Page 1 of 50
!
"#$%&&#'()(*!
+&&%,-./#%'+01+2$
34#",2'2&45"2#01+2$#%6%"+
53,'47'2#3&&28'+8%&6#&'4#&%#34"#&
%'0'$2,96%&%4%:1"#6%;!<+&-*=93+>#?+%:/#?;@
A
B92":/#6%#&5
C"+%&$C6#6%#"2&;@A
B
B@AD983+>#%'5:;@
%D
624:%'4#,9 6%#3431"#6%;<+& =ED@
@
93+>#5282;@%
E
624:%'4#,9*6%#3431"#6%;@F&<+&))@8#+>#"%:"%+./#
GD%
B
-624:%'4#,9H6%'#8%:1"#6%;@<+&) )(->#"6%'3'$2'6##34"&'#8%I%&&#&A
D@83+>#%6"/#@B@83+>#
%1#+@93
J;@A@83+>#E2K2'C#@
B@
93L
@83+>#5@
@83+>#
%1#+@AM
@
@83+>#2>'N%
93%'+13O3%"O3%;@83+>##"6#
2&4#&@%4$
P
!"4!&%6%I"#$%&&#$"2:2'+2'2$2+:%'4%:#826#I%+#2'2&45"2#01+2$#%6%"+$#'4"=
93+>#?+%:/#?@1"&2+%2"#@'&$26##&(H* %:E#2>%:
@<2+C#
6%
Q$%"#+8%&6#&'4#&%"2%$R+8%&6#&'4#&;@
A
B
91"&2+%2"#@<2+C#6%"26##$#""#$C6#+8%&%6%#&5"2+8%&6%#"2&@'&$26##&-H )@
%:E#2>%:
@'*H-)!@2":/#6%#&5
C"+%&$C6#6%#"2&;@A
B
B91"&2+%2"#@>"3$#:I+%4#@
'H - )))
@<2+C#6%"26##$#""#
$C6#+8%&%6%#&5"2+8%&6%#"2&@'43"+6%E#2>%:
@%'4/#I"#I"2%4N"2#6%:I"%&@
"'&I#"4%46;@AD983+>#%'5:@1"&2+%2"#@$&6#@$#:%"$2'4%@
'&$26##&*H %:#"4+%S
@
)H(-( ')))--)-!@"%I"%&%'4'4%6
%:I"%&E"2+C%
";@
91"&2+%2"#@628#"$26#@2"%4#"2''$%2"#6
E"2+C%
"34#:T8%2&46@'&$26##&-(H*-@%:32&#:%&@
'H-H)*H
@
'-(-( (-!*(%D91"&2+%2"#@%:3'2/#%&4N8%+@:#4#"2&4@'&$26##&
H(H -@%:E#2>%:
;@624:%'4#,9 6%#3431"#6%;<+& =
ED91"&2+%2"#@<2+C#6%"'$2&$##:2'>3%&%"''6%&%6%'47'2E%S%""%"''6%&@'43"+6%
'6%I%'6U'$2
@'&$26##&* H(@
-)( !( @--)!-;@
91"&2+%2"#@&#+4%2"#@<2+C#6%'47'2#:"#6%"'.%6%"22:'6%"'.@'43"+6%/#
3+#@'&$26##&()H *@*(H-)-!!;@93+>#5282@
1"&2+%2"#@$&6#@<2+C#6%%6"#%":'#62+8%<2>U'2:#"2:62+8@'43"+6%32"2$%:@
'&$26##&*HH*-@*)()* (!;@91"&2+%2"#@&%I"6#
V362$2+:%'4%@<2+C#6%4+2'#442#+2%24T"2&4%8%&442#+2@'43"+6%E%+#B#"2S#'4%@'&$26##&
)H*(;%
E91"&2+%2"#@&%I"6#@<2+C#6%+$26%&3II2%2+#:%'21%2"#@
'43"+6%/#3+#@'&$26##&H)H -@(-)* !@
*-H (!*-@624:%'4#,
9*6%#3431"#6%;@F&<+&))@8#+>#"%:"%+./#GD91"&2+%2"#@
$&6#@<2+C#6%'47'2#%6"#6%G3%2"#S%
W'626%8%&6%G3%2"#S@'&$26##&(*H*(>
H() (
-*)*--!( ;%
B91"&2+%2"#@
628#"$26#@<2+C#6%"'$2&$##'4%2"#2:%"2B%+%'6%
"8+C#2:@'&$26#&#- H -@
'43"+6%"$3"3
@H-*
)H -! ;@-624:%'4#,9H6%'#8%:1"#6%
;@<+&) )(->#"6%'3'$2'6##34"&'#8%I%&&#&A
D983+>#%6"/#@<2+C#6%
#&532S6
"3S%6%
%$Q+2:"+6
"3S@'&$26##&)HH@'43"+6%"%$2<%@
-()(;@B983+>#
%1#+@<2+C#6%2"'62%""%2"6%>+C/%&
%E%'82'6+28%2">+C/%&@'&$26#%:((H )@
*- H*(!(@))-H;@
93
J@<2+C#6%#&562+8"42'&%6%%2+#"%2"
"42'&@'&$26##&)H @%:/#3+#!@*-((;@A@
83+>#E2K2'C#9<2+C#6%%6"#2:2+C#%"2B%+%'6%+:%26@'&$26##&-H @%:/#
2>3%+@
(H*HH)!@ )!-!;@
B@93
L
@83+>#5@<2+C#6%2:3'6#2+8%"%2"%'47'26%
:">#%"%2"@'&$26##&
HH )@%:/#3+#@)-*-*(!;
@83+>#
%1#+#3#"43"6#@
<2+C#6%2:3'6#3"2'6#2+C#%"4D5+2
#'$%2./#3"2'6#@'&$26##&((H @'43"+6%E#
2>%:;@AM9<2+C#6%#&52$%'4%62+8%2'6+8%2K%2"62+8@'&$26#
#&H @%:&&2!;@
983+>#2>'N@<2+C#6%#/##I%&
#"6%2"#%
&:%"2'6+:%26
#"6%2"#@'&$26##&HH %:/#3+#;%
93%'
+13O3%"O3%@83+>##"6#@<2+C#6%#&53&4#+2'%"2I"%$26+2'@'&$26#%:-H (@
'43"+6%/#3+#@( H! !;
!'4%'6%#"O3%4&%"%:#&"53&"%&I#'&N8%2&@':%6266%&3&I"42$2I.X%&@I%+#<3"4##$#""26#'#
E'$#
%'4"+6#E"&2+@&%6%%:#"4+%S@%:*6%>#&4#6%96%&%K4!<%2"I"&N16#;%O3%
"%&3+4#3'&314"./#6%Y*) @9$%'4#%&%&&%'4%O34"#:2+CX%&@&%4%$%'4#&%$2'OZ%'4%
$2'$#:2+@$%'4#%$2'OZ%'46%"%2&;#3$%"$6%Y 9&%4%'4%3::2+CX%&6%6T+"%&;@<4#
%&4%2'6%:I3"./#$#:I+%4@'#O3%62S"%&I%24#6%&$#1%"46%4#6#&#&%'8#+826#&'&628%"&&<&%&
6#2+Q$24#@O32&&%V:,I+'%V:%'4#@<2''$2:%'4#@2'<#":.X%&@""%>2:%'4./#6%I%&&#+@6#$3:%'4./#
<+&@+3>352&6%2:T8%2&@$#'&42432./#6%%:I"%&6%<$C6@%&4"45>2&6%$#1%"43"%6%&I2&4:%'4#@
%O32I%&6%%K%$3./#$#'<#":%&3&%&I%$2+266%&@I"42+C@62&4"2132./#%#$3+4:%'4#6#I"#634#6#<3"4#@
http://www.jfce.jus.br/consultaProcessual/resimprsentintegra.asp?CodDoc=2177598
3/11/2010
Page 2 of 50
<3>@"%$3I%"./#6#I"#634#%+8>%:@%&4'6#%:$3"&##I"#$%&&#'*(H H!"%<%"%'4%
#34"#&$3&6#&%#&6%&6#1":%'4#&6#$"2:%
-!%'6#%:82&4&I%$3+2"266%&6#$&#@%'4%'6#I#"1%:C2&4#"2"#<%24#
BP
)!%>2&4"%!&%O3%+36#I%"2$2+') !
9<+&)-)- -8#+;@&&2'6#I%+#&I%"24#&$"2:2'2&
<%6%"2&+N82#%>3'6#[>'%"%"$%+#6%\"%'$%E&&RE+3:@$#:I"#8O3%4+<3"4##$#""%3$#:
342+2S./#6%40'%+%&$86#I"42"6$&' 636%:".#@"%>2/#$%'4"+6%#"4+%S9<#4#&
<+&HH(%(*-(**;@+3>6I#"3:2'628Q63#O3%&%26%'42<2$#3$#:#&%'6#3+#5">2#6%#3S
96#$3:%'4#&I%&&#2&%"%+428#&F%:I"%&6%#3S":2'4542$F&<+&)* @ ) *@((@HHH@
-)*@)-@)*)-@*)@**-@*-)*-*!6%I#2:%'4#6%322'C%2"#E"1#&0'2#"F&<+&*)*;
%O3%$C%>#345$&<#"4%6#E'$#
%'4"+@62&4'4%:2&6% 9&%4%'4%$2'$#;:%4"#&@#'6%3:
+V%6%$#'$"%4#6%@:6%%&I%&&3"<#2"#:I26
!%<%"26#+36#2'62$O3%O36"2+C3&8"%<%"26"%&26U'$2$#:#&314%"<0>2#6%&%"&%6%6%3:
%:I"%&6%>":&2'4542$@6%I#&24'6#%:&3&6%I%'6U'$2&@#$3+46&%:I"%6%&<+&&6%>%&&#@
4%"""%42"66#40'%+]#1&%"8!&%@4:15:O3%624#40'%+42'C%'4"662&<".6$#:4:I6%4$#&@%"
%O32I6#$#:&2&4%:6%"%<"2>%"./#@2+3:2'./#"42<2$2+%+'4%"'&6%&%>3"'.@+5:6%$#'4"$#:H
9'#8%$%'4#&;%&$#"&6%:6%2"$#:I"%%'$C2:%'4#6%">:&&@8%'42+6#"%&%&%>:%'4#&6%431#&6%
$2:%'4#
*!%"2<2$!&%@2'6@O3%#&2'<"4#"%&342+2S":&%""I#"4N42+$2"$3+"%+54"2$@$#:62&$#62:'46#@
6%826:%'4%6I46I"#&%"82.#6%$#"4%6%$#'$"%4#'8%"42$+@+5:6%<3"6%2"%+54"2$:'3+%
:$$#C26"N3+2$#
!+36#%:"%<%"U'$24:15:2'62$O3%O36"2+C4%8%'%$%&&266%6%+%8'4:%'4#4#I#>"N<2$#I"582#
%$#'44#$#:2'<#":.X%&"%+428&F%&I%&&3"6I"%6%@I#&2./#6#&#1V%4#&'#2'4%"2#"6
2K#"4%%
62&I#&2./#6#&2&4%:6%&%>3"'.@$#'4'6#$#:&I+'4&6#%62<Q$2#@%:%&I%$2+6
2K#"4%6#
E
%6%#34"&2'<#":.X%&I"282+%>26&I"%K%$3./#6#40'%+$#:4:'CI"%$2&/#@#O3%"%<#".
C2IT4%&%6%I"42$2I./#6%I%&&#&O3%4"1+C:#34"1+C":'#E'$#
%'4"+#3'$#'&4"3./#6#
%62<Q$2##3'2'&4+./#6#&&2&4%:&6%&%>3"'.936#'*!
6%<+&(()H@<#4#&
<+&((H 6#()(*!;
(!"2&%!&%@2'6@O3%#'3:%"N"2#<3"46#9Y*) @;$"$4%"2S#3!&%I#"&%"$#'&4243Q6#6%'#4&
6%$2'OZ%'4"%2&O3%VN%&428%":%:$2"$3+./#@&%'6#O3%'#2'4%"2#"6
2K#"4%%K2&42:2'6:324#&
#34"#&:2+CX%&6%"%2&%:'#4&&%"26&@O3%<#":%8246&I%+#&I"42$2I'4%&6#$"2:%@#O3%4:15:
6%:#'&4"I"582#$#'C%$2:%'4#45:%&:#662&I#&2./#6#&:.#&6%62'C%2"#@$#'<#":%&%8%"2<2$4"85&
6#+36#'*!
6%<+&((H-8#+6#()(*!]624#+36#<2":@2'6@O3%
#&&&+4'4%&"#:I%":$#'4%'6#"%&6%62'C%2"#%428%":#$3266#6%'6""%'4%F&I"%6%&@%824'6##&
&%'&#"%&6%:#82:%'4#@45$C%>"%:#&$#'4%'6#"%&6%&%V6#&&&&+4'4%&342+2S":@4:15:@
"#+6'&%"%$2I2%'4%42I#4:1#"$#"46#8%"42$+:%'4%%:<#":6%I%O3%'1+&@6%<#":6%&+2S"%
$#'63S2"#'3:%"N"2#I#"6%'4"#6#40'%+45"%&26U'$22'2$2+@6%#'6%%:I"%%'6%":<3>
H!&2'8%&42>.X%&2'2$2":!&%+#>#IT&6%&$#1%"46#<3"4#@%:(6%>#&4#6%!&%>3'6!<%2"@
&%'6#O3%'#626#:%&:#:U&@#$#""%3I"2&/##6%'3'$26#A
B
B
O3%6O32"2"@'#62*6%>#&4#@'#8%8%Q$3+#&6%:I"%&E"2+C%
"9%:I"%&6:2'2&4"6I#"
I%"4%'$%'4%#&4:15:"53&AD%
;I>'6#@%:'#4&6%$2'OZ%'4"%2&@YH(@9'#8%$%'4#&%#24%'4:2+"%2&;@&%'6#O3%
#&5
C"+%&4"'&I#"484"U&6#&8%Q$3+#&%:3:$:2'C/#$%>#'C6%&3%:I"%&"'&I#"4%&@4%'6#
&Q6#6%#"4+%S
%: 6%>#&4#96#:2'>#;$#:6%&42'#/#3+#@&%'6#2'4%"$%I46#%:2'&
%"2&@#$&2/#%:O3%<#":%'$#'4"6#&Y-H* 94"U&:2+CX%&@'#8%$%'4#&%$2'OZ%'4%&%2&:2+@
&%4%$%'4#&%$2'OZ%'4"%2&9<+&H!-8#+;6##$3+4#&%:624#&8%Q$3+#&
#'&46&<+&(-6#@
"%+./#4#4+6#&#'S%8%Q$3+#&4"'&I#"46#&'#$&2/#
!
#'&46&<+&)*6#@6%8#+3./#@I#"I"4%6%AD%
F34#"266%I#+2$2+@6%*-(*$563+&6%Y@$6@
4#4+2S'6#O3'426%Y(H-@9#24#$%'4#&%6%S%'#8%:2+%4"%S%'4#&"%2&;6#&YH(@
"%$%126#&6%#&5
C"+%&$C6#6%#"2&
!I"#&&%>32:%'4#6&2'8%&42>.X%&%'&%V#3O3%#2'2&45"2#01+2$#%6%"+6%'3'$2&&%9<+&-*6#
I"%&%'4%I"#$%&&#;@%:6%&%4%:1"#6%@#&"53&=93+>#
?+%:/#?;@
A
B92":/#6%#&5
C"+%&$C6#6%#"2&;@A
B
B@AD983+>#%'5:;@
%D9"#$%&&#'()(*!!$#:
4%&4%:3'C&""#+6&;@4%'6#6%'0'$2&26#"%$%126%:*6%&%4%:1"#6%@$#:2'4%""#>4T"2#6#&
"53&I"%&#&:"$6#&I"#626%&%4%:1"#6%@4%'6#&26#6%4%":2'6$24./#@2'42:./#%
2'4%""#>4T"2#%6%<%&I"5826%6%36%#3S4#&I#"$"4I"%$4T"2I"
#:"$6%E#2>%:%
$24./#I#"%624+6%'47'2#3&&28'+8%&6#&'4#&%"$#&#>5"2#$C6#6%#"2&9<+&-6./#
I%'+$246;
!""#3#2'2&45"2#01+2$#%6%"+'6%'0'$2@%:&3:@O3%'47'2#3&&28'<#2"%$#'C%$26#$#:#
I"4%2'4%>"'4%6O36"2+CO3%#$3I8$& 636%".#@1%:$#:#&%'6#3:6&
I%&&#&O3%I"42$2I#36O32&2./#6#&8%Q$3+#&'E"2+C%
"@&&2:$#:#"$#&#>5"2#$C6#6%
#"2&@%&$+"%$%'6#O3%#&2":/#&#&5+2S#:"4%%"''6%&2%2"%"'$2&$#%":28+%"''6%&2%2"@
I"#I"2%4N"2#&6E"2+C%
"8%'6%":#&#'S%8%Q$3+#&#&5
C"+%&$C6#6%#"2&%:'%>#$2./#
&3&I%24@&%'6#4:15:'%13+#&&"%+.X%&6E"2+C%
"$#:4"'&I#"46#"6%#&5
C"+%&@
"'&I#"4%&6%8%Q$3+#&@O3%VNI%"4%'$%3#&2":/#&%"''6%&2%2"2S2'66%'0'$2O3%#&5
+2S#:"4%@#&5
C"+%&%#2'628Q63#$#'C%$26#$#:#3+#5">2#<#":"%$#'C%$26#&4%'4'6#+3>"3:
82/#'#62(9<+&)*) 6#;2S#"O3%4O3%6%36%#3&4#&@"%&26%'4%%:E#
2>%:%:#4#"2&46%N"$2#"R$C6#6%#"2&@%&4%2":/#6%"$#&#>5"2#%#&5
C"+%&@<#282&4#
%:6+%'
$#:>"'6%O3'4266%6%'#4&6%Y@9$2'OZ%'4"%2&;
-!'4%'6%#2'2&45"2#01+2$#%6%"+O3%#&"53&=%
A
B%&4/#2'$3"&#&'&I%'&6#&"4&@^)$$"4((%-)6#
T62>#
%'+%"4@^@%^@6%2H*-H(@%'O3'4#A
B
B%
%&4/#2'$3"&#&'&I%'&6#"4@^@6%2H*-H(%AD
http://www.jfce.jus.br/consultaProcessual/resimprsentintegra.asp?CodDoc=2177598
3/11/2010
Page 11 of 50
B
B@AD983+>#%'5:;@
@624:%'4#,9 6%#3431"#6%;<+& =
ED@
@93+>#5282;@%
E@624:%'4#,9*6%#3431"#6%;@F&<+&))@8#+@
GD@
B%-624:%'4#,9H6%'#8%:1"#6%;@<+&
) )(-@A
D@83+>#%6"/#@B@83+>#
%1#+%@
93
J;
*-!A#"%+4T"2#&&#6%$262"
*)!"4#I"%&%'4%I"#$%&&#6%8%"2<2$./#634#"2%I"42$2I.X%&'#<3"4##$#""26#'#E'$#
%'4"+6#
E"&2+@&%6%%:#"4+%S@%:*6%>#&4#6%96%&%K4!<%2"I"&N16#;%O3%"%&3+4#3'
&314"./#6%Y*) @9$%'4#%&%&&%'4%O34"#:2+CX%&@&%4%$%'4#&%$2'OZ%'4%$2'$#:2+@
$%'4#%$2'OZ%'46%"%2&%:$%"$6%-H-'#4&6%$2'OZ%'4"%2&;#3$%"$6%Y 9&%4%'4%3::2+CX%&6%6T+"%&;@<4#%&4%2'6%:I3"./#$#:I+%4@'#O3%62S"%&I%24#6%&$#1%"4
6%4#6#&#&%'8#+826#&'&628%"&&<&%&6#2+Q$24#@O32&&%V:,I+'%V:%'4#@<2''$2:%'4#@2'<#":.X%&@
""%>2:%'4./#6%I%&&#+@6#$3:%'4./#<+&@+3>352&6%2:T8%2&@$#'&42432./#6%%:I"%&6%<$C6@
%&4"45>2&6%$#1%"43"%6%&I2&4:%'4#@%O32I%&6%%K%$3./#$#'<#":%&3&%&I%$2+266%&@I"42+C@
62&4"2132./#%#$3+4:%'4#6#I"#634#6#<3"4#@<3>@"%$3I%"./#6#I"#634#%+8>%:@%&4'6#%:$3"&##
I"#$%&&#'*(H H!"%<%"%'4%#34"#&$3&6#&%#&6%&6#1":%'4#&6#$"2:%)
*!'4%'6%:#&@I":%+C#"$#:I"%%'&/#6%4#6#&#&:42S%&%'8#+826#&'I3"./#6#&<4#&@
4%$%":#&@2'2$2+:%'4%@1"%8%&$#:%'4N"2#&&#1"%&#">'2S.X%&$"2:2'#&&%#$"2:%6%+8>%:I"@
IT&@62&$#""%":#&&#1"%#&%+%:%'4#&<N42$#&$#:I"#86#&'#&34#&
D
!"%+266%6#$"2:%#">'2S6#
**!1%!&%O3%#$"2:%%:+">%&$+'/#5<%'7:%'#"%$%'4%@&%'6#$%"4#I2"4&6#&&5$3+#&M%
MVNI#&&3Q:3:#">'2S./#%&4N8%+@$#'48:$#:3:$%"4"%6%6%I#2#%%":$#'&4243Q6#&%:
4#"'#6%3:+26%"'.34"&#">'2S.X%&*@$#:#N<2 2$2+2'@&4"Q6%&$C2'%&&@'2/#
#"&%
fd3&@&/#$%'4%'N"2&@4#6&$#'4'6#$#:3:%&4"343"<#"4%@O3%&3I#"4:#"4%#3I"2&/#6#&
+Q6%"%&&%:>"'6%&+4%".X%&(
* !#%'4'4#@8%"2<2$!&%@43+:%'4%@O3%428266%$"2:2'#&@%:4%":#&6%#">'2S./#6:2'2&4"428
2'4%"'@45$'2$&6%%KI'&/#%+3$"428266%@&&3:23<%2.X%&45%'4/#I%'&2:>2'6&%I+2$N8%2&%:
>"'6%&%:I"%&&@&%'6#$%"4#O3%'42>:%'4%#&T">/#&I01+2$#&"%&I#'&N8%2&I%+#%<%428#$#:14%F
428266%$"2:2'#&4"1+C8:$#:2'628Q63#&6%$%"4<#":<$2+:%'4%26%'42<2$N8%2&9&&+4'4%&@
%&4%+2#'4N"2#&@C#:2$26&@%'4"%#34"#&;%O3%>2:6%<#":2&#+6#3%:1'6#&#3O36"2+C&$#:
I%":'U'$2I%'&%'O3'4#63"8:#&2'4%"%&&%&I"TI"2#&@%'O3'4#C#V%828%'$2:#&&&#$2.X%&
I%":'%'4%&@$#:I"#IT&24#&63"6#3"#&@<#"4%C2%""O32%$3V#&2'4%>"'4%&$C%>:&%%&$#'6%"&#1#
:'4#6I"%'4%2'&3&I%2./#
*(!&&2:@#$"2:%#">'2S6#43+%'8#+8%4'4##&$"2:2'#&#&&#<2&42$6#&@$#:##&O3%&%I"%&%'4:
'&#$2%66%$#:#I"#I"2%4N"2#&6%%:I"%&&$#:&3"I"%%'6%'4%I%"<#":'$%@:&O3%@'8%"66%@
$#'&4243%:!&%I%'&?%:I"%&&6%<$C6?I"%<%428+8>%:6#62'C%2"#6%#"2>%:2+Q$24H@O3'4#
:%&::#6+266%6%$"2:2'#&#&$+N&&2$#&@:&>#"$#:"%+#"6%'./#@$N+$3+#6%"2&$#&@2'8%&42:%'4#&
%:I%&&#+@4"%2':%'4#%&%+%./#6%I%&&#+%&I%$2+2S6#I"428266%&%"6%&%'8#+826@+4#>"36%
8#+42+266%@$#'46#$#:$"%&$%'4%:#12+266%%$#'&4'4%6I4./#F&$2"$3'&4W'$2&
*H!BN@I#2&@O3%&%4%"%::%'4%O3%&%%&4N4"4'6#$#:%+24%6#$"2:%'#&%'426#6%O3%#&34#"%&
%'8#+826#&$#:$"2:%#">'2S6#@%:&3&8N"2&:#6+266%&@>%:6%<#":#3&6I#6%'6#@I#"
2'0:%"&82&@62<2$3+4"I3"./#6#&6%+24#&@+5:6I#&&212+266%6$#'42'3266%6I"N42$6%#34"#&
$"2:%&$#:#<24#6%%'$#1"2"&I"#8&%2'6Q$2#&@<S%'6#I"4%6%#">'2S./#$"2:2'#&$#:I+%K
34"#&&2:@#&83+4#&#&+3$"#&O3%#145:$#:428266%2+Q$24I"#8#$:I"%V3QS#&&#$22&2:%'&3"N8%2&@
6%8%'6#42&66#&&%"+%86#&%:$#'4'I#&&Q8%+6%$"%4./#6%:%626&$34%+"%&I%&&#2&
!&&2:@3&42.'/#:2&&%6%62$I3"""%&I#'&12+266%6%$"2:%&6%:%'#":#'4$#:#'#
I&&6#@%'<"%'4'6#43+:%'4%$"452&@1'6#&%O36"2+C&@I%"2>#&#&%:&3%&&U'$2@8#+N4%2&%:&3
&31&4W'$2@N>%2&%:&3&$"$4%"Q&42$&%#3&6#&%:&3&%&4"45>2&:%&:#V362$22&
!
