDGR SDUD WUDEDOKDU QR PRGR J
'HVVDPDQHLUDVHULDSRVVtYHOSHUFHEHUHP
TXDOYHORFLGDGHRVFOLHQWHVLULDPVHFRPXQL
FDUFRPR6HUYLGRU 1RYDPHQWH IRL XWLOL
]DGRRVRIWZDUH-SHUISDUDUHDOL]DURWHVWH
FRPPHVPRWHPSRGHGXUDomRGRVGHPDLV
cenários.
$SyVDUHDOL]DomRGRVH[SHULPHQ
WRV QRV WUrV FHQiULRV R VRIWZDUH -SHUI JH
URXJUi¿FRVHORJV&RPRVUHVXOWDGRVRE
WLGRVIRLSRVVtYHOPRVWUDURWHPSRGHFDGD
H[SHULPHQWR H WDPEpP D TXDQWLGDGH WRWDO
GHGDGRVWUDQVIHULGRVHDYHORFLGDGHPpGLD
HPTXHRVFOLHQWHVVHFRPXQLFDUDPFRPR
VHUYLGRU 1RV LWHQV D VHJXLU VHUmR DSRQWD
dos os resultados obtidos em cada cenário.
6. RESULTADOS
$WDEHODLOXVWUDDVFRQ¿JXUDo}HV
HDVWD[DVREWLGDVQRžFHQiULR
6.1 Resultados no 1º cenário
Tabela 2 ±&RQ¿JXUDomRGRPRGRGHRSHUDomRGHFDGDFHQiULR
Figura 7: *Ui¿FRGRVHUYLGRUQRžFHQiULR
)RQWH6RIWZDUH-3(5)
'HDFRUGRFRPD)LJXUDHDWD
EHODIRLYHUL¿FDGRTXHR&OLHQWHWUDQV
IHULX HP VHJXQGRV D TXDQWLGDGH GH
.%\WHV D XP D YHORFLGDGH PpGLD
GH .ELWVVHF H R &OLHQWH WUDQVIHULX
QRPHVPRWHPSRDTXDQWLGDGHGH
24
.%\WHV D XPD YHORFLGDGH PpGLD GH Kbits/sec.
1HVWH H[SHULPHQWR R FOLHQWH H RV
VHUYLGRUHVHVWDYDPFRQ¿JXUDGRVQRSDGUmR
E
Interciência
& Sociedade
5HVXOWDGRVQRžFHQiULR
$WDEHODLOXVWUDDVFRQ¿JXUDo}HV
HDVWD[DVREWLGDVQRžFHQiULR
2EVHUYDVH QD ¿JXUD H WDEHOD
TXH R &OLHQWH WUDQVIHULX HP VH
JXQGRVDTXDQWLGDGHGH.%\WHVD
XP D YHORFLGDGH PpGLD GH .ELWVVHF
HR&OLHQWHWUDQVIHULXQRPHVPRWHPSRD
TXDQWLGDGHGH.%\WHVDXPDYHOR
FLGDGHPpGLDGH.ELWVVHF1HVWHFH
QiULR WRGRV RV 3&V HVWDYDP FRQ¿JXUDGRV
QRSDGUmRJ
Tabela 3 ±&RQ¿JXUDomRGRVHTXLSDPHQWRVGRž&HQiULR
Figura 8: *Ui¿FRGRVHUYLGRUQRžFHQiULR
)RQWH6RIWZDUH-3(5)
5HVXOWDGRVQRžFHQiULR
$WDEHODLOXVWUDDVFRQ¿JXUDo}HV
HDVWD[DVREWLGDVQRžFHQiULR
&RQIRUPHPRVWUDD¿JXUDHDWD
EHODIRLYHUL¿FDGRTXHR&OLHQWHWUDQV
IHULX HP VHJXQGRV D TXDQWLGDGH GH
.%\WHV D XPD YHORFLGDGH PpGLD
GH .ELWVVHF H R &OLHQWH WUDQVIHULX
QRPHVPRWHPSRDTXDQWLGDGHGH
.%\WHV D XPD YHORFLGDGH PpGLD GH Kbits/sec.
