XVI Simpósio Brasileiro de Engenharia de Software
"! #$&%'%(!)*+
-, ./01
32 64 587:9;5<=9>@?BACDE<=FHGICKJL<MF=NO9
PRQTS C(UV7VW Q 5X7Y9;ZL[\5OZ]9;UVW^C(7V<=_a`
b O5 =< G Q U-`V<H7dc^9;Z1>&CIUe<=5EfgC
C;W Q 5OA Q `ehAO<=5i?kj Q W? lU
m I9 l Q UV7:9nDo?>p?BA Q3q (C VU VU ;9 `
r Q 587 Q Us9IZL[t5OZ]9IUeWuCI7V<=_a`
b 5 H< G Q U-`V<=7vc9;Z1w Q U-5OC;WxljO_T9
:U ;9 l Q UV7t9XhR_a<=5y?kjOZ SQ ? lU
z C;5O`6{+?|?}< Q ` Q 58l Q U-f
[t5O`:7V<H7VjE7 Q 9;Z r 9;W S jE7V<=5Of
b 5O<HG Q Ue`V<H7vcn9IZ r IC W S <=5BCI`
NOCI5`ehR<M_I?~j5O<=_aCIW S ? lOU
 L€ T‚ …ƒ ‡„ † Iˆ ƒ
<V7=58N 7:9nWP6CnQŒyV` <H5 H<7s;f Q x5<MŠ‹` ]Z ;9_ C;Q1U `t58_ c&7V9 jO97:UV9oS cIQ ŒiUe` C(Q U-7VG _ <H9gQ U-<H5xGCI<MF1`CI7VC6NU Q _-CIC;N7 `"CIr FMNF 9gQ Ca5EW G f Q Q jEC;?‰7V_-46<=N5E`‰< fQ A G CIQQ 5`VA0<=Afg`V5 <H fgQ 5OVU F` <=ŠT_ _ag9 Q C;uW 5g5O7RKW 9I7 lOOj Q UO5 QV7 M< ON(Ca_ XŽICIC :7V7L7 =<ON IC;9 :U L`O5 g9 R`ŠOj gfONQ ON 'C C(a`G U ? Q 64fNOQ C;W 7:A7V;9 <ME55EC;5ff
<=C;W F=FHQ 9…S Š C;_7xA09IC;Z 5@S Q <=CI5U-_TCIU WCI9;`Vj<=5ES5gfQ7+<=<=58W Q 7 S fIQ9;U-UVCI7V7:CI<=59;_ 50Q 9;7:Z9U `:S 9E` _TC(< Q Ue7v_-c‘N0C; `+FMC’AO`aŠsQŒ NOQ 9;F9 Q ?F Y9;N ZQ G‡` QCIU-7 <=9;Q -_jN `RO5 lB;9 CI=F I9 _VgfŽXQ <f;Q UV`u9;jONO5BC…GAOQ`
;UC O5 `:“A jFHIC7aQ Œ‰l =<Š =F =< V7 < Q NO`KC'G C;`uQ l Š Q F=5–FCIF=`<=G<=WuQ5EfC;A <MQ 5—7:7VN N Q <=[t5X587 7 QQ U-UeQCI5 _T7V7<H9g5“U-C’9IQ Z"ŠsAO<H7V<•”N–SQ QUC’Q 58SG 7uQ UV_ac—jOF=FM7:C(jOU-fU Q ` 5XS jO9;Wx`-`Vl <Hl+U F Q I9 ?–6Z 4R˜ `ulC
`VQ<H7 <=f;Q `n<=7:C;ŠsF*NO}<MQ _-<HlN™UVCI_aU-CI< Q 5ša` Œl aQ Q Q GCI<MFH`V7V<HN 7 Q Ayr ŒRC(U ›Xj Q[\U-5E< QZŸQ 9IA™U-WC;C(Q5O7VA <=9gQ S5‘F=C…DXQ c cEQ `tAœ7 WuŠs<H`a7VŒ Nyw?NgcE4 Q `VSO<=_TS ` F=<=r_aC(9;7VQF=<=FM9gC(5 l9;QTU-ž C(C;7:Q W9IUeS < F a`Q ‰Œ`IC C(5 Q U A Q
P˜ Q lE¡¢lBCI` Q A Q 587 QQ U:7VC;z6<=5OQ W Q 587V`FM<=Ž QQ <M5g7 Q -U IC T_ V7 =< G Q ˜ Q lfgQ CIW Q `a? ˜™<H7VNO<M57VN<=`£_T9;5g7 QTž 7aŒOQ Š Q C(U Q
_TC 9;5_ UVQ9gU-CI5 _eQ NxA Z]sŠ9;U6H< V7 _TKN C :7 N 7VjEQ U-jO<=5O` Q fuU‰7V<]N5g7 Q jOU:Z¤` C;_ YU Q M< 85A 7Q `VUV<=fgZ¤C;53_ Z¤9IAU `V`-jO<H_efgNx5`V<=c` `:7 QU W` `158C;7 5OAuAi? C S UV9I7VC(f;9;5<=`V7t¡¢9IU-< Q 587 Q A
SOS
S
Q Q Q Q Q SQQ Q
¥ ¦ §¨©ª@«“¬“­3¨£®‡ª§
¯"°±u²y³´XµL¶E±‡´·¸"¹º*»°o±^¼X½X»°p¾…±(³E»T¿·-¶0°y´IÀ±µ¤±…Á»T°±uÂ"°y¹XµŸ±u¸e¹B¾‡Ã]±‡»:¶»T¹&´@ÄXÅ]ÆXÅÈÇtÉXÊLËÉÌ'ʕÍ'ÇdÎTÏgËÐÁ¿±
»¹+¸eÃ]ÑE³Ã]²¾I´X³E»£Ò·e±I´8Ó»e°y·e¹¿Ñ°¸´X¾T°yß±'ÀE±‡Áß³»T°±´X·±‡´¸£¹XºÔR¹Õ&Öy¿o»ÃŸ³Ñx´³Á¯*±(µ]±‡¾(¹XՒÕn¿o³Ã¤¾‡´X»Ã]¹E³¸‡×
Ø ¸»TÃ]Õ±^ѹB±‡¸x¹³‰ÙiÂR±´X·±^ºv´8¾(±‡Á‘Â"Ã]»T°—»T°±^¾(¹³OÀ±‡·eÑE±…³y¾‡±¹º»°y±…¸±n»T±‡¾T°³y¹µ]¹ÑEÃ]±‡¸(×KÚB¿¾a°Û´8³–ß³O»±'Ü
ÑE·e´X»ÃŸ¹³0°y´¸"Ւ´XÁ±+»e°y±u·±‡¸e°y´ÖÃ]³Ñ¹Xº»·´ÁoÃ]»TÃ]¹³y´µÝ¾‡¹ÕÖ¿o»ÃŸ³oÑÖݹ¸e¸ÃŸÒoµŸ±+Â"°±‡·±Õ’¹¸-»"¿y¸e±‡·¸"ÂR±‡·e±
¿¸e±(Á™»e¹—Â6¹E·eÓ)¹E³Þ¸V»a´X³ÁBÜV´Xµ]¹E³±&Ւ´X¾T°yß³±…¸(×p¯¹Áy´I¶Û»T°±»T·T´8ÁÃ]»ÃŸ¹³i´8µ£¾‡¹EÕ&Ö¿»eß³yїß¸ÑEÃ]ÀÃ]³ÑpÂR´I¶
»¹&»°±ÍIÏ;ß'ÅvÉXÊ£ßaÏgËKàÝáÇdÅÈâBÆ+Â3°ÃŸ¾a°“´8µŸµŸ¹;Â"¸´X³‘±…ÀE±…·KÃ]³¾(·-±I´X¸eß³Ñä³E»T±…·T´X¾…»Tß¹X³—¹º·±(¸-±I´X·e¾a°‘²y±‡µŸÁ¸…ÙLÃ]³BÜ
À¹µ]Àß³ÑnÖ±‡¹Öµ]±K¹Xº ÀX´X·Ã]¹¿y¸sÒy´¾aÓOÑ·¹X¿y³Á¸´X³Á@´XÒßµ]Ã]»TÃ]±(¸Y´¸6Â6±(µ]µ‰´X¸R¹Xº*ÁyÃ]㱇·e±(³E»"¾‡¿oµŸ»¿o·±(¸…×sÚB¹B¾‡Ã¤´Xµ
¾‡¹ÕÖ¿o»TÃ]³ÑÃ]¸x¹X³±n¹Xº»T°±n±'äo´ÕÖoµŸ±(¸3¹º£»e°y±nå:³E»T±…·³±…»u±‡·´&Â3°±‡·e±´&À±(·-¶‘µŸ´X·ÑX±^³O¿ÕnÒ±…·K¹Xºæç±(Ò
¸eÃ]»T±…¸n¾‡´³™Òݱ’À߸ÃM»T±…Á‰Ù迱…·ÃŸ±‡Áš´X³Á™Öoµ¤´I¶±‡Á™Â"ß»°LדÚo¾T°¿µ]±‡·péHê;ëgì6¸T´I¶¸»T°´X»îí¤Í;ÏI߅ÅvÉXÊßaÏgËKàÝáÇdÅÈâÆ
ÄÌaÍI߅Î'Åvï'ÌaÍnÉâyðÇvð'àyÌÏVñ&ßaÏgËKàÝáÇdÅÈâBÆpÉ'àOàÝÊHÅ\ßÉXÇvÅ\Ïgâ)ÅÈâ)òóÅ\ßaó@Í;Ï:ñ'ÇdòsÉXÎTÌÍ;Ì'Î'ôXÌaÍÉ8ÍÉâçÅÈâyÇ:Ì'Î'˒ÌÄXÅvÉÎað
ÏgÎ^ÉñIÏ;ß'áEÍYñIÏgÎ^É&Í;ÏI߅ÅvÉXʉÎTÌ'ÊMÉÇdÅ\Ïgâõ'×
æ籒°y´(À±’ßÁo±(³E»TÃM²y±(Áç´p³O¿ÕnÒ±…·¹XºR¾‡¹Eµ]µ¤´XÒݹE·´8»TÃMÀ±´XÖoÖµŸÃ]¾I´8»ÃŸ¹E³¸x¸¿¾a°œ´8¸(ön÷+Ã]ÑÃ]»T´Xµø Ã]Òy·´X·eß±‡¸
é ùyÙKêg¼;ì\Ù+ú±I´XµM»T°ûÔ´·-±)å:³Bº¢¹E·eՒ´8»TÃ]¹³ûÚ¶¸e»±‡Õ¸™éHêê(ìdÙ+ü°E¶B¸eß¾‡¸–ÔR¹XµŸµ¤´XÒ¹·´8»T¹X·ÃŸ±‡¸“éHê(ìvÙu´X³yÁ‹æÞ±‡ÒBÜ
Òy´X¸±‡Áý³O»±‡·e»´ÃŸ³Õ&±(³E»¸µŸÃŸÓ8±RÕn¿µ]»ÃŸ¿¸e±‡·*æç±(ÒÑE´XÕ±…¸(× æÞ±"¾‡´µŸµO»T°±…Õþæ籇Ҿ…¹EµŸµŸ´XÒݹE·´X»eßÀX±6¸-¶B¸-»±‡Õ¸
¸eß³¾‡±Ã]»u´8µŸµŸ¹;Â"¸+ÁoÃ]ã±(·±…³O»+Öµ¤´I¶X±(·¸´8»+ÁÃ]ã±(·e±‡³O»+¸ÃM»T±…¸+»T¹0ÖµŸ´I¶‘»¹EÑX±‡»°±‡·+Ã]³“±‡Ã]»°±(·u´0°o±(´µM»T°“¾(´X·e±
Ã]³º¢¹·Õ´8»ÃŸ¹³š¸e¶¸-»T±‡Õÿ¹·@´™³±'»:ÂR¹·eÓX±‡Áûæ籇Òû´XÖÖµŸÃŸ¾‡´X»Ã]¹E³‰× Ø ³¹»e°y±‡·’±…äo´Õ&ÖµŸ±–¹Xº+æÞ±‡ÒBÜ:Òy´8¸±(Á
‡¾ ¹ Ÿµ Ÿµ ´ Ò X¹ T· 8´ » ]à EÀ &± e¸ ¶ -¸ » (± Õ Ã]¸n»T°±@÷+Ã]ÑÃ]»T´Xµ Ø Ñ¹·´“ÒO¶Þæç´X»»e±(·¸±…»&´Xµ:ék¼E¼;ìdÙÂ3°±‡·e±0»T°±@¸e¶¸-»T±‡Õ´XßÕ&¸
331
XVI Simpósio Brasileiro de Engenharia de Software
"!#$%'&(#)!*&##++,.-0/$13245$!#6!!7
+#989/$#:;+45+<#=;+!>689/?@/$+A8BCD#45+E,
F #7/+!##G7/H!)I>JK/HLI##9/MN+4#O4<O45=4P7#RQ
37S>(+45T#U)17/6+67/$VW/>+#X89//4
#4#DW
/TY!I>Z7/%>(746,H-9/J$3I8BC#[>(+45\/$+T##S]MTY!^>AY!+45
$V0?#!+BO7Q^!\467/)+,_LI7<Y
89#=/\#7!0`7/a+!>Q
$6I8NC(H4b/J##,*-9/H!+<76#7Y!SI>OY;++T8=S7/*/$V\CD"
4VW_Zc5+!SZ7a$37#4$B8=/7/N7V!$#454$d89!)!Y;9#+!e,gf$
324!GDa#499h!$N8=!!#DN/$9+iD+R7#46V7T4jY#a$!S#+
"7/A+#,lk*S7M!!S>Gm+44TEVXY!##nC(@+o+!E>7/A$Vnp$46
Y;#I8N##qOYE8=#W%#4T###,5rsS/$"/$\+D2(EG`8NJ++#+%8=/[/
8BE>#+0EO+\+97#h#Ttvu<LwN#x,d-mJ7C(!*/NC(O`Y!#4#G(8N
$+#D\@$7QI#7+?!>(9y+y7/y?975Ea7/U#