#'$%24#
!%2'#H-)H62S"%&I%24##&$&#&%:$#:%'4#:&'/#4"S3:$#'$%24#I"%$2&#6%$"2:%
#">'2S6#-@+2:24'6#!&%%O32I""428266%$"2:2'#&#">'2S6FO3%+6#"4((6#
T62>#%'+
E"&2+%2"#@O3+&%V@O36"2+C#31'6#)@%O32I"./#%&42'6%O36I#2&O36"2+C#31'6#53:
>"3I:%'4#&%:O3+O3%"&#<2&42$./#@$#:I+%K266%#3%&4"343"./#62<%"%'$26@%'O3'4##">'2S./#
$"2:2'#&I"%&&3IX%%&4"343"%&I%$Q<2$@'#O3%I%&%#:+>:6%&%3&$#:I#'%'4%%.X%&&&2:$1%
F6#34"2'%#&V3+>6#"%&6%<2'2./#6#O3%&%V"%+:%'4%$"2:%#">'2S6#@#">'2S./##3&&#$2./#
$"2:2'#&
!%'4+:%266
#&4*4".2'4%"%&&'4%I'#":>%'5"2$#"%&I%24#6&$"$4%"Q&42$&6%
O3+O3%"#">'2S./# %&$+"%$%'6#%K2&4U'$2@6%'4"%#34"&@6%3'266%&#$2+9"%I"%&%'46I%+#&
&I%$4#&6%&%"#">'2S./#I"4%6&#$2%66%%26%'42<2$"%:!&%#&&%3&$#:I#'%'4%&$#:+>3:<4#"
%&I%$Q<2$#$IS6%>+342'N!+#&%:I"#+6%3::%4%&I%$Q<2$;@$#:I#"4:%'4#&#$2+I6"#'2S6#94"85&
6%"2432&@$#:I#"4:%'4#62N"2#@$#'634&I%":2426&#3I"#2126&I%+#>"3I#%:%&:#I%+:'%2"6%
8%&42"!&%@&36"!&%@6%%KI"%&&"!&%$#"I#"+:%'4%@6%<+"@%4$;@""'V#I%&&#+9+5:63'266%6:%4
%&I%$Q<2$@58#'46%2'628263+6%"%+2S":%4%&I%$Q<2$6%4#6#&@4"63S26%:.X%&'&$26&'#
Q'42:#6#&&3V%24#&%@I#&4%"2#":%'4%@%:.X%&$#+%428&@I#"%&4"%:%'>V6&F&.X%&6#&6%:2&
:%:1"#&63'266%@62"2>26&#6%&%'8#+82:%'4#%F#14%'./#6#&#1V%428#&$#:3'&;@<#":./#63'266%
&#$2+%:3:%&4"343"6%&$"24Q8%+9$#:I"%%'6%'6#<3'.X%&C2%"N"O32$&%%&I%$Q<2$&6#&:%:1"#&@
I#6%'6#&%":T8%2&#32:T8%2&@1%:$#:#6282&/#6%4"%<&@4"2132./#6%<3'.X%&%#I"%%'$C2:%'4#6%
$">#&%&I%$Q<2$#&$#:#<2:6%#14%'./#6#"%&3+46#$#:3:;%"%$3"&#&:4%"22&9:/#6%#1"6#&
:%:1"#&6#">'2S./##3$I24+""%$66#6#&:%&:#&;@$"%&$%'4'6#O3%&#">'2S.X%&@I#"&%"%:
http://www.jfce.jus.br/consultaProcessual/resimprsentintegra.asp?CodDoc=2177598
3/11/2010
Page 12 of 50
I"4%6&#$2%66%@&/#4:15:>%"6#"&6%&31&2&4%:&@4%2&#3"%6%&@&%'6#&2&4%:&34#I#2542$#&96%
34#!$"2./#;6%6%$2&X%&@8%SO3%I#&&212+24:#&3">2:%'4#6%'#8&2652&%#6%&%'8#+82:%'4#6%#34"&
"%+.X%&I"42"6%3:#1V%428#I"2:N"2#%<2'+@$#:3:4#6#&(
-!%>3'6#'#%+TI%S%RH@I#6%!&%%'4%'6%"I#"#">'2S./#$"2:2'#&O3%+$"$4%"2S6I#"
?&%"1&4'4%"Q>26@I#&&32'6#3:$%"4$#'42'3266%e62'N&42$e@I%+#</6%"%&I%2412+266%6%&%3&
62"2>%'4%&@&%8%"62&$2I+2'2'4%"'@+34&2'4%"'&I%+#I#6%"@:54#6#&I#3$#&I2%6#&#&6%$&42>#@%K4%'&
342+2S./#6$#""3I./#I#+Q42$%I#+2$2+@#$3I./#4'4#%:428266%&+Q$24&$#:#2+Q$24&@&2:I426%
+>3'&&%4#"%&%+%24#"2&@62&4"2132./#>%#>"N<2$I#"S#'&@%'#":%&+3$"#&%#34"&$"$4%"Q&42$&?
)!34"#&34#"%&I%"$%1%:$"2:2'+266%#">'2S6I#"&3&428266%&2'4%'&&%2'2'4%""3I4&@
I#&&32'6#6282&X%&6%4"%<&@I"42$2I./#6%$#+1#"6#"%&#3>%'4%&2'2$2+:%'4%2'&3&I%24#&@&#<2&42$./#
6#&:54#6#&$"2:2'#&#&%8Q42:&62<3&&@$#:2'8"2N8%+$#""3I./#6%:%:1"#&6>2&4"43"@6#
2'2&45"2#01+2$#%6#+Q$2
!+1%"4#2+8"'$#:'2<%&4!&%,?$"2:%#">'2S6#I#&&323:4%K43"628%"&,4%:$"N4%"
4"'&'$2#'+':%626%:O3%'/#"%&I%24&<"#'4%2"&6%$6IQ&%I"%&%'4$"$4%"Q&42$&
&&%:%+C6&%:8N"2&'.X%&]6%45:3:2:%'&#I#6%"$#:1&%'3:%&4"45>2>+#1+%'3:%&4"343"
#">'2S428O3%+C%I%":24%I"#8%24"&<"O3%S&%&4"343"2&6#&2&4%:I%'+]I"#8#$6'#&266%&#$2+
6%+4#83+4#]4%:>"'6%<#".6%%KI'&/#@$#:I"%%'6%'6#3:>:6%$#'634&2'<"$2#'2&&%:8Q42:&
#3$#:8Q42:&62<3&&]62&IX%6%:%2#&2'&4"3:%'42&6%:#6%"'4%$'#+#>2]I"%&%'43:2'4"2'$6#
%&O3%:6%$#'%KX%&$#:#34"#&>"3I#&6%+2'OZ%'$22&%3:"%6%&314%""W'%6%+2>.X%&$#:#&O36"#&
#<2$22&6826&#$2+@%$#'7:2$%I#+Q42$6$#:3'266%]#"2>2'4#&6%%K4"%:82#+U'$2]%K21%3:I#6%"
6%$#""3I./#6%62<Q$2+82&212+266%]3"6%:2+62&<"$%&%&2:3+.X%&%@%:"%&3:#@5$IS6%2'%"$2"#3
<">2+2S"#&I#6%"%&6#I"TI"2#&46#?
*!%>3'6##E@#$"2:%#">'2S6#53:%:I"%246$#'&I2"./#$"2:2'+I%":'%'4%#3%:
$#'42'3266%@4%'6#3:%&4"343"#">'2S6@+2:%'46I%+#:%6#%I%+$#""3I./#@&%'6#:#4286I%+
:12./#@$#:%&4"343"<#":+2S6%$#:##1V%428#I"2:N"2#6%#14%"+3$"#&4"85&6%428266%&2+%>2&
%''&R+8'2
"2:%
#::2&&2#'@<2":#3&%"$"2:%#">'2S6#?2+%>Q42:428266%6%3:#">'2S./#
4"<2$'6#1%'&#3&%"82.#&2+%>2&@2'$+32'6#@:&'/#&%+2:24'6#@#V#>#@I"#&42432./#@
>2#4>%:@&31&4W'$2&$#'4"#+6&@%K4#"&/#@#3#34"428266%$#'4Q'3@#3#34"I"N42$2+%>+O3%4%'C#
#1V%428#6%>"'6%&>'C#&%$#'7:2$#&4"85&6%I"N42$&<"363+%'4&#3$#%"$2428&#32'<+3%'$2
2:I"TI"2'#>#8%"'#-
!#2&1%:@2'6%I%'6%'4%:%'4%6#$#'$%24#6%$"2:%#">'2S6#O3%&%342+2S%)@6%<"#'4:#!'#&&%:I"%
$#:3:%&4"343"#">'2S$2#'+@O3%4"'&$%'6%#:%"#eV3'4:%'4#6%2'628Q63#&e@%&4'6#1&%6'
&&#$2./#6%&3&8#'46%&+28"%&%$#'&$2%'4%&@62"2>26#&3:#1V%428#$#:3:2+Q$24#@$#:1&%%:3:
C2%""O32%6282&/#6%4"%<&@I#&&32'6#$#:#:#4%#"$2#$Q'2#6+4+3$"428266%$#:12K#$3&4#%
2'8%&42:%'4#"%$3I%"N8%+$3"4#I"S#@I#6%'6#$#'4"$#:$#""3I./#6%>%'4%&I01+2$#&
-
"$4%"Q&42$&
(!"42'6#6#&$#'$%24#&I"%&%'46#&@I#6%:#&4"."&I"2'$2I2&$"$4%"Q&42$&6&#">'2S.X%&
$"2:2'#&&@&%'6#I#&&Q8%+O3%+>3:&6%+&'/#%&4%V:I"%&%'4%&%:4#6&&:#6+266%&6%$"2:%
#">'2S6#@O32&&%V:,
;2'<2+4"./#6%&%3&>%'4%&'#&46#@&%V$#""#:I%'6#!#&#3+2$2'6#I"#:2&&X%&6#+#&&#3
#14%'./#6%2'<#":.X%&I"282+%>26&"%&I%24#6%%&4"343"&<Q&2$&%$I$266%6%"%./#6&2'&42432.X%&
#3:%&:#I4"#$2''6##2'>"%&&#"%>3+"6%&%3&>%'4%&'&<#".&%&442&@$#:#@I#"%K%:I+#@
I4"#$Q'2#6%$:I'C&6%$'6264#&@I4"#$Q'2#6%$3"&#&&3I%"2#"%&&%3&>%'4%&@:#":%'4%2"%24##3
:%&:#I>:%'4#6%$3"&#&I"%I"4T"2#&I"2'>"%&&#6%&%3&>%'4%&'I#+Q$2@2'2&45"2#01+2$##3
362$2N"2#4"85&6%$#'$3"&#
1;$"2:2'+266%62<3&$"$4%"2S!&%@%:>%"+@I%+3&U'$26%8Q42:&<2&2$:%'4%2'628263+2S6&@#3
&%V@$"2:2'+266%#">'2S6'#":+:%'4%8242:2SI%&&#&2'6%4%":2'6&@+2>6&%'4"%&2I#"
$2"$3'&4W'$2&6%<4#$#:#@I#"%K%:I+#@$#""%'42&4&6%3:6%4%":2'6#E'$#@$+2%'4%&6%$%"41'6%2"
6%$"4/#6%$"5624#@&%"826#"%&I01+2$#&I#&%'46#&6%6%4%":2'6#T">/##3$#:I#'%'4%&6%6%4%":2'6
<$./##3>"3I#&#$2+%&I%$Q<2$#@I#6%'6#4:15:>2"2:I%&&#+:%'4%$#'4"2'&42432.X%&I"42$3+"%&#3
%&442&*@2'6%I%'6%'4%:%'4%6%&%3&$#:I#'%'4%& +&I%$4#"%8%+I%"2$3+#&266%6#">'2S./#
'4%&62:%'&X%&%O3&%2""%I"12+266%6#&6'#&$3&6#&@1%:$#:#62<2$3+66%6%./#%&44+
I#&4%"2#"
$;12K82&212+266%6#&6'#&!#:#6#6%#I%"./#6&#">'2S.X%&$"2:2'#&&4%:#$#'6/#6%#$3+4"#&
4#&I"%I"4T"2#&%6%%K%$3./#6%:'%2"O3%@O3'6##&<4#&&/#6%&$#1%"4#&@8%"66%2"#2:I$4#&#$2+
6%:#4VN<#2"%+2S6#
6;+4#>"36%#I%"$2#'+266%!#O36"#6&#">'2S.X%&$"2:2'#&&5$#:I#&4#@>%"+:%'4%@I#"
I%&&#&$#:6%62$./#%K$+3&28%O3+2<2$./#6%I#'4'&628%"&&N"%&#'6%&%<.'%$%&&N"2&3
43./#@$#'4'6#$#:%K$%+%'4%"%:3'%"./#%%O32I:%'4#&6%0+42:>%"./#@:324&8%S%&&3I%"2#"%&
#&6#&I#+2$22&@&%'6#$%"4#O3%#@I#"&&2:62S%"@?2'8%&42:%'4#?%:3:./#$"2:2'#&5'+2&66%
:'%2"$3266#&@&%'6##&"2&$#&I#'6%"6#&%:"%+./##I#&&Q8%+UK24#]#1&%"8!&%@2'6@O3%&
2'<#":.X%&6&$#'634&$"2:2'#&&&/#'#":+:%'4%$#:I"42:%'46&@#3&%V@I%&"6%4#6#&#&
:%:1"#&6#">'2S./#$"2:2'#&&1%"%:O3+##1V%428#<2'+6%&3&428266%&2+Q$24&@'%:4#6#&#&
:%:1"#&6#">'2S./#&1%:%K4:%'4%#O3%#&#34"#&:%:1"#&%&4/#%K%$34'6#@6%<#":
I"%&%"8"3::2#">"36%&2>2+#%%824"6%+.X%&34"#&I%$4#I%"$%I4Q8%+5O3%4+$#'<#":266%2:I%+%
+>3'&:%:1"#&&%$#'8%'$%"%:%&4"I"42$2I'6#6%.X%&:%'#"%&@I"%'4%:%'4%2'#$%'4%&@$#:#@
I#"%K%:I+#@%&4"?I%'&:#'24#"'6#8Q42:6%&%OZ%&4"#?@?&T<S2"%4"'&:242"#&%!:2+&?@?%"
%'$""%>6#I%'&6%O3%1""&&%'C&%"%I&&"#&66#&?@?%"I%'&#:#4#"2&46#&6%:2&?@%4$
%;%+#$266%@:36'.&%6I4.X%&&.X%&6&#">'2S.X%&$"2:2'#&&4:15:6%$"$4%"2S:I#"
&3+48%+#$266%6%"%+2S./#@$#'$%'4"'6#%&<#".#&62343"':%'4%I"$#'&%$3./#6%&%3&
#1V%428#&(34"#&&2:@2:I"%&&2#'$I$266%6%6I4./#6#&>%'4%&F&'#8&4%$'#+#>2&@$#:
:#62<2$./#O3&%O3%2'&4'4W'%6%&%3:#63&#I%"'62I"<S%"<"%'4%'#8#&I6"X%&6%&%>3"'.6%
%:I"%&&#32'&42432.X%&@1%:$#:#62'W:2$I+&42$266%6%&3&%:I"%&&6%<$C6@$#:+4%"./#6%
+#$+%N"%6%43./#@4"#$6%$#+1#"6#"%&%<#":./#6%+2'.&%'4"%#">'2S.X%&628%"&&@"%:#./#
6%I%&&#+I">2"%:%:+#$2&2'6'/#42'>26#&@342+2S./#6%'#8&$#'4&1'$N"2&$#:'#:%&<+&#&
%2'<2'6N8%+4"#$6%4%+%<#'%&6%$#'44#
H!1%!&%O3%@'8%"66%@#$"2:%#">'2S6#'#&5$3+#MM'/#4%:3:%&4"343""Q>26%$%'4"+2S6@
#I%"'6#%:8N"2#&>"3I#&%&31>"3I#&O3%@I#"8%S%&@&%&&#$2:6%<#":I%":'%'4%HI""%+2S./#
http://www.jfce.jus.br/consultaProcessual/resimprsentintegra.asp?CodDoc=2177598
3/11/2010
Page 13 of 50
6%'%>T$2#&%&I%$Q<2$#&6%:2#":#'4&&2:@#
I#6%&%&&#$2"#$"2:%I">32#I"$#'&%>32"
":&@F:N<21#+282'I"#14%"$#$Q'@3:"%6%6%$#:%"$2'4%&I""%8%'66%$">"#316@
#34"#>"3I#I"+3>3%+6%":&@$""#&%+#$2&6%$428%2"#%%K%$3./#@%:3:8%"66%2""%6%
$#:I"42:%'466%.X%&
)">'2S.X%&$"2:2'#&&1"&2+%2"&:2&$#'C%$26&%%&4434#&6#$"2:%
(!#&0+42:#&'#&@#">'2S./#$"2:2'#&$C:6"2:%2"#
#:'6#6
I24+!
@<3'66%:
HH-'
&6%
3&4T626%3145@>'C#3'#4#"2%66%I#"&3I#&43"@I#"&&2:62S%"@
?%:I"%&"2+?6#$"2:%@&&3:2'6##$#'4"#+%6#4"N<2$#6%6"#>&'E2K6'42&4@+3>'6#":&%
$""#&I"#34"&O36"2+C&%6#:2''6##:%"$6#6%I%"3%2"#&$+'6%&42'#&
(!%>3'6#&%&1%@#
-$#'4$#:3:41%+6%$#'4"2132.X%&:%'&2&6%&%3&2'4%>"'4%&@&%'6#
"%2&I"#&I"%&#&%:"%>2:%<%$C6#@"%2&I"#&%:"%>2:%1%"4#%"%2&I"#&O3%%&4/#
<#"6$6%26%:2&@4#6#&#&2'4%>"'4%&6%8%:$3:I"2"&%:O3%&42#':%'4#4#6#&#&?&+8%&?#3&%V@
#"6%'&%:'6&6%&%3&62"2>%'4%&]&&2:@&%<#"66#3:?&+8%>%"+?I""%1%+2X%&'&$6%2&@4#6#&#&
2'4%>"'4%&6%8%:I"42$2I"6&:%&:&@&#1I%'6%?V3+>:%'4#?%%K%$3./#?%&4434#?-6#
62&IX%2'6&#1"%+%+66%@"%&I%24#%&#+26"2%66%$2:6%436#%$63:"%$%1%$#'<#":%
I"42$2I./#'#$"2:%&42:!&%O3%#
$#'4%43+:%'4%$#:$%"$6%:2+C#:%'&%'>V6#&%$%"$
6%H:2+&2:I42S'4%&@$#'4"#+'6#Hh6&$6%2&I3+2&4&@4"85&6%&%3"%I"%&%'4'4%:2&428#
"$#&
:$C#@#"$#+
(!
#:'6#%":%+C#-@#">'2S./#$"2:2'#&#"2>2'6'#2#6%'%2"#@'&$%36#$#'44#%'4"%
I"%&#&I#+Q42$#&662463":2+24"%#&I"%&#&$#:3'&'#'&42434#%'+
W'626#%'6%&9'+C"'6%@
4:15:$C:6#6%?