Tabela 4 ±&RQ¿JXUDomRGRVHTXLSDPHQWRVGRž&HQiULR
25
Interciência
& Sociedade
Figura 9: *Ui¿FRGRVHUYLGRUQRžFHQiULR
)RQWH6RIWZDUH-3(5)
7. CONSIDERAÇÕES FINAIS
$SyVDUHDOL]DomRGHWRGRVRVWHV
tes nos três cenários descritos anteriormen
WHIRLSRVVtYHOSHUFHEHUDOJXPDVFDUDFWHUtV
WLFDVTXHGLIHUHPFDGDSDGUmRZLUHOHVVQR
FDVRGHVWHH[SHULPHQWRRVSDGU}HVE
HJ
No 1º cenário com todos os PCs
e o AP estando na banda B o total de da
GRV WUDQVPLWLGRV H D YHORFLGDGH PpGLD GH
WUDQVIHUrQFLDHQWUHRVFOLHQWHVHRVHUYLGRU
VHPDQWLYHUDPHVWiYHLVGXUDQWHWRGRRWHV
WHPLQXWRV
1RžFHQiULRFRPRVFOLHQWHVHR
VHUYLGRU FRQHFWDGRV QD EDQGD * DV YHOR
FLGDGHV PpGLDV DOFDQoDGDV SHORV FOLHQWHV
WLYHUDP XPD GLIHUHQoD FRQVLGHUiYHO HQWUH
HOHVR&OLHQWHFRQVHJXLXXPDYHORFLGDGH
PpGLD GH .ESVVHF H R &OLHQWH DO
FDQoRXDYHORFLGDGHGH.ESVVHF
1R ž FHQiULR FRP R$3 H R 6HU
YLGRU FRQ¿JXUDGRV SDUD RSHUDU QR PRGR
EJ DXWRPiWLFR IRL SRVVtYHO SHUFH
EHU TXH RV FOLHQWHV VH FRQHFWDUDP SUHIH
UHQFLDOPHQWHQRPRGRJ4XDQGRDV
FRQ¿JXUDo}HVGRV&OLHQWHVHIRUDPDOWH
UDGDVSDVVDQGRDRSHUDUUHVSHFWLYDPHQWH
QRVSDGU}HVEHJ$SyVRWpU
PLQR GRV H[SHULPHQWRV QHVVH FHQiULR UH
VXOWDGRVREWLGRVSHOR-SHUIPRVWUDUDPTXH
SDUDQmRWHUTXHHQYLDURVGDGRVHPGLIH
UHQWHVPRGRVSDUDRVFOLHQWHVR$3³HVFR
OKHX´RPRGRESDUDID]HUWUDQVPLV
26
VmRGRVGDGRVGXUDQWHWRGRRH[SHULPHQWR
PHVPR R &OLHQWH HVWDQGR FRQHFWDGR QR
SDGUmR J $R DQDOLVDU R JUi¿FR JH
UDGR SRGHVH SHUFHEHU TXH RV UHVXOWDGRV
IRUDP VXSHULRUHV DR GR ž FHQiULR H PXLWR
LQIHULRUHV DR GR ž FHQiULR FRPSURYDQGR
DVVLPTXHTXDQGRR$3HVWiHPXPDUHGH
RQGHH[LVWHPFOLHQWHVFRQHFWDGRVHPGLIH
UHQWHVSDGU}HVHOHGHWHUPLQDTXHDFRPX
nicação seja feita de acordo com a menor
YHORFLGDGHGHWUDQVPLVVmR
REFERÊNCIAS BIBLIOGRÁFICAS
$16,,((( 6WG (GLWLRQ Wireless Lan Medium Access Control (MAC) and PhyVLFDO/D\HU3+<6SHFL¿FDWLRQV, 1999.
,(((D ,((( 'RF ,((( 3&
802.11 Tutorial – 802.11 MAC Entity: MAC Basic
Access Mechanism Privacy and Access Control.
(8$
025$(6 $OH[DQGUH )HUQDQGHV Redes sem Fio,
,QVWDODomR &RQ¿JXUDomR H 6HJXUDQoD ± )XQGDmentos6mR3DXOR(GLWRUDeULFD/WGD
'817(0$11¶6 -HII Wi-Fi Guide $UL]RQD (8$
3DUDJO\SK3UHVVQG(GLWLRQ
-81,25$OPLU:LUWK/LPDRede de Computadores:
Tecnologia e Convergência das redes5LRGH-D
QHLUR
62$5(6/XL])*RPHV/(026*XLGR&2/&+(5
6pUJLRRedes de Computadores Das LANs, MANs
e WANs às Redes ATM. 5LR GH -DQHLUR (GLWRUD
&DPSXV
Interciência
& Sociedade
7$1(1%$80$QGUHZ6Redes de Computadores.
5LRGH-DQHLUR(GLWRUD&DPSXV(GLomR
7255(6*DEULHORedes de Computadores Curso
Completo.5LRGH-DQHLUR$[FHO%RRNVGR%UDVLO(GL
WRUD(GLomR
Maximiliano Guimarães Santana pHVWXGDQWHXQLYHUVLWiULRGRFXUVRGH&LrQFLDGD&RPSXWDomRQD)DFXOGDGH
0XQLFLSDO³3URI)UDQFR0RQWRUR´SRVVXLQGRH[SHULrQFLDQDiUHDGHUHGHVGHFRPSXWDGRUHVDDQRVDWXDQGR
FRPRDQDOLVWDGHUHGHVHPXPDHPSUHVDSUHVWDGRUDGHVHUYLoRVGHWHOHFRPXQLFDomRQDFLGDGHGH0RJL*XDoX
VHQGRUHVSRQViYHOSRUPDQWHUDHVWUXWXUDGDUHGHLQVWDODomRHFRQ¿JXUDomRGHVHUYLGRUHVLQVWDODomRGHUHGHV
ZLUHOHVVHFDEHDGDVHPDPELHQWHVHPSUHVDULDLVHGRPpVWLFRV
Manoel Peluso Carvalho pPHVWUHHP*HVWmRGH5HGHVGH7HOHFRPXQLFDo}HVSHOD3RQWLItFLD8QLYHUVLGDGH
&DWyOLFDGH&DPSLQDV38&&$03HHVSHFLDOLVWDHP$QDOLVHGH6LVWHPDV&OLHQWH6HUYLGRUSHOD3RQWLItFLD8QL
YHUVLGDGH&DWyOLFDGH&DPSLQDV38&&$03$WXDFRPRSURIHVVRUXQLYHUVLWiULRQD)DFXOGDGH0XQLFLSDO³3URIHV
VRU)UDQFR0RQWRUR´0RJL*XDoX±63QR&HQWUR5HJLRQDO8QLYHUVLWiULRGH(VStULWR6DQWRGR3LQKDO(VStULWR
6DQWRGR3LQKDO±63H)$7(&$UWKXUGH$]HYHGR0RJL0LULP±63
27
Interciência
& Sociedade