(
+h +\# + ,
z 7C({#|$!>(@|+{n/#5@(+)V!0+45$[VARQ
##%2(E,W&##[}6++7a7/JVnQ^D+y4($!7n/iT*+7Q
$X/"$#AD#h#"#~,k€+1>WXr+Y‚+!!)YV7S?>+4 )l
$7Q^+7#5$Dn/g#+7A)6&+37ƒTV$6+!T#4C(N=+
y&#7"„,
…
†P‡JˆN‰Š‹ZŒ51Ž1
`‘’‘d"“a‘
” 4#W>(+45@D++qp%;#!5p;+4€/#:8gCM,?•<#+3/xGZn/
>746H4T*YJY!S<V7R–>?/$W+$\Z7/+=$+,:•<
8N+Gx/$#U*68BE>y/$V
[>(#4—E|8BCl8N#!!989/[#.thV,˜$,%#;#V7S?;wU8=/$6%#+
$+nV$TK/H#0n/y:x, ” 45$#N#n/!V>#OA/07AB
$##™a7<;#!gV`7/#K7CD’++:™=8NC:37(S7##,`LIJV~GE+45$#
/MV97/$#p46V7+!!>J7/WV#<Vm8NCAA+454JEV6)?T8BCD!), F /$W+45$+:+7/!>%!)+$VTE$@7/6$8N+T8=/q8BE!Z8=S7/X/D4
37SS7+#,=-9/WnC(#G~7/T+!S7G;/T(#)!™#GK$p/J$!K/D4"Y;#
:!!+#)!K4;#7=`7/BšY?xG!+9/:#457$!M7(!B]9+45!+!S>
O/$a7G$7/W+!<4E>Y\h!,
k a#+GK8g5##%A7C!!m/++aDA+E,T-™37/#\8=7/"/#YQ
+Vg8N\H/$VB/*74K+!##464U)#GY/D0Y;04!>
YD>y6+!W!–V/A8=/p#4##G<Y/"
8="/T*Z+44TE›7
qS(y$X/O45J046V7[/$VT+qY6n27/$x,1LIq7/U#D2(+Gd8N
$+#D9U8NE>6K/E8s+#0++7H/$*+gD#h#*$g#)!;45
8=/n/+!#a/6R>R7#4W46(+[+!+#,f’7!>GK/$E8B+G’8N#+X/$JI8B
7/+B89/7/O/$+\+6$N$;7!~G(/+G45/N!UY;\V!7#M›7+N
/:+A###,g-9/#>?œg’R7+V7>ž\#?pŸd/$7$/>QIY#"ž\#~,
0¡¢
p
£ Z
¤ ¥ ¦ R§ `
¨ § \
© m
¤ ¦ g
ª $
¥ ­
« ¯
¬ `
® ° R§ N
± ²
 +$V>JžH+1th_žawZg7/689/$*$<#Nx#47N>(746g$3Q
m
MV7W+37!>A8=S7/"#+ap/T#1(+##,:-9/a$DVn/xGx##1[&#$³Q
M+()GN89$!>O#+##?//=Ÿ_a$A/$99+A7/auH&kU, ” !+45+
332
XVI Simpósio Brasileiro de Engenharia de Software
!#"%$!&'(')*'+,$-." 0/2134 4$&%567!'8"*-:9;" * =<
'8">$-?/21@46#$A'&"
BDCE:FHGI&
&
#>"%$J
!K".!-E$LM"%*$ONPCQ*:FHRS 64T' '8".$!&U!M &!*$
LMV8!6NWCQ*!FYXZ
S<S&'$8"$![
#$\ &'
B"!L]^_-Q&
!**"!''^_K`_4T'"*N?CQ* FGD4 4 $4 "%U '<
$4La'8"ZL]'"6$) N?C: F.bU6!c'"*$6d"%&e *&f6ghe`!i !**"S9j
bUk"%$47$->" 0-E$'L]
"%*$6k!\ ''^YlU'')i6\ Lmon!&\ 'p"6'
$J-E$q" 6
;$-/21JBr-E$LsMtTuvxwy]vzQ{}|~4T'#4r&'"*^€z:6‚eƒu%‚zQ{}|v„h4T'4T'&"%^ ;t6ƒ…„†{:zQ{}|v„P4T#<
4T'&"%j‡RS€"% p4 La"!&‡4P
#4P
&K"%*^ˆ]#"e"'U"6"Š‰Œ‹:‹:‹M{:zZ{!Žw_‚Kr‚uv„:„†‘v_|%’rƒ…“.„!‚”fw_‚”
z:vz]vttPu%ƒ•{:y]vzS‚„†—–˜kzSƒ5™_˜)š›ƒœ€v„:„2tPueƒž
„!‚y‡Ÿ|v@žK‚€zQuv)|e‚”5z ƒthƒfƒu¡ƒ…u¢{:Pv8”)‚£'¤ vzS‚u%‚¥
£ )
¤ :{ %u K‚ y K‚ 6
 ˆ
z S 6
t e‚ | { ¦>|vzQ{}ƒ…
‹U§Zž
¨f{}ƒ…¤)K„=f©2|eƒ…yItP¤_zS‚Ku>xzS‚KyJZr‚e‚”‡zƒJž‚zEz‚u>K¤_{:zPt6‚%ƒetP„!‚hª Z“ƒu%’…{:)w
tTu#v_|KzQ{}|e‚%)«ej­¬~$x+­^r-E$Ls]"% $K"%!&'4P'4P
&K"%*^W J%
9_U"%6…"®‰{:r|e‚ŽxzS‚KyJ]”)‚¨‚„!ƒet6‚Ku%
vP”It6‚eƒetP„!‚Žvz2“ƒu’etP„v_|%‚eŽ”_ƒprƒz‚•'t6‚KuK{}‚r|%‚­z:6‚I
vy‚IzE){:_w…e©HzE){!Ž„†{:yp{:z:U6ƒ…“—“‚K„:„rz:h‚K[|v
¤)T”)‚Ku%z vP”[‚v)|e¢ƒzE6‚Ku6ª J‚•'t6‚ue{}‚r|%‚e
‹Ž§>r‚­“YvƒœZw)‚zŒzQ{:)w0vu%ƒ…¤_P”azE){!q”{:„!‚Ky¯y]v¯{!ŽzSƒMvttP„†
vU°2±²vttPu%ƒ'v_|%JzSƒ>tPu%ƒ…zSƒzŒ%tP{:_wŽ“){}|e]‚yDthv…{³…‚e?tPueƒ…¨x{Q”{:)wt6‚eƒetP„!‚“H{:zE‡vP”…¥ƒ[‚•th‚KuK{}‚Kr|e‚
{:kv‘“ƒ…u%’¥ „={!’‚­x‚zQzQ{:_wT«ejU´µ *!q-E$L¶M4P$!*"!&
W4P
#4r&'"*^W ]\ 'D"% "®‰!·D‡KxKz‚y‡
”)‚¨‚„!ƒet6‚uD“‚~v¨‚Iz:6‚‡ƒž'„†{*wvzQ{}ƒ‘zSƒDtPu%ƒ…¨x{Q”)‚Yt6‚eƒ%tT„!‚I“({:z:MzE6‚‡ƒ%t8t6ƒ…uzQ¤)6{:zŒ¯zSƒp{:
¸¤h‚r|e‚Dz:6‚{:u
ƒ“H;„†{:¨‚e'‹7¹‚]ž‚„†{}‚K¨‚‡{:z~{!aƒ…¤uZtPueƒœ
‚eeK{}ƒPv„ˆu%‚e thƒ…
vž
{:„†{:zQ0rƒzDƒ6„†0zƒ[ž
¤_{:„”xzS‚KyJpz:vz
vu‚p|%ƒxKzQ¥‚EºU‚%|zŒ{:¨‚qž'¤_zzEvzv„»xƒ¯{:yItPuƒ¨‚Žz:6‚‡£
¤ v„={:zQ[ƒœ­“ƒ…u%’¯„†{:¨‚8«Kj
¼>½S¼
¾‘¿ À­ÁUÂ2ÃÄ6Å2Æ­ÀÇ>ÈÉUÅ(ÊˈÌÎÍ@ˈÊÏ#ÃYÁ
Ð "% $4 89Ž!ÑD"'&e !Ò8\6$*!6!*9Z6K!$4P'¯i9q"% $4P$!$#"W+Z '"% K9J4T p*$ 4P
!$) Z$-H"%*La­*‘-E$
*‘$)&
!K"%*
~!L]! p"$M\ #"e "%‡$)&
!WL]
&e6 !La'j´µ*" !
a&'$"%e`)"Ž$-( '!O^T" pLaxA$~$i_A'&"J*D"%$M&e *'pa"6$$\ Ó\ '#"% ! 0$-+$V
46&"!&''Z!0$ ."$aiP""%~\ 4 4P$#"Z" ­&
$La4 \"'Z9)"'L]D
*Oj
Ô *!aŠ4 4 $&e®"% "M6MiP
Š'&'
_* 7®!6&'* k*8"'
#"
j@29— x)* 7*"
#"e#"%!]4P$*8"~ &e $#
*‘" JÕ_$_&'WÕ_&
*
&
~ ["% ‡Ö~\ LM "%*
'^!".i ! Z]4 $f$V8!6
]
* Y
" T
4 ' P
4 & " Z
! 8
" Ž
$ ' O
j Ô >-E$_&'\ 2!($]" .6"%!*
¯6*9_!H$-r&\6
"Y+$V
46&"!&''
^T~_*'+'€i9‘"6q4T'$4 *q+.6$&'"\h!9[6$a" q+$VPj~GD&'&
$ !M"%$M!$L‡iT'a"
(ØׅŒ^ "%Ž-E$\ .LM!04 ! &'!4 *
"6"Z\ * U"6­"6 $4 !&U+Y$V[B
ÙµÚ {:ueKzqvP”Û‚r|eƒ…¤)6z‚u%KBk7&
$L]La*"La'""$"\ 9Û" Ÿ&'"!)*"!$-Ž4T'$46*Ó!Û" *
'9)6f9‘'""! j
y Z
B MiP
* ! ' Ñ
- %" 6
"D6
4 #" ! '& \ ZP
i x)* $ U
'& Ó$ * ‘
9 r
i ‡
\ 6
" $ )
$ Ó
* %" ‡
' ' )
9 6
f9
ÙµÜ …ƒ †„ !{  p
&'$8"K`_"~*[+Z!&e["6K9[$&&
\ 'j
J
± %‚ x K| u »{ P
t Qz :{ ¨ ‡
‚ u v :z 6
 ‚ p
u :z  v ‘
 P
t %u e‚ f | eu Ý{ P
t Œz :{ ¨ ‚ ~
B '& * T
i ¯
6
f$ Þ
+ T
4 $ 4 * p
&" 6
\ ** ¢
9 T
i ' 6
ˆ
^ * " $- $f+ß"% K9[$\ 8"."%$¯iT'6fj
Ù
Ùµà ‚ y]ž‚Ku%6ªft6ƒ…{:6zQ¥ƒœK¥ ¨x{}‚K“(BH &'!iPq"6­iT'6
*$Z!0"%L].!'"D ‘La
* -:\6P"%$
" Ž# "\ 9046"%*&'!46"%'j
Ô ‘-E$< *k4 ! &!46*'q'8"%!"6"‡6'! 'p $\6*7 $"¯4K< 'á [9k&'$ &''4 "\6
-ELMK+$VhjŸRS "
O^2 * '¯MK`4T&'"'5"%$€&
4"%\ "% M$)&
#"\ &"\6#[!k$ J"%$
iP'""
\ 4 4P$"H"% &'$_$4T'"*+$Vhj2â¢$'$x''^8! &>+$Vq*(I$_&:**9Ž$6*c'
J&"*)*"S9^
+Z '."% D&"\h6iP
x)*$2LMf9p ãO(-E$LÞ" .+>
9a*"2*(6'&'*iT'Mi89p+Z $)'
$_Y"f^"*
LM 6"%$#9"%$a'906$"D$ 9[$*"%
_!+Z~i \"U!$a$¢$i'#"%*$ ~$-('
#9_ x9Ó&'"*_*"
">" U+$V84 !&'­+.6­"%
&% $!$9*.\ 4 4P$#
["%$¯iTŽ* "%Oj2RS0"%6"Z'6#^h*"Z**LM*
"$Ž" Iä$8"`)"\6T1U
*]464 $&eÓC}ä>1­F$-OÖD$*"c
i"#"26M9'IØå_^)æ…6+Z #D '!M6"%
333
XVI Simpósio Brasileiro de Engenharia de Software
!"#$
&%'(%)("&
*+(,-/.(01%'
("2*(30#4(305"6#(24#72*(8(9:%"17;
<
?