+6%2"/#6#21#?;%4%:$#:#I"2'$2I+"%I"%&%'4'4%43+32S%"''6#6
#&4@
#%"''62'C#E%2"!"@$#'C%$26#4$62&46%6"#>&
(-!#2'Q$2#6#&'#&H@&3">2362&&26U'$2%"$%2"#
#:'6#@O3%I#&4%"2#":%'4%<#":#3#&:2>#&6#&
:2>#&9;@&%'6#O3%43+:%'4%#>"3I#%"$%2"#
#:'6#3"#@:2>#&6#&:2>#&%
#:'6#
8%":%+C#62&I34:#&I#'4#&6%4"N<2$#'#2#6%'%2"#&&2:@43+:%'4%@#
#:'6#%":%+C#$#:'6
#4"N<2$#'#
#:I+%K#6#+%:/#@'>3%2"@"#826U'$2%$"%S2'C#@#%"$%2"#
#:'6#4%:$#:#
"%634#$"2@%'6U@"66%3$&@%13@%""2'C%E2K6#I4%2"#@%'O3'4#:2>#&6#&:2>#&5
"%&I#'&N8%+I%+#4"N<2$#6#$2'C@2+6#&2'C%2"#&@#""#&6#&$$#&%2+2'45:
()!1%!&%@2'6@6%K2&4U'$2--@6%'4"%#34"#&@%:/#3+#6#
#:'6#%8#+3$2#'N"2#E"&2+%2"#6
"2:2'+266%9
E
;@<3'66%:6%S%:1"#6%HHH'%'24%'$2N"2#&5"6%4#@%:3"3+C#&]
#:2&&/#%:#$"N42$6%21%"66%9
;@O3%4%8%#"2>%:'I%'24%'$2N"2"3+#3$2'#6%$:I#&@
%:8"5@'#'#6%HH*]%244W'2$9;@<3'66''42>
&6%%4%'./#6%/#3+#%:HH)
:&2'6%:428266%'%'24%'$2N"2"2#6%#3"+13O3%"O3%@%:"'$#6#$C]'#"'N@
%K2&4%:'#4Q$2&6#"2:%2"#
#:'6#6#"'N9
;@<3'66#%:HH('%'24%'$2N"2
%'4"+6#&46#@
%:24O3"]'#2&4"24#%6%"+@#S@21%"66%%2"%24#9;@<3'66#%::2#6%@'#%4#"
6
%'24%'$2N"26I36]%:2'&%"2&@#"2:%2"#
#:'6#2'%2"#9
;O3%&3">23'#&%>3'6#
&%:%&4"%6%@'%'24%'$2N"2%+&#'B3'>"2%#
#:'6#2'%2"#6%I%".X%&
"2:2'#&&9
;@
<#":6#%:@'%'24%'$2N"2#&5"2+$d:2'@'#:3'2$QI2#6%21%2"/#6&%8%&]'#2#"'6%6#
3+@%K2&4%:#&'#&@$"26#'#"%&Q62#
%'4"+6%#"4#+%>"%@%:H((%#&E"&&@<$./#$"26'
:%&:5I#$6#&'#&]%:%"':13$#@#
#:'6##"4%!#"6%&4%9
;@<3'66#%:HH)'
%'24%'$2N"2"#<%&&#"'21+E"3'#@2'&I2"6#'#
#:'6#%":%+C#]'#2#"'6%6##"4%@#"2:%2"#
#:'6#6%4+9
;@O3%&3">23%:-@'%'24%'$2N"2
%'4"+"#/#
C8%&]'#4#"#&&#6#
3+@#"2:%2"#
#:'6#6#4#"#&&#6#3+9
;%#"2:%2"#
#:'6#621%"66%9
;@6%'4"%
#34"#&
%./#:3'62+<"%'4%#$"2:%#">'2S6#-)
(!">'2S./#6&.X%&'26&"%+2S#3%:6%S%:1"#6%HHH@%:+%":#@4N+2@
#'8%'./#6&
.X%&'26&$#'4"#
"2:%">'2S6#"'&'$2#'+@&%'6#%+1#"6#3:6#$3:%'4#@4:15:$#'C%$26#
$#:#
#'8%'./#6%+%":#@'#O3+&.X%&'26&%KI"%&&:&3$#'82$./#6%O3%%&4%53:
I"#1+%:"%+%>"8%@O3%&TI#6%&%"$#:1426#I#"2'4%":562#6$##I%"./#2'4%"'$2#'+@&%'6#
&&2'6#I#""%I"%&%'4'4%&6%)IQ&%&6&.X%&'26&
(*!+
#'8%'./#-5&3I+%:%'46I#"4"U&I"#4#$#+#&@#&O32&1#"6:N"%&%&I%$Q<2$&6%43./#6#
$"2:%#">'2S6#@O32&&%V:,;"#4#$#+#I""%8%'2"@3I"2:2"%3'2"#"N<2$#6%%&&#&@
%&I%$2+:%'4%3+C%"%&%
"2'.&]1;"#4#$#+#$#'4"#
#'4"1'6#6%:2>"'4%&I#"%""@"%"%$;
"#4#$#+#$#'4"1"2$./#+%>+%#"N<2$#6%":&6%#>#@2'$+3&28%%.&@$%&&T"2#&%3'2.X%&/#
4:15:%'$#"V6&#3&#6%$##I%".X%&12+4%"2&@$#:#6%%'4"%>&$#'4"#+6&@82>2+W'$2%+%4"7'2$%
#I%".X%&&2>2+#&&@+5:6%I"#4%./#<Q&2$6%4%&4%:3'C& '<2+4"./#./#62<%"26%&$34&4%+%<7'2$&
( !6%8%"6%$##I%"./#:0436#&&46#&I"&&%>3""#<3'$2#':%'4#63&42.@%<%428266%6%
&3&6%$2&X%&%I"%8+U'$26#&62"%24#&C3:'#&"%$#'C%$26#&%:"46#&'4%"'$2#'2&%'&
#'&42432.X%&$#'4%:I#"W'%&54TI2$#$#:3:'#'#&&##"6%':%'4#&&2:@4+&2&4%:6%$##I%"./#
2'4%"'$2#'+&%6N@:2&$#:3:%'4%@I#":%2#6#$3:I"2:%'4#6%$"4&"#>4T"2&-*@6#&2&4%:6%
"%$#'C%$2:%'4#6%&%'4%'.&%&4"'>%2"&9$#:#"%$#'C%$2:%'4#6#&I"2'$QI2#&6#"%&I%24##&62"%24#&
6O32"26#&%6$#2&V3+>6;@6#I%626#6%&&2&4U'$2V3"Q62$- 9O3%I%":24%%K%$34"@%:66V3"2&62./#@
4#&&#+2$246#&I#"34#"266%&%&4"'>%2"&@42&$#:#62+2>U'$2&"%+428&2'8%&42>.X%&#32'&4"3./#6%
.X%&V3"Q62$&%:4%""24T"2#%&4"'>%2"#;@6%K4"62./#%64"'&<%"U'$26%I%'6#&
*
#'$%24#
(("62$2#'+:%'4%+8>%:6%62'C%2"#-(4%:&26#I%"$%126$#:#+2:I%S-H6#62'C%2"#&3V#>%"6#
I#"428266%&$"2:2'#&&)@&&%'4'6#&362'W:2$'#"%2'8%&42:%'4#6%4+62'C%2"#%:428266%&+Q$24&
#3:%&:#2+Q$24&)
(H!<2":%4%"2++%R)@%:&3:@O3%,
?+8>%:5#:54#6#I#":%2#6#O3+#&"%$3"&#&I"#8%'2%'4%&6#$"2:%&/#2'4%>"6#&#&&2&4%:&
1'$N"2#&%#:12%'4%6%'%>T$2#&6#:3'6#4#6#,#62'C%2"#e'%>"#e5+86#45<2$":2&1"'$#O3%
http://www.jfce.jus.br/consultaProcessual/resimprsentintegra.asp?CodDoc=2177598
3/11/2010
Page 14 of 50
1"'$#96%#'6%6%$#""%%&$+"%$%6#"6%'#:2'./#<"'$%&1+'$C2:%'46e">%'4!+8%V:%'4#6#
62'C%2"#;A4"85&6%&4%I"#$%&&#O3%26%'4266%6#62'C%2"#&3V#!#3&%V@I"#$%6U'$2$"2:2'#&%
8%"66%2"26%'4266%6#&I"#I"2%4N"2#&6%&&%&428#&!54"'&<#":66%4+<#":O3%#&"%$3"&#&I"%$%:
4%"#"2>%:%:3:<#'4%+%>Q42:9;%&&<#":@&#"2>%'&6#&"%$3"&#&6%&I"%$%:I"&%:I"%%#&
$"2:2'#&#&%'8#+826#&I#6%:$#+C%"#&<"34#&6%&%396%&;C#'"6#%&<#".#62'C%2"#5#&'>3%824+6%
4#6&&428266%&$"2:2'#&&]#I"#$%&&#6%+8>%:I#6%&%"%'$"6#$#:##$#"./#%#&I3+:X%&6%
4#6##&2&4%:@VNO3%I%":24%:O3%#62'C%2"#&%V6%I3"6#%$#+#$6#%:$2"$3+./#I%+##">'2&:#4#6#@
>"'42'6#&&2:&3&06%%&#1"%828U'$2?
H%"2<2$!&%@I#"8%S%&@O3%+8>%:6%62'C%2"#I#6%#$#""%"6%<#":<+>"'4%:%'4%&2:I+%&%:
+>3'&$&#&%2'4%2":%'4%$#:I+%K6%#34"#&@:&>%"+:%'4%I&&I%+#&%&4N>2#&6%$#+#$./#@
%&4"42<2$./#%2'4%>"./#)-@:&'/#&/#<&%&%&4'O3%&#32'6%I%'6%'4%&@:&$#:3'2$'4%&%45
:%&:#&3I%"I#&4&#3$#'$U'4"2$&
H$#+#$./#9I+$%:%'4@#$3+4./##3$#'8%"&/#;$"$4%"2S!&%'2'4"#63./#6#&I"#8%'4#&6#$"2:%'#
&2&4%:1'$N"2##3%$#'7:2$#@&%V4"85&6%%:I"%&&VN%K2&4%'4%&#3$"26&I"2:#"62+:%'4%I"
&%"82"%:6%<$C6@&%VI%+$#:I"6%1%'&%8+#"%+%86#@$#:##1"&6%"4%@2:T8%2&@8%Q$3+#&@:%42&
I"%$2#&#&@O3%I#6%"/#&%"8%'626#&3:$#:I"6#"+%>Q42:#@$#:I#&4%"2#"6%IT&24#6#"%&3+46#6
4"'&./#$#:%"$2+A$+"#O3%@I"'/#$C:"4%'./#@#&+86#"%&342+2S:!&%6%3:"%6%6%@I#"
&&2:62S%"@?I3+8%"2S6#"%&?))O3%"%+2S:4'4#&6%IT&24#&%&O3%&12K#6#+2:24%I"42"6#O3+#
1'$#4%:O3%2'<#":"#&T">/#&6%&%>3"'.@O3'4#'%$%&&N"2#&F+8>%:6#62'C%2"#
H%&4N>2#6%&4"42<2$./#962&&2:3+./#@%'&#:1"%$2:2%'4##3+R%"2'>;54:15:$#'C%$26#$#:#
>24./##3:2&43"./#@O3'6##$#""%2'4%'&:#82:%'4./#6#62'C%2"#6%I#&246#9&%VI"#34"&
2'&42432.X%&1'$N"2&@&%V%:$#'&4'4%&%628%"&&4"'&.X%&$#:%"$22&;'#2'4324#6%I>"#"&4"#6#
62'C%2"#@2:I%62'6#26%'42<2$./#6%&3#"2>%:
H-%&4N>2#<2'+52'4%>"./#92'4%>"42#'#3"%$R$+2'>;@O3'6#?#&"%$3"&#&#"2>2'2&I"#8%'2%'4%&6#
$"2:%VN<#":+86#&%I#&4#&I"&%$"@I#6%'6#&%"2'&%"26#&%:3::12%'4%<2''$%2"#"%&I%24N8%+
62'C%2"#4:15:I#6%&%""%42"6#6#&2&4%:1'$N"2#I""%+2S./#6%O32&2.X%&e+%>Q42:&e@&%:O3%
&%V:I"%&%'46&:324&I%">3'4&2'$#'8%'2%'4%&?)
H)<2":#&53+#E+4S"0'2#")*O3%?#%&I%$Q<2$#W:124#6$"2:2'+266%#">'2S6@#>"'6%
8#+3:%%62'C%2"#I%":24%F&#">'2S.X%&,;#%K%"$Q$2#62'<+3U'$2&#1"%#&&%"826#"%&I01+2$#&
%'$""%>6#&6%$#212!+&@$#""#:I%'6#I#+2$22&@I"#:#4#"%&@<2&$2&@V3QS%&%I#+Q42$#&]1;#<%"46%
I"%&4.X%&&#$22&I#I3+.X%&:%'#&<8#"%$26&@>"'V%'6#&2:I42&%I"#4%./#]$;$#'4"4./#6%
I"#<2&&2#'2&I"3KQ+2#'#&I"#$%&&#&6%+8>%:@$#:#$#'46#"%&@68#>6#&%$#'&%+C%2"#&<2''$%2"#&]
6;$#'28U'$26%2'&42432.X%&<2''$%2"&@2'4%"%&&6&I#"I#+I36&I+2$.X%&]%;#I#2#$:I'C&
I#+Q42$&]<;"%2'8%&42:%'4#%:428266%&+Q$24&@62<2$3+4'6#&%I"./#6#"2>%:6#&+3$"#&?
H<2":%4%"2++%R) O3%,
?C2&4T"26#
"2:%">'2S6#5&%:%+C'4%@%:O3&%4#6#&#&&I%$4#&@FC2&4T"2%F%8#+3./#6%
O3+O3%"#34"$#"I#"./##3428266%2'63&4"2+6%&4%2'Q$2#6#&5$3+#MM#1:324#&&I%$4#&@%+I#6%
&%"%'$"6$#:#:2#"C2&4T"26%&3$%&&#%:I"%&"2+O3%VN%K2&423,&3I%"#34#6#&#&I"#1+%:&@
"%2'8%&423&%3&"%$3"&#&<2''$%2"#&%%KI'623!&%45#$3I"3:I#&2./#%K4"%::%'4%2'<+3%'4%%
$3:3+"#I#6%"2#O3%6%45:C#V%$"2:%#">'2S6#$#'O32&4#3IQ&%&2'4%2"#&]2'<+3%'$2#3I#+Q42$#&6%
:324#&#34"#&IQ&%&@:2&%<2$2%'4%:%'4%O3%O3+O3%">"3I#6%I"%&&/##<2$2+9#3I"2'$2I+:%'4%2'<#":+;
I#6%"2V:2&%&I%""$#'&%>32"]628%"&2<2$#3!&%O3'6#&3&I"2'$2I2&N"%&6%428266%&<#":$"242$6&
%#34$6&]%'4%'6%3%6#:2'#3'#8&4%$'#+#>2&:2&"I26:%'4%O3%O3+O3%"#34"#":#6%
428266%]>%"#36%62$./#%+%+66%%'4"%&%3&e<3'$2#'N"2#&e%$#'O32&4#33:1&%6%$+2%'4%&O3%
6%I%'6%6%&%3&I"#634#&%::324&N"%&#'6%"%+2S&3&#I%".X%&
9;:&3%&&U'$2&#:1"2@+8>%:6%62'C%2"#@%436#O3%&%"%+$2#'$#:%+@53:O3%&4/#6%
542$%3:6#&I"#1+%:&&#$22&%%:I"%&"22&:2&$#""#&28#&6#'#8#&5$3+#+8%SI%'&#>#8%"'#6#&
&46#&'26#&I%"$%1:I+2436%@%K4%'&/#%:%.I"%&%'46I#"%&4%I"#1+%:%+4T"2#
&4"45>2$#'4%"'$2#'+&#1"%"$T42$#&9'4%"'42#'+"$#42$&4"4%>R%I#"4;6%HH(9I31+2$6#%:
<%8%"%2"#6%HHH;4"S&&%>32'4%&I+8"&,+8>%:6%62'C%2"#4%:$#'&%OZU'$2&&#$22&6%8&46#"&
%53::%.I"&%>3"'.'$2#'+@I#"O3%<#"'%$%$#:13&4Q8%+I"O3%#&4"<2$'4%&6%6"#>&%
":&@4%""#"2&4&%#34"#&$"2:2'#&#&#I%"%:%:I+2%:&%3&%:I"%%'62:%'4#&$"2:2'#&#&8'6#
62'C%2"#@#&$"2:2'#&#&:'2I3+:&2&4%:&<2''$%2"#&@'#&&46#'26#&%'#%K4%"2#"%'/#<#"
$#'4"#+6@+8>%:6%62'C%2"#I#6%&#+I"2'4%>"266%6&2'&42432.X%&<2''$%2"&6%3:'./#9;
$"2:%<2''$%2"##">'2S6#%&4N&&3:2'6#3:II%+$68%S:2&&2>'2<2$428#@O3%:%.&%>3"'.
6&I%&&#&@6#&&46#&%6&2'&42432.X%&6%:#$"N42$&+5:62&&#@'#&&$I$266%6%$#'63S2"I#+Q42$
%K4%"'%6%I"#:#8%"'#&&&%>3"'.%I"#&I%"266%%$#'7:2$@5I"%V362$6I#"%&&&:%.&#&
'#&&#&I"$%2"#&6%:#$"N42$#&9O3%I"42$:;+21%"66%6%:%"$6#?
"%82&/#%>+
H*%2H*-@6%--HH(@$#'C%$26$#:#%268>%:6%2'C%2"#@"%&3+46%$#:I"#:2&&#
&&3:26#I%+#E"&2+$#:$#:3'266%2'4%"'$2#'+#<2":"
#'8%'./#$#'4"#"N<2$#+Q$24#6%
'4#"I%$%'4%&%6%31&4W'$2&&2$#4"TI2$&@$#'C%$26$#:#
#'8%'./#6%2%')(@6%H((
H "%8U624+%2O3%,
?#&
"2:%&6%?8>%:?#3$3+4./#6%E%'&@2"%24#&%+#"%&
"4$3+4"#362&&2:3+"'43"%S@#"2>%:@+#$+2S./#@62&I#&2./#@:#82:%'4./##3I"#I"2%66%6%
1%'&@62"%24#&#38+#"%&I"#8%'2%'4%&@62"%4#32'62"%4:%'4%@6%$"2:%,
6%4"N<2$#2+Q$24#6%&31&4W'$2&%'4#"I%$%'4%&#36"#>&<2'&]
!6%4%""#"2&:#%&%3<2''$2:%'4#]9%6./#66I%+%2' @6%H -;
6%$#'4"1'6##34"N<2$#6%":&@:3'2.X%&#3:4%"2+6%&42'6#F&3I"#63./#]
6%%K4#"&/#:%62'4%&%OZ%&4"#]
$#'4"6:2'2&4"./#01+2$@2'$+3&28%%K2>U'$2@I"&2#3I"#34"%:@62"%4#32'62"%4:%'4%@6%
O3+O3%"8'4>%:@$#:#$#'62./##3I"%.#I"I"N42$#3#:2&&/#6%4#&6:2'2&4"428#&]
$#'4"#&2&4%:<2''$%2"#'$2#'+]
I"42$6#I#"#">'2S./#$"2:2'#&
!I"42$6#I#"I"42$3+"$#'4"6:2'2&4"./#I01+2$%&4"'>%2"9"4&-- !E@-- !
%-- !6#
%$"%4#!%2'#()(@6% 6%6%S%:1"#6%H)!
T62>#%'+;9'$2&#2'$+3Q6#I%+%2')* @6%
http://www.jfce.jus.br/consultaProcessual/resimprsentintegra.asp?CodDoc=2177598
3/11/2010
Page 15 of 50
*;
%',"%$+3&/#6%4"U&6%S'#&%:3+4
^'$#""%':%&:I%'O3%:@I"#$3+4"#362&&2:3+"342+2S./#6%1%'&@62"%24#&#38+#"%&
I"#8%'2%'4%&6%O3+O3%"6#&$"2:%&'4%$%6%'4%&"%<%"26#&'%&4%"42>#,
#&$#'8%"4%%:428#&+Q$24#&]
#&6O32"%@"%$%1%@4"#$@'%>#$2@6N#3"%$%1%%:>"'42@>3"6@4%:%:6%IT&24#@:#82:%'4#3
4"'&<%"%]
2:I#"4#3%KI#"41%'&$#:8+#"%&'/#$#""%&I#'6%'4%&#&8%"66%2"#&
^'$#""%@2'6@':%&:I%'O3%:,
342+2S@'428266%%$#'7:2$#3<2''$%2"@1%'&@62"%24#&#38+#"%&O3%&1%&%"%:I"#8%'2%'4%&6%
O3+O3%"6#&$"2:%&'4%$%6%'4%&"%<%"26#&'%&4%"42>#]
I"42$2I6%>"3I#@&&#$2./##3%&$"24T"2#4%'6#$#'C%$2:%'4#6%O3%&3428266%I"2'$2I+#3
&%$3'6N"2562"2>26FI"N42$6%$"2:%&I"%82&4#&'%&4%2
^-4%'44285I3'26'#&4%":#&6#I"N>"<#0'2$#6#"4)6#
T62>#%'+
^)I%'&%"N3:%'466%3:6#2&4%".#&@'#&$&#&I"%82&4#&'#&2'$2&#&6#$I346%&4%"42>#@
&%#$"2:%<#"$#:%426#6%<#":C1243+#3I#"2'4%":562#6%#">'2S./#$"2:2'#&
^I%'&%"N"%63S266%3:6#2&4%".#&%$#:%."N&%"$3:I"26%:"%>2:%1%"4#@I#6%'6##V32S
6%2K"6%I+2$N!+#3&31&4243Q!+I#"I%'"%&4"24286%62"%24#&@&%#34#"@$#!34#"#3I"4Q$2I%$#+1#""
%&I#'4'%:%'4%$#:&34#"266%&@I"%&4'6#%&$+"%$2:%'4#&O3%$#'63S:FI3"./#6&2'<".X%&
I%'2&%6%&334#"2#3F+#$+2S./#6#&1%'&@62"%24#&#38+#"%&#1V%4#6#$"2:%
9;!6%&4$:#&
&%&&#&3V%24&`%2
"4H3V%24:!&%F&#1"2>.X%&"%<%"26&'#&"4&%&I%&&#&V3"Q62$&O3%4%'C:@%:$"N4%"
I%":'%'4%#3%8%'43+@$#:#428266%I"2'$2I+#3$%&&T"2@$3:3+428:%'4%#3'/#,
9;
M!&I%&&#&<Q&2$&#3V3"Q62$&O3%$#:%"$2+2S%:1%'&6%+3K##36%+4#8+#"#3%K%".:428266%&
O3%%'8#+8:>"'6%8#+3:%6%"%$3"&#&%:%&I5$2%9'$+3Q6#I%+%2 @6%H -;!6%&4$:#&
L
6%'42<2$./#6#&
+2%'4%&%'34%'./#6%%>2&4"#&
"4&I%&&#&"%<%"26&'#"4H,
26%'42<2$"/#&%3&$+2%'4%&%:'4%"/#$6&4"#43+2S6#@'#&4%":#&6%2'&4"3.X%&%:'6&6&
34#"266%&$#:I%4%'4%&]
:'4%"/#"%>2&4"#6%4#64"'&./#%::#%6'$2#'+#3%&4"'>%2"@4Q43+#&%8+#"%&:#12+2N"2#&@4Q43+#&
6%$"5624#@:%42&@#3O3+O3%"428#I&&Q8%+6%&%"$#'8%"426#%:62'C%2"#@O3%3+4"I&&"+2:24%<2K6#
I%+34#"266%$#:I%4%'4%%'#&4%":#&6%2'&4"3.X%&I#"%&4%KI%626&]
6%8%"/#4%'6%"@'#I"S#<2K6#I%+#T">/#V362$2+$#:I%4%'4%@&"%O32&2.X%&<#":3+6&I%+#
#'&%+C#
$"26#I%+#"4)@O3%&%I"#$%&&"/#%:&%>"%6#6%V3&42.
^C2IT4%&%6%#$+2%'4%$#'&42432"!&%%:I%&&#V3"Q62$@26%'42<2$./#"%<%"26'#2'$2&#6%&4%"42>#
6%8%"N1"'>%"&I%&&#&<Q&2$&34#"2S6&"%I"%&%'4N!+@1%:$#:#&%3&I"#I"2%4N"2#&
^&$6&4"#&%"%>2&4"#&"%<%"26#&'#&2'$2&#&%6%&4%"42>#6%8%"/#&%"$#'&%"86#&63"'4%#
I%"Q#6#:Q'2:#6%$2'$#'#&I"42"6#%'$%"":%'4#6$#'4#36$#'$+3&/#64"'&./#@I"S#%&4%
O3%I#6%"N&%":I+26#I%+34#"266%$#:I%4%'4%
^-"%>2&4"#"%<%"26#'#2'$2&#6%&4%"42>#&%"N%<%436#4:15:O3'6#I%&&#<Q&2$#3V3"Q62$@
&%3&%'4%&+2>6#&@C#38%""%+2S6#@%:3::%&:#:U&!$+%'6N"2#@#I%".X%&$#:3::%&:I%&&#@
$#'>+#:%"6##3>"3I#O3%@%:&%3$#'V3'4#@3+4"I&&%:#+2:24%<2K6#I%+34#"266%$#:I%4%'4%
"4E'$#
%'4"+:'4%"N"%>2&4"#$%'4"+2S6#<#":'6##$6&4"#>%"+6%$#""%'42&4&%$+2%'4%&
6%2'&42432.X%&<2''$%2"&@1%:$#:#6%&%3&I"#$3"6#"%&9'$+3Q6#I%+%2' @6%H -;
L
#:3'2$./#6%I%".X%&2''$%2"&
"4&I%&&#&"%<%"26&'#"4H,
62&I%'&"/#%&I%$2+4%'./#F&#I%".X%&O3%@'#&4%":#&6%2'&4"3.X%&%:'6&6&34#"266%&
$#:I%4%'4%&)H@I#&&:$#'&42432"!&%%:&5"2#&2'6Q$2#&6#&$"2:%&I"%82&4#&'%&4%2@#3$#:%+%&
"%+$2#'"!&%]
6%8%"/#$#:3'2$"@1&4%'6#!&%6%6"#&$+2%'4%&$2U'$26%4+4#@'#I"S#6%82'4%%O34"#C#"&@F&
34#"266%&$#:I%4%'4%&,
;4#6&&4"'&.X%&$#'&4'4%&6#2'$2&#6#"4O3%3+4"I&&"%:+2:24%<2K6#@I"%&&%<2:@I%+
:%&:34#"266%%'<#":%$#'62.X%&I#"%+%&41%+%$26&@6%8%'6#&%"V3'4626%'42<2$./#O3%&%
"%<%"%#2'$2&#6#:%&:#"42>#]9%6./#66I%+%2' @6%H -;
1;I"#I#&4#3"%+2S./#6%4"'&./#I"%82&4'#2'$2&#6%&4%"42>#
9;?
#2I#1V%428#
H(%"$%1%!&%I%+6%&$"2./#6$#'6341N&2$6#$"2:%6%+8>%:$#'426'#"46%2H*-H(O3%
$#'6342+Q$24$#'&2&4%%:$3+4"#362&&2:3+"'43"%S@#"2>%:@+#$+2S./#@62&I#&2./#@:#82:%'4./#
#3I"#I"2%66%6%1%'&@62"%24#&#38+#"%&I"#8%'2%'4%&@62"%4#32'62"%4:%'4%@6%'4"%#34"&C2IT4%&%&@6%
$"2:%$#'4"6:2'2&4"./#01+2$%I"42$6#&I#"#">'2S./#$"2:2'#&92'$2&#&%;@I#6%'6#
#$3+4./##$#""%"#:2&&28#3$#:2&&28:%'4%%62&&2:3+./#9O3%8%:&%"#$3+4./#$#:<"36%#3
>"'426#$3+4./#;I%'&$#:2&&28:%'4%
HH&$+"%$%%"&#'#62'C#
#&4O3%,
?%'6##>%'4%#$3+4'6##362&&2:3+6##3%&4'6##$3+4"#362&&2:3+"'43"%S962S"%&I%24#F&
$"$4%"Q&42$&I"TI"2&6#I"#634#@&%V:%+&%&&%'$22&&%V:$2"$3'&4'$22&;@#"2>%:9$#'$%"'%'4%F&3
+2$2436%#32+2$2436%;@+#$+2S./#9#'6%&%%'$#'4"#I"#634#;@:#82:%'4./#9"%+$2#'6F$2"$3+./#6#
I"#634#;#3I"#I"2%66%9"%<%"%'4%F+%>242:266%#32+%>242:266%6#6#:Q'2#;6%1%'&@62"%24#&#38+#"%&
I"#8%'2%'4%&62"%4#32'62"%4:%'4%9'%&4%$&#&%%&4NI"%&&3I#"$2"$3+./#'4%"2#"6#I"#634#@&%:
O3%&%I#&&82'$3+!+#NI"N42$6#2+Q$24#;6%$"2:%@4%"N%&&%>%'4%2'$#""26##3%&4"N2'$#""%'6#'&
&'.X%&I"%82&4&'#"46%2H*-HH(?
http://www.jfce.jus.br/consultaProcessual/resimprsentintegra.asp?CodDoc=2177598
3/11/2010
Page 16 of 50
34"#&&2:@O3+O3%"2'<"./#I%'+I"%82&4%:O3+O3%"62I+#:+%>+$#'4"6:2'2&4"./#01+2$
I#6%%'&%V"+8>%:6%62'C%2"#%'/#I%'&#&$"2:%&I"%82&4#&'#Q43+#M6#
T62>#%'+
6%:2&@I"%8U#2'$2&#6#"4I"%8U$#:#$"2:%'4%$%6%'4%#I"42$6#I#"#">'2S./#
$"2:2'#&@&%'6#%&4@$#'<#":%VN%KI#&4#@'/#'%$%&&"2:%'4%6%<2'26+%>+:%'4%I"&3$#'<2>3"./#@
:&$"$4%"2S6I#"&3%&4"343"%428266%&
"%823@2'6#+%>2&+6#"@3:&5"2%6%$#'634&%O32I"6&9^^%6#"46%2H*-H(;@
"%&&+4'6#O3%#&3V%24#428#6#$"2:%6%+8>%:6%62'C%2"#'/#I"%$2&&%"@'%$%&&"2:%'4%@#&3V%24#
428#6#$"2:%'4%$%6%'4%
-&&2:@2'$#""%':%&:I%'O3%:@I"#$3+4"#362&&2:3+"342+2S./#6%1%'&@62"%24#&#38+#"%&
I"#8%'2%'4%&6%O3+O3%"6#&$"2:%&'4%$%6%'4%&"%<%"26#&'#"4,#&$#'8%"4%%:428#&+Q$24#&]#&
6O32"%@"%$%1%@4"#$@'%>#$2@6N#3"%$%1%%:>"'42@>3"6@4%:%:6%IT&24#@:#82:%'4#3
4"'&<%"%]2:I#"4#3%KI#"41%'&$#:8+#"%&'/#$#""%&I#'6%'4%&#&8%"66%2"#&9^6#"46
%2H*-H(;@1%:$#:#O3%:342+2S@'428266%%$#'7:2$#3<2''$%2"@1%'&@62"%24#&#38+#"%&O3%
&1%&%"%:I"#8%'2%'4%&6%O3+O3%"6#&$"2:%&'4%$%6%'4%&"%<%"26#&'%&4%"42>##3I"42$2I6%>"3I#@
&&#$2./##3%&$"24T"2#4%'6#$#'C%$2:%'4#6%O3%&3428266%I"2'$2I+#3&%$3'6N"2562"2>26FI"N42$
6%$"2:%&I"%82&4#&'%&4%29^6#"46%2H*-H(;
)%&&+4%!&%O3%&$#'634&I#6%:&%"2'&4'4W'%&#36%<#":I%":'%'4%@#3&%V@#>%'4%I#6%
$#:I""2:T8%2&$#:I"#634#6#$"2:%'4%$%6%'4%@$#'&3:'6#:#6+266%$#'8%"4%"%:428#&+Q$24#&@
$#:#I#6%"%$%1%"@>3"6"#34%"%:6%IT&24#I"4%6O3'42#"23'66%2+Q$24#&'4%$%6%'4%&@C2IT4%&%
%:O3%4%"%:#&3:<#":I%":'%'4%6%$#'&3:./#@%'&%V'6#I"2&/#%:<+>"'4%
%+%:%'4#&31V%428#9#+#2"%4#%#+#8%'43+;
%>3'6##32S%6%"+5">2#%"''6##"#-@#"4@$I34@6%2H*-HH(%K2>%#6#+#
>%'5"2$#)@#3&%V@$#'&$2U'$2%8#'46%6%"%+2S./#6#&%+%:%'4#&#1V%428#&6#42I#I%'+@'/#%K2>2'6#
'%'C3:%+%:%'4#&31V%428#62$2#'+#32'4%'$2#'+266%%&I%$Q<2$@1&4'6##O3%"%"6#"%&3+46#4QI2$#
*#O3%62S"%&I%24##6#+#%8%'43+@#3&%V@O3'6##>%'4%@I%&"6%'/#6%&%V"#"%&3+46#6#
$"2:%@&&3:%#"2&$#6%&3I"#63./#@$"$4%"2SN8%+O3'6##>%'4%52'62<%"%'4%O3'4#FI"#$%6U'$2
$"2:2'#&6##1V%4#6+8>%:@&&3:2'6##"2&$#6%#$3+4"#362&&2:3+"&3#"2>%:#3'43"%S@
$"%:#&O3%5">2##"#I"%&%'4%&$+"%$2:%'4#&6%<2'2428#&&#1"%#4%:%@'4%"2O3%S6#4%K4#@
I%":242:#!'#&"%I"#63S2"&%3&%'&2':%'4#&'Q'4%>",
?9;"+%21"&2+%2"@#$"2:%56#+#&#?O3'6##>%'4%O32&#"%&3+46##3&&3:23#"2&$#6%I"#63S2!
+#?9"4(@@6#
;#6#+#%8%'43+@?#&3V%24#428#'/#$#'C%$%$#:$%"4%S%K2&4U'$26#&%+%:%'4#&
"%O3%"26#&I%+#42I##1V%428#@63826'6#6&3%K2&4U'$2%@I%&"62&4#@>%@$%24'6#I#&&212+266%6%
&3%K2&4U'$2?*:%KI#&2./#2'6:2&$+",
?6#+#%8%'43+@$#'$%2436#%:4%":#&$#""%'4%&@5$#'6346O3%+%O3%62S&2:%&:#eO3%>Z%'4%e@
eO3%&%2'$#:#6%e@e&%$#'4%$%"@S"e@e'/#:%2:I#"4#e1&%"8%!&%O3%O32'/#CN3:$%24./#6#
"%&3+46#$#:#4+@%&2:&3$%24./#$#:#I#&&212+266%@$#:#I"#112+266%? BNI#"4'4#3:62<%"%'.'#%+%:%'4#$#>'#&$2428#%8#+2428#%:"%+./##6#+#62"%4##6#+#%8%'43+@#
>%'4%4%:$#'C%$2:%'4#6#"%&3+46#I#&&Q8%+#3I"#8N8%+6%&3$#'634@'/##6%&%V'6#62"%4:%'4%@
:&$%24'6##3&%'6#2'62<%"%'4%%&&%"%&3+46#I#&&Q8%+#3I"#8N8%+9;
&42I#&I%'2&6#&2'$2&#&%6#^6#"46%2H*-HH($#'4U:<T":3+&6%&I5$2%,
?'$#""%@2'6@':%&:I%'O3%:,
!342+2S@'428266%%$#'7:2$#3<2''$%2"@1%'&@62"%24#&#38+#"%&O3%&1%&%"%:I"#8%'2%'4%&6%
O3+O3%"6#&$"2:%&'4%$%6%'4%&"%<%"26#&'%&4%"42>#]
!I"42$2I6%>"3I#@&&#$2./##3%&$"24T"2#4%'6#$#'C%$2:%'4#6%O3%&3428266%I"2'$2I+#3
&%$3'6N"2562"2>26FI"N42$6%$"2:%&I"%82&4#&'%&4%2?
N#42I#I"2'$2I+6#"4@O3%+%I"%82&4#'#$I34@'/#$#'45:<T":3+%O328+%'4%
G3%&4/#O3%&%$#+#$5&%CNO323:+$3'+%>2&+428$#+:4N8%+'#:%&:#&%'426#6#&2'$2&#&%6#
^@"%&4"2'>2'6##$"2:%6%+8>%:#6#+#62"%4#@#3&%4"4!&%6%3:#:2&&/#6%+21%"66#
+%>2&+6#"@#3&%V@6%3:&2+U'$2#%+#OZ%'4%<2:6%I%":242"2'$26U'$26+%2'#$&#6%6#+#%8%'43+
6:242'6##6#+#%8%'43+@#$"2:%6%+8>%:6#"4"%&4"2$#'<2>3"6#2'6O3%#>%'4%'/#
428%&&%#$#'C%$2:%'4#I+%'#6#"2>%:#3'43"%S$"2:2'#&6#&1%'&@62"%24#&#38+#"%&%'8#+826#&@
1&4'6#O3%428%&&%$#'C%$2:%'4#6I"#112+266%6%&&%<4#@>2'6#6%<#":2'62<%"%'4%O3'4#F
#$#""U'$26#"%&3+46#6%+2428#
6#34"2'1"&2+%2"628%">%%&&%"%&I%24#'O3'4#@I#"%K%:I+#'47'2#24#:1#%"$#'47'2#E""#&
6%<%'6%:O3%#$"2:%6%+8>%:%K2>%#6#+#62"%4#@#34"#&$#:##6#+<#2>"%2%[2++2:%""6%
+28%2"6:24%:#6#+#%8%'43+(
">3:%'4#I"2'$2I+6#&0+42:#&"%&26%'<+46%"%&4"2./#+%>+%&&%"%&I%24#
$"%&$%'4%!&%O3%2'4%"I"%4./#C2&4T"2$4:15:<8#"%$%%&&4%&%@$<&%8%"2<2$'#24%:)6
KI#&2./#6%#428#&*HHH*,
?O32I"#I"#V%4#@2'6@#$"2:%6%+8>%:6%62'C%2"#2:I#"4./##3%KI#"4./#6%1%'&$#:8+#"%&
2'%K4#&9"4@^@;%&4C2IT4%&%@$#:#'&'4%"2#"%&@%K2>%#I"#V%4#O3%$#'6346%&$"24
4%'C$#:##1V%428##$3+4./##362&&2:3+./#6342+2S./#6%1%'&@62"%24#&#38+#"%&#"23'6#&6#&
"%<%"26#&$"2:%&'4%$%6%'4%&K2>%#I"#V%4#@'%&&%&$&#&@#6#+#62"%4#@6:242'6##6#+#%8%'43+
&#:%'4%I"C2IT4%&%6#$I346#"42>#?
&&#+3.X%&6#2"%24#
#:I"6#&/#8"26&@&%'6#@I#"5:@1#I"4%6&+%2&#:2&&O3'4#F
I#&&212+266%%&I%$Q<2$6#6#+#%8%'43+@$#:#O3%4+O3%&4/#5%'4"%>3%F6#34"2'%FV3"2&I"36U'$2H
%"%$%:6%&4O3%&$#'&4"3.X%&V3"2&I"36%'$22&'#"4%!:%"2$'&"%+428:%'4%#4%:
+%2'#"4%!:%"2$''/#5%KI+Q$24O3'4#F6:2&&/##3'/#6#6#+#%8%'43+'#$"2:%6%+8>%:6%
62'C%2"#/##1&4'4%@I#"$#'&4"3./#V3"2&I"36%'$2+@4+<2>3"8%:&%'6#6:2426'#&4"213'2&'#"4%!
:%"2$'#&4"85&6&&2:6%'#:2'6\2++<3+1+2'6'%&&#3$#'&$2#3&8#26'$%6#$4"2'%@+24%"+:%'4%
6#34"2'6?$%>3%2"6%+21%"6?%6%?%824"$#'&$2U'$2?&2'&4"3.X%&62"2>26&#V0"2%:$&#&6
%&I5$2%&/#2+3&4"428:%'4%6%'#:2'6&6%#&4"2$C2'&4"3$42#'&@+24%":%'4%?&2'&4"3.X%&68%&4"3S?
265256%O3%,
?V3&42<2$./#&31&4'428I""%>"5O3%2>'#"W'$26%+21%"6%$#'C%$2:%'4#I#&2428#&/#2>3+:%'4%
$3+IN8%2&V3&42<2$4284%K43+5O3%@&%>3'6##%'4%'62:%'4#$#:3:@+>35:e$#'C%$%e<4#&:%&:#
O3'6#%+%%&4N:%'#&6#O3%1&#+34:%'4%$%"4#&#1"%%+%&>2"e$#:$#'C%$2:%'4#e@I#"4'4#@'/#5
'%$%&&"2:%'4%>2"I%'&$#:$#'C%$2:%'4#I#&2428#@:&4:15:>2"$#:2'62<%"%'.O3'4#F%+%86
I"#112+266%6%K2&4U'$26#<4#%:O3%&4/#G3'6#%&&2'62<%"%'.%&4NI"%&%'4%@#$#'C%$2:%'4#
eI#&2428#e'/#5%K2>26#?*
$&#'24%644%&8
:I1%++@H 6()9)4C
2"HH;@6%$2626#I%+#G3"4#
2"$324#%6%"+I#6%
http://www.jfce.jus.br/consultaProcessual/resimprsentintegra.asp?CodDoc=2177598
3/11/2010
Page 17 of 50
2+3&4""342+2S./#6"%<%"266#34"2'
++%'
:I1%++<#2$3&66%$"2:%6%+8>%:6%62'C%2"#+@>%'4%2:#12+2N"2#@4%"24%'626#"d
\2'>@4"<2$'4%6%6"#>&@%:3:4"'&./#2:#12+2N"2\2'>4%"2&%I"%&%'46#$#:#3:+%>Q42:#
%:I"%&N"2#28%":8N"2#&%'$#'4"#&6%'%>T$2#&'#&O32&%+%I"%$2$#:$""#&6%+3K#@$%"4&8%S%&
$#:3:I#"&$C%8%":%+C#@#34"&$#:3:I#"&$C%6#3"6#:3:6#&%'$#'4"#&@:#&4"#3
:I1%++3:
:+%4$#'4%'6#Y@%:62'C%2"#<2:6%6%:#'&4""$I$266%<2''$%2"I"6O32"2"3:
2:T8%+2'+:%'4%@<%$C":'%>T$2#$%"$6%3:2:T8%+@4%'6##4"<2$'4%$#'$#"66#%:I>"I#"%+%
Y(@%$#'8%'$26#
:I1%++$%24"#I>:%'4#6%Y*@I#"<#"%$%+%1""#
$#'4"4#%&$"24#I%+62<%"%'.&Y*@<#":I>#&%:62'C%2"#%:I%O3%'#&I$#4%&6%
$#:I"&%'4"%&I"#8&I"#63S26&@%'$#'4"!&%6%I#2:%'4#6%4%&4%:3'C&%>3'6##O3+
:I1%++
4%"26%$+"6#O3%#62'C%2"#I#6%"2&%"I"#8%'2%'4%6%6"#>&V0"2<%6%"+"%$%1%3&&%>32'4%&
2'&4"3.X%&,
?%+%:%'4#6#$#'C%$2:%'4#I#6%&%"&42&<%24#I#"2'<%"U'$2&%K4"Q6&6I"#86%O3%#$3&6#
6%+21%"6:%'4%<%$C#3#&#+C#&I"#O3%@6%#34":'%2"@+C%&%"2T182#:$#'$+3&/#$2:6%
O3+O3%"60826"S#N8%+6%K2&4U'$26%I"#IT&24#$#'&$2%'4%6%%824"6%&$#1%"4I#6%I%":242"2'<%"U'$2
O3'4##$#'C%$2:%'4#
#+#$6#6%#34":'%2"@#$#'C%$2:%'4#6#$3&6#$%"$6%3:<4#I#6%&%"
2'<%"26#62>'#"W'$26%+21%"6$%"$6%K2&4U'$26#<4#
%I%'6%2'4%2":%'4%6#V0"2$#'$+32"$%"$6%K2&4U'$26%6%+21%"6#<%$C"6%#+C#&%&2'<%"U'$2&
6%8%:&%"%K4"Q6&6%O3+O3%"%826U'$26%:#'&4"./#6%'%>+2>U'$2'/#5&3<2$2%'4%I"$#'$+32"
$%"$6I"%&%'.6%8#'46%#36%$#'C%$2:%'4#
3I"%82'#8#$U&O3%3:$3&./#6%$%>3%2"6%+21%"6'/##&34#"2S$#'$+32"O3%#$3&6#>23$#:
$#'C%$2:%'4#I#"O3%%+%6%8%"2&1%"#O3%%&48#$#""%'6#O3'6#68%'66I"#I"2%66%#3O3%@%:
%K%"$Q$2#6%6282'C./#@%+%6%8%"2&1%"#O3%%&48#$#""%'6##3I#"O3%%+%<#2'%>+2>%'4%%:
"%$#'C%$%"#O3%%&48#$#""%'6##3I#"O3%%+%<#22'$34##34#+#%:"%$#'C%$%"#O3%%&48#$#""%'6#
#$#'4"N"2#@##8%"'#6%8%I"#8"$2:6%O3+O3%"60826"S#N8%+O3%#$3&6#:#4286:%'4%%
6%+21%"6:%'4%%824#36%&$#1"2"4#6#&#&<4#&e
:I1%++<#2$#'6%'6I%+#V0"2@:&&3$#'6%'./#<#2"%82&4I%+
#"4%2&4"24+:I%+./##G3"4#
2"$324#@6%$2&/#62&4"24+<#2"%82&6@:'4%'6#!&%6%$2&/#6#V0"2@%'4%'6%'6#
#"4%O3%3:V0"2@
62'4%6&I"#8&@I#6%"2@"S#8%+:%'4%$#'$+32"O3%$3&642'C$#'C%$2:%'4##3O3%
6%+21%"6:%'4%4%"2<%$C6##&#+C#&I"#"2>%:6#62'C%2"#342+2S6#I"O32&2./#6#2:T8%+
"'&$"%8%!&%@I#""%+%8'4%@#&%>32'4%4"%$C#66%$2&/#6#G3"4#
2"$324#,
?#8%"'#'/#I"%$2&I"#8"O3%#$3&6#42'C#I"#IT&24#6%+8"#I"#634#6%428266%2+Q$24#
$#'4"N"2#@$#:#+2'>3>%:6+%2&3>%"%@##8%"'#6%8%I%'&6%:#'&4""O3%#$3&6#42'C
$#'C%$2:%'4#6%O3%4"'&./#6%&42'8!&%+8"I"#634#2+Q$24#
62&42'./#5$"Q42$%:$&#&$#:##I"%&%'4%@'#O3+#$3&6#53:I%&&#62&42'46#2'628Q63#O3%5
<#'4%6#62'C%2"#&3V#&4N$+"#I%+#&34#&O3%
:I1%++'/#>23$#:#I"#IT&24#%&I%$Q<2$#6%+8"
62'C%2"#6%6"#>%3:#428#@&%:60826@%"<%$C"#'%>T$2#2:#12+2N"2#%$#+%4"&3$#:2&&/#@&%:&%
2:I#"4"$#:<#'4%6#62'C%2"##3$#:#%<%24#64"'&./#%:#$3+4"I"4%6#I"%.#6%8%'6#682@
&:#428.X%&6%
:I1%++&/#2""%+%8'4%&#&4%":#&6+%2@O3%&4/#"%+%8'4%'/#5#I"#IT&24#6%
:I1%++@:&&2:&%3$#'C%$2:%'4#6#I"#IT&24#6%\2'>?