= A
> C
@ :
B F
D G
E I
@ K
H J M
L O
B 5
N I
@ P
> J R
Q H :
B T
Q S
UVHDXW7YZLAJL[D\HKS
]^QTLAJEIH
_ ($"("`a("2b")c-Z*/d _fehgji kZ"%%("#$
Zl("6
T%("$"(
#m2*(/("$(nd _'ehohi 2(l#%24I2
+4F*2p9q#+srutwv0Mx"y0Ptwz0Pt,{|}0AF
(w-
~ * 4 \
t ;
documentation
data
work
practice
interviews
domain
information
Requirements
gathering
C&P=Contraints
and Problems
early system
description
C&P
system protagonist
identification
presentation
aspects
knowledge
base
GPM
C&P
interaction scenarios
development
protagonist
scenarios
presentation
aspects
GPM,
usage
scenarios
system architectural
model identification
new scenarios
C&P
representation of the
protagonist tasks
TCMs
THMs
PCM
C&P
HCI design analysis
and enhancement
architectural
model
TCM
C&P
enhanced
specification
THM
UI design
specification
PCM
~ 4\t _ ("$(*`€(*27 e ")*
‚
" g 7*3;
ƒ „…†‡‰ˆ„7Š+„7‹Œ‰Ž‚Œ’‘„7ˆ$‡‰‹“ `F”€b*I#(#7•-*
–47$"&;˜—‚
b70k2
%
"F™Chšh4$+2
F4›(9A
\™œ2(I'F7)(%'78
Fž4
9’4#72*(5")**a";lŸ•c2
*/2
\#7(2$ 0A2
+™+*(.#7*bj2(#"%24+
b2™Z¡¢\(š`
£"(¤;”€¥™+( )}0A‚*4#$
s"¦(£2*("IK#())7#(("9§%("$"(2;
”aK"*(¤0f
§%(#7T"*™I§h*9‰+
\()*F
5h"#$
K%("$"(p§-*))¨%)w; e 830‚2
l+*Im %'#722(("$*s27™©#7%2("s(9h
27™ª4
7)(%™CFd¬«­ gTi ;
®5¯ 7Œa„7Š±°!ˆ2²šŒ€w“²š‹‡7Œ‰R³´„7‹Œq‡ µk¶"Œ}‡¬²‹ `·—·
F%((-#l'j¤(2
84h"8™
#(™I%'(2-%fb("l#*(h("9M-
h%"1("9¸C!(¹*b%(#h
(4)l(-
("4)
334
XVI Simpósio Brasileiro de Engenharia de Software
!"#%$&'()$$*+,-"/.10324-56-'7"
$8$:9
%;6'<&'$:-$36'=%>'&?$3@-)A$)%$CBEDA+F'&?"$G6&
8%=H$%'$I@GJG8'&K6':<&'$$
L)MNPO)Q:R>STNVUXWMZY[S-O)MRQ<UXW]\I^_OT`OTaW<bcAO)MN 9CI"'/$&')de$fI'$/-)-A$%)g$
8GG8'&A-"$f>$:-h6'<&'$:-$*i)1Z@+jk"'*&$/'i<$(@$%_lm1$*Dd:-"
$:G8&H"5n%)-iT<=$#$'<"o$ NqpgO?rsUjMutiWfv_UjM%vWsQTcwRNqUXWMxO:yS-p'RM8z8Ot|{)O)N~}dO<O)M
buQWNXRz8WMU\)Nq\ 5$:-)%'CI"'/+q)$I$IZ-"'5@)$PDk6'<&'$-$)
Y€\)NPO)c‚*Q-S-p>UjNfO-S)N~ƒ8QRa'„…W%t8O)a8L%t8O)MN~U †SRNVUXWsM 9‡Bˆ$8$‰$C)$%:uKw$+u$3<"'Š9
%)'-!A8'%V‹'XŒ-"5$:>$:-4$I=Hw$#+nJ-$I%6'%$776-&'$$3lm7$IDd:-"
6'&_
-"
"'$%:$*'|$:+jPD5%w6'@$
%|6'=A"'5/+‡6'-&$$
Y€\)NPO)cŽQ<WsNXR]z8WsMgU\TNj\ARs\<r1‘7OPbQ-O-\]OTMgNVRNVUXWsM 9“’g:”-"*@-J•%K+,"76'&'$:$
e-"'n-)'$n“*"'&"e'$-)-_TG)_<"'%T-'>%$n'%-J•%,C–>'<"
@J•g%s-A$'GHg$Z—"'*-A$%)$dD3(%Z>dD
"'1%-"Z$:>$:%
6:-&'$I$
61+n6:+qw'&w$w?6''=d-$(@$dlP"
$‹-"?-$(H$)7+q
%<"6-&'$:
$I'$%u)@Z'$'&K
˜*2$‹g7™I2$)‹u'k03™I2$)
šuL_t>O-\)UJzMoRMRa›€]\)U\eRMutœOTMp'RM,S<OTc—OTMN 9žJ-"|"_0B/Ÿ5‹u-"e8$ NXRs\<rAp8UXO)Q:RQ-S-p8UXSRa
cAW%t8O)a> ˜#œ
b -Q <O \ )O M XN R VN XU W 
M -S W #
c b W ,
M )O M F
N A
c %W 8t TO 'a 0™I2œ¡
2 )¡ ‹ NXRs\<r_S<W]WsQtUjMRNVUXWsM—cAW%t8O)a 7™2k¡3 :H'$¢-£-¤"'Z¥#l5)$&[oŸ7G:"'%$$‹d$<"¦w>'$§'xiuZ8¨x
'"')%ˆ)+qk&'-'&©"'œ¥7l_$&ª$6%J•s-[«Ÿ7-|-"s—I"'k8'%$A
&JGsd1"'&"'$:-)-K)G%g'w$§/+q-"%)•'%w%$C')%'A+q
A66'&*"'
¥7l'$&k$6%%J•%-k@—¥#ld$+jPD§'%$&œ$6u)%J•¤¬›­]®¯V
žJ""#'[‹
'>$$C'w%"')%w%d+u"'
¥#l°$&w$C6:+qw%_D
"'
'$$±>'K'%$&'±²$CG>DI$
:—)e'¤¤T<[ZB*$_|%$:‹C0uB*Ÿ³w>)$?A%"')%´k&)-A-"—¥#l
)$&—$:6u%•'%[nlm$CD:-"—$:G8'&?-"
˜*2…‹>7™I2µ—03™I2¶#$w6'K$T
G>TD
6u=-$
+‡"'e$w§)8P‹"g#$I-"'5-$(Z$*+“"'?$:8$-)·6'&'$$%I"'§A
$:-6'$+,'6'-&$f9P-')$&A66@<"+q¤A,-Gd$8$w$d"$u%
6:%$@œ]G
¸I¹º
»…¼½¾¿CÀ½Á/ÂfÃ8¾ÅĞÆ,¾Âf½3Á¶ÇȽ¾¿n¾'Â:½Á
I"'|6:Ao'$T-´+#"'k0B/ŸÉ$K"6-&'$¦0C<&'$:-$K¦Z%"w
$:%ww$8$%Êw6@$A6>'&£AsË:w$Kx-T-¦$%'$ÌI"6'
$)+u-"'#0,B*Ÿž$C"#6'-&$:‡B#A-)-)-G#$:8$Í$CG>)DZ$1%%T-
+[6'-&$$3-'&5D
"—%<"H-"'‹%6'$%-)|@A_.502£'΍<"H6'<&'$%
6%:+qÏ'ZeA<$(@$%oI"'$Z-$(8$w¢"_=$"6'$_:H'$%¢-"''&"
"'7™I2…B*'‹C"'k$:-'+*-$(@$—$%6')ªG8=…"'|
˜/2©3I"'œ0B/Ÿ·$
$'6'6@©DI"…"'w03™I2©‹‡"&"&"'&—"K6')$@--o$6%$%‹°DI"-"©6]G8'$5"'
8% = H8 :Ë % $ '%6')@7+‡"/-8(@$-¡3Ku1'$8A-"'1&'/@,_9
6'@’n&KÐH$"']D
$1-"w8'%$*-"1w6$%$/"'w0uB/Ÿ5!I"'%$w>'$1K$:%£-
%6'1"1'$%I@%+~%1'%$&,
lP§'J[‹]$%)$°3$§-Iu)%°'@+j#"D¢76-&'$F$°1*'"'
e-16:-"'I$:%Ñ@'%%&§w'&7-"'-$(@$C+q“%<"6-&'$%‡lmC$nDd:-"K$:G8&
"I6:-&'$:$6'%$1|>G'%1—%$+n'$:-[‹XŒn-"H—?$|@
$+jPD*)&'%)$d§w7'-_'$'[‹'8'%V‹>'H'TG6A"'*6-@%=$$
+@%)GI$:8$-)$Ÿ7-"$C$)K$“%)%'wDI"e-"'Iw$“'_$$'&
$:%§D
J-"§0uB/Òe"')e37™I2…‹
˜*2Í'_03™I2©sI"'%$:I>')$°)G%e+qÓ-"'.5032
56:
+‡"'50uB*Ÿ?g"'?>')$I56')$@œZ"'1+q]DI='&e$''$%)'$
335
XVI Simpósio Brasileiro de Engenharia de Software
Task Coordination
Model
General
Protagonist Model
Task Hierarchical
Model
Presentation
Component Model
!#"%$
(& *' ) +' ) ,.-0/1-243576298:;3<=8!/?>*@A:CBD8FE1-5#GH,.6%BJI
K LNMOPQRSMONTRMUVVWX
YUVZMW[\]^M`_acb]$"dAe[\VRfg\ih\j
klmnh
jAopjAqrts
uwv rnxjAhZmnq u UMVyUVRTARA#\%Pp0RzWQgUV\M{WzVVcMd
;|^WizW}z{
Q~$d€
zW(f!|
MzP‚MTMU
VƒW^
wMOW„RMO\zW…V†V‡0V
Pˆ$g_U!Tz‰TRMŠ‡{f;|‹e0A|Œ
TZyMWyVwMW„;M9\W
MM#TRzRTH\zW]=UV
M{WzVVR$ŽWMOz
WfO\‘U[TAR[MPQ‘MOW{\zn‡0Wd\7
z7UM4‡R
’.
‡ M \T X
U [ \ M { W z V R g
$ 7
y
A W ( f %
R z W €
z 7
A “ !U R AT R X

’ ZMWˆMQ[‡0V\AP”RVT
zU\z{W
[‡0V
P•WAdeUPpAW0$
–—U
\MW˜™PC0#.VŠe{št
P›\—[‡˜\RP TVzU
z{WœMWœtV{PLVTRAWM
z

|  ž
}
$ – Y
U M W z [ ]
RT M W ’ ’ ŒVQMWŸV‡0V
P TPCU!{WW{\]U¡AWzW}{W
TRzVW¡|^MUMVV†FM#|‹VwWU
0TRA
†
ƒQ
QW ’ €TRM
[ƒAC{‹MO\PpMO[¢
zT;Mzz‡{$–?Q\zRf\]!c"£[RS¤¥~;¦§+$†¨VU¡ATRŠ‰T;MO
WW.
¡#"£zWz
ƒMzz‡
TA
’ R
—M™
TA
`{\MOUª© K X«d|VQ
WR#V\MW`t{#UVZMWƒ˜\…MOWi\R{
TWWAT
W—WRAW{\zn‡zWi\™
AƒMV{W
zU ’ HŽ|‹ARW¬
™U
OZM{W[\$­"€\.\MO
RT M [ .
‡ ^
Z OM w R =f {W R M AT \ z { W ’ A Ž 
| X
W \ A y
U \ M { W V 7
N
P [ ^
\ M  U M T †
$ €€
| z ® f Q
M U V O ¢
\M{WzV^PCM;‡.TRM[V‡™{#MNZMV.W€
AƒM
™\pMW
R{WO$dAWTRAtVV(f=
A
%€MQWRRˆ
TRMU\
]WO…WŠ‡X[R…MTH\z{W ’ …M[.[‡˜\RPN¢ŽRW
MVR¯MT
W$#–w…
zW™M.W\MO\z{W
MT;MU\V]W‡}VQ
A]MTA
WTW[\Š\
R%MˆWVMWTQ
ˆ
C
R%W{\[*MTAQV{W
WRA$°‹WVR±wWw
z‡fwM^
zWA?WM^W\M
W…VM?Mz4|1Pp²OA(\€TRMUVV†\g|^
zW0VR
MTV{W—UTA
[$™–Y
p7\p¡#"³U[9e0zRy
p
zWAy|z
ŒMˆ{ŸM ’ [\
MTA\z{W
zeFW\M
z{WY\M9€Mz9|^7ƒPp²OR
Q0TRPQRW{^\…VR^Ww
V*MT#RVWˆ
±wVRPQWw
$
´ ‘
M e 0 ;T 9M \ R N
W 
…
V Z OM V g
U V Z OM { W z V V ´¢ z wW 
M W M Š ‡ V ‘
M W N
p
W 9M #
M 
M’ ¢
[\
MTA\z{WpzAe|R
d{Wz‡
cV7zW{\RW{
W‹M
dTRMU\V($–z‹PCMA‹\d
A7W{
R[*MT
zWQRMVR‘tgMWzWMOWQU
MWMg
A‰WPCAW0†UVTARV†U[TARAgW{\
MzR
VR±wVPCWw
†M[^ ’ \MWApMOWpzPCURPQRW{\MO\zWNATRVWMV^PpM$ad
AzW{\RW{
WMO
\M
%M ’ [ \ V M AT N
W z e OM ‹
´¢ A e R 0 { { OM 1 ^
| ZT ]
H “ V ‘
%
W 7
V R A ¶µ g
T W RT U \ M C
P R M ’ d[‡0V
P$a^
ƒW{
Ww
z{Wg
%
MT\.MwM!M[€RVT
’ A™MOM%CM ’ VV\MTA\zWCzeR|^z
¢
{dVtVRWTAN
YMW{‡}˜‡˜\P·UV
W{ZMO
WXtRMO\
$d€W[ZMWTf¡W}MC‰V‡0V
RPˆfg¸jH¹jArŽj v
º ¹j‘
UVRVWw
^M…[R‹zW{\WwVƒWQWC
^ZMVQM ’ VV\MTA\zWCAeR®$‘€4|‹He{ARf1¸h v;uQv º ¹jdm®»\¼Oq™rŽ¼ v
0¸ Zj As *r nm q v r+m®¼9qY©*O$¶$gMV\M[TRMOWYTA{W=«Hf\^TRPCPCMWˆhZo º ¹jgV\g
dTAPCPpMWˆh
jAop¼O½j º ¹j
M[p[RVU¡AT\Šez‡—R[TRVU
W%z;|7¢ŽAeVR%Ww
W{\W|^Š\—V{\UFf‘TPCPpMW¢ ’ MO
(f
MWˆWM
MFƒMOW{McWw
V*MT
MO€U¡AVtVP¾
yMO
0TRMO\A¢´AeRW{\Ww
W$
"dO\y
M#M ’ VV\MTH\W}cMYA‡XU
zWTRzU%W}MWw‡Xz
TAUzW%MWiVnŽ|7MO
NRWWAR[ƒWYz
WyMWŸH“TRU
W($ˆ_0T\SMTWTRU%\{H\|^Š\—PC0M
ŠŽ‡ž¤¥~;¿f~;À9§‹MO
QVSM%V{W
{WR‹zWˆVU
OZM{W[V¢Ž
W{\™MUU
MT\($
336
XVI Simpósio Brasileiro de Engenharia de Software
!"#$ %
&')(+*-,)./0213/546,)0879":;,<08(+4=(?>@,<.A/CB'(+,<:+D?(E4302F,)F5GH,).3/502'ID+(E:?J2FK:+431#,).3/508'L084E,</"'M:+9N,)02(+43FL:?,O:P.308DE.