A2:I#"4'4%6%&4$"O3%?2>'#"W'$26%+21%"6?'/#&%$#'<3'6%$#:'%>+2>U'$2@C8%'6#O32:%&:
<"#'4%2"4U'3%@I%+#:%'#&6#I#'4#6%82&4I"#14T"2#@%'4"%#6#+#%8%'43+%$3+I$#'&$2%'4%*
\2++<3+1+2'6'%&&6#$4"2'%4%:&26#$%24I%+&
#"4%&'#"4%!:%"2$'&*@O3'6#CNI"#86%,;O3%#
>%'4%42'C$#'C%$2:%'4#6%+%86I"#112+266%6%O3%#&1%'&@62"%24#&#38+#"%&%'8#+826#&%":
I"#8%'2%'4%&6%$"2:%]%1;O3%#>%'4%>236%:#6#2'62<%"%'4%%&&%$#'C%$2:%'4#
+>3:&
#"4%&4U:%K2>26#O3%#0+42:#%+%:%'4#&%V6%:#'&4"6#4"85&6%I"#86%O3%#>%'4%4%'C
6%+21%"6:%'4%%&$#+C26#I%":'%$%"2>'#"'4%"%&I%24#6%4#6#&#&<4#&O3'6#%"I#&&Q8%+
+4%"'428:#34"&I+8"&@#>%'4%@I%&"6%4%"$#'62.X%&6%I"#<3'6"&%3$#'C%$2:%'4#&#1"%#&
<4#&@#3&%V@&#1"%#"2>%:#3'43"%S6#&1%'&@62"%24#&#38+#"%&%'8#+826#&@%&$#+C%I%":'%$%"
+C%2#%&&%$#'C%$2:%'4#248#
2"$324#%6%"+@I#"%K%:I+#@%'4%'6%O3%&#&4"2$C2'&4"3$42#'&'/#
6%8%:&%"<#"'%$26&#V0"2?&+8#&%C#38%"I"#8O3%&3I#"4%2'<%"U'$26%O3%#$3&6#%&48$2%'4%
6%+%86I"#112+266%6%K2&4U'$26#<4#%:O3%&4/#%6%+21%"6:%'4%>23I"%824"$2U'$26%
4#6#&#&<4#&6%<#":4%"3:6%<%&'#$&#6%3:&31&%OZ%'4%$3&./#?*-'24%644%&83$C%@
--6 94C
"-;@1%:2+3&4"$&#6%&I5$2%2>'#"W'$26%+21%"6<#2"%$#'C%$26@I#2&
O3'6#>%'4%I#+2$2+2'<2+4"6#4%'4#3%KI+2$"#$3&6##"2>%:6#62'C%2"#O3%%"#1V%4#64"'&./#@
%&4%"%>23'%>428:%'4%@#I#'6#!&%F4%'44286%%KI+2$./#
2&$#'&4"3.X%&@%:3:#3#34"<#":@&&%:%+C:!&%#6#+#%8%'43+6+%>2&+./#%6#34"2'
1"&2+%2"#"2&&#%$#'&26%"'6#I"%82&/#>%'5"2$6#"4(@@6#
@%<+46%62&I#&2./#+%>+
%&I%$Q<2$'+%26%+8>%:$#'4"6:2&&/#6#6#+#%8%'43+@I#6%:%+&&%"4"S26&I"'#&&I"N42$
V3"Q62$
/#%+&2'6%&I%$2+:%'4%8+2#&&'#&$&#&VN:%'$2#'6#&%:O3%#>%'4%6#$"2:%'4%$%6%'4%'/#
&%$#'<3'6%$#:#6#$"2:%6%+8>%:
O3%+%O3%C1243+:%'4%&%6%62$F+8>%:6%62'C%2"#6%<#":347'#:@#I"#<2&&2#'+6+8>%:@5
3&3+:%'4%2'62<%"%'4%F#"2>%:%'43"%S6#&1%'&@62"%24#&#38+#"%&%'8#+826#&$#'C%$2:%'4#I+%'#
6#"2>%:%'43"%S$"2:2'#&&545:%&:#2'6%&%VN8%+I#"O3%I#6%I"%V362$"+%>./#6%
6%&$#'C%$2:%'4#%:<343"%%8%'43+I%"&%$3./#I%'+$+2%'4%@6%:2&@4:15:'/#4%:2'4%"%&&%%:
$#:I"42+C"&2'<#":.X%&$%"$6#"2>%:%'43"%S%&I%$Q<2$6#I"#8%'4#6#$"2:%G3'4#:%'#"#
'0:%"#6%I%&&#&$2%'4%&6##$#""26#@4'4#:%+C#"+86#"I"#<2&&2#'+O3%&%:#&4"%K$%&&28:%'4%
?$3"2#&#?I#6%#3I%"6%"#$+2%'4%#3&%%KI#"3:&243./#6%"2&$#I%"'4%%+%'43"+@'%&&&
$2"$3'&4W'$2&@5O3%&%V"%8%+6##>%'4%6+8>%:I%'&#'%$%&&N"2#I""%+2S./#6#&%"82.#@#
O3%3&3+:%'4%'/#2'$+32:2#"%&2'<#":.X%&&#1"%#"2>%:%'43"%S6##1V%4#6+8>%:
+>3'&$3&6#&6%$"2:%&6%+8>%:I%"'4%#34#"6%&4%"42>#@I#"%K%:I+#@#I%"6#"%&6#:%"$6#6%
$W:12#I"+%+##&6#+%2"#&1"&2+%2"#&@$C%>"::%&:#6:242"%:&%3&6%I#2:%'4#&V362$22&&3
428266%2+Q$24'#:%"$6#I"+%+#%:%&:#"%+2S./#6%<"36%&<2''$%2"&I"#$3+4"26%'4266%#3
4"'&.X%&6%&%3&$+2%'4%&*)/##1&4'4%@'/#6:242:I"N42$6%$"2:%6%+8>%:@>%"+:%'4%$#:
%&$3&6%O3%6%&$#'C%$2:#"2>%:#3'43"%S6#62'C%2"#%'8#+826#:"%+266%@+>3:&<2":.X%&
6%2K8:$+"#O3%'/#+C%&$12"%+2S"2'6>.X%&6%&I5$2%#$+2%'4%#3>2"$#:#3:34#"266%
I01+2$
42436%6%&I5$2%$"$4%"2S2'62<%"%'.O3'4##"%&3+46#6#I"TI"2#>2"%&6%O3%I"%&%'4%&#&
"%O32&24#&%K2>26#&I%+6#34"2'6?2>'#"W'$26%+21%"6?@#3&%V@I"#86%O3%#>%'4%42'C
$#'C%$2:%'4#6%+%86I"#112+266%6'43"%S%#"2>%:$"2:2'#&&6#&1%'&@62"%24#&%8+#"%&
%'8#+826#&%@O32.N@6%O3%%+%%&$#+C%3I%":'%$%"+C%2##$#'C%$2:%'4#I+%'#6%&&%&<4#&@'/#&%
82&+3:1"#1V%./#V3"Q62$#3:#"+I""%I34N!+#"%&I#'&N8%+I%+#"%&3+46#6%+2428#%@I#"4'4#@I"
$#'6%'N!+#I#"+8>%:6%62'C%2"#@66"%I"#812+266%6%&3$#'634
#"4'4#@:324#%:1#"'/#CVI"%82&/#+%>+%KI"%&&I"#6#+#%8%'43+'#$"2:%6#"4@$I34@6
%2H*-HH(9$#:#'/#CN%:>%"+I"O3+O3%"#34"#$"2:%'#:#6%+#1"&2+%2"#;@CNI#&&212+266%6%
6:242!+#62'4%6I"%82&/#>%"+6#"4(@@6#
%6%&3I%"42'U'$2%"%+%8W'$2I"%<2$N$26+%2
http://www.jfce.jus.br/consultaProcessual/resimprsentintegra.asp?CodDoc=2177598
3/11/2010
Page 18 of 50
6%+8>%:@:NK2:%O3'6#'/#&%82&+3:1":#1V%.X%&V3"Q62$&#3:#"2&I"4'4#?6%&4$:#&
-#3"4#O3+2<2$6#
#62(6%>#&4#6%@#&%"826#"6#E'$#
%'4"+"'$2&$#6%3+%2K%2"@%:$#:I'C26#
&%"826#"#">%32&">/##I%&@1"23$&<#"4%@4%'6##I"2:%2"#@>#"%:$#:I'C26#&&%"826#"%&
#&56"2'##'4%&%"2%'%$RE%S%""E">@6%'4"6#':%&:&%'6#O3%@IT&4%"&%I"6#
'3:%"N"2#I"4%'6%"F&&#+2$24.X%&6%&O3%I%+"%6%1'$N"2@62"2>23!&%#<3'6#6$&<#"4%I"
+%8'4:%'4#6O3'4266%6%1&%&%$#'4%'4#"%&@#$&2/#%:O3%&%6%I"#3$#::36'.6%I#&2./#
6%3:6&1&%&6%$#'4%'4#"@8%"2<2$'6#@+#>#%:&%>326@'#13"$#'#I2&#6%$#'$"%4#@$#'&44'6#@
%'4/#@82#+./#6%$2'$#$#'4%'4#"%&6%$563+&6%Y@9<+&-6#I%'&#*6#
()(*!;@&%'6#42&<4#&$#:3'2$6#&#&&3I%"2#"%&%F3I%"2'4%'6U'$26#+Q$2%6%"+
(
#:#VN"%>2&4"6#@#+36#I%"2$2+') !
9<+&)-)- -8#+;@&&2'6#I%+#&I%"24#&
$"2:2'2&<%6%"2&+N82#%>3'6#[>'%"%"$%+#6%\"%'$%E&&RE+3:@$#:I"#8O3%4+<3"4#
#$#""%3$#:342+2S./#6%40'%+%&$86#I"42"6$&' 636%:".#@"%>2/#$%'4"+6%
#"4+%S9<#4#&<+&HH(%(*-(**;@+3>6I#"3:2'628Q63#O3%&%26%'42<2$#3$#:#&%'6#3+#5">2#
6%#3S96#$3:%'4#&I%&&#2&%"%+428#&F%:I"%&6%#3S":2'4542$F&<+&)* @ ) *@((@
HHH@-)*@)-@)*)-@*)@**-@*-)*-*!6%I#2:%'4#6%322'C%2"#E"1#&0'2#"F&
<+&*)*;%O3%$C%>#345$&<#"4%6#E'$#
%'4"+@62&4'4%:2&6% 9&%4%'4%$2'$#;:%4"#&@
#'6%3:+V%6%$#'$"%4#6%@:6%%&I%&&3"<#2"#:I26
H%<%"26#+36#2'62$O3%O36"2+C3&8"%<%"26"%&26U'$2*$#:#&314%"<0>2#6%&%"&%6%6%3:
%:I"%&6%>":&2'4542$@6%I#&24'6#%:&3&6%I%'6U'$2&@#$3+46&%:I"%6%&<+&&6%>%&&#@
4%"""%42"66#40'%+]#1&%"8!&%@4:15:O3%624#40'%+42'C%'4"662&<".6$#:4:I6%4$#&6%
:6%2"@%"%O32I6#$#:&2&4%:6%"%<"2>%"./#@2+3:2'./#"42<2$2+%+'4%"'&6%&%>3"'.@+5:6%
$#'4"$#:H9'#8%$%'4#&;%&$#"&6%:6%2"$#:I"%%'$C2:%'4#6%">:&&@8%'42+6#"%&%
&%>:%'4#&6%431#&6%$2:%'4#98%"36#'* @F&<+&HH 6#()(*!;
%"2<2$!&%@2'6@O3%#&2'<"4#"%&342+2S":**&%""I#"4N42+$2"$3+"%+54"2$@$#:62&$#62:'46#@
6%826:%'4%6I46I"#&%"82.#6%$#"4%6%$#'$"%4#'8%"42$+@+5:6%<3"6%2"%+54"2$:'3+%
:$$#C26"N3+2$#@$#'<#":%2:>%'&&%>32""%I"#63S26&,
+36#%:"%<%"U'$24:15:2'62$O3%O36"2+C4%8%'%$%&&266%6%+%8'4:%'4#4#I#>"N<2$#
I"582#%$#'44#$#:2'<#":.X%&"%+428&F%&I%&&3"6I"%6%@I#&2./#6#&#1V%4#&'#2'4%"2#"6
2K
#"4%%62&I#&2./#6#&2&4%:6%&%>3"'.@$#'4'6#$#:&I+'4&6#%62<Q$2#@%:%&I%$2+6
2K#"4%
6#E
%$#:#34"&2'<#":.X%&I"282+%>26&I"%K%$3./#6#40'%+$#:4:'CI"%$2&/#@#O3%
"%<#".C2IT4%&%6%I"42$2I./#6%I%&&#&O3%4"1+C:#34"1+C":'#E'$#
%'4"+#3'
$#'&4"3./#6#%62<Q$2##3'2'&4+./#6#&&2&4%:&6%&%>3"'.936#'*!
6%<+&(()H@
6#()(*!@<#4#&<+&((H ;
"2&%!&%@2'6@O3%#'3:%"N"2#<3"46#9Y*) @;$"$4%"2S#3!&%I#"&%"$#'&4243Q6#6%
'#4&6%$2'OZ%'4"%2&O3%VN%&428%":%:$2"$3+./#@&%'6#O3%'#2'4%"2#"6
2K#"4%%K2&42:2'6
:324#&#34"#&:2+CX%&6%"%2&%:'#4&&%"26&@O3%<#":%8246&I%+#&I"42$2I'4%&6#$"2:%@#O3%
4:15:6%:#'&4"I"582#$#'C%$2:%'4#45:%&:#662&I#&2./#6#&:.#&6%62'C%2"#@$#'<#":%&%
8%"2<2$4"85&6#+36#'*!
6%<+&((H-8#+6#'()(*!]624#+36#
<2":@2'6@O3%#&&&+4'4%&"#:I%":$#'4%'6#"%&6%62'C%2"#%428%":#$3266#6%'6""%'4%F&
I"%6%&@%824'6##&&%'&#"%&6%:#82:%'4#@45$C%>"%:#&$#'4%'6#"%&6%&%V6#&&&&+4'4%&
342+2S":@4:15:@"#+6'&%"%$2I2%'4%42I#4:1#"$#"46#8%"42$+:%'4%%:<#":6%I%O3%'1+&@6%
<#":6%&+2S"%$#'63S2"#'3:%"N"2#I#"6%'4"#6#40'%+45"%&26U'$22'2$2+@6%#'6%%:I"%%'6%":
<3>
-%'6#%:82&4#4%":#6%6%$+".X%&6%"'$2&$#6&
C>&#$C6%#3S@F&<+&-)6#'
()(*!@I"#I"2%4N"2#6#%&4$2#':%'4#%:<"%'4%F$&&2436'"36%:".#@' @
$#'$+32!&%O3%624#40'%++%8#3$%"$6%4"U&:%&%&I"&%"%K%$346#@#3&%V@4%8%2'Q$2#I#"8#+46#2'Q$2#
6%:2#6%@4%'6##<3"4##$#""26#%'4"%#62%*6%>#&4#6%1&%"8%!&%@'#%'4'4#@O3%
<+&%:I"%&6%>":&2'4542$4%8%&%3
$6&4"6#%:H)@$#:"%>2&4"#'3'4
#:%"$2+
':%&:649<+& (6#I%'&#6#()(*!;@4%'6#$&342+2S6&26#+3>6
I%+#I%"Q#6#6%6%:2#6%-6%1"2+6%*@62"%4:%'4%4"85&62:#12+2N"2
+N362#
%"%2&&42:T8%2&469O3%"%I"%&%'4#3#I"#I"2%4N"2#'47'2#%2'+6#%+%&6#
":#%:$#'4"4#<2":6#
%: 6%1"2+6%@$#:<2":"%$#'C%$266#+#$4N"2#@$TI2F&<+&HH6#"%<%"26#;@I%+#8+#"6%
Y*@9&%2&$%'4#&"%2&;:%'&2&
)#O3%62S"%&I%24##&2&4%:6%&%>3"'.6#$2K<#"4%6#E'$#
%'4"+@6%$+"#3#&56%N42:
"8+C#@45$'2$#%:%+%4"7'2$#6#E
CN:2&6%82'4%%$2'$#'#&9%:(6%>#&4#6%@<+& (
6#'()(*!;@O3%"%<%"26#$#<"%62&I3'C6%$2'$#$W:%"&6%<2+:>%:@&%'6#63&'
I#"46%%'4"6I"#&<3'6#&%4"U&6#:%2#6#$#<"%I"I#"46%%'4"6@1%:$#:#%'4"%(%
&%'&#"%&6%I"%&%'.%&%'&#"%&6%2:I$4#'&I"%6%&+4%"2&%4%4#@:&'/#'#I2&#@%&$+"%$%'6#2'6
O3%624&$W:%"&'/#>"8:&2:>%'&:&I%'&&4"'&:24%:I"&+$%'4"+6%&%>3"'.@#'6%
I%&&#I%":'%$%)C#"&I#"62#1&%"8'6#624&2:>%'&$I46&]62&&%2'6O3%#&&N16#&@
6#:2'>#&%<5"2&@624&+%"#I%"6I#"3:<3'$2#'N"2#6%:I"%&6%&%>3"'.@$#'4"46
I%+#E'$#
%'4"+@<2":'6#O3%4#6##&2&4%:%&48%:I+%'#3&#@'/#&1%'6#%KI+2$"$#:#&%6%3#
<3"4#&%:I%"$%I./#6##I%"6#"6%$W:"6$%'4"+6%&%>3"'.8%SO3%@I%&"6%I%'&&+3S%&6%
&%>3"'.6#$#<"%I%":'%$%"%:+2>6&@82&3+2S./##+C#'35I%"<%24@%&$+"%$%'6#O3%63&
%:I"%&&<S2:"%<#":&'#E'$#
%'4"+9"4%2&#%%"4]"%+./#6#&%:I"%>6#&4%"$%2"2S6#&%:
&%"82.#'#E'$#
%'4"+@%&4>2N"2#&6%%'>%'C"2@%&$+:%'&+6%&%"826#"%&%'$#'4":!&%'#I%'&#*
6#'()(*!;2&&%2'6O3%<"%OZ%'48#E"6#%6"#%#E"6#'@'"3
6%:".#@IT&#%KI%62%'4%%'4%&6%2"I"$&
I%"24##6"2>#3">%+%"''6%&N8#"@O3%I"42$2I#36#+36#'* 6%<+&(H(-6#
()(*!@#3826#%:**!<+&(( 8#+@<2":#3O3%,
?9;G5I"2:%2"8%SO3%<S+36#&#1"%&2&4%:6%&%>3"'.@:&I#6%<2":"O3%3::%+C#"
62&I#&2./#6#&&%'&#"%&+N%K2&4%'4%&I#6%"24%"%8246#4+<3"4#@'/#&%'6#2:I"%&$2'6Q8%+&%'&#"%&6%I2&#
I"#:%&:#"%&3+46#]O3%2+3:2'./#IT&#%KI%62%'4%%""%63S26'#2'4%"2#"6$2K!<#"4%@4+8%S
I#"%$#'#:2@%@'#&&%4#"%&@>32$CU&%:%2#$2"$3+'4%@2+3:2'./#%"I>6@&%'6#342+2S6I%'&
http://www.jfce.jus.br/consultaProcessual/resimprsentintegra.asp?CodDoc=2177598
3/11/2010
Page 39 of 50
- !2'2&45"2#01+2$#%6%"+@%:&3&+%>.X%&<2'2&F&<+&--*--!)8#+3:%@"%$#'C%$%3O3%
2'%K2&4%:I"#8&"%<%"%'4%&NI"42$2I./#6%%#'%+'#<3"4##E'$#
%'4"+#3+8>%:6#I"#8%24#6#
$"2:%@I%62'6#&31&#+82./#
#'$+3&X%&6&"#8&$#'426&'#&34#&
-(!#"436##%KI#&4#%I%+#$#'426#'#&34#&@$C%>!&%F$#'$+3&/#O3%#<3"4#O3+2<2$6##$#""26#
$#'4"#E'$#
%'4"+6#E"&2+@'#62*6%>#&4#6%@<#2I"42$6#I#"#">'2S./#$"2:2'#&
$#:I#&4@6%'4"%#34"#&@I%+#&"53&=ED@
@
9%&4%&&%342+2S'6#4:15:6%26%'4266%&%6#$3:%'4#&<+&#&;@A
D@
GD%A
B
B@%'O3'4##&"53&A
B
B
@AD983+>#%'5:;@
@
1%:$#:#GD@
B@
@
E%#&:%&:#&=ED@
@
93+>#5282;%A
D"%+2S":+8>%:6%I"4%6#'3:%"N"2#
<3"46#@':%6266%&3&$3+I12+266%&%$#'<#":%%8#+3./#6#&4#&I#&4%"2#"%&#<3"4#%$#'<#":%
6%&Q>'2#&347'#:#&@&%'6#O3%4#6#&#&6%+24#&<#":$#'&3:6#&'4%"%3'2/#6#&%+%:%'4#&6%<2'26#&
+%>+:%'4%@I%+#I%"<%2.#:%'4#6&$#'634&#1V%428&%'4%I"%&%'.6#&%+%:%'4#&&31V%428#&
$"$4%"Q&42$#&
-H!/#"%&4$#:I"#8634#"2#3I"42$2I./#6#"5393
J;'#&<4#&%:I3"./#@4%'6##2'2&45"2#01+2$#%6%"+"%O3%"26#&31&#+82./#@1%:
$#:##"53B<#2:#"4#@I%+#O3%5%K42'4&3I3'212+266%
!
-!&&2:@$#:#VN:%'$2#'6#@"%&42'$#'4"#8%"&#O3%#$#""%38%'66%#'S%8%Q$3+#&I#"I"4%6
E"2+C%
"%$#:2'4%"8%'./#6%#&5
C"+%&@&%'6#O3%%&4%&12O3%#'3:%"N"2#342+2S6#42'C#"2>%:
'#<3"4##E'$#
%'4"+9"4@%@^@@^@%6%2H*-H(;@'/#&%'6##$&#6#&2":/#&
#&5+2S#:"4%%"'$2&$#%":28+O3%@#O3%436#2'62$@'/#I#&&3Q:4+I%"$%I./#@:&$%"4:%'4%
&12:&%"6%#"2>%:2+Q$24
#'$+32!&%@&&2:@$#:#<4#2'$#'4"#8%"&#@O3%<#2#"53A
B
BO3%:%<%43#3#I>:%'4#6%YH(@%:'#4&6%$2'OZ%'4"%2&@"%<%"%'4%
#&#'S%8%Q$3+#&6O32"26#&6E"2+C%
"@4%'6##&"53&AD
"%$%126#4+2:I#"4W'$2&%:O3%&42#':%'4#@'%::%&:#
O3'6#Y@<#26%2K6#I#"#&5
C"+%&I"$#:I"&<343"&9I"2:%2"$#'6346%+8>%:6%
#&5
C"+%&%0'2$6#&2":/#&#&5+2S#:"4%%"'$2&$#%":28+"4@%@^@@^@%6%2
H*-H(@1%:$#:#"4H%%&%>32'4%&6:%&:+%2;
-!34"#&&2:@<#2#&5
C"+%&O3%:%'4"%>#3#24#6#&#'S%8%Q$3+#&%&$#+C26#&%6O32"26#&I#"%+%$#:
'3:%"N"2#<3"46#I%+#E'$#
%'4"+I"#34"#&2'4%>"'4%&6O36"2+C@1%:$#:#<#2I"%&#%:<+>"'4%
O3'6#4"'&I#"48#&#34"#&4"U&8%Q$3+#&"%&4'4%&@%&$#+C26#&%6O32"26#&6:%&:<#":@&%'6#O3%@
%:624#&4"U&8%Q$3+#&@<#":%'$#'4"6#&#$3+46#&Y-H* 94"U&:2+CX%&@'#8%$%'4#&%$2'OZ%'4%
&%2&:2+@&%4%$%'4#&%$2'OZ%'4"%2&;4:15:I"#8%'2%'4%6#<3"4##E'$#
%'4"+@&%'6#$%"4#@$#:#VN
:%'$2#'6#@O3%I%'&3:I%&&#6%%K4"%:$#'<2'.6#&6%:2&2'4%>"'4%&6#">'2S./#$"2:2'#&
"%&I#'&N8%+I%+#<3"4##E'$#
%'4"+&%"2%'$""%>66%4+:2&4%"9&%>3'6$#'6346%+8>%:"4@
2'$&%@^@%^@%6%2H*-H(!2'6%I%'6%'4%%$#:6%&Q>'2#&I"TI"2#&$#:"%+./#N
I"2:%2"$#'6346%+8>%:$$"4((6#
T62>#%'+;
-!%"$%1%!&%@I%+$#'V3>./#6#&6%I#2:%'4#&%6%:2&I"#8&'#&34#&@O3%"%+:%'4%#&"53&
=ED@
@93+>#5282;I"42$2I":6#
I+'%V:%'4#@I"%I"./#%%K%$3./#6#<3"4##E'$#
%'4"+@1%:$#:#6&428266%&6%#$3+4./#%
I#&4%"2#"6282&/#6%I"4%6#'3:%"N"2#@342+2S'6#!&%6%6#$3:%'4#&<+&#&%#I"2:%2"#I#"4'6#":9"4
@2'$&%@^@%^@%6%2H*-H(%"4@^)@@%@$$"4((6#
T62>#%'+
I+2$N8%2&4#6#&%"4--)6#
T62>#%'+%"4*6%2(*-@$#:"%+./#'47'2#62:";
--!
#'$+32!&%@I%+&I"#8&'#&34#&@O3%#&"53&%
E@
342+2S'6#6#$3:%'4#&O3%'/#+C%&I%"4%'$2:9&%'6#O3%#I"2:%2"#342+2S86#$3:%'4#6#2":/#%#
&%>3'6#6#$3:%'4#<+&#<#"'%$26#I#""$#&6%"'.;82%":#"4+%S$#'&$2%'4%&O3%2"2:$#+%4"
I"4%6#'3:%"N"2#<3"46#6#E'$#
%'4"+%I"#$%6%"&3$#'63./#/#3+#@&%'6#O3%#I"2:%2"#8%2#
$#'4"46#I#"822+8'#62+8%#&%>3'6#I#""$#&6%"'.6%:2&@%&48:#&"53&+N82#
3>3&4#442#+2%
E6%I#&&%6#62'C%2"#&%"4"'&I#"46#%F&&3&62&I#&2.X%&@
O3'6#<#":I"%&#&%:<+>"'4%9"4@2'$&%@^@%^@%6%2H*-H(@$$"4((6#
T62>#%'+@&%'6#4:15:I+2$N8%+&'./#I"%82&46#-)$$"4H 6#
T62>#%'+$#:"%+./#
"$#&21%2"#3II2@$#:I"42$2I./#6%"$#&6%"'.%"4-(6#
T62>#%'+$#:"%+./#+N82#
3>3&4#442#+2;
-)!%"$%1%!&%O3%$#'<2&&/#I"%&%'46I#"GDO3'4#6%&3$#'634'#
<#"'%$2:%'4#6%2'<#":.X%&O3%I#&&212+24":#<3"4#'/#$#'8%'$%@#3&%V@'/#5$"Q8%+O3%:%:1"#&6
#">'2S./#$"2:2'#&O3%<3"4#3#E'$#
%'4"+&%$#'4%'4&&%:%:@I#"4"U&8%S%&@$2"$3+"'&
2:%62.X%&6#E'$#
%'4"+%:$#:I'C26%%3&2:"%I#"4/#&2:I+%&4"%<@I>&&%:#:%&:#
Y@963S%'4#&:2+"%2&;%2'6:2&%:63&I"$%+&2>32&6%$%::2+"%2&@&%'6#I"2:%2"@
&%>3'6##6%I#2:%'4#6%%3&2:"@IT&#I&&%2##$%'4"#6$266%%:<%8%"%2"##3:".#6%@%
&%>3'6@%:3:6%:#'&4"./#&32>%'%"2&6%I"%'4%C#'"6%S'4%#$#:I"#:2&&#&&3:26#@$2'$#
:%&%&IT&#I"2:%2"#$#'44#@'#%K4#62IT&#<3"4#@O3+&%V'#&N16#62*6%>#&4#6%*
&&2:@"%&4$+"#O3%%3&2:"I"42$2I#36#">'2Si.#$"2:2'#&%%<%428:%'4%6#<3"4#@<#"'%$%'6#
2'<#":.X%&8+2#&&I"#"%&4'4%6#">'2S./#$"2:2'#&@"%$%1%3I"4%6#'3:%"N"2#<3"46#%
%:I"%>#3:%2#&6%+8>%:9"4@2'$&%@^@%^@%6%2H*-H(@$$"4((%@
^)6#
T62>#%'+;
-!$#'6346%
B@I#"&38%S@#"%$%1%"#&Y@6%
%3&2:"@:%&:#6%&$#'<2'6#&%"<"34#6#<3"4##E'$#
%'4"+@I">3"6%&#1I"#:%&&6%>'C"
#&V3"#&6#62'C%2"#O3%I#6%"2%:I"%&4"@1%:$#:#&3$#'6346%6%8#+8%"#'3:%"N"2#%3&2:"
$#'<#":%&&#+2$24.X%&6%&4%@6%:#'&4"@6%2>3+<#":@2'4%'&$#'<2'.%I"582#$#'C%$2:%'4#6
#"2>%:2+Q$246#'3:%"N"2#9"4@2'$&%@^@%^@%6%2H*-H(;
http://www.jfce.jus.br/consultaProcessual/resimprsentintegra.asp?CodDoc=2177598
3/11/2010
Page 40 of 50
-*!
#'<2"::!&%@'#&34#&@&$#'634&%<%428&6%a
D'%&$8./#6#40'%+%
"%$%12:%'4#@>3"6%I+2$./#6%I"4%6#'3:%"N"2#<3"46#9"4@2'$&%@^@%^@%6
%2H*-H(@$$"4((%"4@^)6#
T62>#%'+;
- !&&2:@'4%#%KI#&4#%I%+#$#'426#'#&34#&@
6%'0'$2@I"
E#"5393
J@<2+C#6%#&562+8"42'&%
6%%2+#"%2""42'&@'&$26##&)H @%:/#3+#!@*-((;@'<#":6#
"4-(*@6#
T62>#6%"#$%&&#%'+@%ME6#"53
B983+>#
%1#+@<2+C#6%2"'62%""%2"6%>+C/%&%E%'82'6+28%2">+C/%&@'&$26#%:
((H )@
*- H*(!(@))-H;@'<#":6#"4 @6#
T62>#%'+$$"4*
6#
T62>#6%"#$%&&#%'+'4%
%"426/#6%T124#6#"53'&%+:#+28%2">+C/%&9F&<+&-)!
8#+;%
#&6%:2&$3&6#&@'<#":&%>32"6%+2'%6,
!A
B
B@1"&2+%2"#@>"3$#:I+%4#@
'H - )))
@<2+C#6%
"26##$#""#$C6#+8%&%6%#&5"2+8%&6%#"2&@'43"+6%E#2>%:
@%'4/#I"#I"2%4N"2#
6%:I"%&"'&I#"4%46@'&I%'&6#&"42>#&@%@^@@^@%6%2H*-H(@%:
63&.X%&$#:I"#IT&24#&62&42'4#&%%:$#'$3"&#:4%"2+@$$"4((6#
T62>#%'+
!AD@83+>#%'5:@1"&2+%2"#@$&6#@$#:%"$2'4%@'&$26##&
*H %:#"4+%S
@
)H(-( ')))--)-!@"%I"%&%'4'4%6%:I"%&
E"2+C%
"%
91"&2+%2"#@628#"$26#@2"%4#"2''$%2"#6E"2+C%
"34#:T8%2&46@'&$26##&-(H*-@%:32&#:%&@
'H-H)*H
@
'
-(-( (-!*(@'&I%'&6#&"42>#&"4@%@^@@^@%6%2H*-H(@1%:$#:#"4H@
%&%>32'4%&6:%&:+%2
!=ED91"&2+%2"#@<2+C#6%"'$2&$##:2'>3%&%"''6%&%6%'47'2E%S%""
<%"''6%&@'43"+6%'6%I%'6U'$2
@'&$26##&* H(@
-)( !( @--)!-
;@
91"&2+%2"#@&#+4%2"#@<2+C#6%'47'2#:"#6%"'.%6%"22:'6%
"'.@'43"+6%/#3+#@'&$26##&()H *@*(H-)-!!;@
93+>#5282@1"&2+%2"#@$&6#@<2+C#6%%6"#%":'#62+8%<2>U'2:#"2:62+8@'43"+6%
32"2$%:@'&$26##&*HH*-@*)()* (!;@'&I%'&6#&"42>#&@2'$&%@^@
%^@%6%2H*-H(9$63:I"42$#3@I%+#:%'#&@63&.X%&6%+8>%:$#:6%&Q>'2#&
347'#:#&@##$3+4"+#$+2S./#%62&I#&2./#6%I"4%6#'3:%"N"2#<3"46#%#"%$%1%"@>3"6"%4U!+#
%:6%IT&24#;%"4@^)@@%@$$"4((6#
T62>#%'+I+2$N8%2&4#6#&%"4--)6#
T62>#
%'+%"4*6%2(*-@$#:"%+./#'47'2#62:"E%S%""
!91"&2+%2"#@&%I"6#V362$2+:%'4%@<2+C#6%4+2'#442#+2%24T"2&4%8%&
442#+2@'43"+6%E%+#B#"2S#'4%@'&$26##&)H*(;%
E91"&2+%2"#@
&%I"6#@<2+C#6%+$26%&3II2%2+#:%'21%2"#@'43"+6%/#3+#@'&$26##&H)H -@
(-)* !@
*-H (!*-@;'&I%'&6#&"42>#&@2'$&%@^@%^@%6%2
H*-H(@$$"4((@&%'6#4:15:I+2$N8%+&'./#I"%82&46#-)$$"4H 6#
T62>#%'+$#:
"%+./#"$#&21%2"#3II2@$#:I"42$2I./#6%
%"4-(6#
T62>#%'+$#:
"%+./#+N82#3>3&4#442#+2
!GD91"&2+%2"#@$&6#@<2+C#6%'47'2#%6"#6%G3%2"#S%
W'626%8%&6%
G3%2"#S@'&$26##&(*H*(>H() (
-*)*--!( ;'&I%'&6#&"42>#&"4
@2'$&%@^@%^@%6%2H*-H(@$$"4((%@^)6#
T62>#%'+
!
B91"&2+%2"#@628#"$26#@<2+C#6%"'$2&$##'4%2"#2:%"2
B%+%'6%
"8+C#2:@'&$26##&- H -@'43"+6%"$3"3
@H-*
)H -! ;'&I%'&6#"4@2'$&%@^@%^@%6%2H*-H(
%A
D983+>#%6"/#@<2+C#6%#&532S6
"3S%6%
%$Q+2:"+6
"3S@'&$26##&
)HH@'43"+6%%$2<%@-()(;'&I%'&9"4@2'$&%@^@%^@
%6%2H*-H(@$$"4((%"4@^)6#
T62>#%'+
-(!&&#F<2K./#6I%'6#&"53&#"$#'6%'6#&@6#4'6##I"#$%62:%'4#4"2<N&2$#6#"4*(6#
T62>#%'+@"%+.'6#O3%4#6&&.X%&6#&"53&<#":I"TI"2&6%#">'2S.X%&$"2:2'#&&@+&4"%6&
%:I#6%"%$#'7:2$#6%#"2>%:6%&$#'C%$26%&3&I%24@$#:342+2S./#6%66#&%2'<#":.X%&%&I%$22&@
8+%'6#!&%6%I%&&#&+4:%'4%O3+2<2$6&@+26#&&#<2&42$./#45$'2$6%%O32I:%'4#&%
:#82:%'4./#6%8+#"%&O3%$3&:8%"66%2"I%"I+%K266%I#"&3#3&62%:#'4'4%%"$%1%!&%@
2'6@O3%$"2:2'+266%'/#$#'8%'$2#'+$#:#&.X%&I%"I%4"6&I%+#&"53&@+5:6%$3&"%+%86#
6'#<2''$%2"#@"%&3+4:2'6%:6'##$+2::#"+6&#$2%66%
-H!2K#@&&2:@$#:"%+./##"53A
B
B@1"&2+%2"#@>"3$#:I+%4#@
'H - )))
@<2+C#6%"26##$#""#$C6#+8%&%6%#&5"2+8%&6%#"2&@'43"+6%
E#2>%:
@%'4/#I"#I"2%4N"2#6%:I"%&"'&I#"4%46@$#:"%+./##$"2:%I"%82&4#'#"4((
6#
T62>#%'+@4%'6#%:82&4&3I%"&#'+266%6%&82"436%8#+46#$"2:%@1%:$#:#&3$#'634
&#$2+"%I"#8N8%+@+5:6#0'2$#:T8%+4%"&26##+3$"#2+Q$24#%:6%4"2:%'4#6#I4"2:7'2#I01+2$#@$#:
>"8%&$#'&%OZU'$2&&#$22&@%'4%'6#&%"#:%&:#:%"%$%6#"6I%':NK2:@4%'6#%&4$#:#I%'1&%@
I%+#O3%<2K#I%'%:-94"U&;'#&6%"%$+3&/#2K#I%'1&%@$#:"%+./#$63:6#&6#2&$"2:%
6%+8>%:6%62'C%2"#9"42>#@%@^@@^@%6%2H*-H(;@%:63&.X%&$#:
I"#IT&24#&62&42'4#&%%:$#'$3"&#:4%"2+;@I%+#&:%&:#&%+%:%'4#&8%"2<2$6#&@I%'6%96%S;'#&
6%"%$+3&/#@&%'6#O3%$63:6&I%'&"%$%1%#$"5&$2:#6%-96#2&4%".#&;'<#":6#^)6#"4
6:%&:%2H*-H(@I%"<S%'6#@I"$63:6#&$"2:%&6%+8>%:@I%'6%*96%S%&&%2&'#&;
%&%4%:%&%&6%"%$+3&/#@I%+#O3%<2K#%4#"'#6%<2'2428I%'4#4+6%-*94"2'4%&%2&'#&;%6#2&:%&%&
6%"%$+3&/#&%"$3:I"26#%:"%>2:%<%$C6#@'<#":6#"4--%&%>32'4%&6#
T62>#%'+%:3+46%
(93::2+%#24%'4;62&:3+4@&%'6#$662:3+4&<2K6#%:$2'$#&+N"2#&:Q'2:#&@'<#":6#&
"42>#&)H@^$$"4*@^6#
T62>#%'+
-!2K#@$#:"%+./##&"53&AD@83+>#%'5:@1"&2+%2"#@$&6#@
$#:%"$2'4%@'&$26##&*H %:#"4+%S
@
)H(-( ')))--)-!@
"%I"%&%'4'4%6%:I"%&E"2+C%
"%
@1"&2+%2"#@628#"$26#@
2"%4#"<2''$%2"#6E"2+C%
"34#:T8%2&46@'&$26##&-(H*-@%:32&#:%&@
'
H-H)*H
@
'-(-( (-!*(@I%+#$"2:%I"%82&4#'#&"42>#&"4@%@^@@^@
%6%2H*-H(@1%:$#:#"4H@%&%>32'4%&6:%&:+%2@4%'6%'6#&3&12K&$3+I12+266%&@
1#'&'4%$%6%'4%&@'66%'%>428#&%"I%"$%126#$#:"%+./#F&&3&I%"&#'+266%&@1%:$#:#6%826##
<4#6%4%"%:6%8#+826##'3:%"N"2#"%$%126#2'6%826:%'4%@I%'I+2$N8%+$#:#I%':Q'2:@I%+#O3%
<2K#%4#"'#6%<2'2428&@I"$63:6#&"53&@I%'6%-94"U&;'#&6%"%$+3&/#%:"%>2:%1%"4#%
http://www.jfce.jus.br/consultaProcessual/resimprsentintegra.asp?CodDoc=2177598
3/11/2010
Page 43 of 50
?>'%"?@?
"$?#3?b2d#?@Aa
@83+>#?#%+?@?
#O3%2"#?#3?#%+6#"#:2&&/#?@
B@83+>#?#+$#?@
@83+>#?W'2#?@
@
EE@83+>#?
C2$/#?@LEE@
83+>#?U?@@E93;@83+>#
?%+C#?@
Ea
E@83+>#?E2++2?#3?E2'C#?@
@MAE@
@D
@
B%#&68#>6#&
D%
D
Ba@83+>#?"$2U'$2?@&%'6#O3%#&6#2&0+42:#&#1428%":B
'#6_
"%>2/#I"4"'$:%'4#6#<%24#%'3'$26#@%:(6%1"2+6% @=B
D@83+>#
?E#6%?@'#"#$%&&#' (H!*
%>2&4"#@I#"O3%&4/#6%:%"%$2:%'4#@#4"1+C#6%62$6#%62343"'#6#+Q$2%6%"+'&2'8%&42>.X%&
6#I"%&%'4%$&#@6%&4$'6#!&%#&$#:I#'%'4%&63I%"2'4%'6U'$2%>2#'+6#+Q$2%6%"+'#
%"N%
62"%./#%"+6#+Q$2%6%"+@%:%&I%$2+@#&%+%>6#&6%#+Q$2%6%"+3+#26'%R@'47'2#
%+&#
6#&'4#&%"$%+#162'E+4S"@1%:$#:##&&2$#6%:#&%M2:%'%&
-#4#F&<+&)-6#()(*!
)"#$%&&#'*(H H!$#'4"#34"#&82'4%%4"U&6%'3'$26#&@O32&&%V:
EE@83+>#?%4#?@
@83+>#?E#$6%4?@@
@D@83+>#,?
"
C4?@?23Q?#3?
"
C4?@
@83+>#?
C2$/#?@?&&"2'C#?#3?3$'#?@b
@83+>#
?>'%"?@?
"$?#3?b2d#?@Aa
@83+>#?#%+?@?
#O3%2"#?#3?#%+6#"#:2&&/#?@
B@83+>#?#+$#?@
@83+>#?W'2#?@
@
EE@83+>#?