:+QAFM,)'):+9N,)02(+4PJ2/NR+/"JSG,).3/UTKVXWY0ZF(+Q3,):+0243/51\[^]A_39<.!:`*a(1A/"J02F^13/5'M08RE/N1bF)*a(c(+,<.3JedfQ:+F/"1g(+4h,).3/
084c,M/"'):?95,M0Z(+4iF)9N/"4:?'M02(EFj.3/"'/k/":?9<.gB'M(+,):+D+(E4A02FM,l.:+Fl08,)F^*:nm(E'DE(E:?J081/546,)0e7o/51h:+431b08F^95:?Bo:?QAJ2/
(+>HB/5'M>p(?')*a0Z43DOFM(+*/KB3:+',)029"_AJZ:?'q,<:?F)r6F5[
st08,).u,<.3/iTVXW :;,U.:?4A1\Gq:h,<:?F)r#F)/N,U>p(?'O/v:?9w.xB3'M(?,w:?D+(+4302F,O08Fk9":+B,<_3'M/51yR02:h,<.3/fz{|W}[
zH:+FMry.308/"'):?')9w.3089":+J*(1A/"JF).3(~jF`.A(~j,):+FMrcF€:;')/i.302/5'<:?'M9w.30295:+J2Jed(+')D+:+4302‚5/51\[tƒ,w:?FMry9":?4„Q/
1/N9"(+*aB(EF)/N1C0246,)(IFM_3Q…†,<:?F)r6Fq:?F‡02J2J8_3FM,)'<:;,)/51a024&ˆ08D+_'M/‰?:3[ˆƒ|1A1302,M02(E4:;J2J8d+G?/":?9w.C,w:;F)rk9v:;4C9"(?4FM08FM,
(+>X(E43/a(E'*a(E')/U:?9N,<08(+43F"[aŠ†,K*`:"d!:?J2FM(i9N(E4E,w:?084}B3'M(95/513_3'M/"FKj08,).}FM0243D?J2/U(+'K*O_3Je,<08B3J2/O:?95,M02(E43F5[
ƒ^95,)08(E43FNG?084K,)_3')4\G;*a02D+.6,Q/XB‹/5'>p(+')*a/"1(E4I(EQcmM/59N,)FH:+FŒFM.(vj4O084L&H02D+_3'M/X‰?Q\[Œz.3/z{|WŽ02F:?02*a/"1
:?,K13/5F)9N')02QA024Di,)./a.302/5'):+'M9<.6d!(?>@,<:?F)r6FI>p(E'/":?9w.uB3'M(?,w:?D?(E4302F,"[CŠ†4u:+131A08,<08(+4\G/v:;9w.#B3'M(?,w:?D+(+4302F,
.o:;Fq:K*C:nmM(?'XD?(6:?Jo:?FMF)(c9"0Z:n,</"1aj02,M.C02,MF)/5J8>[Hz.A/|D+(6:;J08FR08/5j/51f:;F@:FM,w:n,</l,).:?,‡,<.3/lB3'M(?,w:?D+(+4302F,
:+08*F,<(a:?9w.308/5R+/?[
sub-task
procedure: action
procedure: action
action
action(object)
Task
sub-task
sub-task
(b)
sub-task
(a)
&ˆ08DE_3'M/K‰‡‘/59"(?*B(EF)0e,)08(E4`(?>ˆ:a,):+FMr[
’ (+4F021/N'C,M.3/b/N“A:+*aB3J8/h(+>|,).3/bD6:;*/iF)(?…”9v:?J8JZ/N1–•˜—”™›š•†œc™Nš•†~žUj.3/"'/h,<.A/h*C:~mM(+'D+(E:+J02Fa,)(
/5FM,<:?Q3J208F).€:LFM/"Ÿ6_3/5439"/(?> ,).3')/5/|B302/59"/NF"[‡z@029›…†,<:?9N…”,)(/l02FB3JZ:vd?/"1`j08,).f:OFMŸc_:;')/‘Q(E:+'1€9"(+46,<:?02430843D
:=‰;“A‰#:?'M'<:"d(?>|B‹(?F)08,)02(+43Fh¡˜‰=J80243/5F5G‰}9N(EJ2_3*a4F)¢N[ ƒ a
* ~( +R i
/ "9 +( 34 MF 20 F ), F ?( ‘
> F "/ 2J 5/ N9 ), 20 34 #
D =
: B E( MF e0 <, 80 E( 4
:+4A1x9NJ2089wru(+4y08,U,M(=*:+'Mr},).3:?,aB‹(EF08,)02(E4uj0e,<.\GX/?[£D[eGq:?4y¤(+'¥O[¦zŒ(=j084§:gD6:?*a/+G‡:!BJZ:"d+/5'
43/5/"13F|,)(`/"F,<:+QAJ202FM.g:`F)/NŸc_3/549N/a(?>‡,).'/"/O(+>‡0e,)F^(~j4!*:+'MrcFO¡p¤¨(E'|¥K¢l.(+'M02‚5(+46,<:?J2JedEGR+/5'M,M029v:;J2J8d
(E'@130Z:?D+(+4:?J2JedE[
z029›…†,):+9›…”,<(c/08F¦:l,M_'M4…†Qo:?FM/51UDE:;*C/XQ‹/59v:?_3FM/:^B3J2:vd+/"'ˆ02FŒ(+43J8dL:?J8J2(~j/51L,M(‘*:+r?/:*C(vR?/qj.3/"4
0e,02F024g.302F<©;.3/"'‘,<_A')4\[Uz029›…”,<:+9›…”,<(c/k')/"Ÿ6_308')/5F,j(iB3JZ:vd+/5'MFK>p(+'K:fDE:?*/?[Uª^(;,</k,).3:?,,<029›…†,):+9›…”,<(c/
08FO:i43/5,†j(E'Mr?/51s}/"QuDE:;*C/;GH0S[«/?[P:i*O_3Je,<02BAJZ:vd+/5'KDE:?*/Uj.089<.u0246R?(+J8R+/5FL,jX(gBJ2:vd+/5'MFI,<.3:?,O:?'M/
:+QAJ2/k,<(PB3JZ:vdg,<.A/DE:?*/U,<(+D+/N,<.A/"'I:+431#084E,</"'M:+9N,Ij08,).#/":?9w.u(?,).3/5'KRc0Z:i,).3/"08'‘s#/5Qu95(E4A43/"9›,<02(+4\[
&ˆ08DE_3'M/q¬L08J2J8_3FM,)'):?,M/"F:‘F)95/54:?')02(j.3/5'M/,<.3/BJ2:vd+/5'¤­*C:;r+/5FX:K*(vR+/l:?431a,).3/B3JZ:vd?/"'X¥­_3B1:?,)/5F
,).3/CD6:;*/CF,w:;,)/+[Pz@0Z9w…†,w:;9N…†,M(A/aFM,):+',)Fk(+_A,OQEd#FM/N,),)0243Dh_3By:?4u/5*BA,d=DE:?*/Q®(E:;')1u:;41uDE08Rc0843D
(E4A/L(+>¦,).3/OB3J2:vd+/"'F|,<.A/L7')F,|,<_A')4\[‘¥‘4A9"/O(E4A/L(+>,M.3/kB3J2:~d?/"'F‘02Fl/54:?Q3J2/51y¡˜/+[£D3[l,<.3/OBAJZ:vd+/5'l¤K¢›G
.3/v©;F).A/^*:+r?/5FX.302F<©;.3/"'‡*C(vR?/^:?431,).3/lB3JZ:"dUFM.308>¯,)F‡Q:?9<rk,<(,<.3/l(?,<.A/5'XB3JZ:vd+/5'5[¦z.A02FX/N“9w.:?43D+/^(+>
,)_3')43F^95(E4E,)0246_3/"F^_4E,<02JH:aj084\GJ2(+FMF"G(+'^,M02/K,w:?r;/"F‘B3J2:?9"/;[lst.3/54b,<.A/ODE:?*/K/"4313F5G®d+(?_g9":?4bF,w:;'M,
:43/Nj°(+4A/L0e>ˆ,<.A/5')/I0ZFl:+4h(?B3B‹(+43/546,|(+'d+(+_b9"(?_3J21PBJZ:"di:+DE:;0Z43F,,).3/I95(+*B3_A,)/5'|0e>:?4h:+'M,M087o9N0Z:+J
084c,M/"J8J202D+/54395/^¡pƒ|Š¢HF,<'):;,</5D?dL02FH_F/"1\[Š4O,).3/@J2:;,),)/5'Œ9v:?FM/:|D+(6:?Jc02FH*`:;B3B‹/51O(E4E,<(|,<:?F)r6F¦(?>‹'M_343430843D
,).3/^D+:+*/;G6jq:+0e,)0243DKd+(+_3'X,<_3'M4\Gc734302FM.3024D,<.A/|DE:?*/?Gc:+4A1CF)(I(E4\G:?FXF).3(~j4€0Z4&ˆ08D+_3')/^±[Hs²08,).3024
/":?9w.Pz{^W}Go1302³‹/5'M/"4E,/"J8/"*a/"4E,<F:+'/K')/5BA')/"F/"4E,</51g:?F>p(+J8J2(~jF"
• · 5 +œ ‡º … cR 20 5/ Xj "/ –
1 ?: i
F x
: F <, ?: M, =
/ ), . ?: f
, <, A. =
/ AB )' ?( <, ?: ED +( 34 80 MF i
, +: 80 * `
F ), §
( ;: w9 3. 20 N/ +R ?/ »
[ & +( '
´²µ¶ ; ”• vœ · n ¸ 2— N¹ K
›/ A“ ?: C
* AB 2J ?/ AG ), . / 3B M' ?( w, ?: +D +( 34 20 F , +D 6( ;: \J ?( > ‹¼ eº ?œ ½ MF . v( j i
4 20 i
4 ˆ& 20 ?D _ M' I
/ ± [
´ µ¶ ;•”œv·n¸—2¹N•k•†œ;¹<¾P…`'/5>p/N')F€,<(¿:x1A/N7o43/N1–B308/"9N/=(?>Lj(+')roG_3FM_:?J2Jed„(+>IF).A(+'M,P(E'€J208*0e,</51
1A_'):?,M02(E4®Go:?F)FM02D+4/N1P,)(C(E'/N“B/"9›,</"1g(;>:BA')(+,):+D+(+408F,"[qƒ^4P/N“A:+*aB3J2/K(?>:U,<:?F)rf02FKÀv¼AÁ6œ?•ž
•¯Âž^·Eœ?Ã`ž|¹N•”œ?•žN[
337
XVI Simpósio Brasileiro de Engenharia de Software
!"!#$&%('*)!$,+.-/!0'1$231'1546+.$#7!84:9<;50$/'1=
$>+'1!?3*,$#@-23A'1"!31@>0B'*$2B9C;DE!,FG&H/IJDJLK2NMOI>PQ8RSJTIJDBUVW>BOX2
4ZY[X-!B):'1\MBJ]JLK2^MI>PZ^RBJTI>J_RB9
a` SJcbTdef0
2>!'1g-/)C$0B$#$3/
FOh9i;T]'*j"2#j$+k^"2#$(0)!-!#9jl!XdkmJcb noI>J_bTd
LJ /K I J XI [H Ap I Oq S X QP >r ts I eR P I o *' > : S /u > Q /" 13 e $ v+ > 6 B0 1' $ k 9
gwxcy
SJ2]O'*D4Q)!z2/h)6YO4Z'1{"!#$"[h#'*h>/)W'1o$0h'1)W|'AW$/$#oC$#^>0'1$!9
l/,RBJTI>JcR{$+}2?C'16$Y~0Bh9
game state
Player X
Player O
move
 1' ? !- # !€ t ‚ tƒ …
„ .+ $ {# 1' S0 5 S0 T $ 9
PlayerGoal: play tic-tac-toe
Wait your turn
Finish the game
Update the
game state
Inform your move
to the opponent
 1' ? !- # X († j l e‡ …
„ >$ }+ 1' 0 5 B0 5 ($ 9
ˆ ‰5ˆ Š‹iŒ(Ž‘t’2“”•e‹v–!”t•…—˜“e™Všœ›ŠŽž— Ÿ
l7 „¡'*"¢>#o$+f!eƒ¤£^¥¦>!)Q'1{-/h)§$@)!h0h#'1Y[^2$|¨"!#$>>?$/'1FO>#\#h31B)Z$@$!
/$>!#9ª©t>0G"!#$>?$/'«<2>@'*X
FO@)2B0h#'1Y[h)‘!#$-/?G:l7 „ž9vl „˜'1@:)!'1#h0Bh)
?#"!Z|!#!$)2B>!)§+.$#>FO>!)6B)!?0$!!0'12?,!$)2B#"/#hh!e'*@-231'2¢
#'1?>?#72h%('1?>'1$:>C$!?C
>F9lo!,'*)!C'1^/$>e$/3*46$!$&|¬!NFe$>+]Q"!#$>
>?$!'1
Y!-/o3*$<$@#S%h>3k!\#h31'*$!!'1"Q>C$!?N!h­!)Q$@'1)/h'A+L4'AQm~$#?$35®.
¯BU'T9°9}2$|
!FZ0$($#)/'12>'1$+.$#>0
:"!#$
>?$!'1oFh"23«0h>9
„:$#$&%#U!{)!'*?!h#})!$hv/$>v0$!0h'*%>{/'1V$)23>v$!0>9v;D/'*'1>3«3A4U&!h±>!{'1)2BO'*z2
!"!#$>?$!'*?$>3D®.
¯^!)E
>FOhU}!hž!$&|²!B4³#C#B3«>h)³$6h0ž$!#<>!)´Uµz2¢>3*3*4U
|2µ'*@-23*'0h>-!]2%'1?>'*$^Y¤BD|hX
>FOh9v;D"2>#'*0h-!31#U2j#'12m'1$\$+$!j>F^0h
$>'A%>\,2%('*?O'1$Q$8!$>!h#oF[9j£\31$/U20B'1$!{$+V$>/h#o"!#$?>$2'1=o4Q0-!!
2%'1?'*$8Y¤SD|{BhC
>Ft'1,2l7 „E9;DQ)!)2'*'«$kU>!)!'*#0BB)QB)!?Bt'*Cl „¶>#3«>Y[h3*h)
|'AW'1,-!3*'k0h>-!)ªY4Z!N>0'1$!"[#+.$#Ch)6Y4W"!#$>
>?>$!'1B9]ƒ]#$>
?$!'*0:
u(0
2!?
0S'*$µ®c¯Y[ D|h¨>0
$>!#9g£^)/)!'*'1$2313*4U{"2#$
>?>$!'1W>0B'1$>!Z0¨Y[·"[h#+.$>#Ch)a$
‘$Y~0B9 1' ? /- # Z œ¸ *' 13 *3 !- # X !§7l o ˜
„ .+ $ @# 2Z!" 13 4 h B# ¹9 7¥ >$ 2@ 2Zl „ !$>,$!3*4
!$&|\/X>FO^$+j!N"!314#7Y!-/e>31$#%h>31/<#B3L'1$/!'*":>$!?8!h6U¢'T9°>9o/$m|¦!