C2$/#?@LEE@
83+>#?U?@@E93;@83+>#
?%+C#?@
Ea
E@83+>#?E2++2?#3?E2'C#?@
@MAE@
@D
@
B%#&68#>6#&
D%
D
Ba@83+>#?"$2U'$2?@&%'6#O3%#&6#2&0+42:#&#1428%":B
'#6_
"%>2/#I"4"'$:%'4#6#<%24#%'3'$26#@%:(6%1"2+6% @=B
D@83+>#
?E#6%?@'#"#$%&&#' (H!*
%"E@%<<"%R@>+#1+2S./#6#$"2:%@4Q43+##"2>2'+C%:%">%"@4"63./#6%2$"6#'#V#&@
62#3"#@2#6%'%2"#@%L@#2&5&@+Q$24#!#4O3%6I2"4"2@6+8>%:6%62'C%2"#%6#
4"N<2$#F%$#'#:2>+#1+@4Q43+##"2>2'++2$249C#\:3>>+%"&@"<<2$d%"&@'6
#IR$4&"%B2V$d2'>4C%
+#1+$#'#:R@"63./#6%5">2##I%&@#">%DC"624#"@2#6%'%2"#%[[@
2$C%+@2'$I24+2&:#'>&4%"!O3%:&/##&8%"66%2"#&>%'4%&6#$"2:%#">'2S6#:3'62+@Q43+#
#"2>2'+>'>&4%"
I24+2&:@"63./#6%
6%'6"6%@62#3"#@2#6%'%2"#@ *&4%":#&$"2:%#">'2S6#%:N<2&&/#426#&43+:%'4%$#:#&2'7'2:#&@%&$+"%$%'6#[+4%"
'>'2%++#2%"#824$CO3%?"%&I%24#6#4%":#e:N<2e#3e:N<2&e@52:I#"4'4%+%:1""O3%6%4%":2'6
I%&&#I#6%3&"$#&43:%1"&2+%2"#6%$#"4%24+2'#@<%24#$#:4%$26#%+<24%1"&2+%2"#&#$&#@I%'&
#:#6%+#&%"N24+2'#&&2:@#4%":#e:N<2e"%I"%&%'4>U'%"#/#%&I5$2%&6#>U'%"#:N<2@I#"
%K%:I+#@"Q6%
C2'%&@#
#:'6#%":%+C#@
#&#&4"@%4$:#34"&I+8"&@#4%":#:N<25
$#:#I2SS#3&I>C%442@O3%I#6%&%"%'$#'4"6#%:O3+O3%"I"4%6#:3'6#@2'6O3%I"%I"6#&I#"
'/#24+2'#&#"2&&#@%KI+2$!&%62<3&/#6#4%":#e:N<2eI"6%&2>'"#">'2S.X%&$"2:2'#&&
9;?9I31+2$./#6#T"3:&#1"%#$"2:%&%:<"#'4%2"&@#$#""26#'#3I%"2#""213'+6%3&42.@'#
I%"Q#6#6%- 6%#3431"#6%HH@%8%'4#"%+2S6#I%+'28%"&266%
266%6%/#3+#!'2$26@
3I%"2#""213'+6%3&42.%
%'4"#6%&436#&362$2N"2#&6#
#'&%+C#63&42.%6%"+@%62./#6#
3I%"2#""213'+6%3&42.@
#'&%+C#63&42.%6%"+@
%'4"#6%&436#&362$2N"2#&@E"&Q+2@HH@
I--
%"@+84#"%@2'B2&4T"26N<2!6&#"2>%'&#&'#&&#&62&@Q43+##"2>2'+4#"26%++:N<2
++%#"2>2'22>2#2"'2'#&4"2@"63./#6%+8"##"%'$2'2@624#"'%&I@/#3+#@]@
@2#8''2@2'
#&#&4"!#V32S%#&eB#:%'&6%B#'"e@4Q43+##"2>2'+
#&#&4!UV3>%%4+U&
eC#::%&6eC#''%3"e@4"63./#6%"2+%K'6"%@624#"E%"4"'6E"&2+@2#6%'%2"#@HH-]
@+%K'6%"@2'K$%++%'4
68%"&!C%:N<2'64C%6%4C#<<2"&424+2'"%I31+2$@2"&42'4>%
E##d&%6242#'@%\f#"d@HH*]E@%+\R'2'28%:2+2%&!4C%"2&%@6%$+2%''6"%&3">%'&%#&
:%"2$'e&:#&4I#\%"<3+:N<2%:I2"%&@C#:&3''%E##d&@%\f#"d@*
(%$#"6%!&%O3%CN:2&6%#'S%'#&@'#T"3:&#1"%#$"2:%&%:<"#'4%2"&@#$#""26#'#3I%"2#"
"213'+6%3&42.@'#I%"Q#6#6%- 6%#3431"#6%HH@%8%'4#"%+2S6#I%+'28%"&266%
266%6%
/#3+#!'2$26@3I%"2#""213'+6%3&42.%
%'4"#6%&436#&362$2N"2#&6#
#'&%+C#63&42.
%6%"+@&#1$##"6%'./#>%"+6%[+4%"'>'2%++#2%"#824$C@&%<+862:I#"4W'$26
$#'&$2%'42S./#&#$2+"%&I%24#6#$"2:%#">'2S6#
H@:2&@342+2S:!&%6%4%"$%2"#&9$#'C%$26#&$#:#?+"'V&?;I"O3%43%:62"%4:%'4%'428266%
6%+2428@&&3:2'6#%&4%&"%&I#'&12+266%I%"'4%3&42.&%+>#<#"6%&$#1%"4#2'6@#$"2:2'#&#6%
O3%#"4"4:#&5I%&&#O3%I#&&32"S#N8%+2'&4"3./#@>%"+:%'4%$#:'Q8%+&3I%"2#"@4%:%:I"%>6#&
%&I%$2+2S6#&'&N"%&6%2'<#":N42$@$#'412+266%@%'>%'C"2@%+%4"7'2$%#34"&'%$%&&N"2&#1#:
6%&%:I%'C#6%&3428266%@$#:#2'6I#&&32>"'6%I#6%"6%I%'%4"./#%2'<+3U'$2'&#$2%66%@+5:
6%'#":+:%'4%$#'4"$#:1'$6%68#>6#&%K$+3&28#&%6%62$6#&'4%%8%'432&?2'$7:#6#&?I#"
I"4%6#&T">/#&%>%'4%&%&442&"%&I#'&N8%2&I%+"%I"%&&/#F$"2:2'+266%
%&4%&I%$4#8%"!
@:%&[2++2:+24%6#$"2:%I"%'4%'6%"#$"2:%6%$#+"2'C#1"'$#
Q43+##"2>2'+,C%
"2:2'++24%@4"63./#6%%'2&%+%&@624#"'#+%_%62./#/#3+#
%D@%'@&%'C#"%&6#
"2:%!&'#8&:N<2&$#'4"6%:#$"$2@4Q43+##"2>2'+U&
%2>'%3"&63
"2:%@"63./#6%
+T82&"O3%&@624#"%$#"6@2#6%'%2"#/#3+#@-
#"8%S%&<"%OZ%'4:@$#:6%&%'8#+43"%I#"8%S%&@#&:%2#&&#$22&@I#+Q42$#%%:I"%&"2+@
%"f@N"2#'2%+@2'N<2%
"2:%">'2S6#!&I%$4#&+%>2&34#"2%624
%&I#'&12+266%%'+6&%&4"343"&#">'2S6&6%I#6%"428266%&
"2:2'#&&0:%'0"2&%624#"@2#
6%'%2"#@ -#6%!&%$#'&26%""%+%:%'4#'#":428#&%"$#:I+%:%'46#I%+6#34"2'%V3"2&I"36U'$2%:$6
$&#@8%SO3%@'8%"66%@'/#&%I#6%6%&%V"3:6%<2'2./#+%>+O3%1"'V4#6&&:#6+266%&6%
#">'2S.X%&$"2:2'#&&@'4%'/#%K2&4U'$2"Q>266%&%3&:#6%+#&@I#6%'6#!&%<+"@#2'85&6%
?6%<2'2./#?@%:?$"$4%"2S./#?%O3+O3%"<#":@
#'8%'./#6%+%":#$#'4"%+2'OZU'$2
">'2S6"'&'$2#'+9%&#+3./#6&&%:1+52%"+@'%K#@%$"%4#'@6%6%
:".#);@6%<2'23$#:##">'2S./#$"2:2'#&#>"3I#%&4"343"6#6%4"U&#3:2&I%&&#&O3%%K2&4
63"'4%$%"4#4%:I#%O3%43%$#:#I"#IT&24#6%$#:%4%"3:#3:2&6%+24#&>"8%&9$#'&26%"6#&%&4%&
$#:#O3%+%&I%'6#&$#:I"28./#6%+21%"66%6%I%+#:%'#&O34"#'#&;#36%+24#&42I2<2$6#&$#:
1&%%:4+
#'8%'./#$#:##1V%428#6%#14%"@62"%4#32'62"%4:%'4%@3:1%'%<Q$2#%$#'7:2$#6%#"6%:
:4%"2+
)+%O3Q8#$#<#2I"$2+:%'4%&'6#$#:%62./#6%2 @O3%62<%"%'$2#3O36"2+C#3
1'6#6%#">'2S.X%&$"2:2'#&&@#%KI"%&&"%:&%3"42>#O3%,?"4&4+%26%<2'%%"%>3+:%2#&
6%I"#8%I"#$%62:%'4#&2'8%&42>4T"2#&O3%8%"&%:&#1"%2+Q$24#&6%$#""%'4%&6%.X%&I"42$6&I#"
http://www.jfce.jus.br/consultaProcessual/resimprsentintegra.asp?CodDoc=2177598
3/11/2010
Page 44 of 50
O36"2+C#31'6##3#">'2S.X%&#3&&#$2.X%&$"2:2'#&&6%O3+O3%"42I#?'4"%4'4#@'/#&%4%:
3:6%<2'2./#I"%$2&
42+2S"%:#&:1&%KI"%&&X%&2'62&42'4:%'4%
*
@%'4+:%266@2'#$2%66%
#:I+%K%#
"2:%">'2S6#!$#'4%:I#"'%266%%#
2&$#'&">'2S.X%&
"2:2'#&&@0:%'0"2&624#"@2#6%'%2"#!@)@I)%&%>4&
O32426@'&I+8"&6%C2+2I%+S2'2$d9'#"42>#3'6:%'4#&64%#"26%#">'2S./#2'
">'2S.X%&
#:I+%K&,3:%&436#6&#">'2S.X%&%:<$%6#&I"#1+%:&&#$22&/#3+#,4+&@
H (@I-!$246#I#"%'4+:%266
#&4@#1$24I) ;$#:##""'V#%#14%'./#6%I%&&#+I"
<$2+24""%+2S./#6%+>3:#1V%428#6%$#:3:$#"6#@I#":%2#662&4"2132./#6%<3'.X%&%
"%&I#'&12+266%&
(1$24I*
H
246#I#"0+@2$$2#'"2#6%%"%$C#%'+R
"2:2'#+#>Q@E3%'#&2"%&,&4"%@%>3'6
%62./#@H(-@I*]1"IN> -
%"@#1%"4#@2'
#""3I./#%2"%24#%'+!3:62>'T&42$#6$#""3I./#'#E"&2+@624#"
G3"42%"42'@/#3+#@*%
b@E"3'#[2+C%+:%#34"#&@2'&
3&4#&6
#""3I./#@624#"
b#'"66%'3%"42<<3'>@/#3+#@
E#+%42:E
"2:'@K4"@I1"@IN> ">'2S%6$"2:%2&$#'42'32'>$"2:2'+$#'&I2"'$R@C82'>'#">'2S%6&4"3$43"%6@<%61R<%"'6
$#""3I$2#''6:#4286%61R>"%%6@$246#I#"
@C2%""R@2'N<2&63:#'6%,#">'2&42#'&$"2:2'%++%&
4"'&'42#'+%&$43+245%4I%"&I%$428%&"2&,'28%"&342"%&6%"'$%@@I@$246#I#"%'4
+:%266
#&4@#1$24I()
-
#'<#":%@3"$2@2'&46#%#
"2:%">'2S6#/#R3+#,E
@HH(@I)@
$246#I#"%'4+:%266
#&4@#1$24I(
)%"@"$%+#E4+#3'2@2'
"2:%">'2S6#!&I%$4#&>%"2&%:%$'2&:#&+%>2&@
4+&@_%62./#@/#3+#@ @I"2'$2I+:%'4%@I %D@&1%+N'$C%S"$Q6%@2'
"2:2'+266">'2S6!&I%$4#&I%'+%&@I"#$%&+%&@6:2'2&4"428#&RI#+2$2+%&@624#"Rd2'&#'%
2'2&45"2#%+'4%"2#"@6"2@&I'C@@I"2'$2I+:%'4%I()@
DD@&8+6#@2'%>"%4#
1'$N"2#@$"2:2'+24N#">'2SS4@"2$2$+>>2#@%8&2#'%<2&$+%2'4N+2@
&64"2$%#44'4#'2#2+'2@
%62./#@6#84N+2@ @I"2'$2I+:%'4%I (]
@"232&9#">;@2'
"2:2'+24%">'2&%%!
6U&"%I"5&%'442#'&&#$2+%&3K65<2'242#'&V3"262O3%&@%#">%624%3&@%'%8%!32.@@)@I"2'$2I+:%'4%@
I--
$6%:2$2#'+6%#+Q$2@&%>3'6#6"2'#+28%2"@6#34#"'6#'9II%"62&I#'212+2S6#'
2'4%"'%4@'%82&4&I.#$6U:2$#'-)@:".#)@'#&24%\\\%&I.#$6%:2$#$#:1"@I%&O32&6#
%:6%:".#6%*;@%'3:%"$"$4%"Q&42$&6#$"2:%#">'2S6#,;I+'%V:%'4#%:I"%&"2+];
'42V3"262$266%]-;628%"&2<2$./#6%N"%6%43./#]);%&412+266%6#&&%3&2'4%>"'4%&];$6%26%
$#:'6#]*;I+3"+266%6%>%'4%&] ;$#:I"42:%'4./#](;$T62>#&6%C#'"]H;$#'4"#+%4%""24#"2+];
<2'&+3$"428#&2'>"62'9$246#I#"6"2'#+28%2"2'@3"$R&46#%#$"2:%#">'2S6#
HH*%&%9#34#"6#;$3+66%6%2+#&#<2%
2U'$2&B3:'&6'28%"&266%6%/#3+#/#3+#@
HH*;@I#"&38%S@I#'4O32'S%$"$4%"Q&42$&6#$"2:%#">'2S6#/#%+&,;I"N42$&6%428266%&
2+Q$24&];428266%$+'6%&42']-;C2%""O32#">'2S$2#'+]);I"%82&/#6%+3$"#&];6282&/#6#4"1+C#]
*;3&#682#+U'$2] ;&2:12#&%$#:#&46#](;:%"$6#"2&2+Q$24&]H;I+'%V:%'4#%:I"%&"2+];3&#
62'42:26./#];8%'66%&%"82.#&2+Q$24#&];"%+.X%&$+2%'4%+2&4&]-;I"%&%'.6+%26#&2+U'$2#]);
:#'#IT+2#682#+U'$2];$#'4"#+%4%""24#"2+
*#6%:>2"@I#"%K%:I+#@%&I%$2<2$:%'4%$#'4"
2K$#'7:2$%6%"+6%3:6%4%":2'6$266%@
<3"4'6##&6%IT&24#&6#&$#""%'42&4&@I#"I%"$%1%"%:@$2"$3'&4'$2+:%'4%@+>3:<+C%&I%$Q<2$'
&%>3"'.
#:#@I#"%K%:I+#@#&4O3%&6#
I#+2$22&:2+24"%&%$282&I%+#<4#6%I%"4%'$%"%:F&<#".&
I#+2$22&
(1&%"8%!&%O3%:2#"I"4%6&#">'2S.X%&$"2:2'#&&%&4N%'8#+826%::324&428266%&2+Q$24&
62<%"%'4%&@$#'4'6#$#:$#'&4'4%:I+2./##3+4%"'W'$2@&%:I"%&%>32'6##:%&:#"$2#$Q'2#1N&2$#,
6%&6%O3%CV62'C%2"#%:V#>#@+N%&4"/#&&2:@3:#">'2S./#$"2:2'#&O3%&%6%62O3%2'2$2+:%'4%
&%OZ%&4"#I#6%:2>""I"4"N<2$#6%6"#>&@%6QI""#31#6%$">&@4"N<2$#6%&%"%&C3:'#&#3<3"4#
1'$#@$#'<#":%$#'8%'2U'$26%:#:%'4#
H%"$%1!&%O3%'/#&%I#6%$2"'#:%&:#%O3Q8#$#6#&V3QS%&24+2'#&6#&'#& %(O3%@#4#:"
$#'44#$#::N<2@%'4%'6%":O3%%&4%"$#'&4243Q66%3::3+42I+2$266%6%#">'2S.X%&&%:$"N4%"
6%I%":'U'$2@4%'6#<2":6#O3%6%I#2&6%3:6%+24##3./#:<2#&@#&1'626#&628262:#1#42:I"
+#>#62&&#+8%"%:!&%%6%:#'&4""6%&$#'C%$2:%'4#%'4"%&29%"
BD@'>5+2$#:%"#@2'
I"#K2:$2#'%&+I"#1+%:N42$6%+$"2:2'+266#">'26R%+6%+24#6%&#$2$2T'2+Q$24@62$2#'%&3%8
3"Q62$@E#>#4N
#+7:12@*@I*);+I%"$%I./#5V3&4:%'4%6%&%V6I%+#&:%:1"#&6&
#">'2S.X%&$"2:2'#&&I"@$#:2&&#@6%&$"$4%"2S"%:&3&.X%&
-%"@
"+#&@
!2":'66%6#$"2:%@624#"%$#"6@2#6%'%2"#/#3+#@ _%62./#@
*]
B@N"$2#@#"6%'4"#6#
"2:%!$#""3I./#@4"N<2$#@
@624#"&$"243"&@/#3+#@
]D@%"$28+@2'62$4#6#
"2:%
%#34"#&>"3I#&@62#3"#@2#6%'%2"#@*
-?%&4434#?@'Q'4%>"@<#2I31+2$6#'#626%:2#6%HH @'#V#"'+2N"2##I3+"@$#'<#":%
#&:"#S2'#@2'
#1"&%>"4#&826Q'42:%I%"8%"&'&I"2&X%&1"&2+%2"&G3%::'6%O3%:
#1%6%$%'#I"426#6#$"2:%624#"1V%428@2#6%'%2"#@)@I-*@&%'6#?%+66%@"%&I%24#%
&#+26"2%66%$2:6%436##"426#]34I%++21%"66%@V3&42.%IS]-3'2/#$#'4"&2'V3&42.&%
#I"%&&/#6%'4"#6I"2&/#])$#'4"2132./#6O3%+%&O3%%&4/#%:+21%"66%$#:#&2":/#&6%'4"#6I"2&/#@
I#":%2#6%68#>6#&@62'C%2"#@V36#&<:2+2"%&%./#6%"%&>4%]"%&I%24#%&#+26"2%66%
4#6#&#&:%:1"#&6#"426#@I"O3%'/#CV$#'<+24#&2'4%"'#&!I#"O3%O3%+%O3%$3&"$#'<+24#2'4%"'#
6%'4"#6#"426#@4%'4'6#628262"2":'66%@&%"N%K$+3Q6#%"%I3626#I%+#"426#]*:2&3&"#
"426#I""%&#+8%"$#'<+24#&I%&&#2&$#'4"I%&&#&6%<#"#"O3%#26%+6#"426#%&4N$2:6#&
$#'<+24#&I%&&#2&&#"426#%&4"N&%:I"%+%+%&#+26N"2#4#6#&#&&%3&2'4%>"'4%&I"O3%'/#
8%'C:&#<"%"'%'C3:6%&2>3+66%#32'V3&42.%:$#'<+24#&%K4%"'#&] O3%+%O3%%&428%"%:+21%"66%
e1%:%&4"343"6#e@:&%&O3%$%"6%$#'4"2132"$#:#&2":/#&O3%%&4/#'$6%2@&%"N$#'6%'6#F:#"4%@
&%:I%"6/#](&2'4%>"'4%&6#"426#4%:6%6"1#:%K%:I+#@&%"%:&%>326#&@I#"2&&##"426#
'/#6:24%O3%CV,&&+4#@%&43I"#%%K4#"&/#6%'4"#6#&2&4%:]H"426#'/#6:24%:%'42"&@
4"2./#@2'8%V@$#12.@$+0'2@%>#Q&:#%2'4%"%&&%I%&&#+@:&&2:8%"66%@<26%+266%@C#:1"266%@
&#+26"2%66%%#2'4%"%&&%$#:3:6%4#6#&@I#"O3%&#:#&3:I#"4#6#&%4#6#&I#"3:]#6##2'4%>"'4%
4%"N6%"%&I%24"#"6%:@62&$2I+2'6#"426#
63:82"%$%1%"6%$#"6#$#:O32+#O3%<%SI#"
:%"%$%"#I2'2/#6%4#6#&&%"N#3826%"%&I%246@:&6%$2&/#<2'+&%"N6#&<3'66#"%&6#"426#]
"2:%2"#
#:'6#6
I24+!
<3'66#'#'#6%HH-@'3:+346%&$#:3'+@2'$'&N8%+$#'4"
#I"%&&/#%&2'V3&42.&6#
:I#6%
#'$%'4"./#@e'%K#eN$&6%
3&4T62%"4:%'4#6%3145@
4%:$#:#+%:1&#+34#e21%"66%@3&42.%Se]"426#'/#6:24%"28+266%2'4%"'@62&I34
6%I#6%"'26%"'.6#
#:'6#@I#2&$62'4%>"'4%6#
#:'6#&1%"N<3'./#O3%+C%$#:I%4%6%
e$#"6#e$#:&3$I$266%6%%K%"$%!+]-%:#&6%I%":'%$%"3'26#&%#">'2S6#&I"%824":#&O3%
#$#""'#8:%'4%3::&&$"%&%:%+C'4%#3I2#"##$#""26#'
&6%%4%'./#%:6%#3431"#6%
HH@#'6%I"%&#&<#":$#8"6%:%'4%&&&&2'6#&@:&&$"%%&4%O3%V:2&&%"N%&O3%$26#'
http://www.jfce.jus.br/consultaProcessual/resimprsentintegra.asp?CodDoc=2177598
3/11/2010
Page 45 of 50
$#'&$2U'$26&#$2%66%1"&2+%2"#"O3%'T&6#
#:'6#8:#&&$362"#&2&4%:%<S%"%&&&
34#"266%&:36"%:I#+Q42$$"$%"N"2@6%&3:'@$C%26%2'V3&42.@#I"%&&/#@4#"43"%:&&$"%&'&
I"2&X%&])I"2#"266%6#
#:'6#'#:#:%'4#5I"%&&2#'"#>#8%"'6#"6#&46#6%&428"O3%+%
:I#6%
#'$%'4"./#@e'%K#eF
&6%
3&4T62%"4:%'4#6%3145@6%#'6%&3">23&%:%'4%%
&"QS%&6#
#:'6#'#:%2#6%4'4&+34&2'>+T"2&%4'4#&&#<"2:%'4#&4"#S%&]"42'6#6#
#:'6#$%'4"+6
I24+6#G6#&46#@&62"%4"2S%&6%.X%&#">'2S6&%&2:3+4W'%&%:4#6#&#&
%&41%+%$2:%'4#&I%'2&6#&46#@'3:>3%""&%:4"5>3@&%:<"#'4%2"&@45824T"2<2'+*
2:I#"4'4%5O3%'2'>35:'#&6%4%"N'%&4+34I#"O3%&%:%'4%6#
#:'6#&%%&I+C#3I#"4#6#&#&
2&4%:&I%'24%'$2N"2#&6#&46#%$#'&%>32:#&'#&%&4"343""4:15:6#+6#6%<#"$#::324#&
&$"2<Q$2#&%:324&I%"6&2""%I"N8%2&@:&'#&$#'&#+26:#&'Q8%+%&463+%:562#%+#'>#I"S#'#&
$#'&#+26"%:#&'Q8%+'$2#'+:$#+2>./#$#:#
#:'6#%":%+C#!
%
2"%:#&"%8#+3$2#'"#
IQ&6%'4"#6&I"2&X%&%#'#&&#1".#":6#&%"N#%""#"e6#&#6%"#&#&e@#I"%&&#"%&%42"'#&O3%3&:
#'%K#6%3145%#E'>36#2#6%'%2"#$#:#2'&4"3:%'4#6%82'>'.6&#$2%66%'<1"2$./#
6%:#'&4"#&
#'C%$%:#&'#&&<#".%<#".6#&'#&&#&2'2:2>#&#6%"#&#&@:&%&4:#&I"%I"6#&@
3'26#&%3:I#8#3'26#V:2&&%"N8%'$26#21%"66%@3&42.%SkkkG3"4%+>%'%"+6#
@"2:%2"#
#:'6#6$I24+@%:$#+2>./#$#:#
#:'6#%":%+C#!