0$($#)!'12'*$Q
>F>h"!310>9
338
XVI Simpósio Brasileiro de Engenharia de Software
PlayerGoal: play tic-tac-toe
opponent paired
Wait your turn
new game
win, tie or draw
state updated
Finish the game
end of game
move notified
your move
his move
Inform your move
to the opponent
Update the game state
!
$
" &# %
')(*,+-*,./0/1324.657298;:<24.=*,.>/@?A2CB*,DFE 'G57?
H
$IKJ9$MLONQPSRTIVUXWYIZMP-L R [\]!^_!`Y_Wa_PR
WWYR
bcRS[WaIZWa_R
bFdS-3LPeWafP
g -Lh_
i
hR3hPWa LjWakWYI)R
YRS!mlnW g odSPR
R
Wp_Tqdh_ dSWYP@srtluvcw3hdSWYRh[xfR
dh_fhLyUCfL WYR [zUCPLVU$R !<{=R=U4hf|[}_~h_YPd ZePLv~ I€-f_WYITUCPLVUXR
ILFv‚
d P YR f R YW ƒP hW )
! 
„ 7
P aW I …
P u
I _ P †L ‡
[ YW I u
g _
FU$fPLUˆR‰WYIuPŠWaI
I‹U$IdŒI‹WaIuWYIh
UCfPLVUCR$PPp_fdheWa_P…
xL Ž€ L}!„PWYIW
IhCI_PLz[R
dhPL
…U$fPLUCR=eY=WaIR
SPhYeWaSL‹WaI
IkY g _3)UCfPLVU!F‘oPL’UCRsd PGv‚uRY L‹TLŽ“} Y PƒWsfPLS~ PLhPW
Wa_RYbƒRpPL”_Y)_PoO•dShfhPWUh–WakfU—RYSYRWaGU4
b–P g WaIP˜P3W<P
fdeWYPi_WsPd [™< € PGWYU4Yb)UCfWaIP g YKWaIP‹P…dheWafP‹eWsyWa g _!FQ
O• g f_[yd fhdSWYP7_trlxvƒw
hdSWYR`d_PGv‚…šfL7-W`PkyUCPLVU!){›rtlxvcw
dSW`d_PGv‚
fWaI …7
g fWYf€_yrlZ_v-w3hdSW…fb_pWYS•cWuvWYWYP–u‹d g ~R
fWYPœ_‰vcw
dSWaRS!{bƒPL
>
hd g ~ _ YR f YW Š
C
r 
l -v 3w d s
W f <
R p
YR ƒP YW _ YW ‹
P ƒP W nW ež -v 3w d T
W YW I e <
W L ~ P L T
R 7
P YW I K
aW R 
b YW I R3RYcdheWa LiC$i!,I g R3WxYSŸc PƒWYŽiR
hL7rl_v-w3hdOWaRseY_xWYO•cW[ g e_[ L[ vW
WaP†[
€-L [ƒ_PdaI [-_PLŠePdŒI
hLŠd fhdOWa_P†!\l¡PZLLfWYP†[eWaIC3hRYSPƒWa_WYPZvcw
Sd W9Rrtl,vcw
dSW
WYI_WLh‚hPLRPpWYI‰WaR
b™K¢_PLpR$WaI<d g ‚R
ŽWaPe™_WaIh=rlvcw
dSWYRh!t$ITrtl
vƒw
d WYRZ£&U$fLSWYRŒ¤t_YTWYIsPƒWY &_d Thf g PWaRW
IQeW‰_fVUjWYY R
hPW<_ WaIsP g ’WaP
I_PL LvƒW
I‰_fd _WafPudh g ~P PƒWt_PLp
hd f€_‰W
IRY CfPWCW
I
IKbe cv~YL
g R
_!™$I R
srCl4_v-w3hdSWYRt_YxR
_Žu3V€-fLhLv…WY-fbcfWYR !
‘ofWYIPKWaIfR$dhPWaO•cW[WYId_fvdab g daIPfR g d _ 
P ‚v YR S p
L ƒv Š
YW - _ cb f YW 9
R aW `
hd _ Y 3 u
W YW I d gKg PdheWafPv‚SW¡U4 PiWYITUCLSWdSf d WYPyRY_¥W¡U>_YZPLWaI`_WYIhfPWa Y_d WYf€_sR
-R3WY g
d g ~P PWaR !{¦UCL_ WP€_b_ R4=dh_fvdabxUCI PS€S9WYI$d _PLfWYP`_RYR
-d _WY LTWaW
IUCL_ W
fRŠR
_WYR3N L†!§`S• g f[>UCI P@WYIyPR3WaPdS_iUCLSW’£_!¨!˜ivW3WaPQ¤ZRKdh3eWYhL†[$
dh_fvQ_dŒb‹RŠ
R3Wah3hL@`WaI_W…PR
Wa_Pdhe!ª© PdhO
WYI†[$U$I PS€ WYIR
…dSfdŒbcRŠP¦WYIeW
vW
WaPz£&d PLŽWa_PQ¤S[`dh_fvQ_dŒbKR$P€b_ L†!
>PR3LSWaIO• g f_,WaI=WYdO«nWa_dO«nWY-t~_RYhLh_Yf !‡l¡P…WYIQeWCŒ• g [-WaI x_
¥
Wa_RYbƒRh[]!^_!U4fW_WaYP†[fP g _ g V€_[}L’Wa=WaI g tR
WaeWa_PL…NPR3IWYI g _!
_dŒIWa_RYbQ[zuR
d Y PRYIWRtRYIUCP)_ g fPZWY…IIfIWCWYIs
R
hPWŒeWYP_R
‚hd W
Rh!$I
J9$¬WYIsš =YeWŒ_PR­WtU4fLFRYIVUL“~ hPW=€-OUCR_™WYITRa g TUCfPLVU[~WYIeWfR
YW I x
~v _ 
L W I g !™$I g Vw
ez\W
IxJ9$®RWYZdh_WYYxWYIbƒPLp_\PWYhY_dSWafP
R3W¡-fƒ£Ra¤™_RYR
-d šeWY L`U$W
IKW
I$¯ePLK
V€cL$P- g eWafPsev~-W™WYI$
hRYSPWŒ_W
PK_RY‚hdOWaR
uWYIPWaSadOWaŽ€R
cR
WY g v‚hPqLS€ ‚hL†!;°-dŒIj_P˜P g eWYP@dhPov‚ifPoWY g R
WYIJ$—UCIdŒI…IfIfIƒWYRWaIYSRY PƒWaeWafP…vcw
Sd WYR$R
R
-d šeWYhLuUCfW
IuWYI=i!l|W$dh_PfR
R
R3WWYI>RY>a_Lf_«¡vWYWYP†[edaIhdŒb«¡vWYWYP†[~-«¡†[_PLsfŽ«¡L’U$P g hPƒRh[e g R _[ ~v h • R
$_PƒuWYI Ca_Id †PWY &edhWn-~SRtR
dŒIeRteP g eWafP†[c€cL [_LZPLRYZP†!
339
XVI Simpósio Brasileiro de Engenharia de Software
!#" $%&'
(*),+.--0/#123+547698,:3/-0/6;2<->=76/@?A=7B8,CD/4FEG=IH/JK1#4;CDCD=FJL47:0=F23+.M;/N-3OP-Q2</BSRT1=UC5CD/#VWNXZY0[]\#^_Xa`UbAcd[0e;fP[#Y
g-Q2]=$=F:QBi2qh,8,C.:Q204v+DMwh,+.-3Vr/+D:j6AHxIJr/#J9=71<=7yP8,x7:38,47C.+Dh,1k6r=lV2<+D4F+D-36 -3h,gn/m -u)A4;+D6z1])B+Dh,6;C.M72047+.hrC.M7-3//-o:jB=F8,h,8,CpCD2<+.+.1k8,=UCD20/>+D4;h,6A-0-n/#:02<-N4$=Uhr2q6AVrV,+./sL:Q/CD:3+D/N/6;2<2o)A/ CD4P8,1:3=U/2<-3+D4F/6;6,2]-=Ftu23HK+D4;6 /
47E20)r+.-u1k=U-0/-Q2<h,VAOz=76,V20),/6 m /i+.CDCDhA-320:0=F20/o23)r/h,-3/47E{47h,:q=F8,8r:Q4|=F1])z234$V,/-31:3+DJ}/+D6;20/:0=F1#2<+.4;6
7= Q- ~8 #/ 1 32 j- U4 €E  D+ 3: / #1 <2 D+ F4 r6 T k/ F= ,V / : t
‚uƒ3„ … †‡‰ˆ,Š3†‹wŒŽ‘o‘‡QŠQ’T“ˆ,ŠQ”–•‹
S— ,h .C 02 .+ rh 3- / j: F= ,8 ,8 .C 5+ 1 U= 02 D+ 74 ,6 ˜- 02 r) U= u2 1 F= z6 }J >/ 3: ,h 6 F4 z6 B ,h pC <2 .+ ,8 DC o/ B F= ]1 ,) .+ r6 / u- F= 0: >/ 7= .C 0- 4 Py A6 4 m 6=F-o™>[@^_šn`UY<›
e#œ;œ}žXa\0eF^_Xa`UbrR m ),+D1])ŸB/k=U6,-I2<),=F2I20),/9=F8r8,C.+D1=F2<+.476,-=F:0/1=78r=UJ,C5/z4UEo/6r=7JACD+D6AxBhrCp20+D8,CD/%h,-0/#:02048,C5=kO+.6;2</:0=71#20+.MF/C.OK476 2<4F8 4FE=z6A/2 4;:0y¡t ¢‰6 2<),/
1=F-0/£47E¤6,/#2 4F:0yF/V¥HK/J¦=F8,8rC.+D1=F20+.4;6,-R
20),/9147BBih,6,+.1k=U20+D476§JL/#2 m //6¨hA-0/:Q-+.-
m B/V,+5=l2</VŸJ|O§20),/9¢©6|20/:Q6rm/#2t¢©6ª4F2<)A/: m 4;:3Vr-#Ro+D6Ÿ=
6r/@2 m 4F:0yF/V«HK/J9=F8,8,CD+.1k=U20+D476 m ,) .+ ]1 ) D+ |6 7M 74 pC ;M #/ q- 2 m 4%47:uB4F:0/ h,-3/:3-RTh,-3/:Q-N=F:0/ =7J,CD/>204$8,C5=OS20),/
=78A8,CD+.1k=U20+D476o2<4Fx7/20),/:&=76,V+.6|20/:0=F12 m +.20)/=71<)i4F20),/:ŽMA+D=*20),/+.:ŽHK/J14;6,6A/1#20+D476+D6=j14;6A1h,:3:3/6;2
BI=F6,6,/:t¢©6
Bh,C.20+Dh,-3/:˜=F8,8,CD+.1k=U20+D476A-R;2<),/q14;BBhr6,+.1=F20+D476V,/-0+DxF6
1k=F6£J}/=FsL/1#2</V
J|O2<),/ k= O
20),/
147C.CZ=FJ}47:0=F20+pM;/I-QOP-320/B¬8,:04Fx;:3/-0-3/-R m ),+D1])­+D-iVA/2</#:0B+D6r/#V­J|O2<),/$2©OP8}/S4UEj23)r/£8r=F:Q2<+D1#hrm C5=U:
=78A8,CD+.1k=U20+D476®t—S4;-Q2u=F8,8,CD+.1k=U20+D476A-GE_=7C.C~+D6;2044F6r/o47EŽ2 m 41k=U20/x747:3+D/-¯
° 47A± 6S² @Y =irb h,Q³ ]´ -3le /kµ :#0[ ·¸-¤f 2<@e h,|œ :3}œ 6®ž aX¹ 3\ 7e ¶^ aX l` Ab &µ 7= Q: ˜/ <2 ,) ¤/ 74 A6 / €- D+ 6 m )A+D1])/k=F1])=F120+D476i+.6i2<),/*=F8,8,CD+.1k=U20+D476+D-Jr=U-0/V
°=UºG2¤» =7[#br6;^_O$³Q´<2<eU+.Bµk[0/Ff¼t e#œ;œLžXa\3e7^¶Xa`lbAµ€=F:0/¤2<),/j4;6,/#-G2<),=F2˜=7:Q/u8,=71/V$J;O$+.6,8,hA2G/MF/6;2<-n20)r=F2–1k=F6
4P11h,:
 D+ 3: / #1 <2 D+ F4 r6 T k/ F= ,V / *: D+ ¤- 7= %6 / FM / |6 2 g J¡=F-0/#V=78,8ACD+D1=U2<+.476£J}/1k=Uh,-0/ h,-0/#:0-¤1k=F6SB$=FyF/N=B4kM7/ =U2j=F6|O
20+DB/o=F-¤8,:0/-3/6|20/V6,/@?w2t
u‚ ƒ©½ ¾¿Œd‹AŠQÀ–•oŠ3•qÀ¾¿ŠÁrŒd’~ˆrŠÁ”n•qŒd“€ÃŒd
+.:0/1#2<+.476rT/k=FVA/:{+D-G=>Bh,C.20+.hr-3/:–HK/J$=78,8,C.+D1k=l2<+D476 m ),/:0/j20)r/jBI=vÄ347:GxF4;=7C¡+D-{2<4>CD/k=UV2<)A/qV,+.:0/1 g
20+D4;64FEd=>-3/2n4FE®EÅ47CDCD4 m /:0-{2<),=U2n1=F6Ix74>2<4 =76;OV,+D:3/1#20+D476Ih,6,V,/:G23)r/uC./k=FV,/:G1#4;BBI=76AV®tÆr47:€2<)A+D=78A8,CD+.1k=U20+D476®R m / m .+ DC ®C #1 ;4 ,6 3- D+ ,V / ¤: / F= ]1 %) ,h 0- #/ q: F= ¤- ¼= r8 DC k= 7O / : t
ÇdÈ.É®È¶Ê Ë
ÌwÍÎ7ÏFÐÅÑ&жÒdÓ«ÔkՎÌKÖL×dÍÔÌwØ
(*),/N-ÁOA-Q20/BÙVA/-31:0+.8A2<+.476£+D-¤=F-*EÅ4;C.CD4 m -t{Úi+.CDCDhA-320:0=F20/-n20),/N-31:3//6S47E&47h,:¤x;=7B/Ft
+.:0/#120+D476rT/k=UV,/:o+D- 8,C5=kOF/V m +p2<) =%:0/1#2<=76Ax7hrC5=U:>JL4;=F:3V2<)r=l2B=kO«1476|2<=7+.6h,8204
ÛFÜ EÅ47C.CD4 m /#:0-u476z2<),/ m 47:3y|-08r=71#/7tNÆr4;CDC.4 m /:3-u=F8r8}/=7:q47620)r/ -01:3//#6K=F-q-0B=FCDCdJ¡=UCDCD=U2uV,+.s~/#:0/6|2q8L4;-3+.23+D4;6,-j=F6AVz2<),/+D:¤BI4kM;/ V,+D:3/1#20+D476,-u=7:Q/x7hA+DVr/#VzJ|Oz=IC./=7VA/: )A+D1])
+.Vr/6;20+.Ýr/-u/=71<)8r=F:320+.1+.8r=F20+.6rxi8,CD=vOF/:#t*(*)r=U2u+D-RL=CD/=FV,/:*+D-¤8,:34F2]=Ux;476,+DÞ/VSJ;O£m /k=F1])
8AC5=kO7/:–23)¡=U2G1=76$1]),=F6,x;/¤2<),/jEÅ47CDC.4 /:{B4vM7/jV,+D:3/120+D476I=F2–),+D-<ßU),/: D+ .C aC Žt *( |) ,h - wR k/ F= ]1 )
C./k=FVA/:¼1k=F6§:0/1:0h,+p220),/+.:iEÅ47C5C.4 m /m :3-J|O¦B=FyP+D6,xK=K-Q/CD/1#20+D476¦4;hA2m 4FE ÛFÜ =kMF=F+DC5=UJ,CD/
EÅ47CDCD4 m /:Q-$476à23)r/-QOw-Q20/B =F- m /#CDC=U-
1=F61]),4P4;-Q/z2<),/+D:$B4vM7/zVr+.:3/120+.4;6®tá(*),/#O
=F:3/+DV,/6|23+.Ý¡/#V m +.20)à=-0+DB8,C./SJr+.6r=F:QO¥-Q20:3+D6,x =F6,VŸ=-0/CD/1#2<+.476à1=F6àJL/zBI=FV,/SJ|O
8A:0/-Q-0+.6rxIJ,hw202<4F6,-uhA6|20+DC®20),/ VA/-0+.:0/#Vz6|h,BJL/:j4FEEÅ4FCDC54 m /:3-j+.-¤=F2020=7+D6,/VâÅ-0// Æ+.x7hr:Q/
Ú7ã@tÆr4;:>/#?A=FB8,CD/UR€1476,-3+DV,/:i=SÝ¡1@2<+p2<+D4Fh,-C./=7V,/:6r=7B/V¦ä¤XZZ m +.23)EÅ4;h,:>EÅ47CDCD4 m / 3: 340
XVI Simpósio Brasileiro de Engenharia de Software
"!$#%&')(*++,-.0/112/4356++789",
9
9
' :
, 9
;
' , =
< ;
' ! ?
> @
A B 2 C ;
)
D E
/ F
1 2 ?
H
G B I
< + J
K
L
3 2 21 H
< *( + < M
! N
> O P(/QF*"<BR2569AS%<$TT12(B"/UVP(*+GWP
T12*
+B5(BDXC"Y
DU/4J"Z
)2DU! O (P/QF*"<-(B+[ELT1\*
+B<]3LX+9
]9GD)ER/.VT1\B
!
^ + _( `
T 21 4 +
B )
( E
a
H
G / `
+ 9
[
D + _( , + ]
*( " E
a
B b P )
c
+ B ed [
+/ ^
(12BBde?D+(_H2+! f
g. / 21 1 '/ 5
3 ?
h
]
( B 8
21 ;
/ B( " 2 +/ c
i
< ]
< B ( / M
! k
j B /G(B12(CIBY.g/112/*3l, bYTH/GHmc1212@/n<o+<TBT+BW/cDU/4]2i
<H2(P2/.g/Dp3La
/G`(122(_C"B< !=>NH$TVB<+)3L2(_=
+/G).g/121/43lP)DX/4+
)2+B1b
q12+<=/if9GDKVPX/".r_sH22i.g/112/*35B)
+/Gq*fDX/*n2Ht'
+ 9
c
2 U
D h
! u# r
2 L
l
3 / 8
/ H
B A n
2 [
+ J
6
g. / 21 21 */ 5
3 B L
/ 8
G P U
" r
+
/ G h
( B o
+ 21 $
/ =
9
+ 9
o
/ B @
T \1 B K
+ 6
H
< V
v B P 9
)
21 ;
/ *( " 2 / H
w
, x y! b! z
, H
X
5
3 / 9
C T ( c
B<21bSxD[@+DX/c11zH)29/1bP<oT1\B
!U{GPDU/+, 3L
/+G
DU/GN(B12(_C6Z"v(PB<XY.g/112/*35B,+L/;(B\'B<]+DX?+2G?(_+5<
TH/DUTH1b
[/43?J
+/G?T12*
?"D["!-jk21WT1\B
JC+T$D[C9KH2?DU/4,V
B A z
21 P F
J
/ _( + |
@
R
< 2 B ( 2 / m
+ 2 H
G Z
+ 6
< L
3 H
K
5
z
?
< B P( / *"1\+1,;?DU/4Lm12/;(B+2/a+((B/+<]/]Y<(P/f/+.zB(_c(_CE!
0
0
*
1
*
0
<== SELECT
Bill
Bill
Bill
Bill
Bill: Click near a follower to move it in the direction you wish.
{|Gm}n7Z~l/+<c/. O P(/QF*"<!
 (B)]
;D€<(2TH2/2W/HB<, 3lU2<.0
I
;BD€T/+_+/2Yr.g/1212/*3L!
jt@+12/)TBhY
;D(P/DUTV/J+<fH6"(_b(PG+1FDU/n<P1 /. O 2 B P( 2 / :
Q B + < P B !
‚:ƒ„ ƒ2„
…†:‡nˆV‰4Šg‹xŒ:ŠˆwŽ‰':‡oŒ:‘P‰4‡;’
@
“ 4” &
• *‰ – E
Ž E
• w
ˆ Š ‘ 4‰ ‘
— /"_+/+2U+$11l$(/DXTE/BU+XT1\*
=/12P[`2"(/`(+2/!˜>?HB
(/DXTV/](*+Va;2P3lP<˜+X/+.0%3l$(P/DUTV/9U3?`DX'™/).gGH(/1%
t/1!#%
/<z/r(B+
K/GHzC;,;2P+(P/|E%35UB?T/"_+/+2-DKGHM/;(B(PG!z#%K+|(*+,
356PB<i/[(B+THG6/+r/1b
cGW+(P2/+hHGHY+1/U
nBD)S%+<+(2/HB!?>?9GrG2
a/+"/8"@(B+THGP6/H12
8G6+(2/Hm(/AGHPKa<(B]/cUGH@2B.+(
<iB<P!mšl/B›9GB1
,:U<2WPB<W[/+/f"W+121/'3LLDaœ"HBL/[(B+TG
Y3?/12Y+(2/cT2(PG"!
šl/2<P)/Gl(BWGH<H
,&(cT1\B
PN2+(P53?Y(/TV/<KT12*
BN2AS
.(P5(/DUTV/H9-"<)/+zH2wDX/4Z/h121/+BwT124
+B-29/+1P<K@H5jt)(P/1212+V/"
nPD$!-žkT12*
BM-T/+/2Ÿ<]9
]YGZ+B11
6+RY<vVB9M12/n(B+\/!wjkPWDU/4
ZDX<",HbZ2RBl/GHl/mr(P/H/+<+/R+Z35/C9l[+(_C9/G<122A2m/@LDX/4
H<)T/T++2LD /Y+1219HN/+HB-T12*
BB!->NNT/T+9"2/6/1
mC+MT1\+(l3?]
DX/*B?/;((GN3L(_$N]2(N/12GH2/<vVBB1b
/.z)TV/+1\12@TT/(c+l(*+GBJ12/+l/.
G(B+
6%3l/C@"¡X("!-{|GR¢J/*3LwZT//H2:29/1<62mH2:
nBDf!M£J/+
+R3lWDXB
XBY
U;GDKEBN/+. T1\*
N9B+(2m3LB+(c/+PNH</r(/n/+<+/+
+Z</nPN/5\P.gPh3?[rB(P2/[+DU/K+121TA(B2T+9B!|>?r(B/;/<\'/Z</n
341
XVI Simpósio Brasileiro de Engenharia de Software
!"#"$%"&(')*#+#,#-.'/,#01%,"##2
3546
7+%3
89:;=<>*#
?@A'B
C
:3:D,%/EFE>GHH:/#H4
I("JEF#
;$KL#M"#"&N
:LG4G,)H
A'B
,O7+4MC9P;Q<F5"#"4MM%.E
HG#3RS+D2,#H"'B, TBU
;L<>P5(?V(9W%
.5G
7@(4X3&BHYL
Z2!%M[?/[?S+DM2@#B\T9]Q
D
:
@.YH;GKM#37@W=B""&VB^)"&#B#%_#G`
4G#9RS+D#C8)T
U
H
;PKaW.D%%V
OS@D,#97bHcR8%"#('
.OT
*%D%N
:
L,#R4M#b
#B"L@#H4 ?B3.DQ
dM%"&'BH6G(9*cef>g,h
ikjl,(DC H>4!
7-m*;
Player
Player
Player
Player
Coordinator
n &
D)oprq2#H#sZ(L%9
#.H;
xVy2z
n BD8oR,4G-%.
9B#.`#+tukBOq2H#
sZ(H;WK$vWw?$46D
\ x 9B
y #
z 9^#
w
r
] % (
@
# 3
C
# B
H
!
G
4 I`
B
A &
" "
9#
:G
""#(4GM#8{H!/D,8H@Mc|5<!S@DB;
}~€[~#
‚ƒ+„Vƒ/…T†V‡$ˆY‰aŠb‹‰NŒ(ƒ@^ŽŒˆY†V‰‘[Bƒ@‰aŽ,ˆT†V’
sZD,a*
7QcD*%/#2?^a!.9#)*?(Hr"'GQ%"#('?*c“6#"#"”?
• 97w?NW“6BIT
5 %D%VBc–#""#DA^#[;—9W%
#AG#G
%"& –%NT
*
%D"#
–
7@Q
Q
N"#4); z H
" H
? V
H
T B
. M
!
4 G
% H
@
Q9 O
7 H
# ,
% #
r
T r
(
9
y
%
.Q4!C#H@#k',C
HD"N*/,"V[,2#B
˜J
C.'@HP;
4!('8
Z
y Iu#‘.HB
"
"=46*bwH#0H8b+
H#
š.PbqC#HBsZ)c(4G› n #
D
::H
"
%u#B
™B:#B
"@#u%9
#.;
œ ;XKM#[?M
,R
CR%,"k'
?G"#"‘h/žŸP
8u ikef9ž˜l”i¢¡jW£¡e)£(¡^¤k¤#¡¥6fHe¦8;§;
¨ ¡1l>¡š©`¡^e˜lkªfh^¦Hl”?M
,«*%,"&('
¬­8^R*%.B%BH«B'®R/wO¯"#"L
% &" ' O
Y\ !
“ # " [
" • 97/]M
DBICgV¤Jh
°BfHec±g, Bh
l>fM
˜#[; y J w
" " B
' @
? !
4 c
A MT "",+
H#
H
"#=.DIGlkªfLŸikjV ¡A£Gikj£(¡^eH²h
lYi”¡jPf³/ž9ª,hj ¨ f O´Hf˜lY¥!f9f˜jOgVe¡lFh ¨ ¡ji#¦Hlk¦˜;$µb
T/DMP#+#
MVF46HW%.