'26#&%'$%"%:#&?
-%"D@#&:"@
#1"&%+>"4#&!826Q'42:%I%"8%"&'&I"2&X%&1"&2+%2"&]O3%:'6%
O3%:#1%6%$%'#I"426#6#$"2:%624#"1V%428@2#6%'%2"#@)
--
#'<#":%@#1%"4#@2'
"2:%">'2S6#%2&4%:"2&2#'+@624#"4+&@/#3+#@ @
I -
-)%$#"6%!&%<"&%6%"42'34C%"b2'>,O3%+%O3%$%24I&&28:%'4%#:+%&4N4/#%'8#+826#'%+%
O3'4#O3%:V36I%"I%4"N!+#
-+
#'8%'./#<#2"42<2$6I%+#E"&2+I%+#%$"%4#@6%-)]#"#4#$#+#62$2#'+F
#'8%'./#6&.X%&'26&$#'4"#
"2:%">'2S6#"'&'$2#'+@"%+428##
#:14%#"N<2$#6%
2>"'4%&I#"2%""%&4"%@"Q42:%5"%%$"%4#*@6%-)]#"#4#$#+#62$2#'+F
#'8%'./#
6&.X%&'26&$#'4"#
"2:%">'2S6#"'&'$2#'+%+428#F"%8%'./#@%I"%&&/#%3'2./#6#
"N<2$#6%%&&#&@%:&I%$2+3+C%"%&%
"2'.&%$"%4# @6%-)
-*2&IX%:&#1"%$"4"#>4T"2%C#:#+#>./#6%&%'4%'.%&4"'>%2"#&&%>32'4%&62&I#&2428#&+%>2&,
#'&42432./#6%I01+2$%6%"4286#E"&2+!"42>#&-@@2'$2&#@+Q'%C@H@2'$2&#M@%@^]
%>2:%'4#'4%"'#6#!"42>#&@*@ @2'$2&#&@(@I"N>"<#0'2$#@H@I"N>"<#0'2$#@
@^^%@@^^#-@@-@)@@*@ @I"N>"<#0'2$#@(@I"N>"<#0'2$#@%
H]%26%'4"#63./##
T62>#
282+E"&2+%2"#!%$"%4#!%2)* @6%)H)!"42>#&@^^%@
-@)@@+Q'%&%@I"N>"<#0'2$#@+*% ]
T62>#6%"#$%&&#
282+!%2(*H@6% -!"42>#&
@2'$2&#&%@@2'$2&#&@-@*@ @@@@2'$2&#&@^^%@-@@
@@)(-@)()%()@2'$2&#]
T62>#6%"#$%&&#%'+!%$"%4#!%2-*(H@6%-)!"42>#& (@
(@ (@ (-@ ()@^^#)@ (@ (*@ ( @ ((@2'$2&#&@ (H@^^# @% H]%2&#1"%
.X%&6%+2:%'4#&!%2) (@6% *(!"42>#&@^^#)@%*@I"N>"<#0'2$#]&4434#6
"2'.%6#6#+%&$%'4%!%2(*H@6%- H!"42>#&H(@2'$2&#&@)@^^%@)(@2'$2&#&
@I"N>"<#0'2$#@+Q'%&C@%H]%>3+:%'4#I"<Q$2#6%"634#"01+2$#%'45"I"%4%
#:%"$2+!%$"%4#-*H@6%)-@+4%"6#I%+#%$"%4#*@6%)!"42>#(]#"4"2*@
6%)(H@6#%I"4:%'4#
#'&3+"%3"Q62$#6#2'2&45"2#6&%+.X%&K4%"2#"%&%6%'4/#%$"%4"2
$2#'+6#&2"%24#&6
266'2%3&42.@43+%$"%4"2$2#'+6%3&42.@6#2'2&45"2#63&42.@
I31+2$6'#2N"2#<2$2+6'2/#6%*6%>#&4#6%HH
- %626#6%&&2&4U'$23"Q62$5"%>26#I%+#&4"46#&O3%82'$3+:#&46#1"&2+%2"#@#3@'<+4
6%+%&@:%62'4%>"'426%"%$2I"#$266%&IQ&%&$#:#&O32&#E"&2+4%:$#"6#&6%$##I%"./#
V3"Q62$O3%2'$+32&&2&4U'$2V3"Q62$%::45"2I%'+&/#
#+7:12@#&&46#&'26#&@"'.@4N+2@
#%"3@#"43>+%#&:%:1"#&6#%"$#&3+
-(%>3'6#f@%4%"@2'8>%:6%2'C%2"#!'%>T$2#&2+Q$24#&4"'&<#":6#&%:428266%&+%>2&@
4Q43+##"2>2'+2"4R6%+2'>@4"63./#6%63"6#&&%""%@624#"343"@/#3+#@@%KI"%&&/#
?+8>%:6%62'C%2"#?I"%$%4%"&3">26#'#&&46#&'26#&@'65$66%@O3'6#&O36"2+C&6O3%+
5I#$342+2S8:%:I"%&&6%+8>%:6%"#3I&%$""#&I"6%&82'$3+"#&"%$3"&#&I"#8%'2%'4%&6%&3&
428266%&$"2:2'#&&1$2I*
-H%"
@24+2'#@2'
"2:%6%1"'O3%:%'4#,"%>2:%6%I"%8%'./#%6%"%I"%&&/#@624#"
+:%62'@2&1##"43>+@)@I"2'$2I+:%'4%I)
)428266%&2+Q$24&8"26&$#:#4"N<2$#6%6"#>&@8%'66%":&@I"#&42432./#@4%""#"2&:#@$#""3I./#@
<"36%&@<+&2<2$.X%&@$C'4>%:%%K4#"&/#@$#'4"1'6#@<"36%&+<'6%>N"2&@4"N<2$#6%&%"%&C3:'#&%@
5$+"#@<3"4#"#31#6%62'C%2"#%:>"'6%%&$+
):%&:<#":O3%#$"2:%#">'2S6#@+8>%:6%62'C%2"#5:2>"4T"2@$#&43:'6#&%"%K%"$26
#'6%C#38%":%'#""%&2&4U'$2%342+2S'6##&'%>T$2#&:2&<N$%2&%8'4V#&#&6#:#:%'4#@$#:#
$&&2'#&@12'>#&@$&6%$W:12#@+#V&6%8"%V#@I#&4#&6%>&#+2'@V#+C%"2&%+#V&6%'42>3266%@
"%&43"'4%&@C#452&@1"%&@$&&'#43"'&@+8'6%"2&9#1N&2$#'3'$&26%:#6;@+#$6#"&6%8Q6%#@
I"O3%&6%628%"&X%&%:%&:#%&4$2#':%'4#&6%8%Q$3+#&@#3&%V@&%:I"%428266%&$#:2'4%'&#<+3K#6%
$2K
)f@%4%"@2'8>%:6%2'C%2"#!'%>T$2#&2+Q$24#&4"'&<#":6#&%:428266%&+%>2&@4Q43+##"2>2'+
2"4R6%+2'>@4"63./#6%63"6#&&%""%@624#"343"@/#3+#@@I )-
#'<#":%%4%"2++%R@2'#1$24I*-
))KI"%&&/#342+2S6I#"%4"2++%R@2'#1$24I*)
)%4%"2++%R@2'#1$24I**
)*@#&53+#E+4S"%@5">2#%"''6#9">;@2'8>%:6%2'C%2"#!$#:%'4N"2#&F+%2
I%+#&V3QS%&6&8"&%&I%$2+2S6&%:C#:%'>%:#2'2&4"#2+&#'2II@28""26#68#>6#@#"4#
+%>"%@ @I %(
) %4%"2++%R@2'#1$24I(((H
)(%<%"%'66I%+#E"&2+I%+#%$"%4#)@6%**H@I"#86I%+#%$"%4#%>2&+428#*@6%
)*HH
)H
"4!
2"$3+"(*@6%)@6#E'$#
%'4"+@O3%2'62$O3"%'4%4"U&C2IT4%&%&42&$#:#,
?:#82:%'4./#6%8+#"%&&3I%"2#"%&#+2:24%%&41%+%$26#'#"42>#)@2'$2&#@6
2"$3+"'(H(lY
@j@#36%O3'42&2'<%"2#"%&O3%@I#"&3C1243+266%%<#":@$#'<2>3"%:"42<Q$2#I"13"+6#
"%<%"26#+2:24%]?92'$2&#@??@%:8%"66%#O3%6%&I%"44%'./#5&%>3'6C2IT4%&%;]?&O3%&
6%&$#1%"4#$#:$#1%"43"'#:%&:#62]?92'$2&#@?1?;]?3:%'4#&&31&4'$22&'#8#+3:%6%6%IT&24#&6%
O3+O3%"I%&&#<Q&2$#3V3"Q62$@&%:$3&I"%'4%@%:%&I%$2+&%42&6%IT&24#&&/#I#&4%"2#":%'4%
4"'&<%"26#&@6%'4"#6%$3"4#I%"Q#6#6%4%:I#@6%&42'#'4%"2#":%'4%'/#"%+$2#'6#$#:#
$+2%'4%]?92'$2&#@?6?;]?4"#$6%>"'6%&O3'4266%&6%'#4&6%I%O3%'#8+#"I#"'#4&6%>"'6%
8+#"]?92'$2&#@?<?;]?6%IT&24#&6%>"'6%&O3'42&:%62'4%342+2S./#6%:%2#&%+%4"7'2$#&#3#34"#&
O3%%824%:$#'44#62"%4#$#:#I%&&#+6#1'$#]?92'$2&#@?2?;]?:#82:%'4./#6%"%$3"&#&2'$#:I4Q8%+
$#:#I4"2:7'2#@428266%%$#'7:2$#3#$3I./#I"#<2&&2#'+%$I$266%<2''$%2"I"%&3:266#
$+2%'4%]?92'$2&#@??;]?"%$%12:%'4#6%6%IT&24#&%:$C%O3%&%#3%:%&I5$2%@6%8N"2&+#$+266%&@$#:
4"'&<%"U'$2I"4%"$%2"#&]?92'$2&#@?O?;]?I>:%'4#&'4%$2I6#&6%2:I#"4./#%%KI#"4./#I#"
%:I"%&&%:4"62./##3$3V8+2./#<2''$%2"&%V2'$#:I4Q8%+$#:#:#'4'4%'%>#$26#]?9"42>#@
http://www.jfce.jus.br/consultaProcessual/resimprsentintegra.asp?CodDoc=2177598
3/11/2010
Page 46 of 50
?6?;
#'&#'4%I"%&$"%8%#^6#"46%2H*-H(@I"<2'&6%I"#$%&&:%'4#6./#I%'+1&4:
2'6Q$2#&6I"N42$6#$"2:%'4%$%6%'4%@82>2'6##&I"2'$QI2#&62'6%I%'6U'$26&2'&4"3.X%&9"4@;%
6$%&&#"2%66%:4%"2++2:246%:<$%6#$"2:%'4%$%6%'4%@O3+"%&4"2'>%#I+2$6#"6+%2F
'%$%&&266%6#$#'C%$2:%'4#6&3%K2&4U'$2@:&62&I%'&#$#'C%$2:%'4#6&334#"2%#6
$3+I12+266%6#>%'4%9"4@^@&%>3'6I"4%;%"1%+%"''6%&#:%&@2'@#&53+#
E+4S"%@5">2#%"''6#9">;@2'8>%:6%2'C%2"#!$#:%'4N"2#&F+%2I%+#&V3QS%&6&8"&
%&I%$2+2S6&%:C#:%'>%:#2'2&4"#2+&#'2II@28""26#68#>6#@#"4#+%>"%@ @I H
@#&53+#E+4S"%@5">2#%"''6#9">;@2'8>%:6%2'C%2"#!$#:%'4N"2#&F+%2
I%+#&V3QS%&6&8"&%&I%$2+2S6&%:C#:%'>%:#2'2&4"#2+&#'2II@28""26#68#>6#@#"4#
+%>"%@ @I-*
A%&&4:15:#I2'2/#6%%"&#'#62'C#
#&4@#1$24I)(
-@#&53+#E+4S"%@5">2#%"''6#9">;@2'8>%:6%2'C%2"#!$#:%'4N"2#&F+%2
I%+#&V3QS%&6&8"&%&I%$2+2S6&%:C#:%'>%:#2'2&4"#2+&#'2II@28""26#68#>6#@#"4#
+%>"%@ @I-H%&%>32'4%&
)2S5">2##"#$#:"%+./#F$#'&$2U'$26#$"2:%'4%$%6%'4%O3%?
#:#+%21"&2+%2"'/#%K2>%
%KI+2$24:%'4%4+$#'C%$2:%'4#%&I%$Q<2$#@%$#:#CN4%'6U'$26%6282&/#6%4"%<&%'4"%#>%'4%6#
$"2:%'4%$%6%'4%%#>%'4%6#$"2:%6%+8>%:@:%+C#"2'4%"I"%4./#6#"46%2H*-HH(5
O3%+'#:%&:#&%'426#6#$246#62&I#&2428#6+%>2&+./#'#"4%!:%"2$'@#3&%V@#6#+#@I%+#:%'#&
62"%4#@6%8%1"'>%"#$#'C%$2:%'4#6%O3%#&1%'&%62"%24#&#38+#"%&%'8#+826#&&/#I"#8%'2%'4%&6%
428266%&$"2:2'#&@:&'/#'%$%&&"2:%'4%#$#'C%$2:%'4#%&I%$Q<2$#6%O3+428266%$"2:2'#&#36%
&%3&%+%:%'4#&%$2"$3'&4W'$2&?#1$24IH*
&'#4&6%"#6I52'&%"26&'#4%K4#"%I"#63S26#$#'&4:6#4%K4##"2>2'+
*%<%"%!&%D@'"2O3%0+%@#&5B%'"2O3%@2''3+6%2"%24#%'+E"&2+%2"#,
"4%%"+@/#3+#,@HH @I
D%@6%:@I
(%<%"%!&%E@'47'2#5">2#6%#"%&8>%:6%62'C%2"#,42I2$266%6#$"2:%
'4%$%6%'4%/#3+#]@-@I-*!- ]E@"$#'47'2#6%8>%:6%$I242&%#1"2>.X%&
$282&$#""%+4&@/#3+#]@)@@I]@#6#+<#2>"%#I$24@I( !((]
@3+]
@[2++2:%""6%]@32S+N82#%26%8>%:6%
I242&/#3+#]@HH(@I- ]
H#46%5">2##"#@'##"2>2'+,4Q43+#%K%:I+2<2$428#@&+%2&6&I'C9"4-))@12&@?C?@6#
;@6
">%'42'9"4 (6#
;@6"'.9"4-)!6#
;@6
#+7:129"4) !6#
;@6#"3>329"4*
6#%$"%4#!%R)H)H )@$#:"%6./#6%R *HH(;%6#">329"4H*6#
;'/#&%
"%<%"%:%&I%$2<2$:%'4%#6#+#%8%'43+@#O3%'/#&2>'2<2$O3%&'#":&I%'2&>%"2&'/#6:24:%&4
<#":6%+243#&#&4%K4#&+%>2&+428#&$246#&@I%'&&+%2&6&I'C@">%'42'%6#">3242I2<2$:
<#":$3+I#&6#6%+24#6%+8>%:@#O3%@6%4#6#:#6#@'/#'%$%&&"2:%'4%2:I%6%$#'&4"3./#
2'4%"I"%4428'#&%'426#66:2&&/#6#6#+#%8%'43+I%'&"%6./#6+%2%&I'C#+@I%+<#":6%
42I2<2$./#6#$"2:%6#+#&#@I"%$%%K$+32"I#&&212+266%6#6#+#%8%'43+9+O3%$#'82%"42%&%#4"'&<2"2%&%
12%'%&?&12%'6&?6%O3%+#&:2&:#&I"#$%6%'6%+>3'#6%+#&6%+24#&%KI"%&6#&%'+#&"42$3+#&
'4%"2#"%&"2<#3!&%;
*'24%644%&@8%\%++@-6*H @ 9H4C
2"H *;
*?+2:24%%'4"%#6#+#%8%'43+%$3+I$#:"%I"%&%'4./#53:4%""%'#:#8%62.#@%:1#":2&'#
$:I#I"#$%&&3+6#O3%'#I%'+:'#&&$2U'$2@#+2:24%566#I%+$%24./##3"%V%2./#6
I#&&212+266%6%I"#63./#6#"%&3+46#@%@'#$:I#I"#$%&&3+@$#'<2>3"3:I"#1+%:6%I"#8O3%@%:
$&#6%60826&#1"%$%24./##3"%V%2./#6I#&&212+266%6%I"#63./#6#"%&3+46#@2:I#"N#4"213'+
$#'&26%"./#6%K2&4U'$26%$3+I@%:"S/#6#1%'%<Q$2#660826,2'6312#I"#"%#?9D%
#I$24@I;
*V3"2&I"36U'$2'#"4%:%"2$'&#1"%\2++<3+1+2'6'%&&6#$4"2'%5&2>'2<2$428@:%&:#%:"%+./#
$"2:%&6%+8>%:6%62'C%2"#@I#6%'6#&%"$246#&4Q43+#2+3&4"428#,;'24%644%&828%"!#6"2>3%S@
-(-6*(9&4
2"-;]1;'24%644%&8++R@ %6 9(4C
2";]$;'24%644%&8
1%"C3&%"@()-6( 9(4C
2";]6;'24%644%&8[%"4!32S@(-6@(9-6
2";@
'#O3+&%%'4%'6%3O3%%:I"%&N"2#6%"%:%&&6%62'C%2"#9:#'%R"%:244%";O3%$"2<+&&<43"&I"
62'C%2"#"%$%126#6%&%3&$+2%'4%&%&4N6%+21%"6:%'4%$%>#I"<#'4%6#&<3'6#&]%;'24%644%&8
3''@-6H9&4
2"HH(;]<;'24%644%&8E#"'<2%+6@)-6-94C
2"HH(;@'#O3+&%
%'4%'6%3O3%$#'46#"@O3%42'C$#'C%$2:%'4#6%O3%#$+2%'4%%"3:4"<2$'4%%$#:+2:246&<#'4%&6%
62'C%2"#+%>Q42:#@%&486%+21%"6:%'4%$%>#I"#"2>%:6#62'C%2"#O3%#$+2%'4%+C%<#"'%$%3I"
$#'8%"4%"%:$C%O3%]>;'24%644%&8#'>@H %6*)@ ! 9(4C
2"HH;]C;'24%644%&8
%'&%'@*H-6H*9(4C
2"HH;]2;'24%644%&8"2'$%@)-6 )9*4C
2";]V;'24%644%&
83++%"@H )6) )94C
2"HH;]d;'24%644%&8#$d&#'@)-6-*@HH*[ --H)9)4C
2"HH*;@'#O3+&%%'4%'6%3O3%%:I"%&N"2#6%4"'&:2&&/#6%62'C%2"#9:#'%R4"'&:244%";%&48
6%+21%"6:%'4%$%>#I"#"2>%:6#62'C%2"#O3%+C%<#2%'4"%>3%%:>"'6%O3'4266%@%:%&I5$2%@%:
&$#+&6%II%+@'#I%"Q#6#6'#24%%I#"I%&&#&O3%'/#I%62":O3%#62'C%2"#<#&&%$#'46#]%+;'24%6
44%&8"42S@ -(3II-H)@)'-9+HH;"%<%"U'$2#&$&#&%#&"%&3:#&#"
%KI#&4#&<#":%K4"Q6#&6%%I"4:%'4#<3&42$%
"2:2'+282&2#',&&%4#"<%243"%'6#'%R
3'6%"2'>%$42#'#I$24@IH!
*-'24%644%&8E"'C"4@H H6*) @*!*9(4C
"HH;62<%"%'.6%4"4:%'4#6O3%&4/#
'&
#"4%&:%"2$'&5&&2:"%+46I#"3+2%e3++28',?34"&
#"4%&"%V%24:O3+O3%"4%'44286%
<3'6"$3+I12+266%6\2++<3+1+2'6'%&&%:3:4%#"262'62<%"%'.+&I"%'4%:%'4%$"%624:O3%
$#'&$2#3&8#26'$%5#%O328+%'4%$#'C%$2:%'4#I#&2428##1"%%&44%#"2@#$3&6#6%8%&%"
$#'&26%"6#"%&I#'&N8%+&#1"%3:$3&./#6%\2++<3+1+2'6'%&&&#:%'4%O3'6#%+%5:%'#&e8%&4"3Se6#
O3%e"I#&e#3&%V@O3'6#%+%%&$#+C%I%":'%$%"2>'#"'4%6#&<4#&eI"O3%I#&&+%>"<+46%
$#'C%$2:%'4#I#&2428#'%8%'43+266%6%&%"I'C6#ee>"'6%%"62+#&"I#&@O3%6%&%V>2"%""6#
%%&4"343"&3I"TI"22>'#"W'$2:%":%'4%I"I"%I""&36%<%&@4%:#:%&:#>"36%$3+I12+266%
O3%O3+O3%"#34"#:+<%24#"$C%2#6%8#'46%!'#:2&%+%86#'Q8%+@'#%&O3%:6#
T62>#%'+
#6%+#e9;62<%"%'.6%$#'$%243+2S./#%<3'6:%'4#6$3+I12+266%I#6%4%":324&$#'&%OZU'$2&
I"N42$&#"%K%:I+#@'&V3"2&62.X%&O3%82&+3:1":"I#&@#2'85&68%&4"3S@$#:##<#$#
I"#I"26#6"%&I#'&12+266%62>'#"W'$26%+21%"6@&$#"4%&@'4%&6%I"#8"3:$3&./#I#"
2>'#"W'$26%+21%"6@%K2>%:O3%$3&./#:#&4"%O3%#$3&6#6%+21%"6:%'4%%824#3#14%":2&
$#'C%$2:%'4#e<2:6%I"#826%'$2"I"%+%3:6%<%&'#$&#6%I"#$%&&#e9e@3+2%%6%"+
\C24%$#++"$"2:%&@I-!);
*)&<#'4%&@+:%'48%+:%'4%@'/#I#6%:&%"$246&I#"<#".6%&%>"%6#6%V3&42.
*%+4T"2#"$2+6#&%4#"45$'2$#!$2%'42<2$#!II2+#&$#I26#
@$#:<#4#&6#2'4%"2#"6$&%
$#+%46%<">:%'4#&6%2:I"%&&X%&62>242&F&<+&(H-(6#()(*!
**"4@^)@@%6#
T62>#%'+
* TI2&6%@
@4Q43+#%+%24#"+@<#4#%6%$+"./#6%2:I#&4#6%"%'6F&<+&*) 6#
()(*!1&%"8%!&%O3%624#2'628Q63#3+#5">2#6%#3S9
-)())!)@
)(H!
@$#'&2>'#3$#:#&3646%'&$2:%'4#@$#2'$26%'4%:%'4%@#62(H(@
http://www.jfce.jus.br/consultaProcessual/resimprsentintegra.asp?CodDoc=2177598
3/11/2010