B#.;
Player Bill
Player Jack
Player Bob
directionForFollowers
playerUpdate
playerUpdate
Coordinator
n # B
D œ p¶/w#4G_%%"##
:%9B#.;
342
XVI Simpósio Brasileiro de Engenharia de Software
!"#$&%('*)+,%
-/.0.21435(56.2798:,;<7>=4795@[email protected][email protected]@HM50N"O.@1&[email protected]"S"NJ43T5U.25VXWY3KS"Z4A@7E[\S3]^7B5_QPJ3K=`7Q
N"OaQM8bN"5@5G3KC4c7dQAG?21&3.G7?B.@Z4A@Q"cXHeN=47c+ON"AE.2147f5GF5G.@79HgVihj.>3K5E;_N"A6.21kA679.@143KJ4l3J4SM.@147\?9cK3K79J^.nmP5G79AG]"79A
HMN,=`7cVo/147plP79Fq=&3srt7BA@79J4?97ECb79.u;077JM5@7BAG]"79A0QJ4=e?9c3K7J^.a3JLQv?9N^ccTQCN"[email protected]]"[email protected]"J`7By
.@NyjHzQJ^F{AG7cKQP.23N"J&5G143K8:bcK3l7LQ}|9~29€‚ƒ@€„B…‡† ˆ‰\C7B.u;<7979JŠQ‹5@3J4S"c7d8b797AŒQPJ4=.2147qHqZ`c.2384cK7\AG79HMN".G7
8b779AG5VMŽ7e?!QccK79=}5GZ4?R1ŠQ"JŽQA@?R1`3.27B?9.GZ&AG7zQ5v&2B~n‘u…uP‘K&Rn~v5G3KJ4?B7z3s.’3KJ‚]"NcK]"795\8b77BA\?BN^HM8bN"J&7BJ^.25
.@1&Q.’?!QPJ“793.@1479AŒC7L5G79AG]3KJ4S”NA’?9cK37J^.23J4SgQP.fQ"J^Fk.@3KHe7"VL•>7n]^7BAG.21`79cK795@5B:YJ4N"[email protected]&QP.\QccxNO0.214795G7
8b779Ax?N"HM8NJ47J^.250Qcs;/QF,5(5G797DQJeZ`8`yj.GNyu=&Q.27_]3K7B;–N"Ob.@147/5@1&Q"A67=L;_NA@l5G8&Q?97"V(oN’=4NŒ5GN&:Q>ON^AGH
N"O0ƒG€,ƒ2—† ˆ,‰E35<Z45G7=z.@N\S"Z&QA2QJ‚.G77p.21&Q.<56F,J4?214AGN^J43˜7B=OZ&cKc&AG7984c3K?!QP5<N"O.@1&7D87979AG5/QAG7>HMQ3KJ‚.@Q"3KJ479=
N^J™79Q"?21k?BcK3K79J^.!V(š,NL;<7f3=&79J^.23sO Fz.G147v&Rn~n‘u…U‘K&RB~<Q"A@[email protected]@Qc+HMN,=47BcON^A/.21`3K5p5GF56.279HgV
K› œ‹,"žX‡
“œg,"!)b
Ÿ0‚$ +z¡_$4¢+
W&A@N"H£.@147(3K=479J‚.@3¤&?QP.23N"J’NO.2147a8`A@N".@Q"S"N"J&356.@5Q"J4=v.214793KA+3J‚.@79A@Q"?B.@3KN"J&5Q.Qp143KS"1fQC`5G.2A@Q?9.G3KN^J’c79]"79c
Q"J“QAG?21&3.G7?9.GZ&A@Qc(HMN=47cxON"AŒ¥v3A@79?B.23N"J&¦+7!Q=`7A’1&Q5fCb797J“3K=479J^.23¤47=V™šZ4?R1Ž3=47J^.23s¤&?QP.23KNJ;_Q5
=&7BA@3s]"7=g5@HeNN".@1&csFC&Q5G7=gN"J™.2147ŒZ45G79=”3TJ^.27BA2Q?B.23KNJg5G?979J&Q"AG3NL;p1&79AG7f7Q?R1{84AGN.RQS"N"J43K56.f§84cTQ!F"7BA@5
"Q `J g
= 9? ,N N @A 4= 3 &J Q 2. N RA 0
¨ K3 /
5 !? Q &8 Q 4C Kc ’
7 "N X
O 8 B7 GA O ^N 6A z
H 3 4J d
S G5 "N z
H ’
7 &8 Q 6A 2. 3 ? 4Z Kc Q _
A 2. Q @5 ‚l 5 V
WY3S^Z4A@7™©!ª"Qg3cKcKZ`[email protected].@1&7z«_NN"A@=43J&Q.@N"A’.2Q"56l,5Œ.214AGN"Z4S^1“Q”oE«p¬}VXhj.fJ4N".fN^J4csF5@14N!;E5\.@147
.2Q5@l‚5YNO4.2147<?9N,N"A@=`3KJ&Q=4N"AC4Z`.xAG79]7!Qc5aQ5;_79cKc‚.2147<7n­`3K5U.23KJ`[email protected]"J`5@1438\QPHMN^J`SD.21`7Hg:3V®7Vs:P14N!;
[email protected]@le?NN"A@=43J&Q.@3KN"JL.RQl795p84cKQ"?97VaWY3KS"Z4A@7Œ©ª"Q\AG784AG795G7J^.25/.21`7i.RQ5Gl‚5EQJ4=.21`73KA<AG79cTQP.@3KN^J45G143K8`5
N"OpN"J4cF}N"J&[email protected]^N"J`3K5G.:X3‡V¯7P:x3.\=&795G?AG3C795d.RQ5Gl5dNODQJ&=Š14N;°.@1479FŠQA@7M?NN"A@=43J QP.@79=ŠC^FŽ.@147
?9N,N^A6=43TJ4QP.2N"[email protected]^N"J`3K5G.V
Coordinator
Player
endOfApplication
register on the
coordinator
wait for player updates or
coordinator-initiated actions
player
Registered
wait
player move endOfApplication
playerUpdate
followersChoice
playerUpdate
coordinatorAction
Broadcasted
updatePropagated
coordinatorInitiated
Action
change
followers direction
playerUpdate
direction
ForFollowers
propagate player update
update
followers attributes
broadcast
coordinator action
(b)
(a)
WY3S"Z&AG7L©ª`±aoD«p¬²ONAp?9NN^A@=43J&QP.@N^A/Q"J4=”³acTQF^7BAV
•>NP.27Œ.@1&Q.E.G147\=`75G3S^J479AE=4N,7B5>J4N.D?9N"J4?9793K]7f.@143K5EHeN`=47Bc+N^J™.2147’´4F^V_hjJ&3.G3TQ"ccF":,147Œ3K=&7BJ‚.@3¤&795
[email protected]"5Gl59:X.21479JŽ1&N!;°[email protected]"5Gl‚5qQ"AG7MAG79cTQP.@7=}.@Nk7Q?R1ŠN.@147AB:xQ"J4=“¤&J&QcKcFk;p1 Q.d5G.@3KHdZ`cT3x?!QPZ&5G7
J&Q!]3KS^QP.23N"J{Cb79.u;<7979J}.@Q"5@l‚59Vfop147qZ45G7A65’NO(.2147d56F5G.27BHµQAG7qQcK5GN3KJ‚]N^c]7=k;p3.@143KJ”.21435v84A@N?7B5@5
Q"5/AG78bN"AG.@79=™3KJ}¶·©[P¸‡V(W&Z&A6.@147AGHMNA@7:&WX3KS^Z`A@7d©ªd3cKcZ45G.@A2QP.@795_.@1&QP./.@147’.@7AGHM3J&Q.G3KN^JMNOxQd.@Q"5Gl?Q"J
HMN.23s]PQ.@7fQzJ&Q!]3KS"Q.23N"Jg.@N‹QJ&NP.21479A>N"J&7fN"AvQP?9.23N"J45>NOaN".G1&79A>[email protected]"N^J`3K5G.@5>HMQ!FgQ5i;<79cKc?!QPZ&5G7
.2Q5@ldJ&Q!]3KS^QP.23N"Je3KJq.21`7DoE«p¬¹N"O.G1&7p?NN"A@=`3KJ QP.@N"A(Q5a;E1479Jz3.(AG79?9793]"795_QŒAG7º‚Z4756.0OAGN^HwQ’8&cTQF"79A
ON^A/Z48=&Q.23KJ`Sq.@1&7’5GF56.279H»56.RQP.@Z45V
¥v3KAG79?B.279=f79=`S^795X3KJfoE«p¬¼Q"AG70cTQC7BcKcK79=’;p3.21Œ5G.@3KHdZ4cK3"S"[email protected]=qC^F’8&AGN.2Q"S"N"J43K56.@5V-½56.23HqZ4cZ45
?QJ¾C7{8&Q"5G5G7=¾OA@N"H¿N^J47{[email protected]^N"J`3K5G.M.2NÀQJ`N".2147BAVÁ-i=`=43.@3KN^J&QPcKcF":<56.23KH\Z&cK3E?!QJ¾?9Q"A@AUFÂ=&QP.2Q
Cb79.u;<7979Jg8`[email protected]^N"J435G.@59Vxop147’A67!Q=479A/5G14N"Z4c=™J4N.27D.@1&QP.pQd?9N,N"AG=43KJ&QP.@N^A0=4N75_J&NP.p3KJ^.27BAGO79AG7i3J‹Q"J
Q"8`84cK3?!QP.@3KN"JV_hj.i3T5D3KJ”?R1&Q"AGS"7\NOaHzQ3J4cF™=`7B.279?B.@3KJ4S84cTQF^7BAiZ48b=&Q.G75vQ"J`=k84A@N8 QS^Q.G3TJ4SL.21`7HÃ.@N
.@147ŒN.21479A/84cTQ!F7A@5BV
343
XVI Simpósio Brasileiro de Engenharia de Software
!"#!#$%&'
()*%&'
+ ,!-,!.0/!,
12
"34
567298:;
,1<!=+!>3?
"25@!9!!,A&BC/!,
DB E5FB!95@1-G5HI<2+!(
J2/
,LKIMNC2<!OPRQTS 3?
=U%1'2
(WVX BDX561E!YC3ZX%1'2
,!H!D
3?
5[=\
,1 B
$N7/$
]5=^<!(X_#`5HI<Hab
]N76P3?%%1^8c
]-/59Nd
!,%1+1E
De3?%%1^8c
> ,2` 2B(`SX
^<
fcG%&'2+
D!OG
,I!,gN72/9
%1IB1hh
TOIB
,'F/RO+8i5=^<(
j
kml$noqprl0s
t
6
u #v w
x <2+
%%'A!,1!=!H
,2:+!r B#5FYBT/!,RB3d5=A%!y<2N7+H
,72
"O19
%
/
B(Sz\%|{}N !,h!P !N7X/!,PD
,,]12
"34+$!"12!
"
,!,2+L
DN!,
+1O%+<%~(0!,1D!r+!
"&N7O
2/O5H\%!rN2'D/!"&$
1cB&!
8:6/
Z!7+!c
,%1BH]-/56A{}5= /+
12
1!(r1!c ,2:6
^<\1!c
=N!"
B=%1<2%q
,
,!,2., !,16!<AB+HN-'=€Z%N%&‚Fƒc+'
„†…Af-‡ˆ‰(
Š‹1Œ!e2+\fDJ %1+'Ž+G%F„Bˆq!,
,1N7C*‘R!,
L’“-,
,34BC!,1”_#\<\
5=2
• ‘Z’}$_–c R—d
,!R341%!3?
Z!O]1-
,34fR +!,!
,1%b'h3?2
5621O
\,
,&zBZ
/25H(O‘R’˜$_W5= ,!!6™"š:›hœ`œ+ž2ž7Ÿ¡ ~¢œ£4 ~¤BL¥F¤¦A§ŸA8:G+¨ !
%%1I8cX/!+
+!Rz1
+—d+!G%11BPN\©,+!fc™“ª›hœL « £}§+¬«­+œA¢§>¥6¤¦\§+Ÿ\ B
+!+
1N7!>/!
O+1!>1`
,5H!>3N\©,+!f]™}®+›6ž7¬§+¯>œ7¦Fž ¤^°+£?¯¢:¤‚7¦ «£4 ~¤‚°q!!,A&BE8b
!fy±™&²›³¤´‰µI§¢+£?°Z >
"6¨+C1³
,5H!q3T
>‚
,1N/A!(hVZ<2+
,%1+!!f#
%1/B+{“N !O /
,3d5F2'D‘R’˜$_r!c!#!5H+8B2
,2=I8T
,!
5=5H
!r
,
e-/5He34B
!ZAd
,!0G,9+\<\
5H-,!06 +%'P!,/ d
"0
!7!
3¶]!P
\!,!R!/G!!"YP %'\!!T2
!,
,1=5HA+%1&(
`Sz\Œ3?
P‘ x N %1b}'W_# +
• Se‘ x _–P!P z
2:Œ!+
1N7ŽN-'
15·+X%O„¡KIMBˆ‰(¸Se‘ x _¹1-
‚!6\/5F*34B
!6:º\/!P8* U»B:Y\!, x 'A!"5
0<2%25=2 • » x ]–5=\¼($Se‘ x _‹/!!D» x ½
B e
, F
,! "
1 7N 9
: ,! z
Y 1 ,
1 ! (
’“1!625=%1z5H+ \¼f712<2%b<A1H562'z!,!f¾8G
+%&1!RP» x ½
+ ¨ ³
B ! + < %
7212!(¿’}Žb1¼fTC\2%!/72
"P1!F
,^<AŽŽ,L5=A%1`1!h
e
,! d ¨ % % H
' "! & z
?3 T
/ "
d 2 "! (
) +
6
*1!OÀ’˜0_VR@„†ÁAKˆ8:*1!=Â12
Bg56\ %'`N !W2
!Y-!(y’“¶1!Ã56\%1T "-:>!,15=1%1
7!YY\‚8%!"
/+/
• Ä x –„Å‚ˆ~(¶ÀR’}$_V
%%1I8!0B/56B1]2
B1L3/!,
0-
"34+!03?
5mN !˜
$5HA%1!+(q€R^8.<2+
f¶%&!
2
"IB
T5H !!PA%¼!/d
"3?2
T]!,1¼(
’“Z1!8c2
"GN!+
,<\1H‚0%%!,DB ,2:!
º\/
qH2
"IB
\/59N7
Z3#5H\%11
!":2+!(F’}E1¼f= >X5=%b{~N!,a
,2`%1Y=/ ,!>15H!$B>15=
^<\1P
!,/d
,O3ZN7CX<%15H+\=%3?F+'A%1X EX!,1; B%'A!,!(;Sz
,I<
fcg15D{
"^<5=21D
5=!3d/!N1%1b}'DB=!,12O
,N1%1“'q1!B:1+<H!TR5=\ %!r3¾/
2F<2%<3?
5Æ/!,
T
"º-/
5=2!c9/!,
c12+
,34+fAB.1!+f>,/%¾!,1¼(#’}
, q8c
!+f#2/
>
!""{}
,12a
,2E\<%<!D:%11,%'L+¨ eF1I!q
!/ %b'A1D]/!,
-
"34]
D
,A/+I(
Ç
É
È H
u L
Ê Ë In L
Ì L
s Í G
Ê Î kml0Ï o9vwhÐ
! B¾+
0
+!-!$F
1!˜,{}
12e
,2G3«
ZIB/ "1 6/!+
$12
"34+9+!1¼(
y
,+> %12!$
,D!,HL=Š`+Na%1%1N7
B<D!,'\!,,5=!9+-\(6!q+56+
%&!,!qB3%&12G B!>N7EP
!,/%q3c=’}2
, 9+
h8
"FX<
!"}'³3/ !"
!> 344
XVI Simpósio Brasileiro de Engenharia de Software
4576'8!94
3
!
"
!#"$%&'(
*),+-.$/'021,*
:
;
<
=
$ >
$?
"
( '
<9
#
'
3
5@*!BA9
C
D(E
3
A'#2FGAAH!#)CIJ#
9K!FF(.MLNOPO=5<
F!4#5*Q'<CO=EA
!
85
9
<5R
"AA:S58$T'UA'#D(!##VW!!59
(
X':F
3
AA
D/),+.
<AA'9
!YZ!9P;OH[A=\^]`_:aGb4cd9b_:e9b_Sf2gh)ji@
3
A <
=
A R
A #
@
l
$ P
B
S
#
1 !
'
A <
1 *
k!5*$n
$? 3
3
3
X
(^
`] :
_ e ,
b 2
_ S
o R
g \
A 2
F 'p
(
\
>
*
qF!
B*
G()si@#tb 3
YkA9
!5*Jk59
DmR<RO=
X0AA9(8;
R>
$n.
(m>
u#57F<
B$T>
v$n7
$? 3
#
G
#
B
8
r
!
F *
!
A !
7'(B$%!&59.w7x
'*
(/)
y
z|{~}€
i@79
!#
3
ƒ‚
„Z…‡†‰ˆŠ…Œ‹
…Œ€Ž
'YM5u5'Y;5"6'''
AAH#$%ƒ5<‘B’$”“M
D
• ’R–7—˜G™*)
šœ›-›už˜›-Ÿ¡ "›.¢
]£_gE¤;)”IE)”I7(! 3
hbC¥=)l“¦)C¥GDb4NL‡)l§R)l¨#5/)miR
© <
ª 7
« H
¬ G
­ ® *
¯ .
° U
± G
² :
³ *
´ ·
µ 5
¶ B
´ ,
© <
ª P
« P
« 9
­ '
¸ ·
µ ¶ ¹ n
® ·
µ S
ª 9
¸ ´ bt__:d
• _rºG»!™*¼q_:»½2ºH_:½_!b9¾¿¡_2aa!o9)
]ÀcSg;¨9)<PO=(b¨9)Á¦B·b:IK)!¾m
b98—l)¥ 3
'0iR“M<
8
E¤-*
(!/)lÅKÆtÇ
D
¯ r
´ qµ Ó ¸
Å
Ñ
±°Dµ?¸t¶*µÒ¬Hȯ5´
“Mq¡$M’O=
<5)
!5VvÂ.<·)G§459!(5<A'ÃCE¾Ä
GV
¶D²­È¯*°-¹¸HɦÊ
Æ/Ë
¹«Pµ·ª2̹XÍhÎRÉS´ ÆÐÏÑ
±R¹°r®hµ·¶*µÒ¬9¹®ª<°D³
¹¸HÉ¿±°#¹G¶r®nµ·¶D¯D´5Ô.Õ/¹Ö˜°5¯r¸t¶D¯BΰrÈq×D¹­«ØÊ.´D´:ª2¶rµn¹®¯D´DÔ"±­×È`µ´D²'¯r°5´ b˜A'(
_2c<»SºH_SÙÙbt_2aa»)
]л<gKIK)4’B>;<'k—s)”Ú,k'k
*?)ÛIܓM*
A=*5qF!0ݔYj¦59
©ª<«P«P­G¸'µ·¶¹®hµ·ªS¸9´EªÞ¦®%²'¯.Ê;©lß
—U¤~—˜
S1*
)
b'»!e • ½>™r¼àca2ºG»!f9b¨'_:a!a»9)
á] ½ K
g v
x ˜
§ U
§ Ü
§
’ 0
A G
5
â
)
¥ =
A M
x ¡
ã
.
¤ (D<
@
T
Ý O
B
x <
F
å
)
ä ΘÎUÎ
© <
ª 7
« H
¬ 9
­ W
® *
¯ ° b
ca • ٙrb¾¿:¡_:a!ae9)
]ÀÙSg;¨9)!Ã'!*bL‡)!æumb!¥=)!æu2F<F<b9<8æ8)>¾Ä5!)=w"xv¤u§¡V”I7x!5*(!>4w"
*Ux>
v$n
Ê 5
° 5
¶ G
² ?
µ ® D
¯ *
¶ n
® G
­ 5
° 5
¯ T
´ :
Þ S
ª °
.
¤ (P
˜
§ >
G
F !
) x 9
¨ >
) G
¥ 9
F<
;
<
B
=
¥ ) U
i >
b b .
ç
´2¯r°
ä ¸'®¯r°%Þ¹¶D¯5´ Ñ
Î
ä ¸'®¯rÈ?È£µqÓ¯*¸'®
ȯ*«0¯*¸'®?´K¹¸HÉ8±°5ªS®"ªS®n³D¬'¯D´ )'I7GVWLNbT_2aa9_)
]Ðe<g;¨9),Á-
*>Om)Z—U¤;¼˜Iœ—s#
!'<.¥>D<
B>)
©,ª<«P«P­G¸'µ·¶
¹®hµ·ªS¸9´¿ªÞÛ®%²'¯Ê;©
ß
bU»e
• ½>™rb
¨ 9
0
:
_ a a 9
» )
À] S
f E
g P
æ ) 7
 5
‘ O S
M
9
¿
K
 )  *
) ’ !
!
5
D
G
è '
l
.
¤ (t
U
¼ U
— #
'*
A' M
9
p
4
— 5
*
5
@
) ¦
Å u
Æ é
¹¸HÉ.ë Æì
¹«0¯*³PÍ Î
ÉS´ ÆÐÏÑUí
µ·¯*ÈqÉS´Ußî¯*®%²'ªÉ<´7©U¹<´:¯×rª2ª:ÌsÞ:ªS°
Ç
ªvÞr®hÖU¹°
¯
Å
¯5´*µqÓ¸Ô
é
µ£êGª<¸
?
µ È r
¯ 8
³ © <
ª 7
« H
¬ G
­ ® *
¯ °
,
± ­ × `È µ D
´ ² ?
µ G
¸ Ó bA'(M»!d9_*ºG»»!»9bt_a!ae9)
]Ðo<gEæP)TÂ"
‘O'<
.jÂK)/)B’>
rèG
U¤.(/¼.¤.6'9(m’#5BK’!5ï¥#V
)
ßîª<°hÓ!¹¸ÄðE¹­rÞr«¹¸¿±,­×È`µ´D²'¯*°5´ bt_2aao)
]Ða<gE—s)H¨'/)@ñ
Î
­G«¹¸[©ªS«.¬H­G®¯*°
¸Óµ?¸t¯D¯r°rµ?¸Ó )˜¾Ä:Áu
3
ä ¸'®¯*°#¹G¶r®hµ·ªS¸
VÂ7·bH_2aacG)
345
Ñ
±U´*³!¶D²'ªSȪ
Ó³SÔuò¹S´DÌKÊ.¸H¹È`³2´*µ´K¹¸=É
Ç
ªvÞD®hÖ,¹°5¯
XVI Simpósio Brasileiro de Engenharia de Software
!"$#%
&')()*+*-,.0/1243+5426)87:9;=<.*>245@?BAC26DE24D3F*4,'?@
&'G'?H243+JIK3ML3+()N;3+2FO3>24DP"RQCS:T)()(9?@2656!263+"VUWL3X5YL)3MAF%ZB[]\'^_`^bac]d-eMgfhiYbjkMQlfhm
XnRo!oj
+%pBqrst26D
d6ƒ„|c…^_e8^Y†F„‚‡
3KSpuOvw&'N`3M*Xx(R/1?6?H9
ˆ:‰
~‹ŠŒ

3!V7y3z!(l24Drpu!5@3{/1s|56;26)r&}G?H243M;?+F~^a
a
€_
c‚
iŽ}k-QŽmgb‘'SW9zoo‘
bjb%pBqrsR24D3:SpCO’‹&Ng3X*Mx(./1?@?@93KEIK)l2-!()“56!5@Ggy~^a
a€'_
c…d6ƒ!„]c…^b_e{^Y†y„‚‡.ˆC‰
~‹ŠV
 
i }
 >
k W
S N @
5 )
”
( X
o o Ž fI8w•–!5@
~B^a
a
€_
z!I80•‹!56
!?X—UK˜2@D
3vpB56l243+5@xv™‹šw3Œ›?63+"œ)œIW3+*XqN?6)š&'G'?@263+;?=)24šOr"9()3X?+
c…d@ƒ„]c…^b_e%^1†F„|‡
ˆW‰8~
Š
R
b
h H
i j >
k Q z
!
h b
f g
m z
!
h Ž W
I X
3 *
o !
‘ j !?+”•t‹pW‹pw(3Xq3X24?M”"žI8tO’Ÿ’3+)?@?XE™CD3$Or"9(x!5%&'26569*>2495@3;sCpwEN()3M &'G'?H243+;?+w¡-Z¢Z£Z¥¤
[Hƒ_eXƒ'dM„|c…^_e8^_V¦R^Y†-„§ƒ[6ˆKZB_'\!c‚_`ˆ-ˆM[>c‚_'\`'i]fkMQ¨jhomj!nnOŒ!5{oŽ}h'
bhbI8&*-D}9(3X5+˜&N3+*+x!(&3+*M26)©ª&*Mx(upw;N924«~B^ba
a€_
c…d6ƒ!„c…^_eV^Y†$„|‡
ˆE‰
~‹ŠV
f‘iHk>QjŽzmŽ!’zoo!
nFSO’&)(lL<–)(D
¬!&O’w!565@?+}!"7%!­y!)3X?H3X}“g3X56
s|5Ÿ’3X“F/1243+56*M26L!3C&'G?H263Xq?X®[4^d4ˆ-ˆ6¯!c‚_'\eC^1†B„‚‡
¦²
ˆ-d>c w
µ 8
d
.
¦ ± M
e 1
„ M
ˆ %
a
q
e
ƒ g
_ =
¯
R
¦ Y
^ † ]
„ 
§ ƒ 6
[ 8
ˆ

Z _ !
\ ‚
c `
_ ˆ >
ˆ >
[ ‚
c '
_ š
\
g
¤ ˆ d '
‡ `
_ b
^ )
´ 6
^ \ T
±
|
¶ W
‰ ¦
g
¤ @
ˆ }
½ ƒ e F
»
0
¾ ¦ {
‰
b‘b
N
¬{}&O’u!5@56!?X}"7
­u})3M?63+'“g3X5H
/1243M5@s!*+3+?Ws|!5/1263+563+2@¿À“
~
¦
W›?63M5¢/1}263X5Ys*+3
^e>c|€a³^_‰w²²g´c…d6ƒ!„]c…^_

Z
¸
¤
· ¹ }
¹ 4
¹ º w
» y
¼ …
c d ‡ !
ƒ @
[ ¯ z
e b
^ _ »
!
+
3 :
? ‘ g
m X
 g
V
O
!
5 !
j !
}O’'&(L!:<‹)()D
S
IK3+?@)
ˆw°[@¯¡4Z¢ZZ’¦.±a:²
^_X†zˆ>[4ˆM_`d4ˆ8^b_rÄK€'aqƒ_
ŽFS0O’&')(L!$<‹)()D
gIW3X?@)
!?@3+"T/1}263+54!*M26L3
&'G?H263Xq?XW®B[4^zd-ˆ-ˆ@¯c‚_'\be^Y†F„|‡
~
{O9(24N(x3›:?@3+5
ˆFÁ`[4ˆM_`d-‡zÂ
ÃC[Mc‚„c)e4‡
^a:²€'„Yˆ>[¡-_.„1ˆM[@ƒ'dM„c…^b_»”Å‹c‚´‚´)ˆ-»–Á`[@ƒ_`d-ˆ>N.!3+?{‘mg+.&3MN2:j
`¬{&gO’w!565@?X"Æ7%
`­y`)3X?H3X}“g3X56%<
56J7:pw/:IK3+?@)V24
›y?63X5y/1243+5Hs*M38&'!s‚21Au563%IW3X?@RQ”™tzAu56"?:S:92@Eb24)*KIW3X56lL!26RW¶]eM€ÇXa
c‚„„Yˆ@¯Mºbgj}j
oFS¢O’–&)(lL!V<–()D!
"È7–
‹­y–)3+?@3X}“g3X5@ÆpwN26956ÆpwqN92@3X5H¿179E!É/1263+54*M¿
2@)TIW3+?6VLxE26D3
•¢56!24!)?@2WS:*M26)T#2424R%®[4^d4ˆ-ˆ6¯!c‚_'\eq^Y†8„‚‡
~B^a:²g€„1ˆM[F¦R^dMc]ˆM„]±
‰W_
_
€ƒ´B~^_X†zˆ>[4ˆM_`d-ˆ4»ÃWˆ>´)^
Ä
^b[>clÌ^b_
ˆEÊ!˄‚‡ŒÃC[@ƒzÌXc‚´cƒ!_
„Yˆ-»ŠžÍB»wÃy[Hƒe>c‚´ÎtQj!‘nmj!o!n.S:9
z
!
o o Ž ÏjFS–Ov–&')(L!P<–()Dr"ž7t
0­C–)3+?@3+'“g3X5@=IK3M?6)!
s|5pw((x!“g5@!26L3
SWNN()*z26)?M=¡-_
)V&'G*4D
Ô:€_`ˆ-e
ˆM„wƒ!´£¶]Zu¯!c‚„Y^b[4e1ºz»¢¦²g[-c‚_\'ˆM[-Ögˆ>[>´lƒ\Å0Ô
~–¦»BÊ×4Ø.°N
Ïj+%Ù!
"3+56"*-,2y!"E<w'w'".!5@2+­¢*zN
/1243M54!*M24;U{“}Ú@3M2£*+26?&3+(3X*M26)`®[4^d+Õ
¦
±zeM„Yˆ>a8e+ÛC¡>_
„Yˆ>[ ~
Äu¡ŒÜ Ý°N
Ïjjb%p:–Ÿž2@243+5@?XBOv£pw!
s|5:3X5H
5H9?8›?@3X5/1}263X5Ys*+3
„YˆM[@ƒ'd>„c‚Ј¦.±be>„1ˆMa%eÑ8ˆ-e>cl\_ɧ”c‚„‚‡ªÒyÇ]ÓXˆ-dM„uŠ’^X¯'ˆM´¨e-»yÔFÕ
!3M?:j!n}‘zmj!Ž‘`zooo
?@9(x248{AC(3X"3ys|5/1243X(()3X2
~
b
^ z
_ X
† M
ˆ 4
[ >
ˆ 4
[ M
ˆ `
_ 4
d W
ˆ b
^ E
_
:
Ä '
€ ;
a
!
ƒ E
_
0
Á ƒ >
d 1
„ ^ 6
[ y
e ‚
c _
92@;24*
S
~
^baW²g€'„]c‚_'\
!3M?jm''jo`o!of
()3>G£"©p:”S:()3> "
3+5+’™uD3IW26(¢S:54QE›:?@)T™t3+*-D()!G
);24D3&'*X)!(t&*X3X*M3X?M$~^a
a€'_
z
!
o o Ž 346
c…d6ƒ!„]c…^b_e%^Y†„‚‡
ˆ{‰8~‹ŠŒ.
}iYkMQ¨h!bmh‘g